Hidden symmetry of small spherical viruses and organization principles in "anomalous" and double-shelled capsid nanoassemblies

Theory of density waves and organization of proteins in icosahedral virus capsids

Understanding the physical principles underlying the structural organization of the proteinaceous viral shells is of major importance to advance antiviral strategies. Here, we develop a phenomenological thermodynamic theory, which considers structures of small and middle-size icosahedral viral shells as a result of condensation of a minimum number of protein density waves on a spherical surface. Each of these irreducible critical waves has icosahedral symmetry and can be expressed as a specific series of the spherical harmonics Ylm with the same wave number l. As we demonstrate, in small viral shells self-assembled from individual proteins, the maxima of one critical density wave determine the positions of proteins, while the spatial derivatives of the second one control the protein orientations on the shell surface. In contrast to the small shells, the middle-size ones are always formed from pentamers and hexamers (referred to as capsomers). Considering all such structures deposited in the Protein Data Bank, we unexpectedly found that the positions of capsomeres in these shells correspond to the maxima of interference patterns produced by no more than two critical waves with close wave numbers. This fact allows us to explain the observed limit size of the icosahedral shells assembled from pentamers and hexamers. We also construct nonequilibrium thermodynamic potentials describing the protein crystallization and discuss the reasons behind the specific handedness of the viral shells.

An interaction network approach predicts protein cage architectures in bionanotechnology

Protein nanoparticles play pivotal roles in many areas of bionanotechnology, including drug delivery, vaccination, and diagnostics. These technologies require control over the distinct particle morphologies that protein nanocontainers can adopt during self-assembly from their constituent protein components. The geometric construction principle of virus-derived protein cages is by now fairly well understood by analogy to viral protein shells in terms of Caspar and Klug's quasi-equivalence principle. However, many artificial, or genetically modified, protein containers exhibit varying degrees of quasi-equivalence in the interactions between identical protein subunits. They can also contain a subset of protein subunits that do not participate in interactions with other assembly units, called capsomers, leading to gaps in the particle surface. We introduce a method that exploits information on the local interactions between the capsomers to infer the geometric construction principle of these nanoparticle architectures. The predictive power of this approach is demonstrated here for a prominent system in nanotechnology, the AaLS pentamer. Our method not only rationalises hitherto discovered cage structures but also predicts geometrically viable options that have not yet been observed. The classification of nanoparticle architecture based on the geometric properties of the interaction network closes a gap in our current understanding of protein container structure and can be widely applied in protein nanotechnology, paving the way to programmable control over particle polymorphism.

Close packings of identical proteins in small spherical capsids and similar proteinaceous shells

Understanding the principles governing protein arrangement in viral capsids and structurally similar protein shells can enable the development of new antiviral strategies and the design of artificial protein cages for various applications. We study these principles within the context of the close packing problem, by analyzing dozens of small spherical shells assembled from a single type of protein. First, we use icosahedral spherical close packings containing 60T identical disks, where T ≤ 4, to rationalize the protein arrangement in twenty real icosahedral shells both satisfying and violating the paradigmatic Caspar-Klug model. We uncover a striking correspondence between the protein mass centers in the considered shells and the centers of disks in the close packings. To generalize the packing model, we consider proteins with a weak shape anisotropy and propose an interaction energy, minimization of which allows us to obtain spherical dense packings of slightly anisotropic structural units. In the case of strong anisotropy, we model the proteins as sequences of overlapping discs of different sizes, with minimum energy configuration not only resulting in packings, accurately reproducing locations and orientations of individual proteins, but also revealing that icosahedral packings that display the handedness of real capsids are energetically more favorable. Finally, by introducing effective disc charges, we rationalize the formation of inter-protein bonds in protein shells.

Mapping hyperbolic order in curved materials

Nature employs an impressive range of topologically complex ordered nanostructures that occur in various forms in both natural and synthetic materials. A particular class of these exhibits negative curvature and forms periodic saddle-shaped surfaces in three dimensions. Unlike pattern formation on flat or positively curved surfaces like spherical systems, the understanding of patterning on such surfaces is highly complicated due to the structures being intrinsically intertwined in three dimensions. We present a new method for visualisation and analysis of patterns on triply periodic negatively curved surfaces by mapping to two-dimensional hyperbolic space analogous to spherical projections in cartography thus effectively creating a more accessible "hyperbolic map" of the pattern. Specifically, we exemplify the method via the simplest triply periodic minimal surfaces: the Primitive, Diamond, and Gyroid in their universal cover along with decorations from a soft materials, whose structures involve decorations of soft matter on negatively curved surfaces, not necessarily minimal.

Hidden symmetry of the flavivirus protein shell and pH-controlled reconstruction of the viral surface

Using recent Zika virus structural data we reveal a hidden symmetry of protein order in immature and mature flavivirus shells, violating the Caspar-Klug paradigmatic model of capsid structures. We show that proteins of the outer immature shell layer exhibit trihexagonal tiling, while proteins from inner and outer layers conjointly form a double-shelled close-packed structure, based on a common triangular spherical lattice. Within the proposed structural model, we furthermore rationalize the structural organization of misassembled non-infectious subviral particles that have no inner capsid. We consider a pH-controlled structural reconstruction of the outer shell from the trimeric to the dimeric state, and demonstrate that this transition, occurring during the virus maturation, can be induced by changes in protein charges at lower pH, leading to a decrease in the electrostatic interaction free energy. This transition could also be assisted by electrostatic attraction of shell proteins to the interposed lipid membrane substrate separating the shells.

Packing and trimer-to-dimer protein reconstruction in icosahedral viral shells with a single type of symmetrical structural unit

Understanding the principles of protein packing and the mechanisms driving morphological transformations in virus shells (capsids) during their maturation can be pivotal for the development of new antiviral strategies. Here, we study how these principles and mechanisms manifest themselves in icosahedral viral capsids assembled from identical symmetric structural units (capsomeres). To rationalize such shells, we model capsomers as symmetrical groups of identical particles interacting with a short-range potential typical of the classic Tammes problem. The capsomere particles are assumed to retain their relative positions on the vertices of planar polygons placed on the spherical shell and to interact only with the particles from other capsomeres. Minimization of the interaction energy enforces equal distances between the nearest particles belonging to neighboring capsomeres and minimizes the number of different local environments. Thus, our model implements the Caspar and Klug quasi-equivalence principle and leads to packings strikingly similar to real capsids. We then study a reconstruction of protein trimers into dimers in a Flavivirus shell during its maturation, connecting the relevant structural changes with the modifications of the electrostatic charges of proteins, wrought by the oxidative switch in the bathing solution that is essential for the process. We highlight the key role of pr peptides in the shell reconstruction and show that the highly ordered arrangement of these subunits in the dimeric state is energetically favored at a low pH level. We also discuss the electrostatic mechanisms controlling the release of pr peptides in the last irreversible step of the maturation process.

Protein Cages: From Fundamentals to Advanced Applications

Proteins that self-assemble into polyhedral shell-like structures are useful molecular containers both in nature and in the laboratory. Here we review efforts to repurpose diverse protein cages, including viral capsids, ferritins, bacterial microcompartments, and designed capsules, as vaccines, drug delivery vehicles, targeted imaging agents, nanoreactors, templates for controlled materials synthesis, building blocks for higher-order architectures, and more. A deep understanding of the principles underlying the construction, function, and evolution of natural systems has been key to tailoring selective cargo encapsulation and interactions with both biological systems and synthetic materials through protein engineering and directed evolution. The ability to adapt and design increasingly sophisticated capsid structures and functions stands to benefit the fields of catalysis, materials science, and medicine.

Minimal Design Principles for Icosahedral Virus Capsids

The geometrical structures of single- and multiple-shell icosahedral virus capsids are reproduced as the targets that minimize the cost corresponding to relatively simple design functions. Capsid subunits are first identified as building blocks at a given coarse-grained scale and then represented in these functions as point particles located on an appropriate number of concentric spherical surfaces. Minimal design cost is assigned to optimal spherical packings of the particles. The cost functions are inspired by the packings favored for the Thomson problem, which minimize the electrostatic potential energy between identical charged particles. In some cases, icosahedral symmetry constraints are incorporated as external fields acting on the particles. The simplest cost functions can be obtained by separating particles in disjoint nonequivalent sets with distinct interactions, or by introducing interacting holes (the absence of particles). These functions can be adapted to reproduce any capsid structure found in real viruses. Structures absent in Nature require significantly more complex designs. Measures of information content and complexity are assigned to both the cost functions and the capsid geometries. In terms of these measures, icosahedral structures and the corresponding cost functions are the simplest solutions.

Irreversible and reversible morphological changes in the φ6 capsid and similar viral shells: symmetry and micromechanics

Understanding the physicochemical processes occurring in viruses during their maturation is of fundamental importance since only mature viruses can infect host cells. Here we consider the irreversible and reversible morphological changes that occur with the dodecahedral φ6 procapsid during the sequential packaging of 3 RNA segments forming the viral genome. It is shown that the dodecahedral shape of all the four observed capsid states is perfectly reproduced by a sphere radially deformed by only two irreducible spherical harmonics with icosahedral symmetry and wave numbers l = 6 and l = 10. The rotation of proteins around the 3-fold axes at the Procapsid → Intermediate 1 irreversible transformation is in fact also well described with the shear field containing only two irreducible harmonics with the same two wave numbers. The high stability of the Intermediate 1 state is discussed and the shapes of the Intermediate 2 state and Capsid (reversibly transforming back to the Intermediate 1 state) are shown to be mainly due to the isotropic pressure that the encapsidated RNA segments exert on the shell walls. The hidden symmetry of the capsid and the physicochemical features of the in vitro genome extraction from the viral shell are also elucidated.

Unveiling the Hidden Rules of Spherical Viruses Using Point Arrays

Since its introduction, the Triangulation number has been the most successful and ubiquitous scheme for classifying spherical viruses. However, despite its many successes, it fails to describe the relative angular orientations of proteins, as well as their radial mass distribution within the capsid. It also fails to provide any critical insight into sites of stability, modifications or possible mutations. We show how classifying spherical viruses using icosahedral point arrays, introduced by Keef and Twarock, unveils new geometric rules and constraints for understanding virus stability and key locations for exterior and interior modifications. We present a modified fitness measure which classifies viruses in an unambiguous and rigorous manner, irrespective of local surface chemistry, steric hinderance, solvent accessibility or Triangulation number. We then use these point arrays to explain the immutable surface loops of bacteriophage MS2, the relative reactivity of surface lysine residues in CPMV and the non-quasi-equivalent flexibility of the HBV dimers. We then explain how point arrays can be used as a predictive tool for site-directed modifications of capsids. This success builds on our previous work showing that viruses place their protruding features along the great circles of the asymmetric unit, demonstrating that viruses indeed adhere to these geometric constraints.

Patchy particles by self-assembly of star copolymers on a spherical substrate: Thomson solutions in a geometric problem with a color constraint

Confinement or geometric frustration is known to alter the structure of soft matter, including copolymeric melts, and can consequently be used to tune structure and properties. Here we investigate the self-assembly of ABC and ABB 3-miktoarm star copolymers confined to a spherical shell using coarse-grained dissipative particle dynamics simulations. In bulk and flat geometries the ABC stars form hexagonal tilings, but this is topologically prohibited in a spherical geometry which normally is alleviated by forming pentagonal tiles. However, the molecular architecture of the ABC stars implies an additional 'color constraint' which only allows even tilings (where all polygons have an even number of edges) and we study the effect of these simultaneous constraints. We find that both ABC and ABB systems form spherical tiling patterns, the type of which depends on the radius of the spherical substrate. For small spherical substrates, all solutions correspond to patterns solving the Thomson problem of placing mobile repulsive electric charges on a sphere. In ABC systems we find three coexisting, possibly different tilings, one in each color, each of them solving the Thomson problem simultaneously. For all except the smallest substrates, we find competing solutions with seemingly degenerate free energies that occur with different probabilities. Statistically, an observer who is blind to the differences between B and C can tell from the structure of the A domains if the system is an ABC or an ABB star copolymer system.

Hidden symmetry of the anomalous bluetongue virus capsid and its role in the infection process

Clear understanding of the principles that control the arrangement of proteins and their self-assembly into viral shells is very important for the development of antiviral strategies. Here we consider the structural peculiarities and hidden symmetry of the anomalous bluetongue virus (BTV) capsid. Each of its three concentric shells violates the paradigmatic geometrical model of Caspar and Klug, which is otherwise well suited to describe most of the known icosahedral viral shells. As we show, three icosahedral spherical lattices, which are commensurate with each other and possess locally hexagonal (primitive or honeycomb) order, underlie the proteinaceous shells of the BTV capsid. This interpretation of the multishelled envelope allows us to discuss the so-called "symmetry mismatch" between its layers. We also analyze the structural stability of the considered spherical lattices on the basis of the classical theory of spherical packing and relate the proximity of the outer spherical lattice to destabilization with the fact that during infection of the cell VP2 trimers are detached from the surface of the BTV capsid. An electrostatic mechanism that can assist in this detachment is discussed in detail.

Anomalous small viral shells and simplest polyhedra with icosahedral symmetry: the rhombic triacontahedron case

The development of antiviral strategies requires a clear understanding of the principles that control the protein arrangements in viral shells. Considered here are those capsids that violate the paradigmatic Caspar and Klug (CK) model, and it is shown that the important structural features of such anomalous shells from the Picobirnaviridae, Flaviviridae and Leviviridae families can be revealed by models in the form of spherical icosahedral packings of equivalent rhombic structural units (SUs). These SUs are composed of protein dimers forming the investigated capsids which, as shown here, are based on the rhombic triacontahedron (RT) geometry. How to modify the original CK approach in order to make it compatible with the considered rhombic tessellations of a sphere is also discussed. Analogies between capsids self-assembled from dimers and trimers are demonstrated. This analysis reveals the principles controlling the localization of receptor proteins (which recognize the host cell) on the capsid surface.

Commensurability between protein nanotubes in contractile ejection nanomachines

Contractile ejection nanomachines being sheath-tube assemblies create an opening in the cell membrane to translocate molecules or ions across it. Here, on the most structurally investigated examples of the bacteriophage T4 tail and pyocin R2, we show that the rearrangement of the sheath structure resulting in its contraction and twist occurs in such a way that the contracted sheath becomes commensurate with the inner tube. This fact dictates the previously unknown simple geometrical relationship between the nanotube symmetries. Using the Frank and van der Merwe classical theory of commensurability, we study an interaction between two protein nanotubes forming such nanomachines and obtain an expression for the corresponding energy, which depends on the tube structures and their mutual arrangement. The appearance of commensurability between the contracted sheath and the inner tube decreases both the interaction energy and the total energy of the system. It improves the nanomachine efficiency, since the energy gain obtained increases the torque of the inner tube piercing the cell membrane.

Static and dynamic hidden symmetries of icosahedral viral capsids

Viral shells self-assemble from identical proteins, which tend to form equivalent environments in the resulting assembly. However, in icosahedral capsids containing more than 60 proteins, they are enforced to occupy not only the symmetrically equivalent locations but also the quasi-equivalent ones. Due to this important fact, static and dynamic symmetries of viral shells can include additional hidden components. Here, developing the Caspar and Klug ideas concerning the quasi-equivalence of protein environments, we derive the simplest hexagonal tilings, that in principle could correspond to the local protein order in viral shells, and apply the resulting theory to nucleocytoplasmic large dsDNA viruses. In addition, analyzing the dynamic symmetry of the P22 viral shell, we demonstrate that the collective critical modes responsible for the protein reorganization during the procapsid maturation are approximately equivalent to the normal modes of the isotropic spherical membrane with O(3) symmetry. Furthermore, we establish the relationship between the dynamic symmetry of the P22 procapsid and the protein arrangement regularities that appear only in the mature capsid.

Quasicrystalline and crystalline types of local protein order in capsids of small viruses

Like metal alloys and micellar systems in soft matter, the viral capsid structures can be of crystalline and quasicrystalline types. We reveal the local quasicrystalline order of proteins in small spherical viral capsids using their nets of dodecahedral type. We show that the structure of some of the viral shells is well described in terms of a chiral pentagonal tiling, whose nodes coincide with centers of mass of protein molecules. The chiral protein packing found in these capsids originates from the pentagonal Penrose tiling (PPT), due to a specific phason reconstruction needed to fit the protein order at the adjacent dodecahedron faces. Via examples of small spherical viral shells and geminate capsid of a Maize Streak virus, we discuss the benefits and shortcomings of the usage of a dodecahedral net in comparison to icosahedral one, which is commonly applied for the modeling of viral shells with a crystalline local order.

AChiralPentagonalPolyhedralFramework forCharacterizingVirusCapsidStructures

Recent developments of rational strategies for the design of antiviral therapies, including monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), have naturally relied extensively on available viral structural information. As new strategies continue to be developed, it is equally important to continue to refine our understanding and interpretation of viral structural data. There are known limitations to the traditional (Caspar-Klug) theory for describing virus capsid structures that involves subdividing a capsid into triangular subunits. In this context, we describe a more general polyhedral framework for describing virus capsid structures that is able to account for many of these limitations, including a more thorough characterization of intersubunit interfaces. Additionally, our use of pentagonal subunits instead of triangular ones accounts for the intrinsic chirality observed in all capsids. In conjunction with the existing theory, the framework presented here provides a more complete picture of a capsid's structure and therefore can help contribute to the development of more effective antiviral strategies.