Colorimetric and electrochemical quantification of global DNA methylation using a methyl cytosine-specific antibody

Periodic magnetic modulation enhanced electrochemical analysis for highly sensitive determination of genomic DNA methylation

DNA methylation aberrations have a strong correlation with cancer in early detection, diagnosis, and prognosis, which make them possible candidate biomarkers. Electrochemical biosensors offer rapid protocols for detecting DNA methylation status with minimal pretreatment of samples. However, the inevitable presence of background current in the time domain, including electrochemical noise and variations, limits the detection performance of these biosensors, especially for low concentration analytes. Here, we propose an ultrasensitive frequency-domain electrochemical analysis strategy to effectively separate the weak signals from background current. To achieve this, we employed periodic magnetic field modulation of magnetic beads (MBs) on and off the electrode surface to generate a periodic electrochemical signal for subsequent frequency-domain analysis. By capturing labeled MBs with as low as 0.5 pg of DNA, we successfully demonstrated a highly sensitive electrochemical method for determination of genome-wide DNA methylation levels. We also validated the effectiveness of this methodology using DNA samples extracted from three types of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) cell lines. The results revealed varying genomic methylation levels among different HCC cell lines, indicating the potential application of this approach for early-stage cancer detection in terms of DNA methylation status.

A ratiometric fluorescence assay for the detection of DNA methylation based on an alkaline phosphatase triggered in situ fluorogenic reaction

The accurate and sensitive quantification of DNA methylation is significant for the early diagnosis of cancer. In this work, an alkaline phosphatase (ALP) triggered in situ fluorogenic reaction between ascorbic acid (AA) and 2,3-DAN was employed as a ratiometric fluorescent probe for the accurate and sensitive detection of DNA methylation with the assistance of ALP encapsulated liposomes. The quinoxaline derivative with a yellow fluorescence emission (I525) was generated from the reaction between AA and 2,3-DAN. Meanwhile, the consumption of 2,3-DAN declined its fluorescence intensity (I386). A ratiometric fluorescent probe (I525/I386) constructed by the above in situ fluorogenic reaction was applied for the accurate detection of DNA methylation. The methylated DNA was first captured by its complementary DNA in 96-well plates. Then, 5mC antibody (Ab) linked liposomes that were encapsulated with ALP recognized and combined with the methylation sites of the target DNA. After the liposomes were lysed by Triton X-100, the released ALP triggered the hydrolysis of ascorbic acid diphosphate (AAP) to form AA, participating in the fluorogenic reaction with 2,3-DAN to produce a quinoxaline derivative. Thus, the ratiometric fluorescence detection of DNA methylation was achieved using I525/I386 values. Using the ALP-enzyme catalyzed reaction and liposomes as signal amplifiers, a low detection limit of 82 fM was obtained for DNA methylation detection. Moreover, the accuracy of the assay could be improved using ratiometric fluorescent probes. We hope that the proposed assay will pave a new way for the accurate determination of low-abundance biomarkers.

ALP-assisted chemical redox cycling signal amplification for ultrasensitive fluorescence detection of DNA methylation

Affinity assays allow direct detection of DNA methylation events without requiring a special sequence. However, the signal amplification of these methods heavily depends on nanocatalysts and bioenzymes, making them suffer from low sensitivity. In this work, alkaline phosphatase (ALP)-assisted chemical redox cycling was employed to amplify the sensitivity of fluorescence affinity assays for DNA methylation detection using Ru@SiO2@MnO2 nanocomposites as fluorescent probes. In the ALP-assisted chemical redox cycling reaction system, ALP hydrolyzed 2-phosphate-L-ascorbic acid trisodium salt (AAP) to produce AA, which could reduce MnO2 nanosheets to form Mn2+, making the fluorescence recovery of Ru@SiO2 nanoparticles possible. Meanwhile, AA was oxidized to dehydroascorbic acid (DHA), which was re-reduced by tris(2-carboxyethyl) phosphine (TCEP) to trigger a redox cycling reaction. The constantly generated AA could etch large amounts of MnO2 nanosheets and greatly recover Ru@SiO2 fluorescence, amplifying the signal of the fluorescence assay. Employing the proposed ALP-assisted chemical redox cycling signal amplification strategy, a sensitive affinity assay for DNA methylation detection was achieved using ALP encapsulated liposomes that were linked with the 5mC antibody (Ab) to bind with methylated sites. A detection limit down to 2.9 fM was obtained for DNA methylation detection and a DNA methylation level as low as 0.1% could be distinguished, which was superior to conventional affinity assays. Moreover, the affinity assays could detect DNA methylation more specifically and directly, implying their great potential for the analysis of tumor-specific genes in liquid biopsy.

Probing low abundant DNA methylation by CRISPR-Cas12a-assisted cascade exponential amplification

Aberrant DNA methylation plays a pivotal role in tumor development and metastasis, and is regarded as a valuable non-invasive cancer biomarker. However, the sensitive and accurate quantification of DNA methylation from clinical samples remains a challenge. Herein, we propose an easy-to-operate Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats (CRISPR)-Cas system Assisted Methylation (CAM) approach for the sensitive detection of DNA methylation through the integration of rolling circle amplification and CRISPR-Cas12a-assisted cascade amplification. Briefly, bisulfite was employed to prepare the clinical samples so that the methylated DNA sequences trigger the subsequent triple signal amplifications, whilst the normal counterparts do not. The triple signal amplification procedure consists of methylated DNA sequence-based rolling circle amplification for a preliminary signal enhancement, a nicking enzyme-initiated target cleavage for a secondary amplification, and CRISPR-Cas12a enzyme-mediated trans-cleavage for a tertiary signal enhancement. This proposed approach reveals high sensitivity, which can even distinguish as low as 0.01% methylation levels from mixtures, paving the way towards the acceleration of methylation-based cancer diagnostics and management.

Magnetic Immunosensor Coupled to Enzymatic Signal for Determination of Genomic DNA Methylation

Aberrations of genomic DNA methylation have been confirmed to be involved in the evolution of human cancer and have thus gained the potential to be depicted as biomarkers for cancer diagnostics and prognostic predictions, which implicates an urgent need for detection of total genomic DNA methylation. In this work, we suggested an assay for the quantification of global DNA methylation, utilizing methylation specific antibody (5mC) modified magnetic beads (MBs) for immunorecognition and affinity enrichment. Subsequently, the captured DNA on the surface of MBs interacted with the glucose oxidase-conjugated DNA antibody whose catalytic reaction product was engaged in electrochemical detection of the overall level of DNA methylation on a PB-doped screen-printed electrode. With 15 pg of input DNA, which, to our best knowledge, is the lowest required amount of DNA without sodium bisulfite treatment or amplification, this test strategy was able to perceive as low as 5% methylation level within 70 min including the preparation of anti-5mC-MBs. We believe this detection technique offers a promising option to detect global DNA methylation in both academic and clinical scenarios.

Electrochemical Detection of Global DNA Methylation Using Biologically Assembled Polymer Beads

DNA methylation is a cell-type-specific epigenetic marker that is essential for transcriptional regulation, silencing of repetitive DNA and genomic imprinting. It is also responsible for the pathogenesis of many diseases, including cancers. Herein, we present a simple approach for quantifying global DNA methylation in ovarian cancer patient plasma samples based on a new class of biopolymer nanobeads. Our approach utilises the immune capture of target DNA and electrochemical quantification of global DNA methylation level within the targets in a three-step strategy that involves (i) initial preparation of target single-stranded DNA (ss-DNA) from the plasma of the patients' samples, (ii) direct adsorption of polymer nanobeads on the surface of a bare screen-printed gold electrode (SPE-Au) followed by the immobilisation of 5-methylcytosine (5mC)-horseradish peroxidase (HRP) antibody, and (iii) immune capture of target ss-DNA onto the electrode-bound PHB/5mC-HRP antibody conjugates and their subsequent qualification using the hydrogen peroxide/horseradish peroxidase/hydroquinone (H2O2/HRP/HQ) redox cycling system. In the presence of methylated DNA, the enzymatically produced (in situ) metabolites, i.e., benzoquinone (BQ), binds irreversibly to cellular DNA resulting in the unstable formation of DNA adducts and induced oxidative DNA strand breakage. These events reduce the available BQ in the system to support the redox cycling process and sequel DNA saturation on the platform, subsequently causing high Coulombic repulsion between BQ and negatively charged nucleotide strands. Thus, the increase in methylation levels on the electrode surface is inversely proportional to the current response. The method could successfully detect as low as 5% methylation level. In addition, the assay showed good reproducibility (% RSD ≤ 5%) and specificity by analysing various levels of methylation in cell lines and plasma DNA samples from patients with ovarian cancer. We envision that our bioengineered polymer nanobeads with high surface modification versatility could be a useful alternative platform for the electrochemical detection of varying molecular biomarkers.

e-MagnetoMethyl IP: a magnetic nanoparticle-mediated immunoprecipitation and electrochemical detection method for global DNA methylation

The quantification of global 5-methylcytosine (5mC) content has emerged as a promising approach for the diagnosis and prognosis of cancers. However, conventional methods for the global 5mC analysis require large quantities of DNA and may not be useful for liquid biopsy applications, where the amount of DNA available is limited. Herein, we report magnetic nanoparticles-assisted methylated DNA immunoprecipitation (e-MagnetoMethyl IP) coupled with electrochemical quantification of global DNA methylation. Carboxyl (-COOH) group-functionalized iron oxide nanoparticles (C-IONPs) synthesized by a novel starch-assisted gel formation method were conjugated with anti-5mC antibodies through EDC/NHS coupling (anti-5mC/C-IONPs). Anti-5mC/C-IONPs were subsequently mixed with DNA samples, in which they acted as dispersible capture agents to selectively bind 5mC residues and capture the methylated fraction of genomic DNA. The target-bound Anti-5mC/C-IONPs were magnetically separated and directly adsorbed onto the gold electrode surface using gold-DNA affinity interaction. The amount of DNA adsorbed on the electrode surface, which corresponds to the DNA methylation level in the sample, was electrochemically estimated by differential pulse voltammetric (DPV) study of an electroactive indicator [Ru(NH₃)₆]³⁺ bound to the surface-adsorbed DNA. Using a 200 ng DNA sample, the assay could successfully detect differences as low as 5% in global DNA methylation levels with high reproducibility (relative standard deviation (% RSD) = <5% for n = 3). The method could also reproducibly analyze various levels of global DNA methylation in synthetic samples as well as in cell lines. The method avoids bisulfite treatment, does not rely on enzymes for signal generation, and can detect global DNA methylation using clinically relevant quantities of sample DNA without PCR amplification. We believe that this proof-of-concept method could potentially find applications for liquid biopsy-based global DNA methylation analysis in point-of-care settings.

A site-specific DNA methylation biosensor for both visual and magnetic determination based on lateral flow assay

Tumorigenesis driven by abnormal DNA methylation has highlighted the need to develop a portable, rapid and sensitive strategy for accurate methylation detection with a specific cancer-prognostic gene, which caters to the popularization of precision medicine. In this study, a site-specific biosensor for both visual and magnetic DNA methylation determination has been established based on lateral flow assay. By introducing digoxin- and biotin-labeled primers into PCR, the amplicons can be recognized and captured by gold magnetic nanoparticles (GMNPs) in this biosensor. Working as a signal probe, the optical property of GMNPs allows the amplicons to be interpreted with naked eyes avoiding any complex equipment and cumbersome operation after PCR. Moreover, by virtue of the magnetic property of GMNP, the signal can be explained and recorded by a magnetometer in clinical practice. The introduction of tailor-made primer sets makes it possible to accurately distinguish 0.1% methylated variants in the presence of numerous unmethylated variants as strong interferential background and vice versa at target cytosine-guanine dinucleotide. A distinct signal can be observed with as low as 0.01 pg variants for both visual and magnetic analyses. As a significant tumor suppressor gene, the promoter methylation status of miR-34a is accurately determined with not only cell lines but also with clinical samples, which demonstrates the great potential of this biosensor for cancer diagnosis and prognosis.

Sensitive, Rapid, and Automated Detection of DNA Methylation Based on Digital Microfluidics

Biomarkers based on DNA methylation have attracted wide attention in biomedical research due to their potential clinical value. Therefore, a sensitive and accurate method for DNA methylation detection is highly desirable for the discovery and diagnostics of human diseases, especially cancers. Here, an integrated, low-cost, and portable point-of-care (POC) device is presented to analyze DNA methylation, which integrates the process of pyrosequencing in a digital microfluidic chip. Without additional equipment and complicated operation, droplets are manipulated by patterned electrodes with individually programmed control. The system exhibited an excellent sensitivity with a limit of detection (LOD) of 10 pg and a comparable checkout down to 5% methylation level within 30 min, which offered a potential substitute for the detection of DNA methylation. With the advantages of portability, ease of use, high accuracy, and low cost, the POC platform shows great potential for the analysis of tumor-specific circulating DNA.

Electrochemical biosensing to move forward in cancer epigenetics and metastasis: A review

Early detection and effective treatment are crucial to reduce the physical, emotional, and financial pressure exerted by growing cancer burden on individuals, families, communities, and health systems. Currently, it is clear that the accurate analysis of emerging cancer epigenetic and metastatic-related biomarkers at different molecular levels is envisaged as an exceptional solution for early and reliable diagnosis and the improvement of therapy efficiency through personalized treatments. Within this field, electrochemical biosensing has demonstrated to be competitive over other emerging and currently used methodologies for the determination of these biomarkers accomplishing the premises of user-friendly, multiplexing ability, simplicity, reduced costs and decentralized analysis, demanded by clinical oncology, thus priming electrochemical biosensors to spark a diagnostic revolution for cancer prediction and eradication. This review article critically discusses the main characteristics, opportunities and versatility exhibited by electrochemical biosensing, through highlighting representative examples published during the last two years, for the reliable determination of these emerging biomarkers, with great diagnostic, predictive and prognostic potential. Special attention is paid on electrochemical affinity biosensors developed for the single or multiplexed determination of methylation events, non-coding RNAs, ctDNA features and metastasis-related protein biomarkers both in liquid and solid biopsies of cancer patients. The main challenges to which further work must be addressed and the impact of these advances should have in the clinical acceptance of these emerging biomarkers are also discussed which decisively will contribute to understand the molecular basis involved in the epigenetics and metastasis of cancer and to apply more efficient personalized therapies.

Ultra-low level detection of hepatocellular carcinoma global methylation using a AuNP modified carbon fiber microelectrode

Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is one of the most common cancerous diseases, with a low 5 year survival rate. Global hypomethylation drives genomic instability, which is regarded as one biomarker for early diagnosis. Long interspersed nucleotide element-1 (LINE-1) makes up around 17% of the genome, and could be regarded as a surrogate marker for global DNA methylation. In this work, a gold nanoparticle (AuNP) modified carbon fiber microelectrode (CFME) with a diameter of 7 μm was applied for the first time to detect the methylation level of LINE-1, by distinguishing adsorption affinities between different DNA bases and AuNPs. Several parameters, including AuNP electrodeposition time, sample adsorption time, and DNA concentration have been analyzed and optimized. The detection limit of our assay was 0.1 nM with only 2 μL sample solution. And the CFME had an excellent sensitivity of 10% methylation change and had the capacity to distinguish only one methylated CpG site. The global DNA methylation level of real samples including cell lines and clinical tissues was tested. Higher signals of HCC cell lines and cancer tissues were observed respectively, compared with normal hepatic cell lines and normal tissues. This work provides a promising approach for HCC early diagnosis and prognosis.

Using a AuNP modified carbon fiber microelectrode to detect hepatocellular carcinoma global methylation with an ultra-low concentration of DNA samples.

A simple and low-cost screen printed electrode for hepatocellular carcinoma methylation detection

There is a great demand for robust diagnostic and prognostic approaches for Hepatocellular Carcinoma (HCC). DNA methylation, a common epigenetic modification, has been found in many promoter regions of tumor suppressor genes. Hypermethylation of these gene promoters will repress the gene transcription and lead to the occurrence of cancers. The abnormal methyation level of the p16 gene promoter could be a promising marker for the detection of HCC. The adsorption affinities between different DNA bases and AuNPs are not the same. After bisulfite treatment and asymmetric PCR, methylation and unmethylation sequences can be changed into guanine-enriched and adenine-enriched sequences, respectively. A home-made gold nanoparticle modified screen printed carbon electrode (AuNP-SPCE) was employed to distinguish the adsorption affinities between guanine-enriched and adenine-enriched sequences, which could be used to analyze the level of DNA methylation. Several key experimental factors were investigated and optimized. The results had shown that the optimal AuNP electrodeposition time was 100 s and 15 min of adsorption could distinguish guanine-enriched and adenine-enriched sequences with a concentration of 100 nM at 25 °C. The detection limit of our AuNP-SPCE was 1.1 ng, and the assay had a good sensitivity of 10% methylation change and was able to distinguish only one methylated CpG site. What's more, the RSD over three assays with a disposable AuNP-SPCE was ≤7.2%. The assay was applied to real samples including cell lines and clinical tissues. Compared with normal hepatic cell lines and normal tissues, lower signals of HCC cell lines and cancer tissues were observed, respectively. It had shown a good discrimination of the abnormal methylation level of the p16 gene promoter.

Electrochemical Biosensor for DNA Methylation Detection through Hybridization Chain-Amplified Reaction Coupled with a Tetrahedral DNA Nanostructure

DNA methylation is a key factor in the pathogenesis of gene expression diseases or malignancies. Thus, it has become a significant biomarker for the diagnosis and prognosis of these diseases. In this paper, we designed an ultrasensitive and specific electrochemical biosensor for DNA methylation detection. The platform consisted of stem-loop-tetrahedron composite DNA probes anchoring at a Au nanoparticle-coated gold electrode, a restriction enzyme digestion of HpaII, and signal amplification procedures including electrodeposition of Au nanoparticles, hybridization chain reaction, and horseradish peroxidase enzymatic catalysis. Under optimal conditions, the design showed a broad dynamic range from 1 aM to 1 pM and a detection limit of about 0.93 aM. The approach also showed ideal specificity, repeatability, and stability. The recovery test demonstrated that the design is a promising platform for DNA methylation detection under clinical circumstances and could meet the need for cancer diagnosis.

DNA methylation detection: recent developments in bisulfite free electrochemical and optical approaches

DNA methylation is one of the significant epigenetic modifications involved in mammalian development as well as in the initiation and progression of various diseases like cancer. Over the past few decades, an enormous amount of research has been carried out for the quantification of DNA methylation in the mammalian genome. Earlier, most of these methodologies used bisulfite treatment. However, the low conversion, false reading, longer assay time and complex chemical reaction are the common limitations of this method that hinder their application in routine clinical screening. Thus, as an alternative to bisulfite conversion-based DNA methylation detection, numerous bisulfite-free methods have been proposed. In this regard, electrochemical biosensors have gained much attention in recent years for being highly sensitive yet cost-effective, portable, and simple to operate. On the other hand, biosensors with optical readouts enable direct real time detection of biological molecules and are easily adaptable to multiplexing. Incorporation of electrochemical and optical readouts into bisulfite free DNA methylation analysis is paving the way for the translation of this important biomarker into standard patient care. In this review, we provide a critical overview of recent advances in the development of electrochemical and optical readout based bisulfite free DNA methylation assays.

A bisulfite treatment and PCR-free global DNA methylation detection method using electrochemical enzymatic signal engagement

In this paper we report on a bisulfite treatment and PCR amplification-free method for sensitive and selective quantifying of global DNA methylation. Our method utilizes a three-step strategy that involves (i) initial isolation and denaturation of global DNA using the standard isolation protocol and direct adsorption onto a bare gold electrode via gold-DNA affinity interaction, (ii) selective interrogation of methylation sites in adsorbed DNA via methylation-specific 5mC antibody, and (iii) subsequent signal enhancement using an electrochemical-enzymatic redox cycling reaction. In the redox cycling reaction, glucose oxidase (GO_x) is used as an enzyme label, glucose as a substrate and ruthenium complex as a redox mediator. We initially investigated the enzymatic properties of GO_x by varying glucose and ruthenium concentration to delineate the redox cyclic mechanism of our assay. Because of the fast electron transfer by ruthenium (Ru) complex and intrinsic signal amplification from GO_x label, this method could detect as low as 5% methylation level in 50 ng of total DNA input. Moreover, the use of methylation-specific 5mC antibody conjugated GO_x makes this assay relatively highly selective for DNA methylation analysis. The data obtained from the electrochemical response for different levels of methylation showed excellent interassay reproducibility of RSD (relative standard deviation) < 5% for n = 3. We believe that this inexpensive, rapid, and sensitive assay will find high relevance as an alternative method for DNA methylation analysis both in research and clinical platforms.

Separation-free single-base extension assay with fluorescence resonance energy transfer for rapid and convenient determination of DNA methylation status at specific cytosine and guanine dinucleotide sites

A separation-free single-base extension (SBE) assay utilizing fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) was developed for rapid and convenient interrogation of DNA methylation status at specific cytosine and guanine dinucleotide sites. In this assay, the SBE was performed in a tube using an allele-specific oligonucleotide primer (i.e., extension primer) labeled with Cy3 as a FRET donor fluorophore at the 5'-end, a nucleotide terminator (dideoxynucleotide triphosphate) labeled with Cy5 as a FRET acceptor, a PCR amplicon derived from bisulfite-converted genomic DNA, and a DNA polymerase. A single base-extended primer (i.e., SBE product) that was 5'-Cy3- and 3'-Cy5-tagged was formed by incorporation of the Cy5-labeled terminator into the 3'-end of the extension primer, but only if the terminator added was complementary to the target nucleotide. The resulting SBE product brought the Cy3 donor and the Cy5 acceptor into close proximity. Illumination of the Cy3 donor resulted in successful FRET and excitation of the Cy5 acceptor, generating fluorescence emission from the acceptor. The capacity of the developed assay to discriminate as low as 10% methylation from a mixture of methylated and unmethylated DNA was demonstrated at multiple cytosine and guanine dinucleotide sites.

Porous nanozymes: the peroxidase-mimetic activity of mesoporous iron oxide for the colorimetric and electrochemical detection of global DNA methylation

Peroxidase-mimetic activity of mesoporous Fe₂O₃ nanomaterials in global DNA methylation detection using naked eye and electrochemical readout.

Naked-eye and electrochemical detection of isothermally amplified HOTAIR long non-coding RNA

A naked-eye, colorimetric and electrochemical detection of HOTAIR long non-coding RNA has been demonstrated.