Gas-phase Förster resonance energy transfer in mass-selected and trapped ions

Förster Resonance Energy transfer (FRET) is a nonradiative process that may occur from an electronically excited donor to an acceptor when the emission spectrum of the donor overlaps with the absorption spectrum of the acceptor. FRET experiments have been done in the gas phase based on specially designed mass-spectroscopy setups with the goal to obtain structural information on biomolecular ions labeled with a FRET pair (i.e., donor and acceptor dyes) and to shed light on the energy-transfer process itself. Ions are accumulated in a radio-frequency ion trap or a Penning trap where mass selection of those of interest takes place, followed by photoexcitation. Gas-phase FRET is identified from detection of emitted light either from the donor, the acceptor, or both, or from a fragmentation channel that is specific to the acceptor when electronically excited. The challenge associated with the first approach is the collection and detection of photons emitted from a thin ion cloud that is not easily accessible while the second approach relies both on the photophysical and chemical behavior of the acceptor. In this review, we present the different instrumentation used for gas-phase FRET, including a discussion of advantages and disadvantages, and examples on how the technique has provided important structural information that is not easily obtainable otherwise. Furthermore, we describe how the spectroscopic properties of the dyes are affected by nearby electric fields, which is readily discernable from experiments on simple model systems with alkyl or π-conjugated bridges. Such spectral changes can have a significant effect on the FRET efficiency. Ideas for new directions are presented at the end with special focus on cold-ion spectroscopy.

Cryogenic fluorescence spectroscopy of oxazine ions isolated in vacuo

Recent developments in fluorescence spectroscopy have made it possible to measure both absorption and dispersed fluorescence spectra of isolated molecular ions at liquid-nitrogen temperatures. Absorption is here obtained from fluorescence-excitation experiments and does not rely on ion dissociation. One large advantage of reduced temperature compared to room-temperature spectroscopy is that spectra are narrow, and they provide information on vibronic features that can better be assigned from theoretical simulations. We report on the intrinsic spectroscopic properties of oxazine dyes cooled to about 100 K. They include six cations (crystal violet, darrow red, oxazine-1, oxazine-4, oxazine-170 and nile blue) and one anion (resorufin). Experiments were done with a home-built setup (LUNA2) where ions are stored, mass-selected, cooled, and photoexcited in a cylindrical ion trap. We find that the Stokes shifts are small (14-50 cm-1), which is ascribed to rigid geometries, that is, there are only small geometrical changes between the electronic ground and excited states. However, both the absorption and the emission spectra of darrow-red cations are broader than those of the other ionic dyes, which is likely associated with a less symmetric electronic structure and more non-zero Franck-Condon factors for the vibrational progressions. In the case of resorufin, the smallest ion under study, vibrational features are assigned based on calculated spectra.

Cryogenic Fluorescence Spectroscopy of Ionic Fluorones in Gaseous and Condensed Phases: New Light on Their Intrinsic Photophysics

Fluorescence spectroscopy of gas-phase ions generated through electrospray ionization is an emerging technique able to probe intrinsic molecular photophysics directly without perturbations from solvent interactions. While there is ample scope for the ongoing development of gas-phase fluorescence techniques, the recent expansion into low-temperature operating conditions accesses a wealth of data on intrinsic fluorophore photophysics, offering enhanced spectral resolution compared with room-temperature measurements, without matrix effects hindering the excited-state dynamics. This perspective reviews current progress on understanding the photophysics of anionic fluorone dyes, which exhibit an unusually large Stokes shift in the gas phase, and discusses how comparison of gas- and condensed-phase fluorescence spectra can fingerprint structural dynamics. The capacity for temperature-dependent measurements of both fluorescence emission and excitation spectra helps establish the foundation for the use of fluorone dyes as fluorescent tags in macromolecular structure determination. We suggest ideas for technique development.

Laser-Induced Fluorescence (LIF) Spectroscopy of Trapped Molecular Ions in the Gas Phase

This review focuses on the laser-induced fluorescence (LIF) spectroscopy of trapped gas-phase molecular ions, a developing field of research. Following a brief description of the theory and experimental approaches employed in general for fluorescence spectroscopy, the review summarizes the current state-of-the-art intrinsic fluorescence measurement techniques employed for gas-phase ions. Whereas the LIF spectroscopy of condensed matter systems is a well-developed area of research, the instrumentation used for such studies is not directly applicable to gas-phase ions. However, some measurement schemes employed in condensed-phase experiments could be highly beneficial for gas-phase investigations. We have included a brief discussion on some of these techniques as well. Quadrupole ion traps are commonly used for spatial confinement of ions in the ion-trap-based LIF. One of the main challenges involved in such experiments is the poor signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) arising due to weak gas-phase fluorescence emission, high background noise, and small solid angle for the fluorescence collection optics. The experimental approaches based on the integrated high-finesse optical cavities employed for the condensed-phase measurements provide a better (typically an order of magnitude more) SNR in the detected fluorescence than the single-pass detection schemes. Another key to improving the SNR is to exploit the maximum solid angle of light collection by choosing high numerical aperture (NA) collection optics. A combination of these two approaches integrated with ion traps could transmogrify this field, allowing one to study even weak fluorescence emission from gas-phase molecular ions. The review concludes by discussing the scope of the advances in the LIF instrumentation for detailed spectral characterization of fluorophores of weak gas-phase fluorescence emission, considering fluorescein as one example.

Effect of Freezing out Vibrational Modes on Gas-Phase Fluorescence Spectra of Small Ionic Dyes

While action spectroscopy of cold molecular ions is a well-established technique to provide vibrationally resolved absorption features, fluorescence experiments are still challenging. Here we report the fluorescence spectra of pyronin-Y and resorufin ions at 100 K using a newly constructed setup. Spectra narrow upon cooling, and the emission maxima blueshift. Temperature effects are attributed to the population of vibrational excited levels in S₁, and that frequencies are lower in S₁ than in S₀. This picture is supported by calculated spectra based on a Franck-Condon model that not only predicts the observed change in maximum, but also assigns Franck-Condon active vibrations. In-plane vibrational modes that preserve the mirror plane present in both S₀ and S₁ of resorufin and pyronin Y account for most of the observed vibrational bands. Finally, at low temperatures, it is important to pick an excitation wavelength as far to the red as possible to not reheat the ions.

Unraveling the Mechanism for Tuning the Fluorescence of Fluorescein Derivatives: The Role of the Conical Intersection and nπ* State

Although a large number of fluorescein derivatives have been developed and applied in many different fields, the general mechanisms for tuning the fluorescence of fluorescein derivatives still remain uncovered. Herein, we found that the fluorescence quenching of neutral form of fluorescein derivatives in acidic medium resulted from a dark nπ* state, whereas the fluorescence of the anionic form of fluorescein derivatives in the gas phase and alkaline solutions was tuned by minimal energy conical intersection (MECI). The formation of MECI involved significant rotation of benzene ring and flip-flop motion of xanthene moiety, which would be restricted by intermolecular hydrogen bonding and lowering temperature. The energy barrier for reaching MECI depended on the substituents in the benzene moiety in accordance with experimentally observed substituent effects. These unprecedented mechanisms would lead to a recognition of fluorescein derivatives and could provide a correct and instructive design strategy for further developing new fluorescein derivatives.

Photophysics of Isolated Rose Bengal Anions

Dye molecules based on the xanthene moiety are widely used as fluorescent probes in bioimaging and technological applications due to their large absorption cross-section for visible light and high fluorescence quantum yield. These applications require a clear understanding of the dye's inherent photophysics and the effect of a condensed-phase environment. Here, the gas-phase photophysics of the rose bengal doubly deprotonated dianion [RB - 2H]^2-, deprotonated monoanion [RB - H]^-, and doubly deprotonated radical anion [RB - 2H]^•- is investigated using photodetachment, photoelectron, and dispersed fluorescence action spectroscopies, and tandem ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) coupled with laser excitation. For [RB - 2H]^2-, photodetachment action spectroscopy reveals a clear band in the visible (450-580 nm) with vibronic structure. Electron affinity and repulsive Coulomb barrier (RCB) properties of the dianion are characterized using frequency-resolved photoelectron spectroscopy, revealing a decreased RCB compared with that of fluorescein dianions due to electron delocalization over halogen atoms. Monoanions [RB - H]^- and [RB - 2H]^•- differ in nominal mass by 1 Da but are difficult to study individually using action spectroscopies that isolate target ions using low-resolution mass spectrometry. This work shows that the two monoanions are readily distinguished and probed using the IMS-photo-IMS and photo-IMS-photo-IMS strategies, providing distinct but overlapping photodissociation action spectra in the visible spectral range. Gas-phase fluorescence was not detected from photoexcited [RB - 2H]^2- due to rapid electron ejection. However, both [RB - H]^- and [RB - 2H]^•- show a weak fluorescence signal. The [RB - H]^- action spectra show a large Stokes shift of ∼1700 cm^-1, while the [RB - 2H]^•- action spectra show no appreciable Stokes shift. This difference is explained by considering geometries of the ground and fluorescing states.

Gas-phase action and fluorescence spectroscopy of mass-selected fluorescein monoanions and two derivatives

Gaseous fluorescein monoanions are weakly fluorescent; they display a broad fluorescence spectrum and a large Stokes shift. This contrasts with the situation in aqueous solution. One explanation of the intriguing behavior in vacuo is based on internal proton transfer from the pendant carboxyphenyl group to one of the xanthene oxygens in the excited state; another that rotation of the carboxyphenyl group relative to the xanthene leads to a partial charge transfer from one chromophore (xanthene) to the other (carboxyphenyl) when the π orbitals start to overlap. To shed light on the mechanism at play, we synthesized two fluorescein derivatives where the carboxylic acid group is replaced with either an ester or a tertiary amide functionality and explored their gas-phase ion fluorescence using the home-built LUminescence iNstrument in Aarhus (LUNA) setup. Results on the fluorescein methyl ester that has no acidic proton clearly disprove the former explanation: The spectrum remains broad, and the band center (at 605 nm) is shifted even more to the red than that of fluorescein (590 nm). Experiments on the other variant that contains a piperidino amide are also in favor of the second explanation as here the piperidino already causes the dihedral angle between the planes defining the xanthene and the benzene ring to be less than 90° in the ground state (i.e., 63°), according to density functional theory calculations. As a result of the closer similarity between the ground-state and excited-state structures, the fluorescence spectrum is narrower than those of the other two ions, and the band maximum is further to the blue (575 nm). In accordance with a more delocalized ground state of the amide derivative, action spectra associated with photoinduced dissociation recorded at another setup show that the absorption-band maximum for the amide derivative is redshifted compared to that of fluorescein (538 nm vs. 525 nm).

Absorption and luminescence spectroscopy of mass-selected flavin adenine dinucleotide mono-anions

We report the absorption profile of isolated Flavin Adenine Dinucleotide (FAD) mono-anions recorded using photo-induced dissociation action spectroscopy. In this charge state, one of the phosphoric acid groups is deprotonated and the chromophore itself is in its neutral oxidized state. These measurements cover the first four optical transitions of FAD with excitation energies from 2.3 to 6.0 eV (210-550 nm). The S₀ → S₂ transition is strongly blue shifted relative to aqueous solution, supporting the view that this transition has a significant charge-transfer character. The remaining bands are close to their solution-phase positions. This confirms that the large discrepancy between quantum chemical calculations of vertical transition energies and solution-phase band maxima cannot be explained by solvent effects. We also report the luminescence spectrum of FAD mono-anions in vacuo. The gas-phase Stokes shift for S₁ is 3000 cm^-1, which is considerably larger than any previously reported for other molecular ions and consistent with a significant displacement of the ground and excited state potential energy surfaces. Consideration of the vibronic structure is thus essential for simulating the absorption and luminescence spectra of flavins.