Functional constraints on adaptive evolution of protein ubiquitination sites

Molecular Mechanisms Underlying Vertebrate Adaptive Evolution: A Systematic Review

Adaptive evolution is a process in which variation that confers an evolutionary advantage in a specific environmental context arises and is propagated through a population. When investigating this process, researchers have mainly focused on describing advantageous phenotypes or putative advantageous genotypes. A recent increase in molecular data accessibility and technological advances has allowed researchers to go beyond description and to make inferences about the mechanisms underlying adaptive evolution. In this systematic review, we discuss articles from 2016 to 2022 that investigated or reviewed the molecular mechanisms underlying adaptive evolution in vertebrates in response to environmental variation. Regulatory elements within the genome and regulatory proteins involved in either gene expression or cellular pathways have been shown to play key roles in adaptive evolution in response to most of the discussed environmental factors. Gene losses were suggested to be associated with an adaptive response in some contexts. Future adaptive evolution research could benefit from more investigations focused on noncoding regions of the genome, gene regulation mechanisms, and gene losses potentially yielding advantageous phenotypes. Investigating how novel advantageous genotypes are conserved could also contribute to our knowledge of adaptive evolution.

Discerning evolutionary trends in post-translational modification and the effect of intrinsic disorder: Analysis of methylation, acetylation and ubiquitination sites in human proteins

Intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs) of proteins play significant biological functional roles despite lacking a well-defined 3D structure. For example, IDRs provide efficient housing for large numbers of post-translational modification (PTM) sites in eukaryotic proteins. Here, we study the distribution of more than 15,000 experimentally determined human methylation, acetylation and ubiquitination sites (collectively termed 'MAU' sites) in ordered and disordered regions, and analyse their conservation across 380 eukaryotic species. Conservation signals for the maintenance and novel emergence of MAU sites are examined at 11 evolutionary levels from the whole eukaryotic domain down to the ape superfamily, in both ordered and disordered regions. We discover that MAU PTM is a major driver of conservation for arginines and lysines in both ordered and disordered regions, across the 11 levels, most significantly across the mammalian clade. Conservation of human methylatable arginines is very strongly favoured for ordered regions rather than for disordered, whereas methylatable lysines are conserved in either set of regions, and conservation of acetylatable and ubiquitinatable lysines is favoured in disordered over ordered. Notably, we find evidence for the emergence of new lysine MAU sites in disordered regions of proteins in deuterostomes and mammals, and in ordered regions after the dawn of eutherians. For histones specifically, MAU sites demonstrate an idiosyncratic significant conservation pattern that is evident since the last common ancestor of mammals. Similarly, folding-on-binding (FB) regions are highly enriched for MAU sites relative to either ordered or disordered regions, with ubiquitination sites in FBs being highly conserved at all evolutionary levels back as far as mammals. This investigation clearly demonstrates the complex patterns of PTM evolution across the human proteome and that it is necessary to consider conservation of sequence features at multiple evolutionary levels in order not to get an incomplete or misleading picture.

Loss of conserved ubiquitylation sites in conserved proteins during human evolution

Ubiquitylation of lysine residues in proteins serves a pivotal role in the efficient removal of misfolded or unused proteins and in the control of various regulatory pathways by monitoring protein activity that may lead to protein degradation. The loss of ubiquitylated lysines may affect the ubiquitin‑mediated regulatory network and result in the emergence of novel phenotypes. The present study analyzed mouse ubiquitylation data and orthologous proteins from 62 mammals to identify 193 conserved ubiquitylation sites from 169 proteins that were lost in the Euarchonta lineage leading to humans. A total of 8 proteins, including betaine homocysteine S‑methyltransferase, clin and CBS domain divalent metal cation transport mediator 3, ribosome‑binding protein 1 and solute carrier family 37 member 4, lost 1 conserved lysine residue, which was ubiquitylated in the mouse ortholog, following the human‑chimpanzee divergence. A total of 17 of the lost ubiquitylated lysines are also known to be modified by acetylation and/or succinylation in mice. In 8 cases, a novel lysine evolved at positions flanking the lost conserved lysine residues, potentially as a method of compensation. We hypothesize that the loss of ubiquitylation sites during evolution may lead to the development of advantageous phenotypes, which are then fixed by selection. The ancestral ubiquitylation sites identified in the present study may be a useful resource for investigating the association between loss of ubiquitylation sites and the emergence of novel phenotypes during evolution towards modern humans.