On the involvement of d-electrons in superatomic shells: the group 3 and 4 transition metals

An Open-Shell Superatom Cluster Ta10- with Enhanced Stability by United d-d π Bonds and d-Orbital Superatomic States

We carried out a comprehensive study on the gas-phase reactions of Ta_n^- (n = 5-27) with nitrogen using a customized reflection time-of-flight mass spectrometer coupled with a velocity map imaging apparatus (Re-TOFMS-VMI). Among the studied tantalum clusters, Ta₁₀^- exhibits prominent mass abundance indicative of its unique inertness. DFT calculation results revealed a D_4d bipyramidal prolate structure of the most stable Ta₁₀^-, which was verified by photoelectron spectroscopy experiments. The calculations also unveiled that Ta₁₀^- has the largest HOMO-LUMO gap and second-order difference of binding energy among the studied clusters. This is associated with its well-organized superatomic orbitals, which consist of both 6s and 5d orbitals of tantalum atoms, allowing for splitting of superatomic 1D and 2P orbitals and an enlarged gap between the singly occupied molecular orbital (SOMO) and unoccupied β counterpart, which brings forth stabilization energy pertaining to Jahn-Teller distortion. Also, the SOMO exhibits a united d-d π orbital pattern that embraces the central Ta₈^- moiety.

Vanadium Cluster Neutrals Reacting with Water: Superatomic Features and Hydrogen Evolution in a Fishing Mode

Hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) is known as the heart of various energy storage and conversation systems of renewable energy sources. Here we observe the cluster reactions of a light transition metal, vanadium, with water in a gas-phase flow tube reactor. While HER products of V₁ and V₂ were not observed, the effective HER of water on neutral V_n (n ≥ 3) clusters reveals reasonable and size-dependent reactivity of the vanadium clusters. Superatomic features and reaction dynamics of V₁₀, V₁₃, and V₁₆ are highlighted. Among the three typical superatoms, V₁₀ and V₁₆ exhibit an abnormal superatomic orbital energy level order, 1S|2S|1P|1D..., where the energy-reduced 2S orbital helps to accommodate the geometric structure and hence reinforce the cluster stability. In comparison, V₁₃ bears a less symmetrical structure and reacts readily with water, allowing for recombination of a hydroxyl atom with an adsorbed hydrogen atom, akin to a fishing-mode HER process. The joint experimental and theoretical study on neutral V_n clusters clarifies the availability of superatom chemistry for transition metals and appeals further development of cluster theory based on electronic cloud/orbital analysis instead of simply counting the valence electrons. Also, we provide insights into the HER mechanism of metal clusters and propose a strategy to design new materials for portable fuel cells of hydrogen energy.

Multiple d-d bonds between early transition metals in TM2Lin (TM = Sc, Ti) superatomic molecule clusters

The synthesis and application of compounds with Cr-Cr and V-V d-d quintuple bonds (σ, 2π, 2δ) have led to new thinking about whether d-d multiple bonds also exist between early transition metals such as Sc-Sc and Ti-Ti. In this study, by extensive unbiased global search at the density functional theory level, the low-energy structures of 26e and 30e TM2Lin clusters were obtained. Based on the super valence bond (SVB) theory, the prolate double-core structure of TM2Lin clusters was regarded as a superatomic molecule, of which each half was regarded as an open-shell superatom, and the electronic shell-closure was realized by forming multiple bonds between superatoms. Then, the quintuple super bonds (2δ, 2π, σ) of the Li18Ti2, Li20Sc2, [Li17V2]+, [Li17Ti2]- clusters and the triple super bonds (2π, σ) of the Li24Sc2 and Li24Y2 clusters were confirmed via chemical-bonding analysis. This way of forming multiple bonds between early transition metals through superatomic bonding has promoted the experimental synthesis and application of early transition metal multiple bond compounds.

Design of superatomic systems: exploiting favourable conditions for the delocalisation of d-electron density in transition metal doped clusters

The incorporation of transition metals into superatomic species has led to the proposal of highly tailorable systems, with the transition metal atoms typically acting as magnetic dopants. However, the extent to which d-electrons are able to delocalise from their ionic cores has not been fully recognised. In this work a variety of systems have been explored using a range of exchange-correlation functionals commonly used to explore cluster species, to test the extent of d-electron delocalisation under favourable conditions. Early transition metals have been shown to readily delocalise their valence d-electrons for superatomic shell closing, with higher period atoms showing a greater tendency for delocalisation. Our findings also provide the framework for the design of superatomic systems with large numbers of electrons being contributed from a single atom.

5-Fold symmetry in superatomic scandium clusters: exploiting favourable orbital overlap to sequester spin

The geometries and electronic structures of icosahedral A₁₃^C (A = Sc, Y; C = 0, ±1, ±2) clusters have been determined at a range of multiplicities at each cluster charge, using density functional theory methods. These clusters demonstrate a complex electronic structure which provides insight into the anomalously high magnetic moment of icosahedral group 3 clusters and further contextualises the role of transition metals and d-electrons within the superatomic model. Embedded deeply within the density of states for these clusters are typical superatom orbitals which are populated up to the 2S level. Above the 2S-state there are three states of apparent F symmetry, which are preferentially singly occupied, followed by an abundance of approximately degenerate P-, G-, D- and F-states at the Fermi energy, which are at most singly occupied. In spite of apparent angular symmetry and a nodal structure reminiscent of superatomic orbitals these states are actually formed from preferential overlap of the valence d-orbitals of the cluster atoms. This analysis was further contextualised through analysis of the Sc₁₉ cluster, which shows a similar construction of Kohn-Sham states, but with the breaking of 5-fold symmetry along one of its Cartesian axes. Finally, this work clearly demonstrates the ability of d-electrons to give rise to superatomic orbitals is not just constrained by atomic species but also by the local environment of the atoms.

On the influence of exact exchange on transition metal superatoms

The electronic structure of A7C (A = Hg, Pd, V, Cr, Mn, Fe, Ni, Cu; C = 0, ±1, ±2) clusters has been determined using density functional theory methods. The A7C (A = Hg, Pd, Cr, Cu; C = 0, ±1, ±2) clusters all conform to the existing superatomic model, with a sufficiently stabilised local structure to prevent perturbation upon the introduction of exact exchange to the exchange correlation functional. For the A7C (A = Mn, Fe, Ni; C = 0, ±1, ±2) clusters the incorporation of exact exchange separates the atomic s- and d-electrons, leading to a net increase in the number of superatomic electrons. Conversely the incorporation of exact exchange into the exchange correlation functional decreases the number of superatomic electrons for the V7C (C = 0, ±1, ±2) clusters, owing to the radial extension of the d-orbitals influencing their ability to contribute into superatomic shells.

Size, Composition, and Support-Doping Effects on Oxygen Reduction Activity of Platinum-Alloy and on Non-platinum Metal-Decorated-Graphene Nanocatalysts

Recent investigations reported in the open literature concerning the functionalization of graphene as a support material for transition metal nanoparticle catalysts have examined isolated systems for their potential Oxygen Reduction Reaction (ORR) activity. In this work we present results which characterize the ability to use functionalized graphene (via dopants B, N) to upshift and downshift the adsorption energy of mono-atomic oxygen, O* (the ORR activity descriptor on ORR Volcano Plots), for various compositions of 4-atom, 7-atom, and 19-atom sub-nanometer binary alloy/intermetallic transition metal nanoparticle catalysts on graphene (TMNP-MDG). Our results show several important and interesting features: (1) that the combination of geometric and electronic effects makes development of simple linear mixing rules for size/composition difficult; (2) that the transition from 4- to 7- to 19-atom TMNP on MDG has pronounced effects on ORR activity for all compositions; (3) that the use of B and N as dopants to modulate the graphene-TMNP electronic structure interaction can cause shifts in the oxygen adsorption energy of 0.5 eV or more; (4) that it might be possible to make specific doped-graphene-Ni_xCu_y TMNP systems which fall close to the Volcano Peak for ORR. Our results point to systems which should be investigated experimentally and may improve the viability of future fuel cell or other ORR applications, and provide new paths for future investigations of more detail for TMNP-MDG screening.