Structural and mechanistic analysis of a tripartite ATP-independent periplasmic TRAP transporter

Nanodiscs remain indispensable for Cryo-EM studies of membrane proteins

Nanodiscs, small discoidal membrane patches stabilized by membrane-scaffold proteins (MSPs), are popular tools to stabilize integral membrane proteins (IMPs) for structural studies by cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM). While nanodiscs provide a near-native membrane environment for the incorporated IMPs, they do not reproduce all characteristics of a native membrane. Also, IMPs must first be purified in detergent before they can be reconstituted into MSP-based nanodiscs, a problem that has been overcome by newer approaches, such as copolymer-based native nanodiscs and cell-derived vesicles. In this review, we argue that despite these advances, MSP-based nanodiscs remain a unique tool for the structural interrogation of IMPs.

Molecular determinants of Neu5Ac binding to a tripartite ATP independent periplasmic (TRAP) transporter

N -Acetylneuraminic acid (Neu5Ac) is a negatively charged nine-carbon amino sugar that is often the peripheral sugar in human cell-surface glycoconjugates. Some bacteria scavenge, import, and metabolize Neu5Ac or redeploy it on their cell surfaces for immune evasion. The import of Neu5Ac by many bacteria is mediated by tripartite ATP-independent periplasmic (TRAP) transporters. We have previously reported the structures of SiaQM, a membrane-embedded component of the Haemophilus influenzae TRAP transport system, (Currie et al., 2024). However, none of the published structures contain Neu5Ac bound to SiaQM. This information is critical for defining the transport mechanism and for further structure-activity relationship studies. Here, we report the structures of Fusobacterium nucleatum SiaQM with and without Neu5Ac. Both structures are in an inward (cytoplasmic side) facing conformation. The Neu5Ac-bound structure reveals the interactions of Neu5Ac with the transporter and its relationship with the Na+ binding sites. Two of the Na+-binding sites are similar to those described previously. We identify a third metal-binding site that is further away and buried in the elevator domain. Ser300 and Ser345 interact with the C1-carboxylate group of Neu5Ac. Proteoliposome-based transport assays showed that Ser300-Neu5Ac interaction is critical for transport, whereas Ser345 is dispensable. Neu5Ac primarily interacts with residues in the elevator domain of the protein, thereby supporting the elevator with an operator mechanism. The residues interacting with Neu5Ac are conserved, providing fundamental information required to design inhibitors against this class of proteins.

Lipid Trafficking in Diverse Bacteria

Lipids are essential for life and serve as cell envelope components, signaling molecules, and nutrients. For lipids to achieve their required functions, they need to be correctly localized. This requires the action of transporter proteins and an energy source. The current understanding of bacterial lipid transporters is limited to a few classes. Given the diversity of lipid species and the predicted existence of specific lipid transporters, many more transporters await discovery and characterization. These proteins could be prime targets for modulators that control bacterial cell proliferation and pathogenesis. One overarching goal of our research is to understand the molecular mechanisms of bacterial metabolite trafficking, including lipids, and to leverage that understanding to identify or engineer inhibitory ligands. In recent years, our work has revealed two novel lipid transport systems in bacteria: bacterial sterol transporters (Bst) A, B, and C in Methylococcus capsulatus and the TatT proteins in Enhygromyxa salina and Treponema pallidum. Both systems are composed of transporters bioinformatically identified as being involved in the transport of other metabolites, but substrates were never revealed. However, the genetic colocalization of the genes encoding BstABC with sterol biosynthetic enzymes in M. capsulatus suggested that they might recognize sterols as substrates. Also, homologues of TatTs are present in diverse bacteria but are overrepresented in bacteria deficient in de novo lipid synthesis or residing in nutrient-poor environments; we reasoned that these proteins might facilitate the transport of lipids. Our efforts to reveal the substrate scope of two TatT proteins revealed their engagement with long-chain fatty acids. Enabling the discovery of the BstABC system and the TatT proteins were bioinformatic analyses, quantitative measurements of protein-ligand equilibrium affinities, and high-resolution structural studies that provided remarkable insights into ligand binding cavities and the structural basis for ligand interaction. These approaches, in particular our bioinformatics and structural work, highlighted the diversity of protein sequence and structures amenable to lipid engagement. These observations allowed the hypothesis that lipid handling proteins, in general and especially so in the bacterial domain, can have diverse amino acid compositions and three-dimensional structures. As such, bioinformatics geared at identifying them in poorly characterized genomes is likely to miss many candidates that diverge from well-characterized family members. This realization spurred efforts to understand the unifying features in all of the lipid handling proteins we have characterized to date. To do this, we inspected the ligand binding sites of the proteins: they were remarkably hydrophobic and sometimes displayed a dichotomy of hydrophobic and hydrophilic amino acids, akin to the ligands that they accommodate in those cavities. Because of this, we reasoned that the physicochemical features of ligand binding cavities could be accurate predictors of a protein's propensity to bind lipids. This finding was leveraged to create structure-based lipid-interacting pocket predictor (SLiPP), a machine-learning algorithm capable of identifying ligand cavities with physico-chemical features consistent with those of known lipid binding sites. SLiPP is especially useful in poorly annotated genomes (such as with bacterial pathogens), where it could reveal candidate proteins to be targeted for the development of antimicrobials.

On the function of TRAP substrate-binding proteins: the isethionate-specific binding protein IseP

Bacteria evolve mechanisms to compete for limited resources and survive in new niches. Here we study the mechanism of isethionate import from the sulfate-reducing bacterium Oleidesulfovibrio alaskensis. The catabolism of isethionate by Desulfovibrio species has been implicated in human disease, due to hydrogen sulfide production, and has potential for industrial applications. O. alaskensis employs a tripartite ATP-independent periplasmic (TRAP) transporter (OaIsePQM) to import isethionate, which relies on the substrate-binding protein (OaIseP) to scavenge isethionate and deliver it to the membrane transporter component (OaIseQM) for import into the cell. We determined the binding affinity of isethionate to OaIseP by isothermal titration calorimetry, KD = 0.95 µM (68% CI = 0.6-1.4 µM), which is weaker compared with other TRAP substrate-binding proteins. The X-ray crystal structures of OaIseP in the ligand-free and isethionate-bound forms were obtained and showed that in the presence of isethionate, OaIseP adopts a closed conformation whereby two domains of the protein fold over the substrate. We serendipitously discovered two crystal forms with sulfonate-containing buffers (HEPES and MES) bound in the isethionate-binding site. However, these do not evoke domain closure, presumably because of the larger ligand size. Together, our data elucidate the molecular details of how a TRAP substrate-binding protein binds a sulfonate-containing substrate, rather than a typical carboxylate-containing substrate. These results may inform future antibiotic development to target TRAP transporters and provide insights into protein engineering of TRAP transporter substrate-binding proteins.

Structure and selectivity of a glutamate-specific TAXI TRAP binding protein from Vibrio cholerae

Tripartite ATP-independent periplasmic (TRAP) transporters are widespread in prokaryotes and are responsible for the transport of a variety of different ligands, primarily organic acids. TRAP transporters can be divided into two subclasses; DctP-type and TAXI type, which share the same overall architecture and substrate-binding protein requirement. DctP-type transporters are very well studied and have been shown to transport a range of compounds including dicarboxylates, keto acids, and sugar acids. However, TAXI-type transporters are relatively poorly understood. To address this gap in our understanding, we have structurally and biochemically characterized VC0430 from Vibrio cholerae. We show it is a monomeric, high affinity glutamate-binding protein, which we thus rename VcGluP. VcGluP is stereoselective, binding the L-isomer preferentially, and can also bind L-glutamine and L-pyroglutamate with lower affinity. Structural characterization of ligand-bound VcGluP revealed details of its binding site and biophysical characterization of binding site mutants revealed the substrate binding determinants, which differ substantially from those of DctP-type TRAPs. Finally, we have analyzed the interaction between VcGluP and its cognate membrane component, VcGluQM (formerly VC0429) in silico, revealing an architecture hitherto unseen. To our knowledge, this is the first transporter in V. cholerae to be identified as specific to glutamate, which plays a key role in the osmoadaptation of V. cholerae, making this transporter a potential therapeutic target.

Allosteric substrate release by a sialic acid TRAP transporter substrate binding protein

The tripartite ATP-independent periplasmic (TRAP) transporters enable Vibrio cholerae and Haemophilus influenzae to acquire sialic acid, aiding their colonization of human hosts. This process depends on SiaP, a substrate-binding protein (SBP) that captures and delivers sialic acid to the transporter. We identified 11 nanobodies that bind specifically to the SiaP proteins from H. influenzae (HiSiaP) and V. cholerae (VcSiaP). Two nanobodies inhibited sialic acid binding. Detailed structural and biophysical studies of one nanobody-SBP complex revealed an allosteric inhibition mechanism, preventing ligand binding and releasing pre-bound sialic acid. A hydrophobic surface pocket of the SBP is crucial for the allosteric mechanism and for the conformational rearrangement that occurs upon binding of sialic acid to the SBP. Our findings provide new clues regarding the mechanism of TRAP transporters, as well as potential starting points for novel drug design approaches to starve these human pathogens of important host-derived molecules.

The ultra-high affinity transport proteins of ubiquitous marine bacteria

SAR11 bacteria are the most abundant microorganisms in the surface ocean1 and have global biogeochemical importance2-4. To thrive in their competitive oligotrophic environment, these bacteria rely heavily on solute-binding proteins that facilitate uptake of specific substrates via membrane transporters5,6. The functions and properties of these transport proteins are key factors in the assimilation of dissolved organic matter and biogeochemical cycling of nutrients in the ocean, but they have remained largely inaccessible to experimental investigation. Here we performed genome-wide experimental characterization of all solute-binding proteins in a prototypical SAR11 bacterium, revealing specific functions and general trends in their properties that contribute to the success of SAR11 bacteria in oligotrophic environments. We found that the solute-binding proteins of SAR11 bacteria have extremely high binding affinity (dissociation constant >20 pM) and high binding specificity, revealing molecular mechanisms of oligotrophic adaptation. Our functional data have uncovered new carbon sources for SAR11 bacteria and enable accurate biogeographical analysis of SAR11 substrate uptake capabilities throughout the ocean. This study provides a comprehensive view of the substrate uptake capabilities of ubiquitous marine bacteria, providing a necessary foundation for understanding their contribution to assimilation of dissolved organic matter in marine ecosystems.

On the function of TRAP substrate-binding proteins: Conformational variation of the sialic acid binding protein SiaP

Tripartite ATP-independent periplasmic (TRAP) transporters are analogous to ABC transporters in that they use a substrate-binding protein to scavenge metabolites (e.g., N-acetylneuraminate) and deliver them to the membrane components for import. TRAP substrate-binding proteins are thought to bind the substrate using a two-state (open and closed) induced-fit mechanism. We solved the structure of the TRAP N-acetylneuraminate substrate-binding protein from Aggregatibacter actinomycetemcomitans (AaSiaP) in both the open ligand-free and closed liganded conformations. Surprisingly, we also observed an intermediate conformation, where AaSiaP is mostly closed and is bound to a non-cognate ligand, acetate, which hints at how N-acetylneuraminate binding stabilizes a fully closed state. AaSiaP preferentially binds N-acetylneuraminate (KD = 0.4 μM) compared to N-glycolylneuraminate (KD = 4.4 μM), which is explained by the closed-N-acetylneuraminate bound structure. Small-angle X-ray scattering data alongside molecular dynamics simulations suggest the AaSiaP adopts a more open state in solution than in a crystal. However, the open unliganded conformation can also sample closed conformations. Molecular dynamics simulations also demonstrate the importance of water molecules for stabilizing the closed conformation. Although our data is consistent with an induced fit model of binding, we suggest that the open unliganded conformation may sample multiple states capable of binding substrate. The mechanism by which the ligand is released for import remains to be determined.

Many locks to one key: N-acetylneuraminic acid binding to proteins

Sialic acids play crucial roles in cell surface glycans of both eukaryotic and prokaryotic organisms, mediating various biological processes, including cell-cell interactions, development, immune response, oncogenesis and host-pathogen interactions. This review focuses on the β-anomeric form of N-acetylneuraminic acid (Neu5Ac), particularly its binding affinity towards various proteins, as elucidated by solved protein structures. Specifically, we delve into the binding mechanisms of Neu5Ac to proteins involved in sequestering and transporting Neu5Ac in Gram-negative bacteria, with implications for drug design targeting these proteins as antimicrobial agents. Unlike the initial assumptions, structural analyses revealed significant variability in the Neu5Ac binding pockets among proteins, indicating diverse evolutionary origins and binding modes. By comparing these findings with existing structures from other systems, we can effectively highlight the intricate relationship between protein structure and Neu5Ac recognition, emphasizing the need for tailored drug design strategies to inhibit Neu5Ac-binding proteins across bacterial species.

Cryo-EM Map Anisotropy Can Be Attenuated by Map Post-Processing and a New Method for Its Estimation

One of the most important challenges in cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) is the substantial number of samples that exhibit preferred orientations, which leads to an uneven coverage of the projection sphere. As a result, the overall quality of the reconstructed maps can be severely affected, as manifested by the presence of anisotropy in the map resolution. Several methods have been proposed to measure the directional resolution of maps in tandem with experimental protocols to address the problem of preferential orientations in cryo-EM. Following these works, in this manuscript we identified one potential limitation that may affect most of the existing methods and we proposed an alternative approach to evaluate the presence of preferential orientations in cryo-EM reconstructions. In addition, we also showed that some of the most recently proposed cryo-EM map post-processing algorithms can attenuate map anisotropy, thus offering alternative visualization opportunities for cases affected by moderate levels of preferential orientations.

Characterisation of anhydro-sialic acid transporters from mucosa-associated bacteria

Sialic acid (Sia) transporters are critical to the capacity of host-associated bacteria to utilise Sia for growth and/or cell surface modification. While N-acetyl-neuraminic acid (Neu5Ac)-specific transporters have been studied extensively, little is known on transporters dedicated to anhydro-Sia forms such as 2,7-anhydro-Neu5Ac (2,7-AN) or 2,3-dehydro-2-deoxy-Neu5Ac (Neu5Ac2en). Here, we used a Sia-transport-null strain of Escherichia coli to investigate the function of members of anhydro-Sia transporter families previously identified by computational studies. First, we showed that the transporter NanG, from the Glycoside-Pentoside-Hexuronide:cation symporter family, is a specific 2,7-AN transporter, and identified by mutagenesis a crucial functional residue within the putative substrate-binding site. We then demonstrated that NanX transporters, of the Major Facilitator Superfamily, also only transport 2,7-AN and not Neu5Ac2en nor Neu5Ac. Finally, we provided evidence that SiaX transporters, of the Sodium-Solute Symporter superfamily, are promiscuous Neu5Ac/Neu5Ac2en transporters able to acquire either substrate equally well. The characterisation of anhydro-Sia transporters expands our current understanding of prokaryotic Sia metabolism within host-associated microbial communities.

Structural and biophysical analysis of a Haemophilus influenzae tripartite ATP-independent periplasmic (TRAP) transporter

Tripartite ATP-independent periplasmic (TRAP) transporters are secondary-active transporters that receive their substrates via a soluble-binding protein to move bioorganic acids across bacterial or archaeal cell membranes. Recent cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) structures of TRAP transporters provide a broad framework to understand how they work, but the mechanistic details of transport are not yet defined. Here we report the cryo-EM structure of the Haemophilus influenzae N-acetylneuraminate TRAP transporter (HiSiaQM) at 2.99 Å resolution (extending to 2.2 Å at the core), revealing new features. The improved resolution (the previous HiSiaQM structure is 4.7 Å resolution) permits accurate assignment of two Na+ sites and the architecture of the substrate-binding site, consistent with mutagenic and functional data. Moreover, rather than a monomer, the HiSiaQM structure is a homodimer. We observe lipids at the dimer interface, as well as a lipid trapped within the fusion that links the SiaQ and SiaM subunits. We show that the affinity (KD) for the complex between the soluble HiSiaP protein and HiSiaQM is in the micromolar range and that a related SiaP can bind HiSiaQM. This work provides key data that enhances our understanding of the 'elevator-with-an-operator' mechanism of TRAP transporters.

TRAPs: the 'elevator-with-an-operator' mechanism

Tripartite ATP-independent periplasmic (TRAP) transporters are nutrient-uptake systems found in bacteria and archaea. These evolutionary divergent transporter systems couple a substrate-binding protein (SBP) to an elevator-type secondary transporter, which is a first-of-its-kind mechanism of transport. Here, we highlight breakthrough TRAP transporter structures and recent functional data that probe the mechanism of transport. Furthermore, we discuss recent structural and biophysical studies of the ion transporter superfamily (ITS) members and highlight mechanistic principles that are relevant for further exploration of the TRAP transporter system.

Ion and lipid orchestration of secondary active transport

Transporting small molecules across cell membranes is an essential process in cell physiology. Many structurally diverse, secondary active transporters harness transmembrane electrochemical gradients of ions to power the uptake or efflux of nutrients, signalling molecules, drugs and other ions across cell membranes. Transporters reside in lipid bilayers on the interface between two aqueous compartments, where they are energized and regulated by symported, antiported and allosteric ions on both sides of the membrane and the membrane bilayer itself. Here we outline the mechanisms by which transporters couple ion and solute fluxes and discuss how structural and mechanistic variations enable them to meet specific physiological needs and adapt to environmental conditions. We then consider how general bilayer properties and specific lipid binding modulate transporter activity. Together, ion gradients and lipid properties ensure the effective transport, regulation and distribution of small molecules across cell membranes.

Conformational coupling of the sialic acid TRAP transporter HiSiaQM with its substrate binding protein HiSiaP

The tripartite ATP-independent periplasmic (TRAP) transporters use an extra cytoplasmic substrate binding protein (SBP) to transport a wide variety of substrates in bacteria and archaea. The SBP can adopt an open- or closed state depending on the presence of substrate. The two transmembrane domains of TRAP transporters form a monomeric elevator whose function is strictly dependent on the presence of a sodium ion gradient. Insights from experimental structures, structural predictions and molecular modeling have suggested a conformational coupling between the membrane elevator and the substrate binding protein. Here, we use a disulfide engineering approach to lock the TRAP transporter HiSiaPQM from Haemophilus influenzae in different conformational states. The SBP, HiSiaP, is locked in its substrate-bound form and the transmembrane elevator, HiSiaQM, is locked in either its assumed inward- or outward-facing states. We characterize the disulfide-locked constructs and use single-molecule total internal reflection fluorescence (TIRF) microscopy to study their interactions. Our experiments demonstrate that the SBP and the transmembrane elevator are indeed conformationally coupled, meaning that the open and closed state of the SBP recognize specific conformational states of the transporter and vice versa.

Lipid packing is disrupted in copolymeric nanodiscs compared with intact membranes

Discoidal lipid-protein nanoparticles known as nanodiscs are widely used tools in structural and membrane biology. Amphipathic, synthetic copolymers have recently become an attractive alternative to membrane scaffold proteins for the formation of nanodiscs. Such copolymers can directly intercalate into, and form nanodiscs from, intact membranes without detergents. Although these copolymer nanodiscs can extract native membrane lipids, it remains unclear whether native membrane properties are also retained. To determine the extent to which bilayer lipid packing is retained in nanodiscs, we measured the behavior of packing-sensitive fluorescent dyes in various nanodisc preparations compared with intact lipid bilayers. We analyzed styrene-maleic acid (SMA), diisobutylene-maleic acid (DIBMA), and polymethacrylate (PMA) as nanodisc scaffolds at various copolymer-to-lipid ratios and temperatures. Measurements of Laurdan spectral shifts revealed that dimyristoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DMPC) nanodiscs had increased lipid headgroup packing compared with large unilamellar vesicles (LUVs) above the lipid melting temperature for all three copolymers. Similar effects were observed for DMPC nanodiscs stabilized by membrane scaffolding protein MSP1E1. Increased lipid headgroup packing was also observed when comparing nanodiscs with intact membranes composed of binary mixtures of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-phosphocholine (POPC) and di-palmitoyl-phosphocholine (DPPC), which show fluid-gel-phase coexistence. Similarly, Laurdan reported increased headgroup packing in nanodiscs for biomimetic mixtures containing cholesterol, most notable for relatively disordered membranes. The magnitudes of these ordering effects were not identical for the various copolymers, with SMA being the most and DIBMA being the least perturbing. Finally, nanodiscs derived from mammalian cell membranes showed similarly increased lipid headgroup packing. We conclude that nanodiscs generally do not completely retain the physical properties of intact membranes.

Membrane-anchored substrate binding proteins are deployed in secondary TAXI transporters

Substrate-binding proteins (SBPs) are part of solute transport systems and serve to increase substrate affinity and uptake rates. In contrast to primary transport systems, the mechanism of SBP-dependent secondary transport is not well understood. Functional studies have thus far focused on Na⁺-coupled Tripartite ATP-independent periplasmic (TRAP) transporters for sialic acid. Herein, we report the in vitro functional characterization of TAXIPm-PQM from the human pathogen Proteus mirabilis. TAXIPm-PQM belongs to a TRAP-subfamily using a different type of SBP, designated TRAP-associated extracytoplasmic immunogenic (TAXI) protein. TAXIPm-PQM catalyzes proton-dependent α-ketoglutarate symport and its SBP is an essential component of the transport mechanism. Importantly, TAXIPm-PQM represents the first functionally characterized SBP-dependent secondary transporter that does not rely on a soluble SBP, but uses a membrane-anchored SBP instead.

Structure and mechanism of a tripartite ATP-independent periplasmic TRAP transporter

In bacteria and archaea, tripartite ATP-independent periplasmic (TRAP) transporters uptake essential nutrients. TRAP transporters receive their substrates via a secreted soluble substrate-binding protein. How a sodium ion-driven secondary active transporter is strictly coupled to a substrate-binding protein is poorly understood. Here we report the cryo-EM structure of the sialic acid TRAP transporter SiaQM from Photobacterium profundum at 2.97 Å resolution. SiaM comprises a "transport" domain and a "scaffold" domain, with the transport domain consisting of helical hairpins as seen in the sodium ion-coupled elevator transporter VcINDY. The SiaQ protein forms intimate contacts with SiaM to extend the size of the scaffold domain, suggesting that TRAP transporters may operate as monomers, rather than the typically observed oligomers for elevator-type transporters. We identify the Na⁺ and sialic acid binding sites in SiaM and demonstrate a strict dependence on the substrate-binding protein SiaP for uptake. We report the SiaP crystal structure that, together with docking studies, suggest the molecular basis for how sialic acid is delivered to the SiaQM transporter complex. We thus propose a model for substrate transport by TRAP proteins, which we describe herein as an 'elevator-with-an-operator' mechanism.

Biochemical and structural basis of sialic acid utilization by gut microbes

The human gastrointestinal (GI) tract harbors diverse microbial communities collectively known as the gut microbiota that exert a profound impact on human health and disease. The repartition and availability of sialic acid derivatives in the gut have a significant impact on the modulation of gut microbes and host susceptibility to infection and inflammation. Although N-acetylneuraminic acid (Neu5Ac) is the main form of sialic acids in humans, the sialic acid family regroups more than 50 structurally and chemically distinct modified derivatives. In the GI tract, sialic acids are found in the terminal location of mucin glycan chains constituting the mucus layer and also come from human milk oligosaccharides in the infant gut or from meat-based foods in adults. The repartition of sialic acid in the GI tract influences the gut microbiota composition and pathogen colonization. In this review, we provide an update on the mechanisms underpinning sialic acid utilization by gut microbes, focusing on sialidases, transporters, and metabolic enzymes.