Advances in micro and nanoengineered surfaces for enhancing boiling and condensation heat transfer: a review

Nanostructuring of Additively Manufactured Stainless-Steel Surfaces for Superior Boiling Heat Transfer

While stainless steel offers unique advantages for thermal applications in corrosive environments, it is resilient to traditional nanostructuring techniques such as chemical etching for heat transfer augmentation. In this work, we fabricate a 304L stainless steel alloy using directed energy deposition additive manufacturing, which leads to a metastable microstructure state that facilitates efficient and scalable etching using chloride species. We unveil a two-step etching mechanism that results in the formation of a network of micro- and nanoscale surface structures. This structured surface shows a 5-fold enhancement of the heat transfer coefficient at significantly lower superheat during pool boiling of water, attributed to increased nucleation in suitably sized cavities created by etching. Our work illustrates the vast potential of advances in additive manufacturing techniques for the development of highly efficient and compact thermal systems.

Enhancing Liquid-Vapor Phase-Change Heat Transfer with Micro/Nano-Structured Surfaces

Liquid-vapor phase-change heat transfer plays an important role in many industrial systems, ranging from power generation and air conditioning to water desalination, food processing, and thermal management of electronics and data centers. Recent advances in micro/nanofabrication have enabled desirable manipulation of multiscale dynamics governing droplet/bubble motion and capillary liquid flows for highly efficient phase-change heat transfer. However, there lacks a comprehensive review on the design and fabrication of micro/nanostructured surfaces with controlled morphology and wettability, to enhance the diverse phase-change heat transfer processes. Here, we review the advances in micro/nanostructuring for phase-change heat transfer applications. While traditional mechanical machining and sintering have commonly been used to manufacture structures down to sub-millimeter or micron scales, advanced micro/nanostructure fabrication methods such as laser texturing, oxidation, lithography-based etching, and spray coating are being utilized to manufacture surfaces with hierarchical structures or heterogeneous wettability. Droplets, bubbles, and liquid films generally experience a multiscale life cycle from nanometer scale to millimeter scale in the phase-change processes, including condensation, pool boiling, capillary-driven evaporation, and liquid film boiling. Micro/nanostructured surfaces need to be designed to coordinate different requirements of the surface wettability and morphology for the multiscale dynamics of droplets, bubbles, and films including increased nucleation, facilitated growth, accelerated transport, and departure. For active phase-change processes with pump-driven flow, including flow condensation, flow boiling, jet impingement boiling, and spray cooling, the enhancement strategies using functionalized micro/nanostructures focus on sustaining thin liquid films, strengthening thin film evaporation, promoting nucleate boiling, and regulating bubble departure within the convective liquid film. We conclude this review by a short discussion on the practical aspects of micro/nanoenabled phase-change heat transfer including reliability and scalability.

Mask-Enabled Topography Contrast on Aluminum Surfaces

Patterned solid surfaces with wettability contrast can enhance liquid transport for applications such as electronics thermal management, self-cleaning, and anti-icing. However, prior work has not explored easy and scalable blade-cut masking to impart topography patterned wettability contrast on aluminum (Al), even though Al surfaces are widely used for thermal applications. Here, we demonstrate mask-enabled topography contrast patterning and quantify the resulting accuracy of the topographic pattern resolution, spatial variations in surface roughness, wettability, drop size distribution during dropwise condensation, and thermal emissivity of patterned Al surfaces. The method uses blade-cut vinyl mask templates and a commercially available lacquer resin that serves as a polymer resist against etching. Programmable mask templates enable complex patterning of wettability and emissivity contrast with feature sizes down to ∼1.5 mm. As-fabricated patterned samples show a water contact angle (θ) contrast from <5° to 80° between etched and smooth zones, while patterned samples that are further coated with a hydrophobic promoter show θ contrast between 150° and 120° on etched and smooth zones, respectively. In addition to measuring this wettability contrast via contact angle goniometry, we use condensation visualization experiments to study the spatially controlled condensate morphologies and drop size distributions. These condensation studies demonstrate enhanced droplet shedding on the superhydrophobic regions of striped patterned surfaces compared to homogeneous superhydrophobic surfaces. Motivated by the role of thermal radiation in many phase change processes, we use infrared thermography to map topography-mediated thermal emissivity (ε) contrast between etched (ε ≈ 0.65) and smooth (ε ≈ 0.26) regions. Thus, our study provides a route for researchers to readily create complex and scalable topography-patterned Al surfaces for potential applications in vapor chamber thermal rectification, radiative cooling condensation heat transfer, and high-temperature Leidenfrost or film boiling processes.

Vapor Nucleation on Hybrid-Wetting Nanoconvex Surfaces: The Competition between Intrinsic Wettability and Topography

Hybrid-wetting surfaces with hydrophilic spots reduced from the micrometer to nanometer scale have been confirmed to enhance vapor nucleation while simultaneously minimizing droplet pinning. Given that surface topography also plays a critical role in influencing nucleation characteristics, the effect of competition between intrinsic wettability and topography on nucleation remains unclear when both surface topography and hydrophilic regions approach the critical nucleation size. This work investigated vapor nucleation on two types of hybrid-wetting nanoconvex surfaces. On random hybrid-wetting convex surfaces, the most negative potential energy sites were located at the sides of the convex structures, leading vapor to preferentially nucleate at these locations, consistent with observations on homogeneous surfaces. Despite similar average potential energy values across the surface, wettability variations in hydrophilic and hydrophobic atoms significantly alter the surface energy distribution. As the wettability difference between hydrophilic and hydrophobic atoms increases, stronger hydrophilic atoms generate relatively higher local energy regions, promoting vapor rapid nucleation. The edge effect still exists at a hydrophilic atom ratio of 10%, and competition among hydrophilic spots impedes vapor nucleation and growth. However, when the ratio increases to 40%, the increased surface average potential energy promotes the probability of vapor contacting the surface, leading to rapid vapor nucleation on the sides of the convex structures. In addition, surface potential energy analysis and the Monte Carlo method revealed that nucleation locations on nanoconvex surfaces are governed by the competition between intrinsic wettability and topography. When the magnitude of the potential energy generated by the hydrophilic atoms exceeds that from the topography, stronger solid-liquid interactions at the top of the convex structure increase the likelihood of vapor contacting the surface, resulting in nucleation at the top. Conversely, when the magnitude of the potential energy generated by hydrophilic atoms is lower than that from topography, nucleation preferentially still occurs on the sides.

Unveiling the fundamentals of flow boiling heat transfer enhancement on structured surfaces

Micro- and nanostructured surfaces offer the potential to enhance two-phase heat transfer. However, the mechanisms behind these enhancements are not well-understood due to insufficient diagnostic methods, leading to reliance on trial-and-error surface development. We introduce in situ boroscopy to investigate microscale bubble dynamics during flow boiling nucleation and subsequent flow regime development. This method was applied in saturated flow boiling experiments within chemically etched aluminum and copper tubes. Although the surfaces have self-similar surface structures, our findings revealed varied heat transfer coefficient enhancements, with increases of up to 391% on aluminum and 41% on copper. Using boroscopy, we identified key mechanisms of heat transfer enhancement. We further used mercury porosimetry to determine the impact of pore size distribution on thermal performance. The boroscopy technique introduced here not only elucidates the underlying processes of flow boiling heat transfer enhancement but also has potential applications for the study of other two-phase phenomena.

Bridging Innovations of Phase Change Heat Transfer to Electrochemical Gas Evolution Reactions

Bubbles play a ubiquitous role in electrochemical gas evolution reactions. However, a mechanistic understanding of how bubbles affect the energy efficiency of electrochemical processes remains limited to date, impeding effective approaches to further boost the performance of gas evolution systems. From a perspective of the analogy between heat and mass transfer, bubbles in electrochemical gas evolution reactions exhibit highly similar dynamic behaviors to them in the liquid-vapor phase change. Recent developments of liquid-vapor phase change systems have substantially advanced the fundamental knowledge of bubbles, leading to unprecedented enhancement of heat transfer performance. In this Review, we aim to elucidate a promising opportunity of understanding bubble dynamics in electrochemical gas evolution reactions through a lens of phase change heat transfer. We first provide a background about key parallels between electrochemical gas evolution reactions and phase change heat transfer. Then, we discuss bubble dynamics in gas evolution systems across multiple length scales, with an emphasis on exciting research problems inspired by new insights gained from liquid-vapor phase change systems. Lastly, we review advances in engineered surfaces for manipulating bubbles to enhance heat and mass transfer, providing an outlook on the design of high-performance gas evolving electrodes.

Speleothem-Inspired Copper/Nickel Interfaces for Enhanced Liquid-Vapor Transport by Marangoni and Soret Effects

Geological formations have superior wickability and support the absorption of water and oils into narrow spaces of Earth's crust without external assistance. In this study, we present speleothem inspired heterogeneous porous and wicked copper (Cu)/nickel (Ni) interfaces for enhanced nucleate boiling of water/ethanol mixtures for energy-efficient separation processes. The incorporation of Ni strands within the copper particle matrix significantly enhanced heat transfer. Compared to plain copper, the Cu/Ni speleothem surfaces exhibited a 61% increase in the heat transfer coefficient for water/ethanol mixtures and a 332% increase for water, with a 58% faster onset of nucleate boiling. This enhancement was attributed to Marangoni and Soret effects at the Cu/Ni interfaces, driven by surface tension and concentration gradients. Furthermore, the synergistic wicking action of the Ni strands facilitated rewetting of the surface, replenishing liquid to the porous nucleation sites and preventing surface dry-out, thereby improving the overall heat transfer performance.

Ambient-mediated wetting on smooth surfaces

A consensus was built in the first half of the 20th century, which was further debated more than 3 decades ago, that the wettability and condensation mechanisms on smooth solid surfaces are modified by the adsorption of organic contaminants present in the environment. Recently, disagreement has formed about this topic once again, as many researchers have overlooked contamination due to its difficulty to eliminate. For example, the intrinsic wettability of rare earth oxides has been reported to be hydrophobic and non-wetting to water. These materials were subsequently shown to display dropwise condensation with steam. Nonetheless, follow on research has demonstrated that the intrinsic wettability of rare earth oxides is hydrophilic and wetting to water, and that a transition to hydrophobicity occurs in a matter of hours-to-days as a consequence of the adsorption of volatile organic compounds from the ambient environment. The adsorption mechanisms, kinetics, and selectivity, of these volatile organic compounds are empirically known to be functions of the substrate material and structure. However, these mechanisms, which govern the surface wettability, remain poorly understood. In this contribution, we introduce current research demonstrating the different intrinsic wettability of metals, rare earth oxides, and other smooth materials, showing that they are intrinsically hydrophilic. Then we provide details on research focusing on the transition from wetting (hydrophilicity) to non-wetting (hydrophobicity) on somooth surfaces due to adsorption of volatile organic compounds. A state-of-the-art figure of merit mapping the wettability of different smooth solid surfaces to ambient exposure as a function of the surface carbon content has also been developed. In addition, we analyse recent works that address these wetting transitions so to shed light on how such processes affect droplet pinning and lateral adhesion. We then conclude with objective perspectives about research on wetting to non-wetting transitions on smooth solid surfaces in an attempt to raise awareness regarding this surface contamination phenomenon within the engineering, interfacial science, and physical chemistry domains.