Decoupling salt- and polymer-dependent dynamics in polyelectrolyte complex coacervates via salt addition

Segregative phase separation of strong polyelectrolyte complexes at high salt and high polymer concentrations

The phase behavior of polyelectrolyte complexes and coacervates (PECs) at low salt concentrations has been well characterized, but their behavior at concentrations well above the binodal is not well understood. Here, we investigate the phase behavior of stoichiometric poly(styrene sulfonate)/poly(diallyldimethylammonium) mixtures at high salt and high polymer concentrations. Samples were prepared by direct mixing of PSS/PDADMA PECs, water, and salt (KBr). Phase separation was observed at salt concentrations approximately 1 M above the binodal. Characterization by thermogravimetric analysis, FTIR, and NMR revealed that both phases contained significant amounts of polymer, and that the polymer-rich phase was enriched in PSS, while the polymer-poor phase was enriched in PDADMA. These results suggest that high salt concentrations drive salting out of the more hydrophobic polyelectrolyte (PSS), consistent with behavior observed in weak polyelectrolyte systems. Interestingly, at the highest salt and polymer concentrations studied, the polymer-rich phase contained both PSS and PDADMA, suggesting that high salt concentrations can drive salting out of partially-neutralized complexes as well. Characterization of the behavior of PECs in the high concentration limit appears to be a fruitful avenue for deepening fundamental understanding of the molecular-scale factors driving phase separation in these systems.

Dynamic Ion Gels from the Complex Coacervation of Oppositely Charged Poly(ionic liquid)s

A cationic poly(ionic liquid) (PIL) with pendent butyl imidazolium cations and free bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide (TFSI) anions and an anionic PIL with pendent TFSI anions and free 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium cations are synthesized by postpolymerization chemical modification and reversible addition-fragmentation chain-transfer radical copolymerization, respectively. Upon mixing solutions of these two PILs in acetone with stoichiometric amounts of ion pairs, ionic exchanges induce coacervation and, after solvent evaporation, lead to the formation of a dynamic ion gel (DIG) and the concomitant release of free [1-methyl-3-butyl imidazolium]TFSI ionic liquid (IL). A comparison of thermal (Tg), ion conducting (σDC), and viscoelastic (elastic moduli (G')) properties for DIGs and their parent polyelectrolytes, as well as extracted and IL-doped DIGs, demonstrates the formation of ionic cross-links and the ability to easily produce polymer electrolytes with enhanced ionic conductivity (σDC up to 4.5 × 10-5 S cm-1 at 30 °C) and higher elastic moduli (G' up to 4 kPa at 25 °C and 1 rad s-1), making them highly desirable in many electrochemical applications, including supercapacitors, soft robotics, electrochromic devices, sensors, and solar cells.

Coacervating behavior of amino acid anionic and amphoteric mixed micelle-polymer

In this paper, coacervates were formed with mixed micelles consisting of the anionic amino acid surfactant sodium lauroylsarcosinate (NLS) and amphoteric surfactant cocamidopropyl betaine (CAPB) in combination with cationic guar gum. Based on personal care formulation studies, coacervates were prepared by diluting a concentrated system with water to better suit the product application process. The phase behavior during dilution was revealed by turbidity, which was influenced by the mixed micelle ratio (X), salt concentration, and dilution ratio (R). Optical microscopy, cryo-SEM, SAXS and rotational rheometry were used to characterize the structure and properties of the coacervates, which strongly depended on the interaction strength between the polymer and micelles. Dominated by electrostatic interactions, the coacervates exhibited a dense porous structure with low water content and a high viscoelastic modulus, while weakened interactions resulted in a looser mesh internal structure with lower viscoelasticity, enhancing skin adsorption. These findings enhance our understanding of polymer-mixed micelle systems and offer practical strategies for controlling the properties of coacervates.

Solid-Liquid-Solution Phases in Poly(diallyldimethylammonium)/Poly(acrylic acid) Polyelectrolyte Complexes at Varying Temperatures

The coacervation and complexation of oppositely charged polyelectrolytes are dependent on numerous environmental and preparatory factors, but temperature is often overlooked. Temperature effects remain unclear because the temperature dependence of both the dielectric constant and polymer-solvent interaction parameter can yield lower and/or upper critical solution phase behaviors for PECs. Further, secondary interactions, such as hydrogen bonding, can affect the temperature response of a PEC. That is, mixtures of oppositely charged polyelectrolytes can exhibit phase separation upon lowering and/or increasing the mixture's temperature. Here, the phase behavior of poly(diallylmethylammonium)/poly(acrylic acid) (PDADMA/PAA) complexes under varying KBr ionic strengths, mixing ratios, and temperatures at a fixed pH (in which PAA hydrogen bonding can occur) is examined. At room temperature, the PDADMA/PAA PECs exhibit four different phase states: precipitate, coexisting precipitate and coacervate, solid-like gel, and coacervate. Variable-temperature optical microscopy reveals the upper critical solution temperature (UCST) at which each phase transitioned to a solution state. Interestingly, the UCST value is highly dependent on the original phase of the PEC, in which solid-like precipitates exhibit higher UCST values. Large-scale all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations support that precipitates exhibit kinetic trapping, which may contribute to the higher UCST values observed in the experiment. Taken together, this study highlights the significance of temperature on the phase behavior of PECs, which may play a larger role in stimuli-responsive materials, membraneless organelles, and separations applications.

Effect of Polyelectrolyte Charge Density on the Linear Viscoelastic Behavior and Processing of Complex Coacervate Adhesives

It is well-known that the phase behavior and physicochemical and adhesive properties of complex coacervates are readily tuneable with the salt concentration of the medium. For toxicity reasons, however, the maximum applicable salt concentration in biomedical applications is typically low. Consequently, other strategies must be implemented in order to optimize the properties of the resulting complex coacervates. In this work, the effect of the charge density of a strong polyanion on the properties of complex coacervates was studied. To control this charge density, statistical anionic/charge-neutral hydrophilic copolymers were synthesized by means of an elegant protection/deprotection strategy and subsequently complexed with a strong polycation. The resulting complexes were observed to have an increasing water content as well as faster relaxation dynamics, with either increasing salt concentration or decreasing charge density. Time-salt and time-salt-charge density superpositions could be performed and showed that the relaxation mechanism of the complex coacervates remained unchanged. When the charge density was decreased, lower salt concentration complexes became suitable for viscoelastic adhesion with improved injectability. Such complex coacervates are promising candidates for injectable biomedical adhesives.

Hydrophobically modified complex coacervates for designing aqueous pressure-sensitive adhesives

The rheology of complex coacervates can be elegantly tuned via the design and control of specific non-covalent hydrophobic interactions between the complexed polymer chains. The well-controlled balance between elasticity and energy dissipation makes complex coacervates perfect candidates for pressure-sensitive adhesives (PSAs). In this work, the polyanion poly(3-sulfopropyl methacrylate) (PSPMA) and the polycation quaternized poly(4-vinylpyridine) (QP4VP) were used to prepare complex coacervates in water. Progressive increase of hydrophobicity is introduced to the polyanion via partial deprotection of the protected precursor. Hence, the polymer chains in the complex coacervates can interact via both electrostatic (controlled by the amount of salt) and hydrophobic (controlled by the deprotection degree) interactions. It was observed that: (i) a rheological time-salt-hydrophobicity superposition principle is applicable, and can be used as a predictive tool for rheology, (ii) the slowdown of the stress relaxation dynamics, due to the increase of hydrophobic stickers (lower deprotection degree), can be captured by the sticky-Rouse model, and (iii) the systematic variation of hydrophobic stickers, amount of salt, and molecular weight of the polymers, enables the identification of optimizing parameters to design aqueous PSA systems. The presented results offer new pathways to control the rheology of complex coacervates and their applicability as PSAs.

Coacervate or precipitate? Formation of non-equilibrium microstructures in coacervate emulsions

Non-equilibrium processing of aqueous polyelectrolyte complex (PEC) coacervates is critical to many applications. In particular, many coacervate-forming systems are known to become trapped in out-of-equilibrium states (e.g., precipitation). The mechanism and conditions under which these states form, and whether they age, is not clearly understood. Here, we elucidate the influence of processing on the PEC coarsening mechanism as it varies with flow during mixing for a model system of poly(allylamine hydrochloride) and poly(acrylic acid sodium salt) in water. We demonstrate that flow conditions can be used to toggle the formation of rough, precipitate-like aggregates of micron-scale PEC structures. These structures form at compositions with viscous-dominant equilibrium rheology, and observations of their formation via optical microscopy suggest that they comprise colloidal aggregates of PEC coacervate droplets. We further show that these aggregates exhibit micron-scale coarsening, with a mixing time-dependent characteristic aging time scale. The results show that the formation of precipitate-like structures is not solely determined by composition, but is instead highly sensitive to mass transport and colloidal instability effects. Our observations suggest that the details of mixing flow can provide non-equilibrium structural control of a broad range of PEC coacervate materials orthogonally to structure-property inspired polymeric design. We anticipate that these findings will open the door for future studies on the control of non-equilibrium PEC formation and structure.

Effect of Dynamically Arrested Domains on the Phase Behavior, Linear Viscoelasticity and Microstructure of Hyaluronic Acid - Chitosan Complex Coacervates

Complex coacervates make up a class of versatile materials formed as a result of the electrostatic associations between oppositely charged polyelectrolytes. It is well-known that the viscoelastic properties of these materials can be easily altered with the ionic strength of the medium, resulting in a range of materials from free-flowing liquids to gel-like solids. However, in addition to electrostatics, several other noncovalent interactions could influence the formation of the coacervate phase depending on the chemical nature of the polymers involved. Here, the importance of intermolecular hydrogen bonds on the phase behavior, microstructure, and viscoelasticity of hyaluronic acid (HA)-chitosan (CHI) complex coacervates is revealed. The density of intermolecular hydrogen bonds between CHI units increases with increasing pH of coacervation, which results in dynamically arrested regions within the complex coacervate, leading to elastic gel-like behavior. This pH-dependent behavior may be very relevant for the controlled solidification of complex coacervates and thus for polyelectrolyte material design.

Ionic group-dependent structure of complex coacervate hydrogels formed by ABA triblock copolymers

This study investigates the nanostructure of complex coacervate core hydrogels (C3Gs) with varying compositions of cationic charged groups (i.e., ammonium and guanidinium) using small-angle X-ray/neutron scattering (SAX/NS). C3Gs were prepared by stoichiometric mixing of two oppositely charged ABA triblock copolymers in aqueous solvents, in which A end-blocks were functionalized with either sulfonate groups or a mixture of ammonium and guanidinium groups. Comprehensive small-angle X-ray/neutron scattering (SAX/NS) analysis elucidated the dependence of C3Gs structures on the fraction of guanidinium groups in the cationic end-block (x) and salt concentration (c_s). As x increases, the polymer volume fraction in the cores, and interfacial tension (γ_core) and salt resistance (c*) of the coacervate cores increase, which is attributed to the greater hydrophobicity and non-electrostatic association. Furthermore, we observed that the salt dependence of the interfacial tension follows γ_core ∼ (1 - c_s/c*)^3/2 in all series of x. The results show that the variation of the ionic group provides a powerful method to control the salt-responsiveness of C3Gs as stimuli-responsive materials.

High-throughput microscopy to determine morphology, microrheology, and phase boundaries applied to phase separating coacervates

Evolution of composition, rheology, and morphology during phase separation in complex fluids is highly coupled to rheological and mass transport processes within the emerging phases, and understanding this coupling is critical for materials design of multiphase complex fluids. Characterizing these dependencies typically requires careful measurement of a large number of equilibrium and transport properties that are difficult to measure in situ as phase separation proceeds. Here, we propose and demonstrate a high-throughput microscopy platform to achieve simultaneous, in situ mapping of time-evolving morphology and microrheology in phase separating complex fluids over a large compositional space. The method was applied to a canonical example of polyelectrolyte complex coacervation, whereby mixing of oppositely charged species leads to liquid-liquid phase separation into distinct solute-dense and dilute phases. Morphology and rheology were measured simultaneously and kinetically after mixing to track the progression of phase separation. Once equilibrated, the dense phase viscosity was determined to high compositional accuracy using passive probe microrheology, and the results were used to derive empirical relationships between the composition and viscosity. These relationships were inverted to reconstruct the dense phase boundary itself, and further extended to other mixture compositions. The resulting predictions were validated by independent equilibrium compositional measurements. This platform paves the way for rapid screening and formulation of complex fluids and (bio)macromolecular materials, and serves as a critical link between formulation and rheology for multi-phase material discovery.

Sodium dodecyl sulfate modulates the structure and rheological properties of Pluronic F108-poly(acrylic acid) coacervates)

Micelles formed within coacervate phases can impart functional properties, but it is unclear if this micellization provides mechanical reinforcement of the coacervate whereby the micelles act as high functionality crosslinkers. Here, we examine how sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) influences the structure and properties of Pluronic F108-polyacrylic acid (PAA) coacervates as SDS is known to decrease the aggregation number of Pluronic micelles. Increasing the SDS concentration leads to larger water content in the coacervate and an increase in the relative concentration of PAA to the other solids. Rheological characterization with small angle oscillatory shear (SAOS) demonstrates that these coacervates are viscoelastic liquids with the moduli decreasing with the addition of the SDS. The loss factor (tan δ) initially increases linearly with the addition of SDS, but a step function increase in the loss factor occurs near the reported CMC of SDS. However, this change in rheological properties does not appear to be correlated with any large scale structural differences in the coacervate as determined by small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) with no signature of Pluronic micelles in the coacervate when SDS concentration is >4 mM during formation of the coacervate, which is less than that observed (6 mM SDS) in initial Pluronic F108 solution despite the higher polymer concentration in the coacervate. These results suggest that the mechanical properties of polyelectrolyte-non-ionic surfactant coacervates are driven by the efficicacy of binding between the complexing species driving the coacervate, which can be disrupted by competitive binding of the SDS to the Pluronic.

A simple simulation model for complex coacervates

When oppositely charged polyelectrolytes mix in an aqueous solution, associative phase separation gives rise to coacervates. Experiments reveal the phase diagram for such coacervates, and determine the impact of charge density, chain length and added salt. Simulations often use hybrid MC-MD methods to produce such phase diagrams, in support of experimental observations. We propose an idealized model and a simple simulation technique to investigate coacervate phase behavior. We model coacervate systems by charged bead-spring chains and counterions with short-range repulsions, of size equal to the Bjerrum length. We determine phase behavior by equilibrating a slab of concentrated coacervate with respect to swelling into a dilute phase of counterions. At salt concentrations below the critical point, the counterion concentration in the coacervate and dilute phases are nearly the same. At high salt concentrations, we find a one-phase region. Along the phase boundary, the total concentration of beads in the coacervate phase is nearly constant, corresponding to a "Bjerrum liquid''. This result can be extended to experimental phase diagrams by assigning appropriate volumes to monomers and salts.