Enzyme-assisted mineralization of calcium phosphate: exploring confinement for the design of highly crystalline nano-objects

Role of Heterogeneous Enzyme Activity in the Formation of Calcium Phosphate Nanomaterials

The enzymatic formation of calcium phosphate (CaP) in bone is a prime example of how living organisms utilize enzymes to precisely regulate biomineral nucleation and growth, serving as inspiration for the design of biomimetic nanomaterials. In this study, we investigated the formation mechanisms of enzymatic CaP in buffered solutions using single molecule enzymology and cryo-transmission electron microscopy to probe the relationship between tissue nonspecific alkaline phosphatase (TNALP) activity and CaP formation pathways. We characterized the dynamics of heterogeneous TNALP activity, which consists of singly and doubly active enzyme molecules during enzymatic CaP formation and identified two distinct formation pathways that produce amorphous calcium phosphate nanoparticles and octacalcium phosphate nanoparticles. These results show the complex and potentially powerful relationship between heterogeneous enzyme activity and CaP formation mechanisms, offering a new level of control in space and time for the design of biomimetic nanomaterials.

Bioinspired Nanoscale 3D Printing of Calcium Phosphates Using Bone Prenucleation Clusters

Calcium phosphates (CaPs) are ubiquitous in biological structures, such as vertebrate bones and teeth, and have been widely used in biomedical applications. However, fabricating CaPs at the nanoscale in 3D has remained a significant challenge, particularly due to limitations in current nanofabrication techniques, such as two-photon polymerization (2pp), which are not applicable for creating CaP nanostructures. In this study, a novel approach is presented to 3D print CaP structures with unprecedented resolution of ≈300 nm precision, achieving a level of detail three orders of magnitude finer than any existing additive manufacturing techniques for CaPs. This advancement is achieved by leveraging bioinspired chemistry, utilizing bone prenucleation nanoclusters (PNCs, average size of 5 nm), within a photosensitive resin. These nanoclusters form a highly transparent photoresist, overcoming the light-scattering typically associated with larger calcium phosphate-based nanoparticles. This method not only allows for nanopatterning of CaPs on diverse substrates, but also enables the precise control of microstructure down to the level of submicron grains. The method paves the way for the developing of bioinspired metamaterials, lightweight damage-tolerant materials, cell-modulating interfaces, and precision-engineered coatings.

Seriation of Enzyme-Functionalized Multilayers for the Design of Scalable Biomimetic Mineralized Structures

Biomimetic hydroxyapatites are widely explored for their potential applications in the repair of mineralized tissues, particularly dental enamel, which is acellular and, thus, not naturally reformed after damage. Enamel is formed with a highly-controlled hierarchical structure, which is difficult to replicate up to the macroscale. A biomimetic approach is thus warranted, based on the same principles that drive biomineralization in vivo. Herein, a strategy for the design of enamel-like architectures is described, utilizing enzymes embedded in polyelectrolyte multilayers to generate inorganic phosphate locally, and provide a favorable chemical environment for the nucleation and growth of minerals. Moreover, a method is proposed to build up seriated mineral layers with scalable thicknesses, continuous mineral growth, and tunable morphology. Results show the outstanding growth of cohesive mineral layers, yielding macroscopic standalone fluoride and/or carbonate-substituted hydroxyapatite materials with comparable crystal structure and composition to native human mineralized tissues. This strategy presents a promising path forward for the biomimetic design of biomineral materials, particularly relevant for restorative applications, with an exquisite level of synthetic control over multiple orders of magnitude.

Enzyme-Activated Biomimetic Vesicles Confining Mineralization for Bone Maturation

Inspired by the crucial role of matrix vesicles (MVs), a series of biomimetic vesicles (BVs) fabricated by calcium glycerophosphate (CaGP) modified polyurethane were designed to mediate the mineralization through in situ enzyme activation for bone therapy. In this study, alkaline phosphatase (ALP) was harbored in the porous BVs by adsorption (Ad-BVs) or entrapment (En-BVs). High encapsulation of ALP on En-BVs was effectively self-activating by calcium ions of CaGP-modified PU that specifically hydrolyzed the organophosphorus (CaGP) to inorganic phosphate, thus promoting the formation of the highly oriented bone-like apatite in vitro. Enzyme-catalyzed kinetics confirms the regulation of apatite crystallization by the synergistic action of self-activated ALP and the confined microcompartments of BVs. This leads to a supersaturated microenvironment, with the En-BVs group exhibiting inorganic phosphate (Pi) levels 4.19 times higher and Ca2+ levels 3.67 times higher than those of simulated body fluid (SBF). Of note, the En-BVs group exhibited excellent osteo-inducing differentiation of BMSCs in vitro and the highest maturity with reduced bone loss in rat femoral defect in vivo. This innovative strategy of biomimetic vesicles is expected to provide valuable insights into the enzyme-activated field of bone therapy.

Guidelines derived from biomineralized tissues for design and construction of high-performance biomimetic materials: from weak to strong

Living organisms in nature have undergone continuous evolution over billions of years, resulting in the formation of high-performance fracture-resistant biomineralized tissues such as bones and teeth to fulfill mechanical and biological functions, despite the fact that most inorganic biominerals that constitute biomineralized tissues are weak and brittle. During the long-period evolution process, nature has evolved a number of highly effective and smart strategies to design chemical compositions and structures of biomineralized tissues to enable superior properties and to adapt to surrounding environments. Most biomineralized tissues have hierarchically ordered structures consisting of very small building blocks on the nanometer scale (nanoparticles, nanofibers or nanoflakes) to reduce the inherent weaknesses and brittleness of corresponding inorganic biominerals, to prevent crack initiation and propagation, and to allow high defect tolerance. The bioinspired principles derived from biomineralized tissues are indispensable for designing and constructing high-performance biomimetic materials. In recent years, a large number of high-performance biomimetic materials have been prepared based on these bioinspired principles with a large volume of literature covering this topic. Therefore, a timely and comprehensive review on this hot topic is highly important and contributes to the future development of this rapidly evolving research field. This review article aims to be comprehensive, authoritative, and critical with wide general interest to the science community, summarizing recent advances in revealing the formation processes, composition, and structures of biomineralized tissues, providing in-depth insights into guidelines derived from biomineralized tissues for the design and construction of high-performance biomimetic materials, and discussing recent progress, current research trends, key problems, future main research directions and challenges, and future perspectives in this exciting and rapidly evolving research field.

Calcium Phosphate-Based Nanomaterials: Preparation, Multifunction, and Application for Bone Tissue Engineering

Calcium phosphate is the main inorganic component of bone. Calcium phosphate-based biomaterials have demonstrated great potential in bone tissue engineering due to their superior biocompatibility, pH-responsive degradability, excellent osteoinductivity, and similar components to bone. Calcium phosphate nanomaterials have gained more and more attention for their enhanced bioactivity and better integration with host tissues. Additionally, they can also be easily functionalized with metal ions, bioactive molecules/proteins, as well as therapeutic drugs; thus, calcium phosphate-based biomaterials have been widely used in many other fields, such as drug delivery, cancer therapy, and as nanoprobes in bioimaging. Thus, the preparation methods of calcium phosphate nanomaterials were systematically reviewed, and the multifunction strategies of calcium phosphate-based biomaterials have also been comprehensively summarized. Finally, the applications and perspectives of functionalized calcium phosphate biomaterials in bone tissue engineering, including bone defect repair, bone regeneration, and drug delivery, were illustrated and discussed by presenting typical examples.

Kinetic Study of Calcium Phosphate Mineralisation in Biomimetic Conditions: An Enzymatic Model Approach

Although it has been studied for decades, calcium phosphate (CaP) biomineralisation remains an unclear process involving many possible pathways depending on subtle biological parameters that are hard to mimic. In this work, we explore the catalytic activity of enzymes to direct CaP crystallisation. This idea derives from the remarkable capacity of matrix vesicles (MVs) to control CaP biomineralisation in vivo by involving a variety of proteins, including enzymes. We highlight how the enzymatic control of the release of phosphate ions allows to better steer when and how the minerals form by tuning the enzymatic activity. We also illustrate how this enzymatic control enables the deeper understanding of the role of a crystallisation inhibitor, magnesium ions. Moreover, we propose in this study the original and extensive use of both dynamic (DLS) and static (SLS) light scattering measurements to follow the mineralisation in real-time and to provide kinetic quantitative parameters to describe this phenomenon. The combination of the techniques reveals noticeable differences in terms of nucleation and growth process between the two levers used in this approach: (i) adjusting the time evolution of the supersaturation or (ii) moderating the crystallisation process. This study allowed also to pinpoint specific intermediate structures, rarely seen and difficult to isolate, that differ when magnesium ions are introduced in the mixture.

Tunable Enzyme-Assisted Mineralization of Apatitic Calcium Phosphate by Homogeneous Catalysis

While it has long been mimicked by simple precipitation reactions under biologically relevant conditions, calcium phosphate biomineralization is a complex process, which is highly regulated by physicochemical factors and involves a variety of proteins and other biomolecules. Alkaline phosphatase (ALP), in particular, is a conductor of sorts, directly regulating the amount of orthophosphate ions available for mineralization. Herein, we explore enzyme-assisted mineralization in the homogeneous phase as a method for biomimetic mineralization and focus on how relevant ionic substitution types affect the obtained minerals. For this purpose, mineralization is performed over a range of enzyme substrate concentrations and fluoride concentrations at physiologically relevant conditions (pH 7.4, T = 37 °C). Refinement of X-ray diffraction data is used to study the crystallographic unit cell parameters for evidence of ionic substitution in the lattice, and infrared (IR) spectroscopy and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) are used for complementary information regarding the chemical composition of the minerals. The results show the formation of substituted hydroxyapatite (HAP) after 48 h mineralization in all conditions. Interestingly, an expansion of the crystalline unit cell with an increasing concentration of the enzyme substrate is observed, with only slight changes in the particle morphology. On the contrary, by increasing the amount of fluoride, while keeping the enzyme substrate concentration unchanged, a contraction of the crystalline unit cell and the formation of elongated, well-crystallized rods are observed. Complementary IR and XPS data indicate that these trends are explained by the incorporation of substituted ions, namely CO₃^2- and F^-, in the HAP lattice at different positions.

Stiff and Tough Hydrogels Prepared Through Integration of Ionic Cross-linking and Enzymatic Mineralization

Enzymatic mineralization has become an effective approach to enhancing the stiffness of hydrogels for bone tissue engineering, but generally with limited toughness. On the other hand, double network cross-linking provides hydrogel with enhanced toughness. In this study, we integrated double cross-linking method with enzymatic mineralization to synthesize stiff and tough hydrogels. We have synthesized three kinds of sodium alginate-polyacrylamide (SA-PAM) double-network hydrogels and systematically compared the composition and structure differences, mechanical properties, and biological properties of the different hydrogels in the absence and presence of mineralization. In particular, we examined the role of specific cross-linking ions, i.e., calcium, zinc and strontium ions, in modulating the mineralization process. Synergistic effect of ionic cross-linking and enzymatic mineralization was clearly observed with dramatic increase in compressive modulus. In particular, mineralized hydrogel cross-linked with Sr2+ showed the highest compressive Young's modulus of 17.28 ± 3.56 MPa, which was 37 times of that of the original hydrogel. In addition, it had the highest tensile Young's modulus at 2.60 ± 0.25 MPa and 84 ± 5.5% elongation at break. Such synergistic effect from Sr2+ was attributed to a more uniformed mineralization process due to the early initiation of a more homogeneous nucleation process and subsequent denser mineralized structure. Cellular study also suggested that cell proliferation, adhesion and osteogenic differentiation were improved as a result of enzymatic mineralization. Our results provided an effective way for the preparation of stiff and tough hydrogels with osteogenesis, and demonstrated potential in bone tissue engineering applications. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: : Hydrogels with excellent stiffness, stability and biocompatibility have attracted significant attentions in the bone tissue engineering applications. Our results suggested that the synergistic effect of ionic cross-linking and enzymatic mineralization rendered more enhancement of the compressive and tensile stiffness of SA-PAM DN hydrogels, as well as the toughness, swelling stability and cellular response. In particular, mineralized hydrogel cross-linked with Sr2+ showed the highest compressive Young's modulus of 17283 ± 3556KPa, which was 37 times of that of the original hydrogel. Such synergistic effect from Sr2+ was attributed to a more uniformed mineralization process. The cell proliferation, adhesion and osteogenic differentiation were greatly improved as a result of enzymatic mineralization, where the MSCs cultured on strontium ion cross-linked mineralized hydrogel showed the best performance.

Enzymatic Approach in Calcium Phosphate Biomineralization: A Contribution to Reconcile the Physicochemical with the Physiological View

Biomineralization is the process by which organisms produce hard inorganic matter from soft tissues with outstanding control of mineral deposition in time and space. For this purpose, organisms deploy a sophisticated "toolkit" that has resulted in significant evolutionary innovations, for which calcium phosphate (CaP) is the biomineral selected for the skeleton of vertebrates. While CaP mineral formation in aqueous media can be investigated by studying thermodynamics and kinetics of phase transitions in supersaturated solutions, biogenic mineralization requires coping with the inherent complexity of biological systems. This mainly includes compartmentalization and homeostatic processes used by organisms to regulate key physiological factors, including temperature, pH and ion concentration. A detailed analysis of the literature shows the emergence of two main views describing the mechanism of CaP biomineralization. The first one, more dedicated to the study of in vivo systems and supported by researchers in physiology, often involves matrix vesicles (MVs). The second one, more investigated by the physicochemistry community, involves collagen intrafibrillar mineralization particularly through in vitro acellular models. Herein, we show that there is an obvious need in the biological systems to control both where and when the mineral forms through an in-depth survey of the mechanism of CaP mineralization. This necessity could gather both communities of physiologists and physicochemists under a common interest for an enzymatic approach to better describe CaP biomineralization. Both homogeneous and heterogeneous enzymatic catalyses are conceivable for these systems, and a few preliminary promising results on CaP mineralization for both types of enzymatic catalysis are reported in this work. Through them, we aim to describe the relevance of our point of view and the likely findings that could be obtained when adding an enzymatic approach to the already rich and creative research field dealing with CaP mineralization. This complementary approach could lead to a better understanding of the biomineralization mechanism and inspire the biomimetic design of new materials.

Embedding Collagen in Multilayers for Enzyme-Assisted Mineralization: A Promising Way to Direct Crystallization in Confinement

The biogenic calcium phosphate (CaP) crystallization is a process that offers elegant materials design strategies to achieve bioactive and biomechanical challenges. Indeed, many biomimetic approaches have been developed for this process in order to produce mineralized structures with controlled crystallinity and shape. Herein, we propose an advanced biomimetic approach for the design of ordered hybrid mineralized nano-objects with highly anisotropic features. For this purpose, we explore the combination of three key concepts in biomineralization that provide a unique environment to control CaP nucleation and growth: (i) self-assembly and self-organization of biomacromolecules, (ii) enzymatic heterogeneous catalysis, and (iii) mineralization in confinement. We use track-etched templates that display a high density of aligned monodisperse pores so that each nanopore may serve as a miniaturized mineralization bioreactor. We enhance the control of the crystallization in these systems by coassembling type I collagen and enzymes within the nanopores, which allows us to tune the main characteristics of the mineralized nano-objects. Indeed, the synergy between the gradual release of one of the mineral ion precursors by the enzyme and the role of the collagen in the regulation of the mineralization allowed to control their morphology, chemical composition, crystal phase, and mechanical stability. Moreover, we provide clear insight into the prominent role of collagen in the mineralization process in confinement. In the absence of collagen, the fraction of crystalline nano-objects increases to the detriment of amorphous ones when increasing the degree of confinement. By contrast, the presence of collagen-based multilayers disturbs the influence of confinement on the mineralization: platelet-like crystalline hydroxyapatite form, independently of the degree of confinement. This suggests that the incorporation of collagen is an efficient way to supplement the lack of confinement while reinforcing mechanical stability to the highly anisotropic materials. From a bioengineering perspective, this biomineralization-inspired approach opens up new horizons for the design of anisotropic mineralized nano-objects that are highly sought after to develop biomaterials or tend to replicate the complex structure of native mineralized extracellular matrices.

Layer-by-layer assembly in nanochannels: assembly mechanism and applications

Layer-by-layer (LbL) assembly is a versatile technology to construct multifunctional nanomaterials using various supporting substrates, enabled by the large selection freedom of building materials and diversity of possible driving forces. The fine regulation over the film thickness and structure provides an elegant way to tune the physical/chemical properties by mild assembly conditions (e.g. pH, ion strength). In this review, we focus on LbL in nanochannels, which exhibit a different growth mechanism compared to "open", convex substrates. The assembly mechanism in nanochannels is discussed in detail, followed by the summary of applications of LbL assemblies liberated from nanochannel templates which can be used as nanoreactors, drug carriers and transporting channels across cell membranes. For fluidic applications, robust membrane substrates are required to keep in place nanotube arrays for membrane-based separation, purification, biosensing and energy harvesting, which are also discussed. The good compatibility of LbL with crossover technologies from other fields allows researchers to further extend this technology to a broader range of research fields, which is expected to result in an increased number of applications of LbL technology in the future.

Photocrosslinkable nanocomposite ink for printing strong, biodegradable and bioactive bone graft

3D printing is known as a cost-effective technique that shows huge potential in fabrication of graft substitutes for bone tissue regeneration. However, the tradeoff between 3D printability, mechanical strength and bioactivity of the printed materials (i.e., inks) remains a challenge. In this work, we present a novel photocrosslinkable nanocomposite ink composed of tri-block poly (lactide-co-propylene glycol-co-lactide) dimethacrylate (P_mL_nDMA, m and n respectively represent the unit length of propylene glycol and lactide) and hydroxyethyl methacrylate (HEMA)-functionalized hydroxyapatite nanoparticles (nHAMA). The reactive HEMA-conjugated nHAMA, is designed to covalently crosslink with the surrounding polymer matrix to further increase the interfacial bonding between them. We find that the nHAMA can rapidly interact with P_mL_nDMA upon light exposure within 140 s and form an inorganic-organic co-crosslinked nanocomposite network, further enhancing the nanofiller-matrix interfacial compatibility. Notably, our nanocomposites possess significantly improved mechanical performances compared to the polymer, with compressive modulus increasing by nearly 10 times (from ⁓40 to ⁓400 MPa). Moreover, thanks to the low exothermic heat generation (<37 °C) during photocrosslinking, our nanocomposite ink enables facile encapsulation and long-term release of heat-labile biomolecules like bone morphogenic protein-2 (BMP-2). Furthermore, it demonstrates a readily tunable rheological property, wettability, degradation, and printability as a 3D bone scaffold. Together with its superior osteogenic ability both in vitro and in vivo, we envision that our nanocomposite ink holds great promise in 3D printing of bone grafts.