The negative response of the flash electroretinogram in glaucoma

Correlation Between Optical Coherence Tomography and Photopic Negative Response of Flash Electroretinography in Ganglion Cell Complex Assessment in Glaucoma Patients

Purpose

To investigate the correlation between the photopic negative response (PhNR) of the light-adapted flash electroretinography (ERG) and measurements of standard automated perimetry (SAP) and optical coherence tomography (OCT) in assessment of retinal ganglion cells’ (RGCs) affection in glaucoma.

Patients and Methods

A cross-sectional study included 40 eyes of glaucoma patients and 40 eyes of age- and gender-matched normal subjects. Participants underwent a complete ophthalmologic assessment, SAP, OCT, and light-adapted flash ERG using the extended PhNR protocol of the International Society for Clinical Electrophysiology of Vision (ISCEV). Glaucomatous eyes were divided into 3 subgroups: mild (n = 15), moderate (n = 11) and severe glaucoma (n = 14) according to the mean deviation (MD) of SAP. Measurements of SAP, OCT and ERG parameters were analyzed, and correlations between PhNR measurements and other study measurements were evaluated.

Results

PhNR amplitudes and PhNR/b-wave ratios were significantly reduced in glaucoma cases compared to healthy controls, and they showed a significant and progressive decline across the three glaucoma subgroups (P < 0.05). An exception to this is PT (b-wave peak to PhNR trough) PhNR amplitude where its reduction was statistically non-significant when comparing between controls and mild glaucoma cases (P = 0.178), and between moderate and severe glaucoma cases (P = 0.714). PhNR amplitudes and PhNR/b-wave ratios correlated significantly with SAP and OCT parameters (P < 0.05).

Conclusion

PhNR correlates well with SAP and OCT parameters in glaucoma assessment. PhNR could be a valuable supplementary tool for objective assessment of the RGCs’ function in glaucoma.

Photopic negative response of full-field electroretinography in patients with different stages of glaucomatous optic neuropathy

Purpose

To evaluate photopic negative response (PhNR) discrimination ability between healthy and glaucomatous patients.

Methods

Ninety eyes of 50 patients with primary open angle glaucoma (POAG) and 45 eyes of 23 healthy age- and sex-matched controls were investigated. Based on European Glaucoma Society criteria, POAG patients were divided into three groups: early, moderate and advanced glaucoma. Following measurements were analysed: mean defect (MD) from Humphrey Visual Field Analyzer, SITA standard 24-2 white on white perimetry; nerve fibre index (NFI) obtained from scanning laser polarimetry; and GDx and PhNR amplitude and PhNR/b-wave ratio. PhNR was elicited by red stimuli with flash strength of 1.6 cd s/m² on blue background of 25 cd/m². Correlations between retinal ganglion cells function (PhNR), retinal sensitivity (MD) and structure (NFI) were calculated. Sensitivity and specificity of PhNR parameters were calculated with standard formulas. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves were used to determine optimal cut-off values. The area under the curve (AUC) was used to compare the ROC curves results between PhNR amplitude and ratio.

Results

PhNR amplitude and ratio were significantly reduced in early, moderate and advanced glaucoma groups compared to controls. The sensitivity and specificity to detect glaucoma in early POAG were equal to 53.3 and 90.0 % for PhNR amplitude and 60.0 and 70.0 % for PhNR ratio; in moderate POAG 63.3 and 80.0 % for PhNR amplitude and 60.0 and 86.7 % for PhNR ratio; and in advanced POAG 76.6 and 80.0 % for PhNR amplitude, 90.0 and 73.3 % for PhNR ratio. There were no significant differences between AUC for PhNR amplitude (0.76–0.86) and PhNR ratio (0.78–0.86), p > 0.05. PhNR amplitudes and ratios correlated significantly with MD measured by SAP and NFI obtained from GDx (p < 0.05). PhNR amplitude significantly decreases with advancement of visual field defects in glaucoma patients.

Conclusions

PhNR reveals dysfunction of RGCs in early, moderate and advanced stage of POAG. PhNR has good discrimination ability in detecting glaucomatous patients. PhNR might be a useful test in glaucoma diagnosis.

MfERG responses to long-duration white stimuli in glaucoma patients

The intent of our study was to evaluate whether the response to a long-duration white stimulus in the multifocal electroretinogram (mfERG) is sufficiently sensitive to detect early retinal dysfunction in glaucoma. On-off mfERGs were recorded from 15 NTG and 15 HTG patients and compared with 14 control subjects. Recording parameters were the following: LED stimulus screen (RETIscan™), 100-ms stimulus duration, 200-ms stimulus interval, 11-min total recording time, stimulus matrix of 61 elements, frame rate: 70 Hz, Lmax: 180 cd/m(2), Lmin: 0 cd/m(2), and filter setting: 1-200 Hz. The second negative response following stimulus onset (N2-on), as well as following stimulus offset (N2-off), was analyzed as an overall response and in quadrants, as well as in 4 small central and four adjoining peripheral areas per quadrant. The latency of the N2-on was significantly delayed in HTG in all response averages tested, while in NTG this was only seen in the overall response and in the small central response averages (P < 0.05). The most sensitive measure in HTG was the latency of the N2-on of the small peripheral response average of the superior temporal quadrant with an area under the ROC curve of 0.881. For NTG, the most representative measure was the latency of the N2-on of the small central response average of the inferior nasal quadrant with an area under the ROC curve of 0.793. Our results showed that in stimulation with long-duration flashes, the second negative response following the on response, representative of the early PhNR, is affected in glaucoma where N2-on showed a latency delay in POAG patients. The latency delay of the N2-on was more prominent for HTG than for NTG.

On and off responses of the photopic fullfield ERG in normal subjects and glaucoma patients

Recent studies suggest a diagnostic value of the photopic negative response (PhNR) with a long-duration stimulus. The aim of this study was to record the on and off responses of the photopic fullfield electroretinogram (ERG) in normal subjects and glaucoma patients. We focused on different waves of the responses after onset and offset of the long-duration stimulus ERG. Photopic fullfield ERGs were recorded in response to a white bright LED flash on a white 20 cd/m(2) background. Stimulus luminances were 40, 60 and 80 cd/m(2). Responses were averaged using a flash duration of 240 ms and an offset period of 500 ms. We examined 19 healthy subjects, 27 patients with glaucomatous optic disc atrophy and 7 ocular hypertensive patients. The amplitudes and implicit times of the on and off responses of the human ERG depended on flash luminance. Comparing patients with glaucoma and healthy subjects for the 60 cd/m² flash, there was a significant change in the PhNRs (at onset: P < 0.01, at offset: P < 0.001) of the d-wave and of the i-wave at offset (P < 0.01). No significant difference was found for peak times of the fullfield ERG and for a- and b-wave amplitudes. PhNR amplitudes were significantly correlated with mean thickness of retinal nerve fibre layer as measured with OCT. In comparison with the normal photopic long-flash ERG, glaucoma patients showed changes in the PhNR amplitude following stimulus onset and in waves following stimulus offset.

The effect of broadband and monochromatic stimuli on the photopic negative response of the electroretinogram in normal subjects and in open-angle glaucoma patients

The aim was to investigate the effects of monochromatic and broadband stimuli on the amplitude of the photopic negative response (PhNR) and to compare the sensitivities of these stimuli for the detection of ganglion cell damage in glaucoma patients. Forty-one healthy subjects were studied, along with 16 patients with open-angle glaucoma. Photopic electroretinograms (ERGs) were elicited with monochromatic red, amber, green, and broadband white stimuli of progressively brighter intensities in a blue background. Pattern ERGs were also recorded using a 0.8 degrees checkerboard pattern on a 21.6 degrees x 27.8 degrees screen. In the photopic ERGs of the control subjects, the PhNR amplitude was significantly higher (P < 0.01) to red than to monochromatic amber, green, and broadband white stimuli of the same intensity. In glaucoma patients, the percentage of amplitude reduction was greater for the PhNR to red (68%, P < 0.001) than to the broadband stimulus (38%, P = 0.001). The PhNR to red monochromatic stimulus appeared to be a more sensitive parameter, with a larger area enclosed by the receiver-operating characteristic curve (0.97) than for the PhNR to broadband stimulus (0.76). Also, the PhNR to red stimulus showed a more significant correlation with the pattern ERG and the visual field defects (P < 0.05) than the PhNR elicited with broadband stimulus. These findings suggest that ganglion cell activity can be more efficiently evaluated with the PhNR elicited with a red than with a broadband stimulus. The PhNR thus appears to be a promising test for the diagnostics of the ganglion cell dysfunction.

The photopic negative response of the blue-on-yellow flash-electroretinogram in glaucomas and normal subjects

The photopic negative response of the flash-electroretinogram driven by the middle- and long-wavelength cones has been shown to be reduced in non-human primates with experimental glaucoma and in human patients with glaucoma. The photopic negative response for the blue-sensitive response has been studied using a blue-green silent-substitution-technique on a red background. The aim of this study was to re-evaluate the value of the photopic negative response of the blue-sensitive pathway in glaucoma using a conventional flash-electroretinogram. In 37 eyes of 37 controls (age: 53 +/- 13.6 years) and 37 eyes of 37 patients with open-angle glaucoma of different perimetric visual field defects (age: 58.3 +/- 10 years; MD: 11.7 +/- 6.7 dB) of the Erlangen glaucoma registry Ganzfeld flash-electroretinograms (LKC, UTAS 3000) were recorded using blue Xenon-flashes of increasing photopic luminance (0.013, 0.018, 0.030, and 0.052 cd s/m(2); 440 nm) on a bright yellow background (238 cd/m(2); 550 nm) after 2 min of light adaptation. Amplitudes and implicit times of the photopic negative response and of L&M-cone- and S-cone-driven b-waves were compared between glaucomas and controls for all flash energies (unpaired t-test). The amplitudes of the photopic negative response were significantly reduced in glaucoma patients for all flash energies (P < 0.001). The implicit times of L&M-cone-driven b-wave (0.013, 0.018, 0.030, and 0.052 cd s/m(2)) and S-cone-driven b-wave (0.030 and 0.052 cd s/m(2)) were significantly prolonged in glaucoma patients (P < 0.05). The changes in these implicit times, however, are very small (1.5 ms or less). The other measures did not differ significantly. The amplitude of the photopic negative response and the implicit times of the L&M-cone and S-cone b-wave in the same responses of the blue-on-yellow flash-electroretinogram are potentially useful in the evaluation of inner-retinal function in glaucoma.

Retinal ganglion cell activity from the multifocal electroretinogram in pig: optic nerve section, anaesthesia and intravitreal tetrodotoxin

Non-invasive recordings of the retinal activity have an important role to play in the diagnosis of retinal pathologies. The detection of diseases that involve retinal ganglion cells (RGCs), such as optic atrophy and glaucoma, may be improved by isolating the RGC contribution from the multifocal electroretinogram (mfERG). In this study, mfERGs were performed on 20 pigs, 1-6 weeks following unilateral retrobulbar optic nerve section (ONS). The stimuli were 103 non-scaled high-contrast hexagons from which summed and individual mfERG responses were obtained in experimental and control fellow eyes under conditions of ketamine (n = 11) or isoflurane anaesthesia (n = 9). The effect of intravitreal injection of tetrodotoxin (TTX; n = 6) was also investigated. The summed mfERG responses showed a first positive peak (P1) with a short latency (21 ms) followed by two smaller peaks (P2 and P3) of longer latency (46 and 65 ms, respectively). While P2 and P3 amplitude were highly correlated with the time post-optic nerve section (ONS) (P2: r(2) = 0.669; P = 0.007; P3: r(2) = 0.651; P = 0.005), P1 was not (r(2) = 0.193; P = 0.38). P1 and P2 showed no implicit time variation as a function of retinal location, while P3 implicit time varied along the axis of the visual streak, generating a naso-temporal asymmetry. However, the P3 implicit time did not vary consistently with distance away from the optic nerve head. Intravitreal injections of TTX reduced P2 and P3 in the control eyes, consistent with the effect of ONS, and also induced a series of regular oscillations lasting up to 200 ms post stimulus. Under isoflurane anaesthesia, all components of the mfERG ifn experimental and control eyes were, at all time points post-ONS, of similar amplitude and without naso-temporal asymmetry, suggesting a reduced participation of RGCs under these anaesthesic conditions. These data clearly demonstrate that it is possible to isolate the RGC contribution from non-invasive multifocal electroretinography.

S-cone, L + M-cone, and pattern, electroretinograms in ocular hypertension and glaucoma

Silent substitution and selective adaptation techniques were used to obtain full field S-cone and L + M-cone electroretinograms from 18 patients with ocular hypertension (OHT), 9 with normotensive glaucoma (NTG), 18 with early primary open angle glaucoma (POAG) and 19 normal controls. Pattern electroretinograms were also recorded, using a reduced check size to increase the contribution of retinal ganglion cells. In the OHT and POAG groups, statistically significant reductions (P = 0.05-0.001) were observed in the amplitudes, most notably in the late negative waves of all three types of ERG compared to the controls. These are thought to reflect ganglion cell activity. The results imply a diffusely distributed loss of activity (20-35%) affecting many retinal pathways to a similar extent in OHT and early POAG, with an additional amount (<5%) in POAG corresponding approximately to the loss associated with local field defects. The electrophysiology indicated that virtually all cases of untreated OHT have greater retinal dysfunction than the least affected cases of POAG. The NTG group showed a different pattern of loss in that the PERG was markedly affected but the S-cone ERG was not significantly reduced.

Inter-ocular and inter-session reliability of the electroretinogram photopic negative response (PhNR) in non-human primates

PURPOSE

To assess the inter-ocular and inter-session reliability for a range of parameters derived from the photopic electroretinogram (ERG) in a group of normal non-human primates.

METHODS

Inter-ocular differences for photopic ERGs were assessed in a group of normal anesthetized adult rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta, n=29); inter-session reliability was assessed for 23 eyes of 23 animals tested 3 months later. Signals were acquired using Burian-Allen contact lens electrodes, whereby the contralateral cornea served as a reference. Photopic ERGs were elicited using red Ganzfeld flashes (-0.5-0.67 log photopic cd.sm(-2)) on a rod suppressing blue-background (30 scotopic cdm(-2)). Measurement reliability was established for a-wave, b-wave, photopic negative response (PhNR) and oscillatory potential (OP) amplitudes, as well as for their implicit times, by calculation of the 95% limits-of-agreement (LOA) and the coefficient-of-variation (COV) for each parameter.

RESULTS

OP and a-wave amplitudes increased with intensity up to 0.67 log photopic cd.sm(-2), following a typical saturating function, whereas b-wave and PhNR amplitudes both declined above 0.42 log photopic cd.sm(-2). Inter-session variability was greater than inter-ocular variability. The inter-session COVs for PhNR amplitude (10-20%) were similar to the other photopic ERG components (a-wave: 12-17%, b-wave: 12-17%, OPs: 13-19%). Inter-session LOAs were also similar across components, but on average, were smallest for responses to moderate intensities (0.0-0.42 log photopic cd.sm(-2)).

CONCLUSION

In non-human primates, the 95% LOA for inter-session measurements of the photopic ERG a-wave, b-wave, OPs and PhNR are all similar. Inner-retinal damage may best be measured using the PhNR amplitude for moderately bright stimulus intensities. B-wave and PhNR amplitudes for brighter flashes are smaller and more variable. The ratio of PhNR:b-wave amplitudes manifests smaller variability and may therefore be useful for detection of selective PhNR loss.

Ganglion cell contributions to the rat full-field electroretinogram

The purpose of this study was to determine what contributions are made to the rat full-field electroretinogram (ERG) by ganglion cells (GCs). To that end, the ERG was assessed longitudinally following optic nerve transection (ONTx). Additional studies were conducted using intravitreal injections of pharmacologically active substances. The ERG was recorded simultaneously from both eyes of anaesthetized adult Brown-Norway rats (ketamine: xylazine: acepromazine, 55: 5: 1 mg kg(-1)) using custom silver chloride electrodes. Stimuli were brief, white xenon discharges delivered via a Ganzfeld under dark-adapted and light-adapted conditions (150 cd m(-2)). ERGs were obtained 1, 2, 3, 4 and 9 weeks after ONTx (n = 8) or sham (n = 8) operations. ONTx reduced both positive and negative components of the scotopic threshold response (pSTR and nSTR). Scotopic ERG responses to brighter flashes, including a-waves, b-waves and oscillatory potentials (OPs) were unaffected by ONTx. ONTx reduced the photopic b-wave and OPs. TTX (6 microM) reduced the pSTR and nSTR, but not the scotopic a-wave, b-wave or OPs. TTX had dramatic effects on the photopic ERG, surpassing the effects of ONTx. TTX application 9 weeks post-ONTx had little additional effect on the STR. Inhibition of inner retinal responses using GABA (10 mM) or NMDA (0.8 mM) reduced the nSTR substantially. Similar results were obtained with antagonists of AMPA/KA ionotropic glutamate receptors 6-cyano-7-nitroquinoxaline-2,3(1H,4H)-dione (CNQX, 0.2 mM) or cis-2,3-piperidinedicarboxylic acid (PDA, 5 mm); however, both also reduced the scotopic b-wave by approximately 40 %. By contrast, the NMDA receptor antagonist D(-)-2-amino-7-phosphonoheptanoic acid (D-AP7, 0.2 mM) had no effect alone, but the combination of D-AP7 and CNQX completely abolished the STR. The results of this study indicate that: (1) both pSTR and nSTR components in the rat depend directly upon intact GC responses, and that amacrine cell contributions to these components are relatively small; (2) scotopic ERG response components to brighter flashes receive little influence from GCs; (3) the rat photopic ERG also reflects GC signals and may serve as an additional useful test of GC function; (4) TTX had dramatic effects on the rat photopic ERG that were not attributable to GC currents, but rather to voltage-gated sodium currents in amacrine or interplexiform cells; (5) a small residual negative STR persisted after ONTx that was likely to be generated by graded responses of third-order retinal cells, most likely amacrine cells.

Objective measurement of visual function in glaucoma

Of the objective (electrophysiological), functional tests of glaucomatous damage, three hold the most promise. Some evidence suggests that the pattern electroretinogram, the photopic negative response of the electroretinogram, and the multifocal visual-evoked potential can detect early glaucomatous damage, damage that may be missed on static automated achromatic perimetry. However, in their current forms, these tests can supplement, but cannot replace, static automated achromatic perimetry. Further, the multifocal visual-evoked potential is the only one of these tests that supplies topographic information about local damage. In addition, we still lack a complete understanding of the relation between these tests and the underlying damage to ganglion cells. In this context, it has recently been suggested that the signal in the multifocal visual-evoked potential response may be linearly related to the loss of ganglion cells. Finally, more information is needed about these tests from longitudinal or prospective studies.