Teasing apart trauma: neural oscillations differentiate individual cases of mild traumatic brain injury from post-traumatic stress disorder even when symptoms overlap

Long-term resting EEG correlates of repetitive mild traumatic brain injury and loss of consciousness: alterations in alpha-beta power

Objective

Long-term changes to EEG spectra after mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI, i.e., concussion) have been reported; however, the role of injury characteristics in long-term EEG changes is unclear. It is also unclear how any chronic EEG changes may underlie either subjective or objective cognitive difficulties, which might help explain the variability in recovery after mTBI.

Methods

This study included resting-state high-density electroencephalography (EEG) and mTBI injury data from 340 service members and veterans collected on average 11 years after injury as well as measures of objective and subjective cognitive functioning. The average absolute power within standard bands was computed across 11 spatial regions of the scalp. To determine how variation in brain function was accounted for by injury characteristics and aspects of cognition, we used regression analyses to investigate how EEG power was predicted by mTBI history characteristics [number, number with post-traumatic amnesia and witnessed loss of consciousness (PTA + LOC), context of injury (combat or non-combat), potentially concussive blast exposures], subjective complaints (TBIQOL General Cognitive and Executive Function Concerns), and cognitive performance (NIH Toolbox Fluid Intelligence and premorbid IQ).

Results

Post-traumatic amnesia (PTA) and loss of consciousness (LOC), poorer cognitive performance, and combat experience were associated with reduced power in beta frequencies. Executive function complaints, lower premorbid IQ, poorer cognitive performance, and higher psychological distress symptoms were associated with greater power of delta frequencies. Multiple regression confirmed the relationship between PTA + LOC, poor cognitive performance, cognitive complaints, and reduced power in beta frequencies and revealed that repetitive mTBI was associated with a higher power in alpha and beta frequencies. By contrast, neither dichotomous classification of the presence and absence of mTBI history nor blast exposures showed a relationship with EEG power variables.

Conclusion

Long-term alterations in resting EEG spectra measures of brain function do not appear to reflect any lasting effect of a history of mTBI or blast exposures. However, power in higher frequencies reflects both injury characteristics and subjective and objective cognitive difficulties, while power in lower frequencies is related to cognitive functions and psychological distress associated with poor long-term outcomes after mTBI.

Contextual Effects of Traumatic Brain Injury on the Connectome: Differential Effects of Deployment- and Non-Deployment-Acquired Injuries

OBJECTIVE

To identify differential effects of mild traumatic brain injury (TBI) occurring in a deployment or nondeployment setting on the functional brain connectome.

SETTING

Veterans Affairs Medical Center.

PARTICIPANTS

In total, 181 combat-exposed veterans of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan (n = 74 with deployment-related mild TBI, average time since injury = 11.0 years, SD = 4.1).

DESIGN

Cross-sectional observational study.

MAIN MEASURES

Mid-Atlantic MIRECC (Mid-Atlantic Mental Illness Research, Education, and Clinical Center) Assessment of TBI, Clinician-Administered PTSD Scale, connectome metrics.

RESULTS

Linear regression adjusting for relevant covariates demonstrates a significant (P < .05 corrected) association between deployment mild TBI with reduced global efficiency (nonstandardized β = -.011) and degree of the K-core (nonstandardized β = -.79). Nondeployment mild TBI was significantly associated with a reduced number of modules within the connectome (nonstandardized β = -2.32). Finally, the interaction between deployment and nondeployment mild TBIs was significantly (P < .05 corrected) associated with increased mean (nonstandardized β = 9.92) and mode (nonstandardized β = 14.02) frequency at which connections occur.

CONCLUSIONS

These results demonstrate distinct effects of mild TBI on the functional brain connectome when sustained in a deployment versus nondeployment context. This is consistent with findings demonstrating differential effects in other areas such as psychiatric diagnoses and severity, pain, sleep, and cognitive function. Furthermore, participants were an average of 11 years postinjury, suggesting these represent chronic effects of the injury. Overall, these findings add to the growing body of evidence, suggesting the effects of mild TBI acquired during deployment are different and potentially longer lasting than those of mild TBI acquired in a nondeployment context.