Ligand effect on the NMR, vibrational and structural properties of tetra- and hexanuclear ruthenium hydrido clusters: a theoretical investigation

Supramolecular nanocapsules as two-fold stabilizers of outer-cavity sub-nanometric Ru NPs and inner-cavity ultra-small Ru clusters

The synthesis of metallic nanoparticles (MNP) with high surface area and controlled shape is of paramount importance to increase their catalytic performance. The detailed growing process of NP is mostly unknown and understanding the specific steps would pave the way for a rational synthesis of the desired MNP. Here we take advantage of the stabilization properties exerted by the tetragonal prismatic supramolecular nanocapsule 8·(BArF)₈ to develop a synthetic methodology for sub-nanometric RuNP (0.6-0.7 nm). The catalytic properties of these sub-nanometric nanoparticles were tested on the hydrogenation of styrene, obtaining excellent selectivity for the hydrogenation of the alkene moiety. In addition, the encapsulation of [Ru₅] clusters inside the nanocapsule is strikingly observed in most of the experimental conditions, as ascertained by HR-MS. Moreover, a thorough DFT study enlightens the nature of the [Ru₅] clusters as tb-Ru₅H₂(η⁶-PhH)₂(η⁶-pyz)₃ (2) trapped by two arene moieties of the clip, or as tb-Ru₅H₂(η¹-pyz)₆(η⁶-pyz)₃ (3) trapped between the two Zn-porphyrin units of the nanocapsule. Both options fulfill the Wade-Mingos counting rules, i.e. 72 CVEs for the closotb. The trapped [Ru₅] metallic clusters are proposed to be the first-grown seeds of subsequent formation of the subnanometric RuNP. Moreover, the double role of the nanocapsule in stabilising ∼0.7 nm NPs and also in hosting ultra-small Ru clusters, is unprecedented and may pave the way towards the synthesis of ultra-small metallic clusters for catalytic purposes.

A combined theoretical/experimental study highlighting the formation of carbides on Ru nanoparticles during CO hydrogenation

Formation of stable carbides during CO bond dissociation on small ruthenium nanoparticles (RuNPs) is demonstrated, both by means of DFT calculations and by solid state ¹³C NMR techniques. Theoretical calculations of chemical shifts in several model clusters are employed in order to secure experimental spectroscopic assignations for surface ruthenium carbides. Mechanistic DFT investigations, carried out on a realistic Ru₅₅ nanoparticle model (∼1 nm) in terms of size, structure and surface composition, reveal that ruthenium carbides are obtained during CO hydrogenation. Calculations also indicate that carbide formation via hydrogen-assisted hydroxymethylidyne (COH) pathways is exothermic and occurs at reasonable kinetic cost on standard sites of the RuNPs, such as 4-fold ones on flat terraces, and not only in steps as previously suggested. Another novel outcome of the DFT mechanistic study consists of the possible formation of μ₆ ruthenium carbides in the tip-B₅ site, similar examples being known only for molecular ruthenium clusters. Moreover, based on DFT energies, the possible rearrangement of the surface metal atoms around the same tip-site results in a μ-Ru atom coordinated to the remaining RuNP moiety, reminiscent of a pseudo-octahedral metal center on the NP surface.

Carboxylic acid-capped ruthenium nanoparticles: experimental and theoretical case study with ethanoic acid

Given that the properties of metal nanoparticles (NPs) depend on several parameters (namely, morphology, size, surface composition, crystalline structure, etc.), a computational model that brings a better understanding of a structure-property relationship at the nanoscale is a significant plus in order to explain the surface properties of metal NPs and also their catalytic viability, in particular, when envisaging a new stabilizing agent. In this study we combined experimental and theoretical tools to obtain a mapping of the surface of ruthenium NPs stabilized by ethanoic acid as a new capping ligand. For this purpose, the organometallic approach was applied as the synthesis method. The morphology and crystalline structure of the obtained particles was characterized by state-of-the art techniques (TEM, HRTEM, WAXS) and their surface composition was determined by various techniques (solution and solid-state NMR, IR, chemical titration, DFT calculations). DFT calculations of the vibrational features of model NPs and of the chemical shifts of model clusters allowed us to secure the spectroscopic experimental assignations. Spectroscopic data as well as DFT mechanistic studies showed that ethanoic acid lies on the metal surface as ethanoate, together with hydrogen atoms. The optimal surface composition determined by DFT calculations appeared to be ca. [0.4-0.6] H/Rusurf and 0.4 ethanoate/RuSurf, which was corroborated by experimental results. Moreover, for such a composition, a hydrogen adsorption Gibbs free energy in the range -2.0 to -3.0 kcal mol-1 was calculated, which makes these ruthenium NPs a promising nanocatalyst for the hydrogen evolution reaction in the electrolysis of water.

Computation provides chemical insight into the diverse hydride NMR chemical shifts of [Ru(NHC)4(L)H]0/+ species (NHC = N-heterocyclic carbene; L = vacant, H2, N2, CO, MeCN, O2, P4, SO2, H-, F- and Cl-) and their [Ru(R2PCH2CH2PR2)2(L)H]+ congeners

Relativistic density functional theory calculations, both with and without the effects of spin-orbit coupling, have been employed to model hydride NMR chemical shifts for a series of [Ru(NHC)₄(L)H]^0/+ species (NHC = N-heterocyclic carbene; L = vacant, H₂, N₂, CO, MeCN, O₂, P₄, SO₂, H^-, F^- and Cl^-), as well as selected phosphine analogues [Ru(R₂PCH₂CH₂PR₂)₂(L)H]⁺ (R = ⁱPr, Cy; L = vacant, O₂). Inclusion of spin-orbit coupling provides good agreement with the experimental data. For the NHC systems large variations in hydride chemical shift are shown to arise from the paramagnetic term, with high net shielding (L = vacant, Cl^-, F^-) being reinforced by the contribution from spin-orbit coupling. Natural chemical shift analysis highlights the major orbital contributions to the paramagnetic term and rationalizes trends via changes in the energies of the occupied Ru d_π orbitals and the unoccupied σ*_Ru-H orbital. In [Ru(NHC)₄(η²-O₂)H]⁺ a δ-interaction with the O₂ ligand results in a low-lying LUMO of d_π character. As a result this orbital can no longer contribute to the paramagnetic shielding, but instead provides additional deshielding via overlap with the remaining (occupied) d_π orbital under the L_z angular momentum operator. These two effects account for the unusual hydride chemical shift of +4.8 ppm observed experimentally for this species. Calculations reproduce hydride chemical shift data observed for [Ru(ⁱPr₂PCH₂CH₂PⁱPr₂)₂(η²-O₂)H]⁺ (δ = -6.2 ppm) and [Ru(R₂PCH₂CH₂PR₂)₂H]⁺ (ca. -32 ppm, R = ⁱPr, Cy). For the latter, the presence of a weak agostic interaction trans to the hydride ligand is significant, as in its absence (R = Me) calculations predict a chemical shift of -41 ppm, similar to the [Ru(NHC)₄H]⁺ analogues. Depending on the strength of the agostic interaction a variation of up to 18 ppm in hydride chemical shift is possible and this factor (that is not necessarily readily detected experimentally) can aid in the interpretation of hydride chemical shift data for nominally unsaturated hydride-containing species. The synthesis and crystallographic characterization of the BAr^F₄^- salts of [Ru(IMe₄)₄(L)H]⁺ (IMe₄ = 1,3,4,5-tetramethylimidazol-2-ylidene; L = P₄, SO₂; Ar^F = 3,5-(CF₃)₂C₆H₃) and [Ru(IMe₄)₄(Cl)H] are also reported.

Zwitterionic amidinates as effective ligands for platinum nanoparticle hydrogenation catalysts

Pt NPs covered with zwitterionic amidinates as ligands exhibit an exciting ligand effect in the hydrogenation of carbonyl groups when electron donor/acceptor groups are introduced in the N-substituents.

Ligand control of metal nanoparticles (MNPs) is rapidly gaining importance as ligands can stabilize the MNPs and regulate their catalytic properties. Herein we report the first example of Pt NPs ligated by imidazolium-amidinate ligands that bind strongly through the amidinate anion to the platinum surface atoms. The binding was established by ¹⁵N NMR spectroscopy, a precedent for nitrogen ligands on MNPs, and XPS. Both monodentate and bidentate coordination modes were found. DFT showed a high bonding energy of up to –48 kcal mol^–1 for bidentate bonding to two adjacent metal atoms, which decreased to –28 ± 4 kcal mol^–1 for monodentate bonding in the absence of impediments by other ligands. While the surface is densely covered with ligands, both IR and ¹³C MAS NMR spectra proved the adsorption of CO on the surface and thus the availability of sites for catalysis. A particle size dependent Knight shift was observed in the ¹³C MAS NMR spectra for the atoms that coordinate to the surface, but for small particles, ∼1.2 nm, it almost vanished, as theory for MNPs predicts; this had not been experimentally verified before. The Pt NPs were found to be catalysts for the hydrogenation of ketones and a notable ligand effect was observed in the hydrogenation of electron-poor carbonyl groups. The catalytic activity is influenced by remote electron donor/acceptor groups introduced in the aryl-N-substituents of the amidinates; p-anisyl groups on the ligand gave catalysts several times faster the ligand containing p-chlorophenyl groups.

Shape, electronic structure and steric effects of organometallic nanocatalysts: relevant tools to improve the synergy between theory and experiment

An integrated package that uses structural, first principles and thermodynamic approaches is expected to play a significant role in advancing our knowledge of nanocatalysts.

Theoretical characterization of the surface composition of ruthenium nanoparticles in equilibrium with syngas

A deeper understanding of the relationship between experimental reaction conditions and the surface composition of nanoparticles is crucial in order to elucidate mechanisms involved in nanocatalysis. In the framework of the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis, a resolution of this complex puzzle requires a detailed understanding of the interaction of CO and H with the surface of the catalyst. In this context, the single- and co-adsorption of CO and H to the surface of a 1 nm ruthenium nanoparticle has been investigated with density functional theory. Using several indexes (d-band center, crystal overlap Hamilton population, density of states), a systematic analysis of the bond properties and of the electronic states has also been done, in order to bring an understanding of structure/property relationships at the nanoscale. The H : CO surface composition of this ruthenium nanoparticle exposed to syngas has been evaluated according to a thermodynamic model fed with DFT energies. Such ab initio thermodynamic calculations give access to the optimal H : CO coverage values under a wide range of experimental conditions, through the construction of free energy phase diagrams. Surprisingly, under the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis experimental conditions, and in agreement with new experiments, only CO species are adsorbed at the surface of the nanoparticle. These findings shed new light on the possible reaction pathways underlying the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis, and specifically the initiation of the reaction. It is finally shown that the joint knowledge of the surface composition and energy descriptors can help to identify possible reaction intermediates.

DFT 2H quadrupolar coupling constants of ruthenium complexes: a good probe of the coordination of hydrides in conjuction with experiments

Transition metal (TM) hydrides are of great interest in chemistry because of their reactivity and their potential as catalysts for hydrogenation reactions. 2H solid-state NMR can be used in order to get information about the local environment of hydrogen atoms, and more particularly the coordination mode of hydrides in such complexes. In this work we will show that it is possible to establish at the level of density functional theory (DFT) a viable methodological strategy that allows the determination of 2H NMR parameters, namely the quadrupolar coupling constant (C(Q)) respectively the quadrupolar splitting (deltanuQ) and the asymmetry parameter (etaQ). The reliability of the method (B3PW91-DFT) and basis set effects have been first evaluated for simple organic compounds (benzene and fluorene). A good correlation between experimental and theoretical values is systematically obtained if the large basis set cc-pVTZ is used for the computations. 2H NMR properties of five mononuclear ruthenium complexes (namely Cp*RuD3(PPh3), Tp*RuD(THT)2, Tp*RuD(D2)(THT) and Tp*RuD(D2)2 and RuD2(D2)2(PCy3)2) which exhibit different ligands and hydrides involved in different coordination modes (terminal-H or eta2-H2), have been calculated and compared to previous experimental data. The results obtained are in excellent agreement with experiments. Although 2H NMR spectra are not always easy to analyze, assistance by quantum chemistry calculations allows unambiguous assignment of the signals of such spectra. As far as experiments can be achieved at very low temperatures in order to avoid dynamic effects, this hybrid theoretical/experimental tool may give useful insights in the context of the characterization of ruthenium surfaces or nanoparticles with solid-state NMR.