Ultra-specific discrimination of single-nucleotide mutations using sequestration-assisted molecular beacons

Thermodynamics and Kinetics-Directed Regulation of Nucleic Acid-Based Molecular Recognition

Nucleic acid-based molecular recognition plays crucial roles in various fields like biosensing and disease diagnostics. To achieve optimal detection and analysis, it is essential to regulate the response performance of nucleic acid probes or switches to match specific application requirements by regulating thermodynamics and kinetics properties. However, the impacts of thermodynamics and kinetics theories on recognition performance are sometimes obscure and the relative conclusions are not intuitive. To promote the thorough understanding and rational utilization of thermodynamics and kinetics theories, this review focuses on the landmarks and recent advances of nucleic acid thermodynamics and kinetics and summarizes the nucleic acid thermodynamics and kinetics-based strategies for regulation of nucleic acid-based molecular recognition. This work hopes such a review can provide reference and guidance for the development and optimization of nucleic acid probes and switches in the future, as well as for advancements in other nucleic acid-related fields.

High-Selectivity Single-Nucleotide Variant Capture Technology Based on the DNA Reaction Network

The extremely low abundance of circulating tumor DNA in blood samples has limited the development of liquid biopsy techniques for the early diagnosis of major diseases. In this study, we demonstrate a DRN-based screening technique, SCREEN, which achieves the specific capture and enrichment of low abundance SNV nucleic acid samples without selective amplification. The SCREEN technique achieved a 108-fold increase in the abundance of single-nucleotide variant (SNV) nucleic acids from highly homologous mixtures (from 0.01% to 1.08%) and has been shown to significantly increase the abundance of SNV nucleic acids from 0.1% to 51% further through two rounds of capture. As a highly effective pre-enrichment technique, SCREEN has demonstrated the ability to enhance NGS in detecting an ultralow abundance SNV nucleic acid powerfully and has high compatibility with existing molecular diagnostic methods.

Complexation design of cationized gelatin and molecular beacon to visualize intracellular mRNA

The objective of this study is to prepare cationized gelatin-molecular beacon (MB) complexes for the visualization of intracellular messenger RNA (mRNA). The complexes were prepared from cationized gelatins with different extents of cationization and different mixing ratios of MB to cationized gelatin. The apparent size of complexes was almost similar, while the zeta potential was different among the complexes. Irrespective of the preparation conditions, the complexes had a sequence specificity against the target oligonucleotides in hybridization. The cytotoxicity and the amount of complexes internalized into cells increased with an increase in the cationization extent and the concentration of cationized gelatin. After the incubation with complexes prepared from cationized gelatin with the highest extent of cationization and at mixing ratios of 10 and 20 pmole MB/μg cationized gelatin, a high fluorescent intensity was detected. On the other hand, the complex prepared with the mixing ratio at 20 pmole/μg did not show any cytotoxicity. The complex was the most effective to visualize the glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) mRNA endogenously present. In addition, even for enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) mRNA exogenously transfected, the complex permitted to effectively detect it as well. It is concluded that both the endogenous and exogenous mRNA can be visualized in living cells by use of cationized gelatin-MB complexes designed.

Improvement of Molecular Diagnosis Using Domain-Level Single-Nucleotide Variants by Eliminating Unexpected Secondary Structures

Identification of single-nucleotide variants (SNVs) is of great significance in molecular diagnosis. The problem that should not be ignored in the identification process is that the unexpected secondary structure of the target nucleic acid may greatly affect the detection accuracy. Herein, we proposed a conditional domain-level SNV diagnosis strategy, in which the subsequent SNV detection can only be carried out after eliminating the unexpected secondary structure of target DNA. Specifically, the target DNA is assembled into a rigid double strand, which makes folding the target DNA difficult and the unexpected secondary structure is eliminated. Based on this double-stranded structure, specially designed probes are used to detect double-stranded properties and report abundant domain-level oligonucleotide information to improve the effective information in the detection results and complete domain-level SNV diagnosis. If the unexpected secondary structure is not eliminated, the detector will first detect it and feed back to us, ensuring the accuracy of the subsequent detection results. With the occurrence (or not) of SNV and the change of the SNV site, in the proof-of-concept experiment, we successfully identified the four homologous sequences to be tested related to BRAF gene.

Intracellular Nonenzymatic In Situ Growth of Three-Dimensional DNA Nanostructures for Imaging Specific Biomolecules in Living Cells

Real-time in situ monitoring of low-abundance cancer biomarkers (e.g., miRNAs and proteins) in living cells by nonenzymatic assembly entirely from original DNA probes remains unexplored due to an extremely complex intracellular environment. Herein, a nonenzymatic palindrome-catalyzed DNA assembly (NEPA) technique is developed to execute the in situ imaging of intracellular miRNAs by assembling a three-dimensional nanoscale DNA spherical structure (NS) with low mobility from three free hairpin-type DNAs rather than from DNA intermediates based on the interaction of designed terminal palindromes. Target miRNA was detected down to 1.4 pM, and its family members were distinguished with almost 100% accuracy. The subcellular localization of NS products can be visualized in real time. The NEPA-based sensing strategy is also suitable for the intracellular in situ fluorescence imaging of cancer-related protein receptors, offering valuable insight into developing sensing protocols for understanding the biological function of vital biomolecules in disease pathogenesis and future therapeutic applications.

Combining competitive sequestration with nonlinear hybridization chain reaction amplification: an ultra-specific and highly sensitive sensing strategy for single-nucleotide variants

Highly specific and sensitive detection of single-nucleotide variants (SNVs) is of central importance in disease diagnosis and pharmacogenomics. However, it remains a great challenge to successfully detect very low amounts of mutant SNV sequences in real samples in which a SNV sequence may be surrounded by high levels of closely related wild-type sequences. Herein, we propose an ultra-specific and highly sensitive SNV sensing strategy by combining the competitive sequestration with the nonlinear hybridization chain reaction (HCR) amplification. The rationally designed sequestration hairpin can effectively sequester the large amount of wild-type sequence and thus dramatically improve the hybridization specificity in recognizing SNVs. To improve the detection sensitivity, a new fluorescent signal probe is fabricated by intercalating SYBR Green I dye into the nonlinear HCR based DNA dendrimer to further bind with SNVs for signal amplification. The hyperbranched DNA dendrimer possesses large numbers of DNA duplexes for dye intercalation, thus the signal probe shows strong fluorescence intensity, leading to large fluorescence signal amplification. Taking advantage of the improved hybridization specificity of the competitive sequestration and the enhanced fluorescence response of the nonlinear HCR amplification, the developed sensing strategy enables ultra-specific and highly sensitive detection of SNVs. Taking human pancreatic cancers and colorectal carcinomas related KRAS gene mutations as models, the developed strategy shows remarkably high specificity against 17 SNVs (discrimination factors ranged from 126 to 1001 with a median of 310), and achieves high sensitivity for 6 KRAS mutations (the best resultant detection limit reached 15 pM for KRAS G13D (c.38G > A)). Notably, combined with PCR amplification, our SNV sensing strategy could detect KRAS G12D (c.35G > A) from extracted human genomic DNA samples at abundance as low as 0.05%. This work expands the rule set of designing specific and sensitive SNV sensing strategies and shows promising potential application in clinical diagnosis.

Enhanced SNP-sensing using DNA-templated reactions through confined hybridization of minimal substrates (CHOMS)

DNA or RNA templated reactions are attractive for nucleic acid sensing and imaging. As for any hybridization-based sensing, there is a tradeoff between sensitivity (detection threshold) and resolution (single nucleotide discrimination). Longer probes afford better sensitivity but compromise single nucleotide resolution due to the small thermodynamic penalty of a single mismatch. Herein we report a design that overcomes this tradeoff. The reaction is leveraged on the hybridization of a minimal substrate (covering 4 nucleotides) which is confined by two guide DNAs functionalized respectively with a ruthenium photocatalyst. The use of a catalytic reaction is essential to bypass the exchange of guide DNAs while achieving signal amplification through substrate turnover. The guide DNAs restrain the reaction to a unique site and enhance the hybridization of short substrates by providing two π-stacking interactions. The reaction was shown to enable the detection of SNPs and SNVs down to 50 pM with a discrimination factor ranging from 24 to 309 (median 82, 27 examples from 3 oncogenes). The clinical diagnostic potential of the technology was demonstrated with the analysis of RAS amplicons obtained directly from cell culture.

DNA Strand Displacement Reaction: A Powerful Tool for Discriminating Single Nucleotide Variants

Single-nucleotide variants (SNVs) that are strongly associated with many genetic diseases and tumors are important both biologically and clinically. Detection of SNVs holds great potential for disease diagnosis and prognosis. Recent advances in DNA nanotechnology have offered numerous principles and strategies amenable to the detection and quantification of SNVs with high sensitivity, specificity, and programmability. In this review, we will focus our discussion on emerging techniques making use of DNA strand displacement, a basic building block in dynamic DNA nanotechnology. Based on their operation principles, we classify current SNV detection methods into three main categories, including strategies using toehold-mediated strand displacement reactions, toehold-exchange reactions, and enzyme-mediated strand displacement reactions. These detection methods discriminate SNVs from their wild-type counterparts through subtle differences in thermodynamics, kinetics, or response to enzymatic manipulation. The remarkable programmability of dynamic DNA nanotechnology also allows the predictable design and flexible operation of diverse strand displacement probes and/or primers. Here, we offer a systematic survey of current strategies, with an emphasis on the molecular mechanisms and their applicability to in vitro diagnostics.

Target-Triggered Polymerization of Branched DNA Enables Enzyme-free and Fast Discrimination of Single-Base Changes

Single-base changes lead to important biological and biomedical implications; however, the discrimination of single-base changes from normal DNA always remains a grand challenge. Herein we developed a DNA recognition and amplification system based on artificial branched DNA, namely, target-triggered polymerization (TTP), to realize enzyme-free and fast discrimination of single-base changes. Branched DNA as monomers rapidly polymerized into DNA nanospheres only with the trigger of specific DNA. Our TTP system worked reliably over a wide range of conditions. Remarkably, our TTP system was capable of discriminating base-changing DNA from normal DNA, including distinguishing 1-4 nucleotide changes and positions of single base, which was attributed to the significant amplification of small differences in hybridization thermodynamics and kinetics. We further proposed a theoretical method for calculating the hybridization probability of nucleic acids, which performed highly consistent with experimental results.

Detection of Several Homologous MicroRNAs by a Single Smart Probe System Consisting of Linear Nucleic Acid Blockers

We report a universal smart probe (SP) that is capable of detecting several homologous let-7 microRNAs (miRNAs). While the SP is complementary to let-7a, and therefore, strongly binds to this target, due to sequence homology, the SP also has equal propensity to non-specifically hybridize with let-7b and let-7c, which are homologous to let-7a. The fluorescence signal of the SP was switched off in the absence of any homologous member target, but the signal was switched on when any of the three homologous members was present. With the assistance of nucleic acid blockers (NABs), this SP system can discriminate between homologous miRNAs. We show that the SP can discriminate between let-7a and the other two sequences by using linear NABs (LNABs) to block non-specific interactions between the SP and these sequences. We also found that LNABs used do not cross-react with the let-7a target due to the low LNABs:SP molar ratio of 6:1 used. Overall, this SP represents a universal probe for the recognition of a homologous miRNA family. The assay is sensitive, providing a detection limit of 6 fmol. The approach is simple, fast, usable at room temperature, and represents a general platform for the in vitro detection of homologous microRNAs by a single fluorescent hairpin probe.

Locus-patterned sequence oriented enrichment for multi-dimensional gene analysis

Multi-dimensional gene analysis provides in-depth insights into gene sequence, locus variations and molecular abundance, whereas it is vulnerable to the perturbation of complex reaction networks and always compromises on the discrimination of analogous sequences. Here, we present a sequence oriented enrichment method patterned by the prescribed locus without crosstalk between concurrent reactions. Energetically favourable structures of nucleic acid probes are theoretically derived and oriented to a specific gene locus. We designed a pair of universal probes for multiple conserved loci to avoid side reactions from undesired interactions among increased probe sets. Furthermore, competitive probes were customized to sink analogues for differentiating the reaction equilibrium and kinetics of sequence enrichment from the target, so variant loci can be synchronously identified with nucleotide-level resolution. Thus, the gene locus guides sequence enrichment and combinatorial signals to create unique codes, which provides access to multidimensional and precise information for gene decoding.

A versatile single-molecule counting-based platform by generation of fluorescent silver nanoclusters for sensitive detection of multiple nucleic acids

The good photostability and strong brightness of individual DNA-templated silver nanoclusters (DNA-AgNCs) have been confirmed by single-molecule imaging in this work and DNA-AgNCs as a new class of outstanding fluorophores are applied in the construction of single-molecule counting-based probes for the first time. Based on the fluorescent AgNC-generating molecular beacons (AgNC-MBs), we present a versatile method for simultaneous analysis of multiple nucleic acids. Distinct from previous designs in which a AgNC stabilizing sequence is incorporated into the stem of a hairpin DNA to form the AgNC-MB, we prepared a nicked MB in which the AgNC stabilizing sequence is hybridized with the longer stem of a single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) with a stem-loop structure. Our proposed AgNC-MB is activated by probe-target hybridization then releasing the AgNC stabilizing sequence via a toehold-mediated strand displacement reaction, the versatility of which has been greatly improved because bases in the target-binding region are not involved in the formation of DNA-AgNCs. As a proof of concept, the simultaneous detection of two breast cancer-related MicroRNAs (miR-21 and let-7a miRNA) has been achieved with total internal reflection fluorescence (TIRF)-based imaging and the detection sensitivity of our method has been demonstrated to be improved by at least two orders of magnitude compared with conventional AgNC-MBs. Furthermore, in the single-nucleotide mutation identification assay, the simultaneous detection strategy introduces a competitive reaction between the two probe-target hybridizations, resulting in the excellent discrimination ability of the AgNC-MB sensing platform and the mutant-type targets can be successfully detected at low abundance. The new AgNC-MB sensing platform demonstrated potential to make AgNCs an attractive alternative to conventional organic dyes for single-molecule studies.

A DNA electrochemical biosensor based on triplex DNA-templated Ag/Pt nanoclusters for the detection of single-nucleotide variant

A label-free electrochemical biosensor based on the triplex DNA-templated Ag/Pt bimetallic nanoclusters (triplex-Ag/PtNCs) and locked nucleic acid (LNA) modified X-shaped DNA probe was developed for the detection of single-nucleotide variant (SNV) related to β-thalassemia. Firstly, using triplex DNA as template, a site-specific and homogeneous Ag/PtNCs was prepared, which can effectively catalyze the 3,3,5,5-tetramethylbenzidine-H₂O₂ system and thus be employed as a signal reporter in the field of electrochemical biosensor. Secondly, the LNA modified X-shaped probes were assembled on gold electrode surface, which can only be dissociated in the presence of target, leading to the hybridization with triplex-Ag/PtNCs and significant increase of current signal. In this way, the detection limit for SNV of β-thalassemia was 0.8 fM with variant allele frequency (VAF) as low as 0.0001%.

Targeted Detection of Single-Nucleotide Variations: Progress and Promise

Advances in nucleic acid sequencing and genotyping technologies have facilitated the discovery of an increasing number of single-nucleotide variations (SNVs) associated with disease onset, progression, and response to therapy. The reliable detection of such disease-specific SNVs can ensure timely and effective therapeutic action, enabling precision medicine. This has driven extensive efforts in recent years to develop novel methods for the fast and cost-effective analysis of targeted SNVs. In this Review, we highlight the most recent and significant advances made toward the development of such methodologies.

Simple protocol for sequence-specific detection of mixed-base nucleic acids using a smart probe with NABs

A fluorescent smart probe (SP) was used to detect a mixed-base ribonucleic acids sequence. While the SP presents excellent sensitivity for the target, it gives subtle discrimination between the perfect target sequence and several mismatch sequences. Its sequence-specificity for the target was greatly enhanced by using nucleic acid blockers (NABs), which are unlabeled, non-fluorescent hairpin oligonucleotides that are perfectly complementary to those mismatch sequences. This approach is simple, feasible at room temperature, requires no amplification enzymes, and it is suitable for applications requiring routine nucleic acids sequence detection and quantification methods such as genetic testing and biomedical diagnostics.

Endonuclease IV recognizes single base mismatch on the eighth base 3' to the abasic site in DNA strands for ultra-selective and sensitive mutant-type DNA detection

Since single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) is related with many diseases and drug metabolic polymorphous and SNP genotyping is rising rapidly in many biological and medical areas, various methods of discriminating SNPs have been developed, one of which is an enzyme-based method. We uncovered a unique property of endonuclease IV due to which it can discriminate single base mismatches in different positions of DNA strands containing an abasic site, and we also discovered a new property: a mismatch in the +8 position could inhibit the cleavage of endonuclease IV. Then, we coupled +8 mismatch with other mismatches along with the discrimination effect of melting temperature to develop a new ultra-selective and sensitive genotyping system, which showed high discrimination factors. The detection limit was as low as 0.05-0.01%. Our new discovery improves the understanding of endonuclease IV. Also, the method could be applied to clinical real samples; thus, it merits further investigation and improvement for application in clinical utilization for early screening of specific diseases.

Probing DNA Hybridization Equilibrium by Cationic Conjugated Polymer for Highly Selective Detection and Imaging of Single-Nucleotide Mutation

Hybridization-based probes emerge as a promising tool for nucleic acid target detection and imaging. However, the single-nucleotide selectivity is still challenging because the specificity of hybridization reaction is typically low at room temperature. We disclose an effective and simple method for highly selective detection and in situ imaging of single-nucleotide mutation (SNM) by taking the advantages of the specific hybridization of short duplex and the signal amplifying effect of cationic conjugated polymer (CCP). Excellent discrimination of the nucleic acid strands only differing by single nucleotide was achieved enabling the sensitive detection of SNM at the abundance as low as 0.1%. Single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (smFRET) study reveals that the presence of CCP enhances the perfect matched duplex and the mismatched duplex to a different extent, which can be an explanation for the high single-nucleotide selectivity. Due to the simple design of the probe and the stable brightness of CCP, highly selective mRNA in situ imaging was achieved in fixed cells. Melanoma cell line A375 with BRAF V600E point mutation exhibits higher FRET efficiency than liver cancer cell line HegG2 that was not reported having the mutation at this point.

Combining cooperativity with sequestration: a novel strategy for discrimination of single nucleotide variants

We present a novel strategy for the discrimination of single nucleotide variants (SNVs) by combining cooperativity with sequestration, which displays remarkably high specificity (discrimination factors ranging from 67 to 618 with a median of 194) against 12 model SNVs and can be easily integrated with PCR amplification to detect KRAS G12D mutation.

Simultaneous multiple single nucleotide polymorphism detection based on click chemistry combined with DNA-encoded probes

Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) are emerging as important biomarkers for disease diagnosis, prognostics and disease pathogenesis. As one type of disease is always connected to several SNP sites, there is great demand for a reliable multiple SNP detection method. Herein, we mimicked a ligation reaction based on DNA ligase and originally utilized an enzyme-free DNA template-directed click reaction for SNP detection. With 5'-alkyne and 3'-azide groups labelled on two oligonucleotide probes, the target DNA-directed Cu(i)-catalyzed alkyne-azide cycloaddition (CuAAC) click reaction produced a new DNA strand with a triazole backbone, as a mimic of a DNA phosphodiester linkage. Trace amounts of the target (as low as 25 fmol in 50 μL) could be sensitively detected using capillary gel electrophoresis with laser-induced fluorescence (CGE-LIF). Meanwhile, SNP caused an obvious difference in the efficiency of the click reaction, and 0.5% SNP could be easily detected. More importantly, multiplexed SNP detection in a one tube reaction was successfully achieved only by encoding different lengths of the DNA probes for the different SNP sites.

Ultraspecific Multiplexed Detection of Low-Abundance Single-Nucleotide Variants by Combining a Masking Tactic with Fluorescent Nanoparticle Counting

To be able to detect simultaneously multiple single-nucleotide variants (SNVs) with both ultrahigh specificity and low-abundance sensitivity is of pivotal importance for molecular diagnostics and biological research. In this contribution, we for the first time developed a multiplex SNV detection method that combines the masking tactic with fluorescent nanoparticle (FNP) counting based on the sandwich design. The method presents a rivaling performance due to its advantageous features: the masking reagent was designed to hybridize with an extremely large amount of the wild-type sequence to render the assay with high specificity; FNP counting provides a sensitive multiplexed SNV detection; the sandwich design facilitates an easy separation to make the detection free of interferences from the matrix. For single SNV target discrimination, including the 6 most frequently occurring DNA KRAS gene mutations and 2 possible RNA KRAS gene mutations as well as 11 artificial mutations, the discrimination factor ranged from 204 to 1177 with the median being 545. Among the tested 19 SNVs, abundances as low as 0.05% were successfully identified in 14 cases, and an abundance as low as 0.1% was identified for the remaining 5 cases. For multiplexed detection of SNVs in the KRAS gene, abundances as low as 0.05-0.1% were achieved for multiple SNVs occurring at the same and different codons. As low as 0.05% low-abundance detection sensitivity was also achieved for PCR amplicons of human genomic DNA extracted from cell samples. This proposed method presents the potential for ultrahigh specific multiplexed detection of SNVs with low-abundance detection capability, which may be applied to practical applications.

Programmable DNA switches and their applications

DNA switches are ideally suited for numerous nanotechnological applications, and increasing efforts are being directed toward their engineering. In this review, we discuss how to engineer these switches starting from the selection of a specific DNA-based recognition element, to its adaptation and optimisation into a switch, with applications ranging from sensing to drug delivery, smart materials, molecular transporters, logic gates and others. We provide many examples showcasing their high programmability and recent advances towards their real life applications. We conclude with a short perspective on this exciting emerging field.

Detection of low-abundance point mutations by competitive strand assisted endonuclease IV signal amplification system

Genetic mutations are important molecular biomarkers for cancer diagnosis and surveillance. Therefore, the development of methods for mutation detection characterized with straightforward, highly specific and sensitive to low-level mutations within various sequence contexts is extremely needed. Although some of the currently available methods have shown very encouraging results, their discrimination efficiency is still very low. Herein, we demonstrate a fluorescent probe coupled with blocker and property of melting temperature discrimination, which is able to identify the presence of known or unknown single-base variations at abundances down to 0.1% within 20 min. The discrimination factors between the perfect-match target and single-base mismatched target are determined to be 10.15-38.48. The method is sequence independent, which assures a wide range of application. The new method would be an ideal choice for high-throughput in vitro diagnosis and precise clinical treatment.

Discrimination Cascade Enabled Selective Detection of Single-Nucleotide Mutation

Owing to the significance of single nucleotide mutation (SNM) for personalized medicine, the detection of SNM with high accuracy has recently attracted considerable interest. Here, we present a kinetic method for selective detection of SNM based on a discrimination cascade constructed by combining the toehold strand displacement (TSD) and endonuclease IV (Endo IV) catalyzed hydrolysis. The single-nucleotide specificity of the two DNA reactions allows highly selective detection of all types of single nucleotide changes (including single-nucleotide insertion and deletion), achieving a high discrimination factor with a median of 491 which is comparable with recently reported methods. For the first time, the enzyme assisted nucleic acid assay was characterized by single molecule analysis on total internal reflection fluorescence microscope (TIRFM) suggesting that the two steps do not work independently and the rate of TSD can be tuned by Endo IV facilitated conformation selection. The effective discrimination of the point mutation of BRAF gene in cancer and normal cell line suggests that this method can be a prominent post-PCR genotyping assay.