Literature-based evaluation of four 'hard endpoint' models for assessing drug-induced torsades de pointes liability

Cross clinical-experimental-computational qualification of in silico drug trials on human cardiac purkinje cells for proarrhythmia risk prediction

The preclinical identification of drug-induced cardiotoxicity and its translation into human risk are still major challenges in pharmaceutical drug discovery. The ICH S7B Guideline and Q&A on Clinical and Nonclinical Evaluation of QT/QTc Interval Prolongation and Proarrhythmic Potential promotes human in silico drug trials as a novel tool for proarrhythmia risk assessment. To facilitate the use of in silico data in regulatory submissions, explanatory control compounds should be tested and documented to demonstrate consistency between predictions and the historic validation data. This study aims to quantify drug-induced electrophysiological effects on in silico cardiac human Purkinje cells, to compare them with existing in vitro rabbit data, and to assess their accuracy for clinical pro-arrhythmic risk predictions. The effects of 14 reference compounds were quantified in simulations with a population of in silico human cardiac Purkinje models. For each drug dose, five electrophysiological biomarkers were quantified at three pacing frequencies, and results compared with available in vitro experiments and clinical proarrhythmia reports. Three key results were obtained: 1) In silico, repolarization abnormalities in human Purkinje simulations predicted drug-induced arrhythmia for all risky compounds, showing higher predicted accuracy than rabbit experiments; 2) Drug-induced electrophysiological changes observed in human-based simulations showed a high degree of consistency with in vitro rabbit recordings at all pacing frequencies, and depolarization velocity and action potential duration were the most consistent biomarkers; 3) discrepancies observed for dofetilide, sotalol and terfenadine are mainly caused by species differences between humans and rabbit. Taken together, this study demonstrates higher accuracy of in silico methods compared to in vitro animal models for pro-arrhythmic risk prediction, as well as a high degree of consistency with in vitro experiments commonly used in safety pharmacology, supporting the potential for industrial and regulatory adoption of in silico trials for proarrhythmia prediction.

Translational science approach for assessment of cardiovascular effects and proarrhythmogenic potential of the beta-3 adrenergic agonist mirabegron

INTRODUCTION

Translational assessment of cardiac safety parameters is a challenge in clinical development of beta-3 adrenoceptor agonists. The preclinical tools are presented that were used for assessing human safety for mirabegron.

METHODS

Studies were performed on electrical conductance at ion channels responsible for cardiac repolarization (I_Kr, I_Ks, I_to, I_Na, and I_Ca,L), on QT-interval, subendocardial APD₉₀, T_peak-end interval, and arrhythmia's in ventricular dog wedge tissue in vitro and on cardiovascular function (BP, HR, and QT_c) in conscious dogs.

RESULTS

In conscious dogs, mirabegron (0.01-10mg/kg, p.o.) dose-dependently increased HR, reduced SBP but DBP was unchanged. Propranolol blocked the decrease in SBP and attenuated HR increase at 100mg/kg mirabegron. Mirabegron, at 30, 60, or 100mg/kg, p.o., had no significant effect on the QT_c interval. In paced dog ventricular wedge, neither mirabegron nor metabolites M5, M11, M12, M14, and M16 prolonged QT, altered transmural dispersion of repolarization, induced premature ventricular contractions, or induced ventricular tachycardia. Mirabegron nor its metabolites inhibited I_Kr, I_Ks, I_to I_Na, or I_Ca,L at clinically relevant concentrations.

DISCUSSION

Up to exposure levels well exceeding human clinical exposure no discernible effects on ion channel conductance or on arrhythmogenic parameters in ventricular wedge resulted for mirabegron, or its main metabolites, confirming human cardiac safety findings. In vivo, dose-related increases in HR with effects markedly higher than seen clinically, was mediated in part by cross-activation of beta-1 adrenoceptors. This non-clinical cardiac safety test program therefore proved predictive for human cardiac safety for mirabegron.

A study of early afterdepolarizations in a model for human ventricular tissue

Sudden cardiac death is often caused by cardiac arrhythmias. Recently, special attention has been given to a certain arrhythmogenic condition, the long-QT syndrome, which occurs as a result of genetic mutations or drug toxicity. The underlying mechanisms of arrhythmias, caused by the long-QT syndrome, are not fully understood. However, arrhythmias are often connected to special excitations of cardiac cells, called early afterdepolarizations (EADs), which are depolarizations during the repolarizing phase of the action potential. So far, EADs have been studied mainly in isolated cardiac cells. However, the question on how EADs at the single-cell level can result in fibrillation at the tissue level, especially in human cell models, has not been widely studied yet. In this paper, we study wave patterns that result from single-cell EAD dynamics in a mathematical model for human ventricular cardiac tissue. We induce EADs by modeling experimental conditions which have been shown to evoke EADs at a single-cell level: by an increase of L-type Ca currents and a decrease of the delayed rectifier potassium currents. We show that, at the tissue level and depending on these parameters, three types of abnormal wave patterns emerge. We classify them into two types of spiral fibrillation and one type of oscillatory dynamics. Moreover, we find that the emergent wave patterns can be driven by calcium or sodium currents and we find phase waves in the oscillatory excitation regime. From our simulations we predict that arrhythmias caused by EADs can occur during normal wave propagation and do not require tissue heterogeneities. Experimental verification of our results is possible for experiments at the cell-culture level, where EADs can be induced by an increase of the L-type calcium conductance and by the application of I blockers, and the properties of the emergent patterns can be studied by optical mapping of the voltage and calcium.

Vernakalant is devoid of proarrhythmic effects in the complete AV block dog model

The anesthetized chronic AV-blocked dog (cAVB) and methoxamine-sensitized rabbit model are widely used to determine pro-arrhythmic properties of drugs. In general, both models show similar results. However, conflicting data have also been reported; K201 and AZD1305 induced Torsade de Pointes (TdP) exclusively in cAVB dogs. Vernakalant, an antiarrhythmic drug that blocks several ion channels has been approved only in Europe. Its propensity to induce repolarization-dependent TdP arrhythmias has been evaluated solely in the methoxamine-sensitized rabbits. We therefore assessed the proarrhythmic potential of vernakalant in the cAVB dog model. Vernakalant was evaluated in 10 mongrel dogs (sinus rhythm (SR) 2mg/kg; chronic AV block (cAVB) 2+3mg/kg). The same dogs were challenged with dofetilide (25 μg/kg) to evaluate TdP inducibility. During the serial experiments the animals were paced from the right ventricular apex (60 beats/min). Short-term variability of repolarization (STV) was quantified for proarrhythmic risk. In SR (n=8) vernakalant prolonged QT (265 ± 11 to 311 ± 18 ms P<0.01(**)) but not PQ or QRS. In cAVB (n=8), 2mg/kg vernakalant prolonged QT (391 ± 43 to 519 ± 73 ms(**)) and QRS (103 ± 24 to 108 ± 23 ms(**)). After a 30 min lag-time, 3mg/kg vernakalant (n=4) increased QT to a lesser extent (413 ± 34 to 454 ± 27 ms(**)) while maintaining QRS prolongation (114 ± 18 to 122 ± 20 ms(**)). Neither dose increased STV or caused arrhythmias. Dofetilide prolonged QT (398 ± 51 to 615 ± 71 ms(**)), increased STV (1.0 ± 0.4 to 2.2 ± 1.0 ms P<0.05(⁎)) and induced TdP arrhythmias in 6/8(⁎) cAVB dogs. Vernakalant did not induce arrhythmias in the cAVB dog model. Higher dosages (3mg/kg) did not prolong repolarization further whereas negative inotropic effects were starting to become apparent precluding further increases in dose.

Improvement of cardiac efficacy and safety models in drug discovery by the use of stem cell-derived cardiomyocytes

BACKGROUND

The pharmaceutical industry suffers from high attrition rates during late phases of drug development. Improved models for early evaluation of drug efficacy and safety are needed to address this problem. Recent developments have illustrated that human stem cell-derived cardiomyocytes are attractive for using as a model system for different cardiac diseases and as a model for screening, safety pharmacology and toxicology.

OBJECTIVE

In this review, we discuss contemporary drug discovery models and their characteristics for cardiac efficacy testing and safety assessment. Additionally, we evaluate various sources of stem cells and how these cells could potentially improve early screening and safety models.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that human stem cells offer a source of physiologically relevant cells that show great potential as a future tool in cardiac drug discovery. However, some technical challenges related to cell differentiation and production and also to validation of improved platforms remain and must be overcome before successful application can become a reality.

Update on the cardiac safety of moxifloxacin

Cardiac safety was compared in patients receiving moxifloxacin and other antimicrobials in a large patient population from Phase II-IV randomized active-controlled clinical trials. Moxifloxacin 400 mg once-daily monotherapy was administered orally (PO) or sequentially (intravenous/oral, IV/PO). Across 64 trials, 21,298 patients received PO therapy (10,613 moxifloxacin, 10,685 comparators) while 6846 received sequential IV/PO therapy (3431 moxifloxacin, 3415 comparators). Treatment-emergent cardiac adverse event (AE) rates were similar for moxifloxacin and comparators in PO (6.6% vs 5.8%) and IV/PO (11.0% vs 12.0%) trials. Treatment-emergent cardiac adverse drug reactions were rare in PO (moxifloxacin 3.2% vs comparators 2.4%) and IV/PO (moxifloxacin 1.4% vs comparators 1.5%) patients. There were five (<0.02%) treatment-emergent drug-related deaths due to cardiac events out of 28,144 patients; one PO patient died treated with comparators, one patient died treated with IV/PO moxifloxacin, and three patients died after treatment with IV/PO comparators. Only one case of treatment-related non-fatal torsade de pointes occurred in the comparator arm. Incidence rates of cardiac AEs remained low in populations at elevated risk of cardiac events predisposed to QTc prolongation (i.e. community-acquired pneumonia patients admitted to the intensive care unit and/or mechanical ventilation, patients with documented prolongation of baseline QTc interval, women, and patients ≥ 65 years old). There was no evidence of unexpected cardiac events. After moxifloxacin treatment, an expected small prolongation in QTcB and QTcF was found. This analysis of numerous clinical trials shows the favorable cardiac safety profile of moxifloxacin, when used appropriately and according to its label, versus other antibiotics.

Role of mixed ion channel effects in the cardiovascular safety assessment of the novel anti-MRSA fluoroquinolone JNJ-Q2

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

JNJ-Q2, a novel broad-spectrum fluoroquinolone with anti-methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus activity, was evaluated in a comprehensive set of non-clinical and clinical cardiovascular safety studies. The effect of JNJ-Q2 on different cardiovascular parameters was compared with that of moxifloxacin, sparfloxacin and ofloxacin. Through comparisons with these well-known fluoroquinolones, the importance of effects on compensatory ion channels to the cardiovascular safety of JNJ-Q2 was investigated.

EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH

JNJ-Q2 and comparator fluoroquinolones were evaluated in the following models/test systems: hERG-transfected HEK293 cells sodium channel-transfected CHO cells, guinea pig right atria, arterially perfused rabbit left ventricular wedge preparations and in vivo studies in anaesthetized guinea pigs, anaesthetized and conscious telemetered dogs, and a thorough QT study in humans.

KEY RESULTS

The trend for effects of JNJ-Q2 on Tp-Te, QT, QRS and PR intervals in the non-clinical models and the plateau in QTc with increasing plasma concentration in humans are consistent with offsetting sodium and calcium channel activities that were observed in the non-clinical studies. These mixed ion channel activities result in the less pronounced or comparable increase in QTc interval for JNJ-Q2 compared with moxifloxacin and sparfloxacin despite its greater in vitro inhibition of I(Kr).

CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS

Based on the non-clinical and clinical cardiovascular safety assessment, JNJ-Q2 has a safe cardiovascular profile for administration in humans with comparable or reduced potential to prolong QT intervals, compared with moxifloxacin. The results demonstrate the importance of compensatory sodium and calcium channel activity in offsetting potassium channel activity for compounds with a fluoroquinolone core.

Comparison of the IKr blockers moxifloxacin, dofetilide and E-4031 in five screening models of pro-arrhythmia reveals lack of specificity of isolated cardiomyocytes

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Drug development requires the testing of new chemical entities for adverse effects. For cardiac safety screening, improved assays are urgently needed. Isolated adult cardiomyocytes (CM) and human embryonic stem cell-derived cardiomyocytes (hESC-CM) could be used to identify pro-arrhythmic compounds. In the present study, five assays were employed to investigate their sensitivity and specificity for evaluating the pro-arrhythmic properties of I(Kr) blockers, using moxifloxacin (safe compound) and dofetilide or E-4031 (unsafe compounds).

EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH

Assays included the anaesthetized remodelled chronic complete AV block (CAVB) dog, the anaesthetized methoxamine-sensitized unremodelled rabbit, multi-cellular hESC-CM clusters, isolated CM obtained from CAVB dogs and isolated CM obtained from the normal rabbit. Arrhythmic outcome was defined as Torsade de Pointes (TdP) in the animal models and early afterdepolarizations (EADs) in the cell models.

KEY RESULTS

At clinically relevant concentrations (5-12 µM), moxifloxacin was free of pro-arrhythmic properties in all assays with the exception of the isolated CM, in which 10 µM induced EADs in 35% of the CAVB CM and in 23% of the rabbit CM. At supra-therapeutic concentrations (≥100 µM), moxifloxacin was pro-arrhythmic in the isolated rabbit CM (33%), in the hESC-CM clusters (18%), and in the methoxamine rabbit (17%). Dofetilide and E-4031 induced EADs or TdP in all assays (50-83%), and the induction correlated with a significant increase in beat-to-beat variability of repolarization.

CONCLUSION AND IMPLICATIONS

Isolated cardiomyocytes lack specificity to discriminate between TdP liability of the I(Kr) blocking drugs moxifloxacin and dofetilide or E4031.

Keeping the rhythm: hERG and beyond in cardiovascular safety pharmacology

Following its involvement in life-threatening cardiac arrhythmias, the catchword 'hERG' has become infamous in the drug discovery community. The blockade of the ion channel coded by the human ether-á-go-go-related gene (hERG) has been correlated to a prolongation of the QT interval in the ECG, which again is correlated to a potential risk of a life-threatening polymorphic ventricular tachycardia - torsades de pointes (TdP). Therefore, in vitro investigations for blockade of this ion channel have become a standard, starting early in most drug discovery projects and often accompanying the whole project; at some stage, scientists in many medicinal chemistry programs have to deal with hERG channel liabilities. Data for the compound effects on hERG channel activity are generally part of the safety pharmacology risk assessment in regulatory submissions and, at this stage, are ideally conducted in compliance with good laboratory practice. With the withdrawal of clobutinol from the market, owing to its perceived risk of introducing TdP, the importance of the hERG channel has very recently been reconfirmed. Despite being of such importance for drug discovery, the relevance and impact of hERG data are sometimes misinterpreted, as there are drugs that block the hERG-coded ion channel but do not cause TdP, and drugs that cause TdP but do not block the hERG channel. This review aims to provide an overview of TdP, including the cardiac action potential and the ion channels involved in it, as well as on the relevance and interpretation of in vitro hERG channel data and their impact for drug discovery projects. Finally, novel cardiac safety test systems beyond in vitro hERG channel screening are discussed.

A HESI consortium approach to assess the human predictive value of non-clinical repolarization assays

Drug-induced ventricular arrhythmia and Torsades de Pointes remain a serious public health issues in bringing safe new pharmaceuticals to the market place. Under the auspices of the International Life Science Institute (ILSI)-Health and Environmental Sciences Institute (HESI), a consortium involving representatives from pharmaceutical companies, regulatory agencies and opinion leaders from the scientific and medical research communities has been initiated. The objectives are (1) to assess the concordance between signals in non-clinical repolarization assays and clinical QT interval prolongation; (2) to investigate the mechanisms for any discrepancy identified between non-clinical and clinical results and to determine viable and successful alternative approaches to identify these compounds; and (3) to assess the proarrhythmic potential of such compounds. At present, the consortium is conducting a retrospective analysis of non-clinical and clinical data from both FDA and contributing companies' databases and supplementing with a literature review. The overall objectives of these initial efforts are to establish a quantitative integrated risk assessment for each compound; to define criteria for concordance and apply them to the database in order to identify non-concordant compounds.

International Life Sciences Institute (Health and Environmental Sciences Institute, HESI) initiative on moving towards better predictors of drug-induced torsades de pointes

Knowledge of the cardiac safety of emerging new drugs is an important aspect of assuring the expeditious advancement of the best candidates targeted at unmet medical needs while also assuring the safety of clinical trial subjects or patients. Present methodologies for assessing drug-induced torsades de pointes (TdP) are woefully inadequate in terms of their specificity to select pharmaceutical agents, which are human arrhythmia toxicants. Thus, the critical challenge in the pharmaceutical industry today is to identify experimental models, composite strategies, or biomarkers of cardiac risk that can distinguish a drug, which prolongs cardiac ventricular repolarization, but is not proarrhythmic, from one that prolongs the QT interval and leads to TdP. To that end, the HESI Proarrhythmia Models Project Committee recognized that there was little practical understanding of the relationship between drug effects on cardiac ventricular repolarization and the rare clinical event of TdP. It was on that basis that a workshop was convened in Virginia, USA at which four topics were introduced by invited subject matter experts in the following fields: Molecular and Cellular Biology Underlying TdP, Dynamics of Periodicity, Models of TdP Proarrhythmia, and Key Considerations for Demonstrating Utility of Pre-Clinical Models. Contained in this special issue of the British Journal of Pharmacology are reports from each of the presenters that set out the background and key areas of discussion in each of these topic areas. Based on this information, the scientific community is encouraged to consider the ideas advanced in this workshop and to contribute to these important areas of investigations over the next several years.