Overwhelming genetic heterogeneity and exhausting molecular diagnostic process in chronic and progressive ataxias: facing it up with an algorithm, a gene, a panel at a time

Diagnostic Yield of NGS Tests for Hereditary Ataxia: a Systematic Review

Next-generation sequencing (NGS), comprising targeted panels (TP), exome sequencing (ES), and genome sequencing (GS) became robust clinical tools for diagnosing hereditary ataxia (HA). Determining their diagnostic yield (DY) is crucial for optimal clinical decision-making. We conducted a comprehensive systematic literature review on the DY of NGS tests for HA. We searched PubMed and Embase databases for relevant studies between 2016 and 2022 and manually examined reference lists of relevant reviews. Eligible studies described the DY of NGS tests in patients with ataxia as a significant feature. Data from 33 eligible studies showed a median DY of 43% (IQR = 9.5-100%). The median DY for TP and ES was 46% and 41.9%, respectively. Higher DY was associated with specific phenotype selection, such as episodic ataxia at 68.35% and early and late onset of ataxia at 46.4% and 54.4%. Parental consanguinity had a DY of 52.4% (p = 0.009), and the presumed autosomal recessive (AR) inheritance pattern showed 62.5%. There was a difference between the median DY of studies that performed targeted sequencing (tandem repeat expansion, TRE) screening and those that did not (p = 0.047). A weak inverse correlation was found between DY and the extent of previous genetic investigation (rho = - 0.323; p = 0.065). The most common genes were CACNA1A and SACS. DY was higher for presumed AR inheritance pattern, positive family history, and parental consanguinity. ES appears more advantageous due to the inclusion of rare genes that might be excluded in TP.

Feasibility of Follow-Up Studies and Reclassification in Spinocerebellar Ataxia Gene Variants of Unknown Significance

Spinocerebellar ataxia (SCA) is a heterogeneous group of neurodegenerative disorders with autosomal dominant inheritance. Genetic testing for SCA leads to diagnosis, prognosis and risk assessment for patients and their family members. While advances in sequencing and computing technologies have provided researchers with a rapid expansion in the genetic test content that can be used to unravel the genetic causes that underlie diseases, the large number of variants with unknown significance (VUSes) detected represent challenges. To minimize the proportion of VUSes, follow-up studies are needed to aid in their reclassification as either (likely) pathogenic or (likely) benign variants. In this study, we addressed the challenge of prioritizing VUSes for follow-up using (a combination of) variant segregation studies, 3D protein modeling, in vitro splicing assays and functional assays. Of the 39 VUSes prioritized for further analysis, 13 were eligible for follow up. We were able to reclassify 4 of these VUSes to LP, increasing the molecular diagnostic yield by 1.1%. Reclassification of VUSes remains difficult due to limited possibilities for performing variant segregation studies in the classification process and the limited availability of routine functional tests.

Genetic etiology of a Chinese ataxia cohort: Expanding the mutational spectrum of hereditary ataxias

INTRODUCTION

Hereditary ataxias demonstrate a high degree of clinical and genetic heterogeneity. Understanding the genetic etiology of hereditary ataxias is crucial for genetic counseling and clinical management.

METHODS

The clinical and genetic data of patients with familial or sporadic ataxias who referred to our tertiary medical center were retrospectively analyzed. Probands in this study underwent SCA repeat expansion panel firstly to screen for repeat expansion SCAs; those with negative results had NGS-targeted panels or WES testing to detect conventional mutations.

RESULTS

A total of 223 patients were enrolled from 206 families. 5 kinds of coexisting SCA repeat expansions were observed (SCA3/SCA17, SCA3/SCA8, SCA2/SCA8, SCA3/SCA12 and SCA8/SCA12) in 12 patients from 8 families, among which SCA2/SCA8, SCA8/SCA12 and SCA3/SCA12 were reported for the first time. The coexistence of expanded SCA3 with SCA17 alleles was the most common in our study. NGS identified pathogenic/likely pathogenic variants in 12 ataxia causative genes in 13 probands. Spastic paraplegia ataxia was the most common diagnosis. Six novel mutations were detected in five ataxia-related genes.

CONCLUSION

Coexistence may not specific to a certain SCA subtype and the frequency might have been underestimated before. SCA repeat expansion panel should be considered in patients with overlapping SCA features. In addition, our study broadened the conventional mutation spectrum in ataxia-related genes. These results facilitate a better understanding of the genetic basis for hereditary ataxias.

Diagnostic Yield of Whole Exome Sequencing for Adults with Ataxia: a Brazilian Perspective

Previous studies using whole exome sequencing (WES) have shown that a significant proportion of adult patients with undiagnosed ataxia in European and North American cohorts have a known genetic cause. Little is known about the diagnostic yield of WES in non-Caucasian ataxic populations. Herein, we used WES to investigate a Brazilian cohort of 76 adult patients with idiopathic ataxia previously screened for trinucleotide expansions in known ataxia genes. We collected clinical and radiological data from each patient. WES was performed following standard procedures. Only variants labeled as pathogenic or likely pathogenic according to American college of medical genetics and genomics (ACMG) criteria were retrieved. We determined the diagnostic yield of WES for the whole cohort and also for subgroups defined according to presence or not of pyramidal signs, peripheral neuropathy, and cerebellar atrophy. There were 41 women and 35 men. Mean age at testing was 48 years. Pyramidal signs, peripheral neuropathy, tremor, and cerebellar atrophy were found in 38.1%, 13.1%, 10.5%, and 68.3% of all subjects, respectively. Diagnostic yield of WES was 35.5%. Thirty-six distinct mutations were found in 20 different genes, determining the diagnosis of 18 autosomal recessive and 9 autosomal dominant ataxias. SACS and SPG7 were the most frequently found underlying genes. WES performed better in the subgroup with vs the subgroup without spasticity (p = 0.005). WES was diagnostic in 35.5% of cases of the Brazilian cohort of ataxia cases. These results have implications for diagnosis, genetic counseling and eventually treatment.