A prototype device for standardized calibration of pulse oximeters II

Multi-analyte calibration and verification of a multi-parameter laser-based pulse oximeter

Almost since its introduction pulse oximetry was known to overestimate oxygen saturation in cases of carbon monoxide poisoning or elevated methemoglobin (metHb) levels. To eliminate this dangerous behavior some manufacturers have added additional LED emitters to try to increase the number of measured hemoglobin species and to improve measurement accuracy, but have not been very successful. We hypothesized that the use of narrow-band laser light sources would make accurate and precise measurement of the four primary species of hemoglobin possible, even in cases of elevated levels of carboxyhemoglobin (COHb). Calibration and verification studies were performed on a tissue simulator that employed an artificial finger pulsating with whole human blood. This simulator allowed safe generation of 165 different combinations of the levels of oxyhemoglobin (O₂Hb), COHb, metHb, and reduced hemoglobin (RHb) for calibration of the laser-based pulse oximeter. A follow-on study used 56 mixed hemoglobin levels for verification and statistical analysis of the performance of this device. This laser-based pulse oximeter measured all four species of hemoglobin accurately and precisely (A_RMS ≤ 1.8%) for metHb levels in the clinically normal range. At elevated metHb levels the device continued to provide accurate and precise measurements of metHb and RHb (A_RMS ≤ 1.7%). The use of monochromatic laser light sources can create a new generation of highly accurate, multi-parameter, pulse oximeters.

Approaches for calibration and validation of near-infrared optical methods for oxygenation monitoring

Pulse oximetry for arterial oxygenation monitoring and tissue oximetry for monitoring of cerebral oxygenation or muscle oxygenation are based on quantitative in vivo diffuse optical spectroscopy. However, in both cases the information on absolute or relative concentration of human tissue constituents and especially on hemoglobin oxygenation can often not be retrieved by model-based analysis. An in vivo calibration against an accepted reference measurement can be a practical alternative. Pulse oximeters and most of commercial cerebral tissue oximeters rely on empirical calibration based on invasive controlled human desaturation studies. As invasive in vivo tests on healthy subjects are ethically disputable and should be limited to exceptional cases this calibration practice is unsatisfactory. We present the current status and problems of calibration and validation in pulse oximetry and cerebral tissue oximetry including the pros and cons of in vivo as well as in vitro methods. We emphasize various digital and physical phantom approaches and discuss the prospects of their application and possible further developments.

A Comparative Analysis of Arterial Oxygen Saturation among Tibetans And Han Born And Raised at High Altitude

This study compares resting arterial oxygen saturation as measured by pulse oximetry (Sp(O2)) among 818 Tibetans and 668 Han who were born and raised at altitudes between 3200 and 4300 m in Qinghai Province, Western China. Both Tibetans and Han show an increase in Sp(O2) values between the ages of 5 and 19 yr, and both groups show a decline after the third decade. However, mean, age-adjusted Sp(O2) values at rest do not differ significantly among growing Tibetans and Han aged 5 through 19 yr or among Tibetans and Han aged 20 through 51 yr. Therefore, the results of this study do not support the hypothesis that indigenous groups possess a superior arterial saturation while awake and at rest compared to lowlanders who have been born and raised at high altitude. Differences between adult Tibetan males and females approach statistical significance (females show higher values than males), while differences between adult Han males and females are not statistically significant. A review of the literature indicates that substantial interstudy variation exists in resting Sp(O2) values among Tibetans residing at high altitudes (between 2% and 4%, depending on the age of individuals measured) and may reflect differences in sample size, health of participants, instruments, probe location, and measurement protocols.