Aerobic biotransformation of a novel highly functionalized polyfluoroether-based surfactant using activated sludge from a wastewater treatment plant

A Comparative Biodegradation Study to Assess the Ultimate Fate of Novel Highly Functionalized Hydrofluoroether Alcohols in Wastewater Treatment Plant Microcosms and Surface Waters

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are a class of chemicals present in a wide range of commercial and consumer products due to their water-repellency, nonstick, or surfactant properties, resulting from their chemical and thermal stability. This stability, however, often leads to persistence in the environment when they are inevitability released. We utilized microbial microcosms from wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) sludge to determine how employing different functional groups such as heteroatom linkages, varying chain lengths, and hydrofluoroethers (HFEs) will impact the ultimate fate of these novel PFAS structures. A suite of five novel fluorosurfactant building blocks (F7 C3 OCHFCF2 SCH2 CH2 OH (FESOH), F3 COCHFCF2 SCH2 CH2 OH (MeFESOH), F7 C3 OCHFCF2 OCH2 CH2 OH (ProFdiEOH), F7 C3 OCHFCF2 CH2 OH (ProFEOH), and F3 COCHFCF2 OCH2 CH2 OH (MeFdiEOH)) and their select transformation products, were incubated in WWTP aerobic microcosms to determine structure-activity relationships. The HFE alcohol congeners with a thioether (FESOH and MeFESOH) were observed to transform faster than the ether congeners, while also producing second-generation HFE acid products (F7 C3 OCHFC(O)OH (2H-3:2 polyfluoroalkyl ether carboxylic acid [PFECA]) and F3 COCHFC(O)OH (2H-1:2 PFECA). Subsequent biodegradation experiments with 2H-1:2 PFESA and 2H-1:2 PFECA displayed no further transformation over 74 days. Surface water Photofate experiments compared 2H-1:2 PFECA, and 2H-1:2 polyfluorinated ether sulfonate (PFESA) with their fully fluorinated ether acid counterparts, and demonstrated the potential for both HFE acid species to completely mineralize over extended periods of time, a fate that highlights the value of studying novel PFAS functionalization. Environ Toxicol Chem 2024;00:1-9. © 2023 The Authors. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of SETAC.

Electron-bifurcation and fluoride efflux systems in Acetobacterium spp. drive defluorination of perfluorinated unsaturated carboxylic acids

Enzymatic cleavage of C-F bonds in per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) is largely unknown but avidly sought to promote systems biology for PFAS bioremediation. Here, we report the reductive defluorination of α, β-unsaturated per- and polyfluorocarboxylic acids by Acetobacterium spp. Two critical molecular features in Acetobacterium species enabling reductive defluorination are (i) a functional fluoride efflux transporter (CrcB) and (ii) an electron-bifurcating caffeate reduction pathway (CarABCDE). The fluoride transporter was required for detoxification of released fluoride. Car enzymes were implicated in defluorination by the following evidence: (i) only Acetobacterium spp. with car genes catalyzed defluorination; (ii) caffeate and PFAS competed in vivo ; (iii) models from the X-ray structure of the electron-bifurcating reductase (CarC) positioned the PFAS substrate optimally for reductive defluorination; (iv) products identified by 19 F-NMR and high-resolution mass spectrometry were consistent with the model. Defluorination biomarkers identified here were found in wastewater treatment plant metagenomes on six continents.

Avoiding Regrettable Replacements: Can the Introduction of Novel Functional Groups Move PFAS from Recalcitrant to Reactive?

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) are present in a range of commercial and consumer products. These chemicals are often high-performance surfactants or nonstick/water-repellant coatings due to their chemical stability; however, this stability leads to select PFAS being environmentally persistent. To facilitate degradation, new fluorosurfactant building blocks (F7C3-O-CHF-CF2-S-CH2-CH2-OH (FESOH), F3C-O-CHF-CF2-S-CH2-CH2-OH (MeFESOH), F7C3-O-CHF-CF2-O-CH2-CH2-OH (ProFdiEOH), F7C3-O-CHF-CF2-CH2-OH (ProFEOH), and F3C-O-CHF-CF2-O-CH2-CH2-OH (MeFdiEOH)) have been systematically developed with heteroatom linkages such as ethers, thioethers, and polyfluorinated carbons. The room temperature, gas-phase OH oxidation rate constants, and products of these chemicals were monitored in an atmospheric chamber to investigate their fate in the atmosphere. Analysis was performed using online high-resolution chemical ionization mass spectrometry (CIMS) using the iodide reagent ion and via offline UPLC-MS/MS. FESOH and MeFESOH, the thioether congeners, were observed to have the largest rate constants of kFESOH = 2.82 (±0.33) and kMeFESOH = 2.17 (±0.17) (×10-12 cm3 molecules-1 s-1, respectively). First-, second-, and third-generation products of OH oxidation were observed as a function of time, while product quantification yielded ultrashort perfluoropropionic acid (PFPrA) and short polyfluoroether acid species as the terminal products for FESOH and ProFdiEOH. There was evidence for MeFESOH being fully mineralized, demonstrating the potential benign chemical architecture.

Finding a way out? Comprehensive biotransformation study of novel fluorinated surfactants

In this study the environmental fate of two novel trifluoromethoxy-substituted surfactants with respectively an ether or thioether linkage were investigated, of which the design aimed for less persistency and complete mineralization. Long-term microbial transformation studies under aerobic conditions in activated sludge-wastewater medium were performed for 126 days. A semi-closed experimental system with a trapping sorbent was selected to avoid losses of possible volatile transformation products (TPs). The changes in the concentration of the surfactants and their expected TPs were monitored by target analysis using liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry. Significant decrease in the concentration of the surfactants was observed over the incubation period. The main detected TPs were short-chained carboxylic acids (CAs), including a CA with two fluorinated carbon atoms representing the last product prior to mineralization. High stability of these CAs and lack in the formation of inorganic fluoride over the incubation time was however observed. Consequently, unequivocal final mineralization of the investigated surfactants could not be confirmed. Regarding the mass balance, the total amount of detected substances achieved only 30-37% of the expected concentration at the end of the incubation time. The reason of the incomplete mass balance should be further investigated.

Aerobic Biotransformation and Defluorination of Fluoroalkylether Substances (ether PFAS): Substrate Specificity, Pathways, and Applications

Fluoroalkylether substances (ether PFAS) constitute a large group of emerging PFAS with uncertain environmental fate. Among them, GenX is the well-known alternative to perfluorooctanoic acid and one of the six proposed PFAS to be regulated by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. This study investigated the structure-biodegradability relationship for 12 different ether PFAS with a carboxylic acid headgroup in activated sludge communities. Only polyfluorinated ethers with at least one -CH2- moiety adjacent to or a C=C bond in the proximity of the ether bond underwent active biotransformation via oxidative and hydrolytic O-dealkylation. The bioreactions at ether bonds led to the formation of unstable fluoroalcohol intermediates subject to spontaneous defluorination. We further demonstrated that this aerobic biotransformation/defluorination could complement the advanced reduction process in a treatment train system to achieve more cost-effective treatment for GenX and other recalcitrant perfluorinated ether PFAS. These findings provide essential insights into the environmental fate of ether PFAS, the design of biodegradable alternative PFAS, and the development of cost-effective ether PFAS treatment strategies.