Pain characteristics and nicotine deprivation as predictors of performance during a laboratory paradigm of smoking cessation

The Role of Pain Avoidance in the Relation between Pain Intensity and Smoking Cessation Processes

Scientific evidence suggests that smokers who experience varying levels of pain are more likely to maintain their addiction to tobacco. The relationship between pain intensity and cognitive-based smoking processes within a mechanistic framework has received relatively little attention. Pain avoidance may influence the association between pain intensity and smoking, as it is a construct that is related to adverse pain and smoking processes. Thus, the current cross-sectional study examined the indirect effect of pain intensity on three clinically significant smoking processes (i.e., prior quit problems, perceived barriers for cessation, and negative affect reduction smoking expectancies) through pain avoidance among 95 treatment-seeking adult smokers. Regression analyses were conducted using bootstrapping techniques through PROCESS, a conditional modeling program that utilizes an ordinary least squares-based path analytical framework to test for both direct and indirect associations. Results indicated that pain intensity had a statistically significant indirect association with quit problems and perceived barriers for cessation, through pain avoidance. Pain intensity did not have a statistically significant indirect association with the negative affect reduction of smoking expectancies through pain avoidance. The current findings provide evidence for the role of pain avoidance as a potential transdiagnostic mechanism that contributes to maladaptive smoking outcomes within the larger context of the reciprocal model of pain and substance use.

Ecological momentary assessment of cigarette smoking behavior and pain intensity among individuals with chronic back pain who smoke

Chronic pain affects ∼20% of the adult population and is associated with smoking. Smoking and pain worsen each other in the long term, but short-term temporal associations between smoking and pain throughout the day are unclear. Understanding these relationships may inform strategies for managing comorbid smoking and pain. Participants with chronic back pain who smoke responded to 81.5% of ecological momentary assessment (EMA) prompts delivered 5 times daily. Independent variables were: 1) urge to smoke (from 1-9), 2) intention to smoke (about to smoke, not about to smoke), and 3) smoking recency (smoked <30 min ago, smoked >30 min ago); smoking now was included as a separate category in models 2 and 3. Associations with pain intensity (from 1-9) were estimated using multi-level models, including an interaction term between the independent variable and Pain and Smoking Inventory score (PSI). Urge to smoke was associated with increased pain intensity (β=0.10 [SE=0.02], p<0.001), and this difference was greater for individuals with higher PSI scores (β=0.03 [0.01], p=0.003). Not being about to smoke was associated with lower pain intensity than smoking now (β=-0.29 [0.09], p=0.001). Compared to smoking now, both smoking <30 min ago (β=-0.30 [0.09], p=0.001) and smoking >30 min ago (β=-0.23 [0.11], p=0.029) were associated with lower pain intensity. Smoking urges may increase pain intensity (or vice versa), especially when people perceive strong relationships between smoking and pain. Smoking may also attenuate perceived pain. Further research is needed on interventions that combine tailored smoking cessation treatments and behavioral pain management strategies. PERSPECTIVE: This analysis of momentary data reported throughout the day by people with back pain who smoke revealed novel insights into short-term relationships between pain and smoking. Study results can inform future treatment development for individuals with chronic pain who smoke.

Pain Interference and Intensity in Relation to Abstinence Outcomes Following a One-Session Personalized Feedback Smoking Cessation Digital-Intervention

Background: Pain is a highly common and costly health problem that is strongly linked to cigarette smoking. Pain interference, the degree to which pain impedes physical, occupational, recreational, and social functioning, may have an important role in terms of smoking cessation. However, no study has examined the role of pain interference as a predictor of relapse following a quit attempt in a smoking cessation trial. Objectives: The current study examined the role of pain interference, above the effects of pain intensity, on relapse following a quit attempt. Participants were 121 treatment-seeking adult cigarette smokers (29% female; Mage = 29.32, SD = 7.52) who attended a randomized-controlled trial (RCT) testing the effect of a digital single-session personalized feedback intervention (PFI) for distress tolerance and cigarette smoking behavior. Multiple logistic regressions were conducted to examine pain intensity and pain interference scores as predictors of 7-day point prevalence abstinence (PPA) at 2 weeks and 4 weeks following the 1-session intervention. Models controlled for sex, baseline cigarette dependence, treatment condition, and baseline distress tolerance. Results: Pain interference was associated with higher odds of reporting relapse at 4-week post intervention (OR: 1.54, 95% CI [1.06, 2.25]).), while pain intensity only showed a non-significant association with higher odds of reporting relapse at 2-week (OR: 1.40, 95% CI [0.67, 2.94]). Conclusions: This prospective study highlights the effect of pain interference on later-stage relapse outcomes following participation in a cigarette smoking cessation program.

Pain interference among adult dual combustible and electronic tobacco users in terms of perceived barriers for quitting

Electronic cigarette (e-cigarette) use has become increasingly common among combustible cigarette users, and dual use may represent a more severe type of nicotine addiction. Experiencing pain is one prevalent domain that may be important to understand quit processes and behavior among dual users. Although most past research on pain and nicotine/tobacco has focused on combustible cigarette use, initial work on e-cigarette users has found that greater pain severity is associated with higher levels of dependence and negative thinking patterns about e-cigarette use. Yet, there has been no effort to explore the experience of pain among dual users in terms of perceived barriers for quitting combustibles or e-cigarettes. The present study sought to examine pain interference among dual combustible and e-cigarette users in terms of perceived barriers for quitting among 138 (45.9% female; Mage = 35.96 years, SD = 7.16) adult dual users (i.e., users of both combustible cigarette and e-cigarettes). Hierarchical linear regression models indicated that pain interference was significantly associated with both perceived barriers for cessation of combustible cigarettes and perceived barriers for cessation of e-cigarettes. Overall, the present investigation served as an initial evaluation of the role of pain interference in terms of perceived barriers for quitting combustible and e-cigarettes among adult daily dual users. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).

The Effect of Smoking Cessation on Acute Pain: A Systematic Review

Smoking is a known risk factor for developing various pain-related disorders. However, acute pain often triggers the craving for cigarette consumption, resulting in a positive feedback mechanism. In addition, there is evidence of decreased pain tolerance during the early stages of abstinence. Therefore, in this study, we aimed to investigate whether a period of decreased pain tolerance and increased pain intensity occurs during smoking cessation. A systematic literature search was conducted through PubMed and Web of Science databases for controlled studies investigating the influence of smoking cessation on acute (defined as pain presentation of < 3 months) and postoperative pain. The outcomes of interest included pain perception threshold, pain tolerance, pain intensity, and postoperative opioid requirements. The search strategy yielded 1478 studies, of which 13 clinical studies met our inclusion criteria. The included studies collectively represented data from 1721 participants from four countries. Of these, 43.3% of the included individuals were females. The mean age of the included subjects was 44.2 ± 8.2 years. The duration of smoking cessation varied considerably. The shortest duration was 2 h; others investigated the effect after more than 1 month of smoking cessation. Smokers had a history of 14.6 ± 9.9 years of nicotine abuse. The mean number of daily smoked cigarettes was 17.5 ± 10.3. Most studies examined in this systematic review show a negative influence of smoking cessation on acute pain. However, the affected pain modalities, the duration of the altered pain perception, and whether male and female smokers are equally affected could not be ascertained due to high heterogeneity and few available studies.

The Impact of Smoking on the Development and Severity of Chronic Pain

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The purpose of this review is to examine the impact of smoking and its role on the development of chronic pain and provide a critical review of recent literature.

RECENT FINDINGS

Recent studies demonstrate the bidirectional and dependent relationship between smoking and chronic pain. Those who are in pain have a more difficult time in the cessation of smoking as well as an increased sensitivity to pain during abstinence, lower confidence, and higher relapse rates. The fear of pain and the anxiety and depression that abstinence causes results in a grim outcome for long-term cessation. The dependent nature between chronic pain and smoking is affected by numerous variables. Providers should consider a multiprong approach to treating chronic pain and targeting smoking cessation treatment by providing motivational therapy, nicotine replacement, and medication therapies to prevent relapse, and providing those who are more likely to relapse with a higher level of care.

Perceived pain and smoking interrelations among veterans with chronic pain enrolled in a smoking cessation trial

INTRODUCTION

The Pain and Smoking Inventory (PSI) measures patients' perceived interrelations of their pain and smoking behavior, and comprises three conceptually-distinct domains: smoking to cope with pain (PSI-Cope), pain as a motivator of smoking (PSI-Motivate), and pain as a barrier to cessation (PSI-Barrier). Associations between PSI scores and pain interference and self-efficacy to quit smoking, two measures that can affect cessation outcomes, remain unclear.

METHODS

Secondary analysis of baseline data from 371 Veterans with chronic pain (88% male, M  age = 60) enrolled in a randomized smoking cessation trial. We used sequential multivariate regression models to examine associations between the three PSI domains and pain interference/self-efficacy.

RESULTS

Of 371 Veterans who completed baseline surveys, 88% were male with median age 60 years. PSI-Motivate scores were positively associated with pain interference (B: 0.18, 95% CI: 0.02, 0.34). PSI-Barrier sub-scores were negatively associated with self-efficacy (B: -0.23, 95% CI:-0.36, -0.10).

CONCLUSION

Findings suggest that individuals who hold maladaptive perceptions of pain-smoking interrelations may be more likely to endorse higher pain interference and lower self-efficacy-two established predictors of cessation outcomes. Moreover, each PSI subscale demonstrated unique relationships with the dependent variables, and our results provided support for a three-factor structure. These findings further demonstrate that the PSI comprises three conceptually and empirically distinct domains; future research should evaluate the clinical utility of assessing each domain in relation to cessation outcomes.

Pain and smoking study (PASS): A comparative effectiveness trial of smoking cessation counseling for veterans with chronic pain

Introduction

Smoking is associated with greater pain intensity and pain-related functional interference in people with chronic pain. Interventions that teach smokers with chronic pain how to apply adaptive coping strategies to promote both smoking cessation and pain self-management may be effective.

Methods

The Pain and Smoking Study (PASS) is a randomized clinical trial of a telephone-delivered, cognitive behavioral intervention among Veterans with chronic pain who smoke cigarettes. PASS participants are randomized to a standard telephone counseling intervention that includes five sessions focusing on motivational interviewing, craving and relapse management, rewards, and nicotine replacement therapy versus the same components with the addition of a cognitive behavioral intervention for pain management. Participants are assessed at baseline, 6, and 12 months. The primary outcome is smoking cessation.

Results

The 371 participants are 88% male, a median age of 60 years old (range 24–82), and smoke a median of 15 cigarettes per day. Participants are mainly white (61%), unemployed (70%), 33% had a high school degree or less, and report their overall health as “Fair” (40%) to “Poor” (11%). Overall, pain was moderately high (mean pain intensity in past week = 5.2 (Standard Deviation (SD) = 1.6) and mean pain interference = 5.5 (SD = 2.2)). Pain-related anxiety was high (mean = 47.0 (SD = 22.2)) and self-efficacy was low (mean = 3.8 (SD = 1.6)).

Conclusions

PASS utilizes an innovative smoking and pain intervention to promote smoking cessation among Veterans with chronic pain. Baseline characteristics reflect a socioeconomically vulnerable population with a high burden of mental health comorbidities.

I smoke to cope with pain: patients' perspectives on the link between cigarette smoking and pain

BACKGROUND

For people with chronic pain, cigarette smoking is associated with greater pain intensity and impairment. Researchers have hypothesized a reciprocal relationship in which pain and smoking exacerbate each other, resulting in greater pain and increased smoking. This study aimed to qualitatively examine patient perspectives on this association.

METHODS

A retrospective thematic analysis of smoking cessation counseling notes for 136 veterans in the Pain and Smoking Study, a tailored smoking cessation trial, was conducted. A validated codebook was applied to each counseling note by four independent coders using Atlas.ti (Atlas.ti, Berlin, Germany). Coders participated in a consensus-forming exercise with salient themes validated among the wider research team.

KEY RESULTS

Participants averaged 60 years of age (range 28-77 years) and were 9% female. The median number of cigarettes smoked per day was 15, with a mean pain intensity score in the last week (from 0-10) of 5.1. While not all patients acknowledged a connection between pain and smoking, we found that (1) pain motivates smoking and helps manage pain-related distress, as a coping strategy and through cognitive distraction, and (2) pain motivates smoking but smoking does not offer pain relief. Concerns about managing pain without smoking was identified as a notable barrier to cessation.

CONCLUSION

Many patients with chronic pain who smoke readily identified pain as a motivator of their smoking behavior and are reluctant to quit for this reason. Integrated interventions for smokers with pain should address these perceptions and expectancies and promote uptake of more adaptive self-management strategies for pain.

[Relation between tobacco smoking and pain: A narrative review of the scientific literature]

INTRODUCTION

Tobacco smoking and pain have an intimate, complex, two-way interaction. The purpose of this narrative review of the literature is to present what is currently understood about the relationship.

STATE OF KNOWLEDGE

Tobacco smoking (and the associated chronic exposure to nicotine) has been defined as a risk factor for chronic pain, involving nociceptive sensitisation. For people who smoke, pain will be both a motivational factor for tobacco consumption and a barrier to tobacco use cessation. Conversely, nicotine (acute exposure) has clearly demonstrated analgesic properties, mediated in particular by activation of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors.

PERSPECTIVES

The management of pain in people who smoke is still largely unaddressed, and further studies will be needed to develop effective strategies for tobacco use cessation in this context. Nicotine and modulators of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors represent innovative strategies for the discovery of new analgesics.

CONCLUSIONS

The effects of smoking on pain, chronic nociceptive sensitisation and acute analgesia, serve to maintain tobacco consumption via negative reinforcement. A holistic therapeutic strategy is necessary to maximise the likelihood of successful smoking cessation.