T3 versus T4a staging challenges in deeply invasive colonic adenocarcinomas and correlation with clinical outcomes

[Prognostic factors: Degree of subserosal invasion, tumor-serosal distance and subserosal elastic boundary invasion in colonic adenocarcinoma]

The aim was to study the prognostic impact of tumor infiltration of the subserosa in colonic adenocarcinoma, by evaluating the degree of tumor infiltration in the subserosa (DISS), tumor-serosa distance (DTS), and invasion of the elastic boundary of the subserosa (ILE) after elastic fiber staining.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

All patients operated on for colonic adenocarcinoma classified as pT3 without lymph node or visceral metastasis operated on at the CHU d'Amiens between 2004 and 2017 were included. All slides were reviewed by 2 pathologists. Bivariate and subgroup analyses were performed according to the presence of a DISS≤5mm or>5mm, a DTS≤1mm or>1mm and the presence or absence of an ILE. These statistical analyses were then correlated with the 5-year survival.

RESULTS

One hundred and one patients were included in the study. We performed elastic fiber staining on an average of 2 tumor blocks per case and 39.6% of patients had invasion of the elastic boundary. However, bivariate and subgroup analyses showed no statistically significant association between DISS, DTS or ILE and 5-year survival.

CONCLUSION

None of these three histopathological criteria proved to have prognostic value in our series, contrary to some results in the literature. However, as these data are subject to a number of confounding factors, we do not recommend that pathologists specify these different criteria in their reports.

The clinical significance of elastic lamina invasion in patients with pStage II colorectal cancer: a notable prognostic indicator

BACKGROUND

Some colorectal cancers (CRCs) are clinically diagnosed as cT4a with　serosal invasion (SI). However, the cT4a is most often underdiagnosed pathologically as pT3 without SI by hematoxylin-eosin (H&E) staining alone. Using Elastica van Gieson (EVG) staining, some pT3 tumors invade the elastic lamina (EL), which extends just below the serosal layer. Recently, EL invasion (ELI) has been described as a poor prognostic factor for disease-free survival (DFS) and overall survival (OS) in patients with pStage II CRC. However, its clinicopathological significance remains unclear due to the limited number of studies and poor understanding of ELI.

OBJECTIVE

This study investigated the association between the ELI and patient prognosis.

METHODS

After 1982, pathological diagnosis was routinely performed using H&E and EVG staining methods, and long-term follow up was performed until 2016. All clinicopathological features including ELI were prospectively registered into our computer and 569 patients with pStage II CRC were collected from the database. Based on the ELI status, pT3 was divided into three pathological categories: pT3ELI - was defined as pT3a, pT3ELI + as pT3b and unidentified EL (pT3EL -) as pT3u.

RESULTS

Using H&E staining alone, gross cT4a was most often pathologically underdiagnosed as pT3 (93.8%) and very rarely as pT4a, resulting in a large diagnostic discrepancy. Using EVG staining, 60.7% of the cT4a tumors were diagnosed as pT3b. The 10-year DFS and OS rates were similar for pT3a and pT3u patients. However, the 10-year DFS and OS rates of pT3b patients were significantly lower than those of pT3a patients (75.6% vs. 95.6%, p < 0.0001 and 58.4% vs. 70.6%, p = 0.0024, respectively) but did not differ from those of pT4a patients (70.6%, p = 0.5799 and 52.0%, p = 0.1116, respectively). Multivariate analysis revealed that the ELI was the strongest independent risk factor for recurrence and CRC-specific death (p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

A better understanding of the ELI allows us to reconsider the diagnostic discrepancy of serosal invasion, i.e., pT3b should be considered pT4a. The ELI-based subclassification of pT3 is expected to be incorporated into the TNM staging system in the future. The ELI is a notable prognostic indicator in patients with pStage II CRC.

Identification of an Objective Cut-Off Point to Define the Clinical Stage T4a in Colon Cancer

Introduction: The current state of pathology practice and the variability in diagnosing pT4a colon cancer have been underexplored in existing studies. Our objective was to establish a specific cutoff point to distinguish between the pathological stages of pT3 and pT4a in colon cancer. Methods: We conducted a cross-sectional study involving pT3 and pT4 (pN0-2, cM0) colon cancers, measuring the distance to the serosa. Patients were categorized and analyzed based on this distance and the peritoneal reaction, with the aim being to ascertain their prognostic implications. Results: A total of 384 patients were analyzed. Patients with a distance between the invading front of cancer and the serosa ≥ 1 mm without a peritoneal reaction exhibited a median survival of 118 months, contrasting the amount of 70 months for those with <1 mm plus peritoneal reaction. Only lengths <1 mm with peritoneal reaction showed a significant correlation with mortality (p < 0.001). Conclusion: Our study revealed that patients in whom neoplastic cells were less than 1 mm from the serosal surface, accompanied by a peritoneal reaction (hemorrhage, inflammation, neovascularization, fibrin), had significantly lower survival rates compared to those with more than 1 mm distance and without peritoneal response (70 vs. 118 months, p < 0.001). Hence, such cases should be considered within the pT4a stage.

Assessment of Elastic Laminal Invasion Contributes to an Objective pT3 Subclassification in Colon Cancer

The extent of tumor spread influences on the clinical outcome, and which determine T stage of colorectal cancer. However, pathologic discrimination between pT3 and pT4a in the eighth edition of the American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC)-TNM stage is subjective, and more objective discrimination method for deeply invasive advanced colon cancer is mandatory for standardized patient management. Peritoneal elastic laminal invasion (ELI) detected using elastic staining may increase the objective discrimination of deeply invasive advanced colon cancer. In this study, we constructed ELI study group to investigate feasibility, objectivity, and prognostic utility of ELI. Furthermore, pT classification using ELI was investigated based on these data. At first, concordance study investigated objectivity using 60 pT3 and pT4a colon cancers. Simultaneously, a multi-institutional retrospective study was performed to assess ELI's prognostic utility in 1202 colon cancer cases from 6 institutions. In the concordance study, objectivity, represented by κ, was higher in the ELI assessment than in pT classification. In the multi-institutional retrospective study, elastic staining revealed that ELI was a strong prognostic factor. The clinical outcome of pT3 cases with ELI was significantly and consistently worse than that of those without ELI. pT classification into pT3 without ELI, pT3 with ELI, and pT4a was an independent prognostic factor. In this study, we revealed that ELI is an objective method for discriminating deeply invasive advanced colon cancer. Based on its feasibility, objectivity, and prognostic utility, ELI can subdivide pT3 lesions into pT3a (without ELI) and pT3b (with ELI).

The measured distance between tumor cells and the peritoneal surface predicts the risk of peritoneal metastases and offers an objective means to differentiate between pT3 and pT4a colon cancer

Substantial variability exists in what pathologists consider as pT4a in colorectal cancer when tumor cells are within 1 mm of the free peritoneal surface. This study aimed to determine if the measured sub-millimeter distance between tumor cells and the free peritoneal surface would offer an objective means of stratifying patients according to the risk of developing peritoneal metastases. Histological slides of patients included in the COLOPEC trial, with resectable primary c/pT4N0-2M0 colon cancer, were centrally reassessed. Specific tumor morphological variables were collected, including distance from tumor to free peritoneal surface, measured in micrometers (µm). The primary outcome, 3-year peritoneal metastasis rate, was compared between four groups of patients stratified for relation of tumor cells to the peritoneum: 1) Full peritoneal penetration with tumor cells on the peritoneal surface, 2) 0-99 µm distance to the peritoneum, 3) 100-999 µm to the peritoneum, and 4) ≥1000 µm to the peritoneum, by using Kaplan-Meier analysis. In total, 189 cases were included in the present analysis. Cases with full peritoneal penetration (n = 89), 0-99 µm distance to the peritoneal surface (n = 34), 100-999 µm distance (n = 33), and ≥1000 µm distance (n = 33), showed significantly different 3-year peritoneal metastases rates of 25% vs 29% vs 6% vs 12%, respectively (Log Rank, p = 0.044). N-category did not influence the risk of peritoneal metastases in patients with a tumor distance beyond 100 µm, while only the N2 category seemed to result in an additive risk in patients with a distance of 0-99 µm. The findings of this study suggest that the measured shortest distance between tumor cells and the free peritoneal surface is useful as an objective means of stratifying patients according to the risk of developing peritoneal metastases. This simple measurement is practical and may help in providing a precise definition of pT4a. Trial registration: NCT02231086 (Clinicaltrials.gov).

Pathology and Prognosis of Colonic Adenocarcinomas With Intermediate Primary Tumor Stage Between pT2 and pT3

CONTEXT.—

Primary tumor stage (pT) is an important prognostic indicator in colonic adenocarcinomas; however, cases that have no muscle fibers beyond the advancing tumor edge but also show no extension beyond the apparent outer border of muscularis propria (termed pT2int), have not been previously studied.

OBJECTIVE.—

To address the clinicopathologic characteristics and prognosis of pT2int tumors.

DESIGN.—

We recharacterized 168 colon carcinomas and compared pT2int cases to bona fide pT2 and pT3 tumors.

RESULTS.—

In side-by-side analysis, 21 pT2int cases diverged from 29 pT2 tumors only in terms of larger size (P = .03), but they were less likely to show high-grade (P = .03), lymphovascular (P < .001), and extramural venous invasion (P = .04); discontinuous tumor deposits (P = .02); lymph node involvement (P = .001); and advanced stage (P = .001), compared with 118 pT3 tumors. Combining pT2int with pT2 cases (versus pT3) was a better independent predictor of negative lymph nodes in multivariate analysis (P = .04; odds ratio [OR], 3.96; CI, 1.09-14.42) and absent distant metastasis in univariate analysis (P = .04), compared with sorting pT2int with pT3 cases (versus pT2). Proportional hazards regression showed that pT2 and pT2int cases together were associated with better disease-free survival compared with pT3 tumors (P = .04; OR, 3.65; CI, 1.05-12.70). Kaplan-Meier analysis demonstrated that when pT2int were grouped with pT2 tumors, they were significantly less likely to show disease progression compared with pT3 (P = .002; log-rank test) and showed a trend toward better disease-specific survival (P = .06), during a mean patient follow-up of 44.9 months.

CONCLUSIONS.—

These data support the conclusion that pT2int carcinomas have clinicopathologic characteristics and are associated with patient outcomes more closely aligned with pT2 rather than pT3 tumors.