The routes for transformation of follicular lymphoma

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Aggressive transformation, a frequent event in the natural history of follicular lymphoma, is associated with increased lymphoma-related mortality and yet the underlying biology remains poorly defined. This review outlines recent advances in our understanding of the genetic basis and evolutionary process leading to transformation.

RECENT FINDINGS

Both the antecedent indolent and transformed follicular lymphoma (tFL) arise through branched divergent evolution with tumors emerging from a founder precursor population, the common progenitor cell. Although the majority of tFLs maintain a germinal center B-cell gene expression signature, an activated B-cell-type (ABC-type) profile appears to predominate in BCL2-translocation negative cases. It does not appear that a single unifying genetic or epigenetic event promotes a fitter and more aggressive clone.

SUMMARY

Transformed follicular tumors are genetically heterogeneous perhaps reflecting the varying clinical behavior and outcomes of this disease event. Follicular lymphoma and tFL remain incurable tumors highlighted by our inability to eradicate the founder common progenitor cell population with current therapies. Progress has now been made in defining the genetic events and evolutionary pathways responsible for transformation. Although more research is required in predicting and understanding the biology of transformation, there are opportunities to improve outcomes by preferentially directing targeted therapies toward 'actionable' early and transformation-specific aberrations.

Transformation of follicular lymphoma

Histological transformation of follicular lymphoma (FL) to a more aggressive non-Hodgkin's lymphomas is a pivotal event in the natural history of FL and is associated with poor outcome. While commonly observed in clinical practice and despite multiple studies designed to address its pathogenesis, the biology of this process represents an enigma. In this chapter we present a state of the art review summarizing the definition of histologic transformation, its incidence, pathogenesis, clinical manifestations, treatment and outcome. Furthermore, we specifically emphasize gaps in our knowledge that should be addressed in future studies.

Transformation of follicular lymphoma to diffuse large B-cell lymphoma proceeds by distinct oncogenic mechanisms

This study was undertaken to further elucidate the biological mechanisms underlying the frequent event of transformation of follicular lymphoma (FL) to diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (t-FL). The gene expression profiles of 20 paired lymph node biopsies, derived from the same patient pre- and post-transformation, were analysed using the Lymphochip cDNA microarray. TP53 mutation analysis was performed and copy number alterations at the c-REL and CDNK2A examined. Immunohistochemistry was performed on an independent panel of paired transformation paraffin-embedded samples. Transformed follicular lymphoma was predominantly of the germinal centre B-like phenotype both at the mRNA and protein level. Despite this homogeneity, transformation proceeded by at least two pathways. One mechanism was characterised by high proliferation, as assessed by the co-ordinately expressed genes of the proliferation signature. This group was associated with the presence of recurrent oncogenic abnormalities. In the remaining cases, proliferation was not increased and transformation proceeded by alternative routes as yet undetermined. Genes involved in cellular proliferation prevailed amongst those that were significantly increased upon transformation and T cell and follicular dendritic-associated genes predominated amongst those that decreased. t-FL is a germinal centre B (GCB)-like malignancy that evolves by two pathways, one that is similar in proliferation rate to the antecedent FL and the other that has a higher proliferation rate and is characterised by the presence of recognised oncogenic abnormalities.

Lack of Bcl-2 expression in follicular lymphoma may be caused by mutations in the BCL2 gene or by absence of the t(14;18) translocation

Follicular lymphoma (FL), except grade 3B, is characterized by the chromosomal translocation t(14;18)(q32;q21), which results in over-expression of the Bcl-2 protein. Ten per-cent of all FLs, however, do not show Bcl-2 protein expression with standard immunohistochemistry using a monoclonal Bcl-2 antibody against residues 41-54 of the Bcl-2 protein. In this study, the biological background of 18 Bcl-2-negative FL cases grade I, II, or IIIa was investigated by immunohistochemical staining and western blot analysis with alternative antibodies. Bcl-2 protein was demonstrated in five of the 18 cases and all of these carried the t(14;18) translocation. Of the 13 cases that were Bcl-2 negative with alternative antibodies, 12 lacked the t(14;18) translocation. PCR and subsequent sequence analysis of cDNA demonstrated that three cases with a t(14;18) contained somatic mutations in the translocated BCL2 gene, resulting in amino acid replacements in the region of the epitope recognized by the antibody. In conclusion, the majority of Bcl-2-negative FL lack a t(14;18) but a significant subset of these tumours are false negative due to mutations in the BCL2 gene. These findings may have consequences for the use of Bcl-2 immunohistochemistry for diagnostic purposes.

Oral cyclophosphamide therapy for patients with residual or relapsed indolent-type lymphoma after initial treatment for aggressive lymphomas. A sub-group of patients with apparent transformed indolent lymphoma

Lymph node or bone marrow biopsy from sixty-one patients affected by aggressive non-Hodgkin lymphomas (NHL) were retrospectively evaluated to assess the histology at relapse. Eighteen cases (29.5%) were proven to have relapsed or persistent low-grade lymphoma after conventional therapy. In 5/18 patients association of low and high-grade lymphoma was detectable at diagnosis by bone marrow biopsy. In the remaining 13/18 no evidence of follicular lymphoma was detected at diagnosis. The outcome of these patients was compared to that of 43 patients relapsed without change in histology and treated by a second line therapy. Of these 43 patients, 13 were not responders (NR), 10 achieved a partial remission (PR) and 18 complete remission (CR). Two were lost during follow-up. The 18 patients with residual/relapsed indolent subtype received oral cyclophosphamide (100 mg/day for 15 days every month for six months): 3 of them had NR, 5 CR, and 10 PR. The overall survival (OS) median time was 39 months in low-grade resistant/relapsed patients and 20 months in patients with aggressive histology. OS at 24 months was 71 and 41%, respectively, (p < 0.02). Most of the patients with high-grade disease were refractory or relapsed after a median of five months, whereas cases with low-grade NHL showed a long lasting stable PR. We suggest that the higher grade patients with residual or relapsed low grade lymphoma were, in fact, transformed low-grade at diagnosis and, after removing the more aggressive component by chemotherapy, it is possible to manage these patients by conventional therapy for indolent lymphomas.