Chemistry meets biology in the coordination dynamics of metalloproteins

Metal sites in proteins are often presented in an idealized way that does not capture the intrinsic dynamic behavior of the protein or the extrinsic factors that affect changes in the coordination of the metal ion in biological space and time. The bioinorganic chemistry possible in healthy and diseased living organisms is limited by prevailing pH values, redox potentials, and availability and concentrations of metal ions and ligands. Changes in any of these parameters and protein-protein or protein-ligand interactions can result in differences in the type of metal ion bound, metal occupancy, and coordination number or geometry. This article addresses the plasticity and complexity of metal coordination in proteins when these parameters are considered. It uses three examples of zinc sites with sulfur donor atoms from cysteines in mammalian proteins: alcohol dehydrogenases, metallothioneins, and zinc transporters of the ZnT (SLC30A) family. Coordination dynamics of the metal sites in these proteins has different purposes; in alcohol dehydrogenases for the metal ion to perform its different roles in the catalytic cycle, in metallothioneins for serving as a metal buffer, and in ZnT zinc transporters for sensing metal ions and moving them through the protein and thus biological membranes. Defining the biological and chemical parameters that determine and affect coordination dynamics of metal ions in proteins will inform future investigations of metalloproteins.

Structural motifs in the early metallation steps of Zn(II) and Cd(II) binding to apo-metallothionein 1a

Many proteins require a metal cofactor to function and these metals are often involved in the protein folding process. The protein metallothionein (MT) has a dynamic structure capable of binding to a variety of metals with different stoichiometries. The most well-understood structure is the seven-metal, two domain structure formed upon metallation using Zn(II) or Cd(II). However, the partially metallated states and the pathways to form these clusters are less well-understood, although it is known that the pathways are pH dependent. Using stopped flow methods, it is shown that the metallation rates of the less cooperative Zn(II) binding pathway is much more impacted by low pH conditions that that of the more cooperative Cd(II) binding pathway. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) methods reveal specific mixtures of bridging and terminally bound MxSy structures form in the first few metallation steps. Using a combination of methods, the data show that the result of unfolding this intrinsically disordered apo-MT structure using guanidinium chloride is that the formation of preliminary bridging structures that form in the first few metallation steps is impeded. The data show that more terminally bound structures form. Our conclusion is that the compact conformation of the native apo-MT at physiological pH allows for rapid formation of complex metal-thiolate structures with high affinity that provides protection from oxidation, a function that is suppressed upon unfolding. Overall, these results highlight both the importance of the apo-MT structure in the metallation pathway, but also the differences in Zn(II) and Cd(II) binding under different conditions.

Metallothionein-3 and carbonic anhydrase metalation properties with Zn(II) and Cd(II) change as a result of protein-protein interactions

Metallothioneins (MT) are regulators of the metals Zn(II) and Cu(I) and act as antioxidants in many organisms, including in humans. Isoform 3 (MT3) is expressed constitutively in central nervous tissue and has been shown to have additional biological functions, including the inhibition of neuronal growth, the regulation of apoptosis, and cytoskeleton modulation. To facilitate these functions, protein-protein interactions likely occur. These interactions may then impact the metalation status of the MT and the recipient metalloprotein. Using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry and circular dichroism spectroscopy, we report that the interaction between the zinc metalloenzyme, carbonic anhydrase (CA), and MT3, impacts the metalation profiles of both apo-MT3 and apo-CA with Cd(II) and Zn(II). We observe two phases in the metalation of the apo-CA, the first of which is associated with an increased binding affinity of apo-CA for Cd/Zn(II) and the second pathway is associated with apo-CA metalated without a change in binding affinity. The weak interactions that result in this change of binding affinity are not detectable as a protein complex in the ESI-mass spectral data or in the circular dichroism spectra. These unusual metalation properties of apo-CA in the presence of apo-MT3 are evidence of the effects of protein-protein interactions. With adjustment to take into account the interaction of both proteins, we report the complete Cd(II) and Zn(II) binding constants of MT3 under physiological conditions, as well as the pH dependence of these binding pathways.

Evolution of Cd2+ and Cu+ binding in Helix pomatia metallothioneins

Metallothioneins (MTs) are small proteins present in all kingdoms of life. Their high cysteine content enables them to bind metal ions, such as Zn2+, Cd2+, and Cu+, providing means for detoxification and metal homeostasis. Three MT isoforms with distinct metal binding preferences are present in the Roman Snail Helix pomatia. Here, we use nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) to follow the evolution of Cd2+ and Cu+ binding from the reconstructed ancestral Stylommatophora MT to the three H. pomatia MT (HpMT) isoforms. Information obtained from [15N,1H]-HSQC spectra and T2 relaxation times are combined to describe the conformational stability of the MT-metal complexes. A well-behaved MT-metal complex adopts a unique structure and does not undergo additional conformational exchange. The ancestor to all three HpMTs forms conformationally stable Cd2+ complexes and closely resembles the Cd2+-specific HpCdMT isoform, suggesting a role in Cd2+ detoxification for the ancestral protein. All Cu+-MT complexes, including the Cu+-specific HpCuMT isoform, undergo a considerable amount of conformational exchange. The unspecific HpCd/CuMT and the Cu+-specific HpCuMT isoforms form Cu+ complexes with comparable characteristics. It is possible to follow how Cd2+ and Cu+ binding changed throughout evolution. Interestingly, Cu+ binding improved independently in the lineages leading to the unspecific and the Cu+-specific HpMT isoforms. C-terminal domains are generally less capable of coordinating the non-cognate metal ion than N-terminal domains, indicating a higher level of specialization of the C-domain. Our findings provide new insights into snail MT evolution, helping to understand the interplay between biological function and structural features toward a comprehensive understanding of metal preference.

Metallothionein-2: An emerging target in inflammatory diseases and cancers

Metallothionein-2 (MT-2) was originally discovered as a mediator of zinc homeostasis and cadmium detoxification. However, MT-2 has recently received increased attention because altered expression of MT-2 is closely related to various diseases such as asthma and cancers. Several pharmacological strategies have been developed to inhibit or modify MT-2, revealing its potential as drug target in diseases. Therefore, a better understanding of the mechanisms of MT-2 action is warranted to improve drug development for potential clinical applications. In this review, we highlight recent advances in determining the protein structure, regulation, binding partners, and new functions of MT-2 in inflammatory diseases and cancers.

Apo-metallothionein-3 cooperatively forms tightly compact structures under physiological conditions

Metallothioneins (MTs) are essential mammalian metal chaperones. MT isoform 1 (MT1) is expressed in the kidneys and isoform 3 (MT3) is expressed in nervous tissue. For MTs, the solution-based NMR structure was determined for metal-bound MT1 and MT2, and only one X-ray diffraction structure on a crystallized mixed metal-bound MT2 has been reported. The structure of solution-based metalated MT3 is partially known using NMR methods; however, little is known about the fluxional de novo apo-MT3 because the structure cannot be determined by traditional methods. Here, we used cysteine modification coupled with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, denaturing reactions with guanidinium chloride, stopped-flow methods measuring cysteine modification and metalation, and ion mobility mass spectrometry to reveal that apo-MT3 adopts a compact structure under physiological conditions and an extended structure under denaturing conditions, with no intermediates. Compared with apo-MT1, we found that this compact apo-MT3 binds to a cysteine modifier more cooperatively at equilibrium and 0.5 times the rate, providing quantitative evidence that many of the 20 cysteines of apo-MT3 are less accessible than those of apo-MT1. In addition, this compact apo-MT3 can be identified as a distinct population using ion mobility mass spectrometry. Furthermore, proposed structural models can be calculated using molecular dynamics methods. Collectively, these findings provide support for MT3 acting as a noninducible regulator of the nervous system compared with MT1 as an inducible scavenger of trace metals and toxic metals in the kidneys.

An Integrated Mass Spectrometry and Molecular Dynamics Simulations Approach Reveals the Spatial Organization Impact of Metal-Binding Sites on the Stability of Metal-Depleted Metallothionein-2 Species

Mammalian metallothioneins (MTs) are a group of cysteine-rich proteins that bind metal ions in two α- and β-domains and represent a major cellular Zn(II)/Cu(I) buffering system in the cell. At cellular free Zn(II) concentrations (10-11-10-9 M), MTs do not exist in fully loaded forms with seven Zn(II)-bound ions (Zn7MTs). Instead, MTs exist as partially metal-depleted species (Zn4-6MT) because their Zn(II) binding affinities are on the nano- to picomolar range comparable to the concentrations of cellular Zn(II). The mode of action of MTs remains poorly understood, and thus, the aim of this study is to characterize the mechanism of Zn(II) (un)binding to MTs, the thermodynamic properties of the Zn1-6MT2 species, and their mechanostability properties. To this end, native mass spectrometry (MS) and label-free quantitative bottom-up and top-down MS in combination with steered molecular dynamics simulations, well-tempered metadynamics (WT-MetaD), and parallel-bias WT-MetaD (amounting to 3.5 μs) were integrated to unravel the chemical coordination of Zn(II) in all Zn1-6MT2 species and to explain the differences in binding affinities of Zn(II) ions to MTs. Differences are found to be the result of the degree of water participation in MT (un)folding and the hyper-reactive character of Cys21 and Cys29 residues. The thermodynamics properties of Zn(II) (un)binding to MT2 are found to differ from those of Cd(II), justifying their distinctive roles. The potential of this integrated strategy in the investigation of numerous unexplored metalloproteins is attested by the results highlighted in the present study.

Structurally restricted Bi(III) metallation of apo-βMT1a: metal-induced tangling

Non-toxic bismuth salts are used in anti-ulcer medications and to protect against nephrotoxicity from anticancer drugs. Bismuth salts also induce metallothionein (MT), a metal-binding protein that lacks a formal secondary structure. We report the impact on the metallation properties of Bi(III) to the 9-cysteine β fragment of MT as a function of cysteine accessibility using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. At pH 7.4, Bi2βMT formed cooperatively. Cysteine modification shows that each Bi(III) was terminally bound to three cysteinyl thiolates. Non-cooperative Bi(III) binding was observed at pH 2.3, where cysteine accessibility is increased. However, competition from H4EDTA inhibited Bi(III) binding. When GdmCl, a well-known denaturing agent, was used to increase cysteine accessibility of the apoβMT at pH 7.4, a greater fraction of Bi3βMT formed using all nine cysteines. The change in binding profile and equilibrium of Bi2βMT was determined as a function of acidification, which changed as a result of competition with H4EDTA. There was no Bi(III) transfer between Bi2βMT, Cd3βMT, and Zn3βMT. This lack of metal exchange and the resistance towards binding the third Bi(III) suggest a rigidity in the Bi2βMT binding sites that inhibits Bi(III) mobility. These experiments emphasize the conformational control of metallation that results in substantially different metallated products: at pH 7.4 (many cysteines buried) Bi2βMT, whereas at pH 7.4 (all cysteines accessible) enhanced formation of Bi3βMT. These data suggest that the addition of the first two Bi(III) crosslinks the protein, blocking access to the remaining three cysteines for the third Bi(III), as a result of tangle formation.

Interplay between Carbonic Anhydrases and Metallothioneins: Structural Control of Metalation

Carbonic anhydrases (CAs) and metallothioneins (MTs) are both families of zinc metalloproteins central to life, however, they coordinate and interact with their Zn2+ ion cofactors in completely different ways. CAs and MTs are highly sensitive to the cellular environment and play key roles in maintaining cellular homeostasis. In addition, CAs and MTs have multiple isoforms with differentiated regulation. This review discusses current literature regarding these two families of metalloproteins in carcinogenesis, with a dialogue on the association of these two ubiquitous proteins in vitro in the context of metalation. Metalation of CA by Zn-MT and Cd-MT is described. Evidence for protein-protein interactions is introduced from changes in metalation profiles of MT from electrospray ionization mass spectrometry and the metalation rate from stopped-flow kinetics. The implications on cellular control of pH and metal donation is also discussed in the context of diseased states.

pH dependence of the non-cooperative binding of Bi3+ to human apo-metallothionein 1A: kinetics, speciation, and stoichiometry

ESI-MS along with cysteine modification show that the binding of Bi³⁺ to apo-metallothionein is non-cooperative with a coordination of BiS(cys)₃ up to Bi₆MT. Stopped flow kinetics reveal that the rate of binding depends on the pH and the Bi³⁺ anion.

Metallothionein Cd4S11cluster formation dominates in the protection of carbonic anhydrase

Results from ESI-MS and stopped flow kinetics show that apo-MT protects from toxic metalation of apo-CA with Cd²⁺due to the protein–protein interactions in solution.

The pathways and domain specificity of Cu(i) binding to human metallothionein 1A

We describe the sequential formation of 3 key Cu(i)–thiolate clusters in human metallothionein 1A using a combination of ESI-MS and phosphorescence lifetime methods.