Compression anastomosis (AKA-2) in colorectal surgery: results in 442 consecutive patients

Small bowel magnetic compression anastomosis creation for bypass procedures in a porcine model

BACKGROUND

Stapled and hand-sewn techniques dominate gastrointestinal anastomotic procedures. These techniques are effective but not without flaws. Retained foreign bodies, pathways from mucosa to serosa, and increased scar tissue are some of the drawbacks, and can lead to postoperative complications. The GI Windows Flexagon™ system utilizes self-forming magnets (SFM's) to create anastomoses by compression, sealing serosa to serosa, leaving no foreign bodies. Combining the Flexagon™ SFM with the OTOLoc™ device (implant with a central lumen which provides radial support to the enterotomies), enables immediate flow through the anastomosis and facilitates creation of enteral bypass procedures unique to this technology. We sought to compare the safety and efficacy of the GI Windows Flexagon™ and OTOLoc™ technologies against conventional stapling.

METHODS

A preclinical study was conducted on 14 Yorkshire swine to compare laparoscopic magnetic and stapled duodenoileostomies and jejunojejunostomies. Study endpoints included: adverse or serious adverse events, anastomotic burst pressure, adhesions, histopathology, and bacterial ingress. A Likert scale was used to assess the usability of the devices.

RESULTS

All procedures were successfully completed via laparoscopic approach; no adverse or serious adverse events were observed at the 42-day endpoint. All SFM's were expelled in less than 20 days. Average anastomotic burst pressure was 129.2 mmHg for SFM compared to 79.4 mmHg in stapled controls. Adhesion scores were similar between groups. Histopathology revealed that magnetic anastomoses have less intestinal wall distortion, fewer signs of chronic inflammation, and no bacterial ingress. The usability of all devices was reported as "Easy" or "Very Easy."

CONCLUSION

GI Windows magnetic compression anastomoses creation in this porcine model revealed an overall ease of use, all while demonstrating procedural feasibility, safety, and clinical effectiveness. Surprisingly, in nearly all results assessed, SFM anastomoses were found to be comparable to the control stapled anastomoses in regard to structural, physiological, and histological endpoints.

New alternative colorectal anastomotic devices: A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Colorectal anastomotic devices have been used for nearly a century, with stapled anastomoses being the most common despite leak rates up to 20 ​%. This review aimed to evaluate newer alternative devices.

METHOD

A systematic review and meta-analysis of publications from the last decade were conducted, focusing on devices forming colorectal anastomoses, excluding those facilitating sutured or stapled anastomoses or designed to prevent leaks. Data from MEDLINE, Embase, Cochrane, and ClinicalTrials.gov were analysed.

RESULTS

Eighteen studies (7 human, 10 animal, 1 ex-vivo) involving 955 anastomoses were included. Compression mechanisms were the most common. The pooled complication rate in human studies was 9.7 ​% (95 ​% CI: 4.3-15.2 ​%) with significant heterogeneity (I2 ​= ​81.7 ​%). The leak rate after compression anastomoses was 3.3 ​% (95 ​% CI: 1.9-4.7 ​%) with no heterogeneity (I2 ​= ​0 ​%). A novel device with transanal catheters allowed intraoperative and postoperative assessment.

CONCLUSIONS

Outcomes are comparable to existing methods, with new technologies offering promising advancements.

Comparative early histologic healing quality of magnetic versus stapled small bowel anastomosis

BACKGROUND

Successful anastomotic healing is critical to preventing complications after intestinal surgery. We aimed to compare the early healing of end-to-end small bowel anastomosis by self-forming magnets with surgical stapling in a porcine model.

METHOD

Six Yorkshire pigs underwent 2 simultaneous small bowel anastomoses using a circular stapler and self-forming magnet technique. The primary outcome was healing quality, measured by 4 histologic features: inflammatory cell infiltration, collagen formation, grade of inflammation, and bacterial infiltration at the anastomosis. The samples were evaluated at days 1, 3, and 7. Gross evaluation of anastomotic integrity was a secondary outcome.

RESULTS

The self-forming magnet group displayed significant differences at each time point. On day 1, the stapled group displayed dense inflammatory cell infiltration and extensively ulcerated intestinal layers with significant edema. The self-forming magnet group showed less inflammatory infiltrate, and all intestinal layers remained compressed in direct apposition. By day 3, the self-forming magnet group already exhibited neovascularization with scant bacterial colonies. By contrast, stapled anastomoses had large areas of inflammation separating collagen fibers with prevalent bacterial infiltrations. On day 7, self-forming magnet anastomoses were characterized by robust neovascularization, maturing granulation tissue, and mucosal re-epithelization without significant inflammation. Meanwhile, stapled samples had persisting dense inflammation, tissue cavities with hemorrhage, and immature fibrous tissue. Grossly, the self-forming magnet created a patent lumen without defect, whereas stapled anastomoses demonstrated focal areas of serosal separation.

CONCLUSION

Bowel anastomosis by self-forming magnets is associated with superior early histologic healing metrics, including early seal generation through mechanical compression, decreased inflammation, early neovascularization, lower bacterial infiltration, and faster re-epithelization.

The Evolving Use of Magnets in Surgery: Biomedical Considerations and a Review of Their Current Applications

The novel use of magnetic force to optimize modern surgical techniques originated in the 1970s. Since then, magnets have been utilized as an adjunct or alternative to a wide array of existing surgical procedures, ranging from gastrointestinal to vascular surgery. As the use of magnets in surgery continues to grow, the body of knowledge on magnetic surgical devices from preclinical development to clinical implementation has expanded significantly; however, the current magnetic surgical devices can be organized based on their core function: serving as a guidance system, creating a new connection, recreating a physiologic function, or utilization of an internal–external paired magnet system. The purpose of this article is to discuss the biomedical considerations during magnetic device development and review the current surgical applications of magnetic devices.

The Colorectal Anastomosis: A Timeless Challenge

Colorectal anastomosis is a sophisticated problem that demands an elaborate discussion and an elegant solution. "Those who forget the past are condemned to repeat it." George Santayana, Life of Reason , 1905.

Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis on Colorectal Anastomotic Techniques

Purpose

Anastomosis creation after resective gastrointestinal surgery is a crucial task. The present review examines the techniques and implants currently available for anastomosis creation and analyses to which extent they already address our clinical needs, with a special focus on their potential to enable further trauma minimization in visceral surgery.

Methods

A multi-database research was conducted in MEDLINE, Scopus, and Cochrane Library. Comparative controlled and uncontrolled clinical trials dealing with anastomosis creation techniques in the intestinal tract in both German and English were included and statistically significant differences in postoperative complication incidences were assessed using the RevMan5.4 Review Manager (Cochrane Collaboration, Oxford, UK).

Results

All methods and implant types were analyzed and compared with respect to four dimensions, assessing the techniques' current performances and further potentials for surgical trauma reduction. Postoperative outcome measures, such as leakage, stenosis, reoperation and mortality rates, as well as the tendency to cause bleeding, wound infections, abscesses, anastomotic hemorrhages, pulmonary embolisms, and fistulas were assessed, revealing the only statistically significant superiority of hand-suture over stapling anastomoses with respect to the occurrence of obstructions.

Conclusion

Based on the overall complication rates, it is concluded that none of the anastomosis systems addresses the demands of operative trauma minimization sufficiently yet. Major problems are furthermore either low standardization potentials due to dependence on the surgeons' levels of experience, high force application requirements for the actual anastomosis creation, or large and rigid device designs interfering with flexibility demands and size restrictions of the body's natural access routes. There is still a need for innovative technologies, especially with regard to enabling incisionless interventions.

Evaluation of sutureless anastomosis after ileostomy takedown using the self-forming magnet anastomosis system in a porcine model

BACKGROUND

Current standard of care for creation of small bowel anastomoses after a loop ileostomy reversal includes the use of stapler devices and sutures. Compression anastomosis devices have been used for decades, aimed toward improved outcomes with a "staple free" & "suture free" anastomosis. The self-forming magnet (SFM) device is a type of compression anastomosis device used to safely and effectively create an end-to-end small bowel anastomosis without the localized inflammatory response seen with sutures or staples, as no foreign bodies are left behind.

METHODS

A Good Laboratory Practice preclinical study using a porcine model to evaluate creating an in vivo anastomosis via magnetic compression between two segments of small bowel (jejunum or ileum) was performed. Magnetic anastomoses were compared to stapled and handsewn anastomoses. Six animals were used for the magnetic anastomosis and eight for the two control groups for a total of 14 subjects.

RESULTS

Mean creation times were 17.1 min (SD 6.06) for the SFM group, 10.3 min (SD 6.55, CI 95%) for the stapled anastomosis group, and 28.3 min (SD 2.63, CI 95%) for the suture anastomosis group, with a statistically significant difference among groups (p < 0.0021). All evaluated SFM anastomosis, stapled anastomosis, and handsewn anastomosis underwent a burst test with a pressure of 1.3 PSI. All six magnets used for anastomoses were naturally expelled. The range of days to expel magnets was 10-17 days. Intestinal anastomoses using magnets had considerably less residual scarring and intestinal distortion than anastomoses done with either suture or staples.

CONCLUSION

This preclinical study documents the safety and efficacy of creating end-to-end small bowel anastomoses after ileostomy takedown using a magnetic compression device. The result is an anastomosis free of foreign objects with less inflammation, scarring, distortion, and mural thickening than seen in sutured or stapled anastomoses.

Design and development of a hybrid bioartificial water-induced shape memory polymeric material as an integral component for the anastomosis of human hollow organs

A large number of pathologies require the resection of the bowel and anastomoses to rejoin the two remaining stumps to regain lumen patency. Various materials have been used to rejoin one bowel end to the other such as catgut, stainless steel, and absorbable sutures. The present method for anastomosis surgery uses an entero-entero anastomosis (EEA) circular stapler with only a staple line. This method can have some drawbacks, such as intracellular fluid leakage and local inflammations. The aim of this study is to design and develop a novel bioartificial polymer with a ring shape made of polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) and gelatin (80/20 ratio (w/w)) loaded both directly with acetylsalicylic acid and with nanoparticles incorporating the same drug to reduce local inflammation even for a prolonged period of time. A physical method (8cycles freezing/thawing) was used to obtain a crosslinked bioartificial shape memory ring. Mechanical analysis showed a storage modulus having a comparable value with that of the human colon. HPLC analysis pointed out a sustained and prolonged release of the anti-inflammatory drug both immediately after anastomosis surgery and during healing period. Cell culture tests indicated the cytocompatibility of the bioartificial device. A shape memory of the hydrogel prepared in ring form was observed at 37°C after immersion in water. These bioartificial devices can represent a new approach to serve as a multifunctional anastomotic ring.

COMPRES: a prospective postmarketing evaluation of the compression anastomosis ring CAR 27(™) /ColonRing(™)

AIM

Preclinical studies have suggested that nitinol-based compression anastomosis might be a viable solution to anastomotic leak following low anterior resection. A prospective multicentre open label study was therefore designed to evaluate the performance of the ColonRing(™) in (low) colorectal anastomosis.

METHOD

The primary outcome measure was anastomotic leakage. Patients were recruited at 13 different colorectal surgical units in Europe, the United States and Israel. Institutional review board approval was obtained.

RESULTS

Between 21 March 2010 and 3 August 2011, 266 patients completed the study protocol. The overall anastomotic leakage rate was 5.3% for all anastomoses, including a rate of 3.1% for low anastomoses. Septic anastomotic complications occurred in 8.3% of all anastomoses and 8.2% of low anastomoses.

CONCLUSION

Nitinol compression anastomosis is safe, effective and easy to use and may offer an advantage for low colorectal anastomosis. A prospective randomized trial comparing ColonRing(™) with conventional stapling is needed.

Diagnosis, management and outcome of early anastomotic leakage following colorectal anastomosis using a compression device: is it different?

AIM

Compression anastomosis has proved to be safe for rectal reconstruction with leak rates comparable to those observed using circular stapling devices. However, there are no data on whether the metallic compression ring alters the ease of diagnosis or the treatment in cases of leakage. In this study, we present our experience with early leakage following compression anastomosis.

METHOD

A prospective registry was used for data review. Patients with anastomotic leakage following compression anastomosis between November 2008 and September 2013 were included.

RESULTS

In all, 197 (92 female) patients were operated using a novel compression device. Early leakage was found in 10 (5.1%) patients after a median of 5 (3-14) days. The radiologist was able to detect leakage using CT in nine out of 10 cases unequivocally. Removal of the ring was necessary in eight of the 10 cases, and salvage of the anastomosis was feasible on six occasions. In all diverted cases with a low anastomosis, a transanal repair of the defect was feasible in three cases, including a single patient with complete separation of the anastomosis.

CONCLUSION

Artefacts on the CT scan caused by the compression ring did not hamper the diagnosis of anastomotic leakage. Removal of the ring in the early postoperative period is not associated with complete separation of the bowel ends. Salvage of anastomosis is feasible in most cases.

Niti CAR 27 Versus a Conventional End-to-End Anastomosis Stapler in a Laparoscopic Anterior Resection for Sigmoid Colon Cancer

PURPOSE

The Niti CAR 27 (ColonRing) uses compression to create an anastomosis. This study aimed to investigate the safety and the effectiveness of the anastomosis created with the Niti CAR 27 in a laparoscopic anterior resection for sigmoid colon cancer.

METHODS

In a single-center study, 157 consecutive patients who received an operation between March 2010 and December 2011 were retrospectively assessed. The Niti CAR 27 (CAR group, 63 patients) colorectal anastomoses were compared with the conventional double-stapled (CDS group, 94 patients) colorectal anastomoses. Intraoperative, immediate postoperative and 6-month follow-up data were recorded.

RESULTS

There were no statistically significant differences between the two groups in terms of age, gender, tumor location and other clinical characteristics. One patient (1.6%) in the CAR group and 2 patients (2.1%) in the CDS group experienced complications of anastomotic leakage (P = 0.647). These three patients underwent a diverting loop ileostomy. There were 2 cases (2.1%) of bleeding at the anastomosis site in the CDS group. All patients underwent a follow-up colonoscopy (median, 6 months). One patient in the CAR group experienced anastomotic stricture (1.6% vs. 0%; P = 0.401). This complication was solved by using balloon dilatation.

CONCLUSION

Anastomosis using the Niti CAR 27 device in a laparoscopic anterior resection for sigmoid colon cancer is safe and feasible. Its use is equivalent to that of the conventional double-stapler.

Anastomotic leakage after low anterior resection for rectal cancer: comparison of stapled versus compression anastomosis

PURPOSE

Surgical technique and perioperative management in rectal cancer surgery have been substantially improved and standardized during the last decades. However, anastomotic leakage following low anterior resection still is a significant problem. Based on animal experimental data of improved healing of compression anastomosis, we hypothesized that a compression anastomotic device might improve healing rates of the highest-risk anastomoses.

METHODS

All low anterior resections for rectal cancer performed or directly supervised by the senior author between January 2004 and June 2012 were analyzed. Only patients with a stapled or compression anastomosis located within 6 cm from the anal verge were included. Until December 2008, circular staplers were employed, while since January 2009, a novel compression anastomotic device was used for rectal reconstruction exclusively.

RESULTS

Out of 197 patients operated for rectal cancer, a total of 96 (34 females, 35.4 %) fulfilled inclusion criteria. Fifty-eight (60.4 %) were reconstructed with circular staplers and 38 (39.6 %) using a compression anastomotic device. Significantly, more laparoscopic procedures were recorded in the compression anastomosis group, but distribution of gender, age, body mass index, American Society of Anaesthesiologists score, rate of preoperative radiotherapy, tumor staging, or stoma diversion rate were similar. Anastomotic leakage was observed in seven cases (7/58, 12.1 %) in the stapled and twice (2/38, 5.3 %) in the compression anastomosis group (p = 0.26).

CONCLUSIONS

In this series, rectal reconstruction following low anterior resection using a novel compression anastomotic device was safe and (at least) equally effective compared to traditional circular staplers concerning leak rate.

Magnetic compression in gastrointestinal and bilioenteric anastomosis: how much force?

AIM

The concept of compression alimentary anastomosis is well established. Recently, magnetic axial alignment pressures have been encompassed within such device constructs. We quantify the magnetic compression force and pressure required to successfully achieve gastrointestinal and bilioenteric anastomosis by in-depth interrogation of the reported literature.

METHODS

Reports of successful deployment and proof of anastomotic patency on survival were scrutinized to quantify the necessary dimensions and strengths of magnetic devices in (a) gastroenteral anastomosis in live porcine models and (b) bilioenteric anastomosis in the clinical setting. Using a calculatory tool developed for this work (magnetic force determination algorithm, MAGDA), ideal magnetic force and compression pressure were quantified from successful reports with regard to their variance by intermagnet separation.

RESULTS

Optimized ranges for both compression force and pressure were determined for successful porcine gastroenteral and clinical bilioenteric anastomoses. For gastroenteral anastomoses (porcine investigations), an optimized compression force between 2.55 and 3.57 kg at 2-mm intermagnet separation is recommended. The associated compression pressure should not exceed 60 N/cm(2). Successful bilioenteric anastomoses is best clinically achieved with intermagnet compression of 18 to 31 g and associated pressures between 1 and 3.5 N/mm(2) (at 2-mm intermagnet separation).

CONCLUSION

The creation of magnetic compression anastomoses using permanent magnets demonstrates a remarkable resilience to variations in magnetic force and pressure exertion. However, inappropriate selection of compression characteristics and magnet dimensions may incur difficulties. Recommendations of this work and the availability of the free online tool (http://magda.ucc.ie/) may facilitate a factor of robustness in the design and refinement of future devices.

Early surgical outcomes of NiTi endoluminal compression anastomotic clip (NiTi CAC 30) use in patients with gastrointestinal malignancy

BACKGROUND

The NiTi endoluminal Compression Anastomotic Clip (CAC™) 30 (NiTi CAC 30) (NiTi Alloys Technologies, Ltd., Netanya, Israel) is a new device with shape-memory characteristics. We aimed to investigate the safety and early surgical outcomes of NiTi CAC 30 for intestinal anastomosis in patients with gastrointestinal malignancy.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Fifty patients operated on with NiTi CAC 30 were matched for sex, age, body mass index, operation type (open versus laparoscopy), operation name, and anastomosis type with patients in a control group operated on with a stapling device between November 2009 and May 2010. Early clinical outcomes were investigated.

RESULTS

One misfired case of NiTi CAC 30 was excluded. Between the two groups, no significant differences were observed in demographics except for previous abdominal operation history. The results of early clinical outcomes were investigated, including operation time, estimated blood loss, time to first flatus, first defecation, and discharge, and complications. No differences were noted. Postoperatively, migration started in 1 patient between 3 and 5 days, 11 patients between 6 to 7 days, and 37 patients after 8 days. The expulsion of 31 cases occurred between 2 and 3 weeks, postoperatively. The NiTi CAC 30 was expulsed within 1 week in 4 patients and between 1 to 2 weeks in 8 patients. An expulsion occurred in 1 case at over 4 weeks. No problems related to early migration and expulsion were observed, and no anastomotic leakage and bleeding occurred.

CONCLUSIONS

Intestinal anastomosis with the NiTi CAC 30 was safe and feasible without anastomotic leakage and reoperation compared with the stapling technique.

Compression anastomoses in colorectal surgery: a review

The main serious risks of anastomotic construction in the colon and rectum include dehiscence and stricture formation. There is a resurgence of interest in sutureless anastomoses formed by compression elements since the introduction of shape memory alloy (SMA) systems, which evoke minimal early inflammatory response whilst maintaining anastomotic integrity. Currently, the most commonly used SMA is the nickel-titanium (NiTi) alloy that is highly biocompatible, returning to its pre-deformed stable (austenite) shape under different mechanical and thermal loads for use in humans. Pre-clinical data for shape memory alloy systems in colorectal anastomoses are limited, but it appears to be safe in porcine and canine models with limited leakage and reduced stricture formation. There does not appear to be any difference in tissue biochemistry of inflammatory markers when compared with conventional stapled techniques, although the few studies available show a markedly reduced early inflammatory response at the anastomotic site with the NiTi device. The majority of the clinical data concerning compression anastomoses are derived from the biofragmentable anastomotic ring device. This device has fallen out of use because of reported leaks, instrumental failure and problems with device expulsion. A novel SMA device, the NiTi anastomotic ring, permits construction of a low rectal anastomosis construction during open or laparoscopic procedures. The preliminary data demonstrate a safety comparable to conventional staple technology. This device also provides the potential of benefit of reduced anastomotic inflammation, because the compression ring results in direct serosa-to-serosa (or alternatively serosa-to-muscularis propria) apposition without the persistence of residual foreign material. This type of construction could lead to a reduced incidence of early anastomotic leakage and/or the development of anastomotic stenosis. Randomized clinical trials employing a NiTi arm for elective, emergency and high-risk colorectal anastomoses are required to determine its indications and clinical profile as well as to assess whether such technology may selectively obviate the need for proximal diversion in low colorectal anastomoses.

Compression anastomoses in colon and rectal surgery with the NiTi ColonRing™

BACKGROUND

The aim of this prospective study was to evaluate safety and efficacy of the NiTi ColonRing™ for anastomoses on the colon or rectum.

METHODS

During the period September 2008-June 2011, anastomosis using the NiTi ColonRing™ was scheduled to be performed on 60 patients (36 females, 24 males/mean aged 67 years), 53 of whom underwent colectomy for cancer and 7 reconstruction after Hartmann's procedure. Application of the device failed in one case due to anatomical reasons. Colorectal resections performed were as follows: Right hemicolectomy (5 patients), left colectomy (2), sigmoidectomy (15) and low anterior resection (31). A follow-up clinic visit after 1 month was planned for all patients. Ten patients among the first 14 had rectosigmoidoscopy at 2-3 months. All cancer patients were scheduled for colonoscopy at 12 months.

RESULTS

No intraoperative or postoperative bleeding related to the anastomotic technique was recorded. Median hospital stay after surgery was 10.2 days (9-22 days). One patient died on day 13 due to myocardial infarction. Clinically apparent leak was detected in one patient who had undergone reconstruction after Hartmann; the only treatment required was total parenteral nutrition for 12 days. Anastomotic stenosis occurred in another one patient who had undergone reconstruction after Hartmann; it was easily resolved by balloon dilatation. Mild complications were encountered in 23 other patients (39%). Oral feeding started after day 4. Anastomotic rings were expelled naturally within 7-17 days (mean, 9.2 days). A satisfactory anastomosis was revealed in patients examined colonoscopically at 2-3 and 12 months. Mean follow-up was 15.2 months (2-33 months).

CONCLUSIONS

NiTi ColonRing™ is reliable, safe and efficacious for large bowel anastomoses.

[Intestinal anastomoses and techniques in the lower gastrointestinal tract]

Surgery of the lower gastrointestinal tract includes segmental resections for benign colorectal diseases and radical resections for treating colorectal cancer performed under elective and emergency conditions. The most important part of the surgical procedure is the reconstruction of the physiological intestinal continuity by anastomosis. At present laparoscopic surgery has widened the array of different suturing and stapling techniques. The effectiveness of manual and stapled anastomoses depends on the expertise of the surgeon. However, skillful preparation of the hand-sutured technique is essential.

Efficacy of NiTi Hand CAC 30 for jejunojejunostomy in gastric cancer surgery: results from a multicenter prospective randomized trial

BACKGROUND

Although a novel technique for the performance of intestinal sutureless anastomosis using a compression device has recently been investigated, it has not yet received widespread acceptance. We performed a multicenter prospective randomized trial in order to determine the clinical efficacy of the NiTi Hand CAC 30, a type of compression anastomosis clip (CAC), for jejunojejunostomy in gastric cancer surgery.

METHODS

Forty-seven patients from 6 institutions, who were diagnosed with gastric adenocarcinoma, were enrolled; these patients were randomized to a CAC group and a hand-sewn (control) group. Three patients dropped out for various reasons, and results for 44 patients were finally analyzed. The CAC group consisted of 20 patients, and there were 24 patients in the control group.

RESULTS

Anastomosis time, the primary endpoint of this trial, was shorter in the CAC group than in the control group (P < 0.001). However, total operation times (P = 0.055) did not differ. All reconstructions were completed by Roux-en-Y anastomosis, and the complication rates of the two groups did not differ (P = 0.908); however, jejunojejunostomy leakage occurred in two patients in the CAC group.

CONCLUSIONS

Our prospective multicenter clinical trial showed that the use of the NiTi Hand CAC™ 30 for jejunojejunostomy in gastric cancer surgery was feasible and could reduce anastomosis time. However, considering that there were two cases of leakage, extended use of the NiTi Hand CAC™ 30 should be carefully applied.

The use of a compression device as an alternative to hand-sewn and stapled colorectal anastomoses: is three a crowd?

BACKGROUND

The NiTi CAR™ 27 is a newer device that uses compression to create an anastomosis. An analysis of this device in the creation of colorectal anastomoses in humans has yet to be reported in the USA.

METHODS

A non-randomized, prospective pilot study of the NiTi CAR™ 27 device in patients undergoing a left-sided colectomy between March 2008 and August 2009 was performed.

RESULTS

Twenty-three patients (9 men and 14 women) underwent a left-sided colectomy and compression anastomosis with the CAR™ 27 device. Minor morbidities, 3 of 23 (13%) patients, included one small postoperative abscess requiring antibiotics alone and two postoperative anastomotic strictures requiring balloon dilation. Major morbidities, 1 of 23 (4%) patients, included a partial anastomotic dehiscence/leak requiring surgical dismantling of the anastomosis and diversion.

CONCLUSION

The CAR™ 27 device shows promise as a safe and effective alternative for the creation of colorectal anastomoses. However, studies in a larger patient population are warranted to demonstrate equivalence of this device.

Evaluation of the NiTi Shape Memory BioDynamix ColonRing™ in colorectal anastomosis: first in human multi-center study

BACKGROUND

Shape-memory compression bowel anastomosis using a nickel and titanium alloy may reduce leak rates and eliminate foreign anastomotic material. Its safety and efficacy had been demonstrated by animal studies. We conducted the first prospective multi-center clinical evaluation of the safety and effectiveness of BioDynamix anastomosis with ColonRing™ for large-bowel end-to-end or side-to-end anastomosis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The ColonRing™ was compared to the standard double-stapled colorectal/colocolonic anastomosis. Intraoperative and immediate postoperative and 1- and 3-month postoperative follow-up data were recorded.

RESULTS

Ten study patients (four males, median age 62 years, range 35-75) were compared to 13 demographically matched controls (six males, median age 62 years, range 47-82). Colorectal neoplasia was the most frequent indication for surgery (21/23 patients, 91%). The median anastomotic distance from the anal verge for both groups was 10 cm (6-20 cm). The first postoperative bowel movement was on day 5 ±2.2 (study group) and on day 4 ±1.8 (controls), and the median hospital stay was 8 days (6-14 days) and 7 days (6-13 days), respectively. There were no anastomotic leaks. There were three minor complications in each group, unrelated to the device in the study group. Two patients required transanal digital extraction of the ring which was detached but not expelled (one had a soft anastomotic stricture).

CONCLUSIONS

Our preliminary results in this first study on humans indicate that the safety and efficacy of BioDynamix anastomosis with ColonRing™ in colorectal anastomosis in human is comparable to standard staples technology and warrant larger studies for further validation.

An alternative to conventional hand-sewing colocolic anastomosis: anastomosis with absorbable surgical barrier film without sutures

AIM

As a result of its high morbidity and mortality rates, anastomotic leakage is one of the most feared complications in colorectal surgery. Therefore, this issue is one of the most relevant in colorectal surgery and a lot of work has been conducted to research it. The aim of this experimental study was to compare colocolic anastomosis performed by using absorbable surgical barrier film without suture and conventional anastomosis performed by hand-sewing technique in terms of anastomosis safety.

METHOD

In this study, 40 Norway Wistar Albino 3-month-old female rats were used. Each weighed between 250 and 300g. The rates were divided into two groups, a control group and an experimental group. Full-thickness incisions were made on the ascending colon of both groups of rats. The control group's anastomoses were conducted using a hand-sewn technique consisting of one layer of nonabsorbable sutures (Gambee suture). The experimental group's anastomoses were performed using absorbable surgical barrier film without sutures. Afterwards, sample pieces of the anastomosis area were taken from all rats on either the 3rd or the 7th day following the operation, resulting in subgroups that led to a total of four test groups. The samples taken were subjected first to an anastomosis bursting pressure test followed by histopathological examinations and a test to detect the levels of hydroxyproline in the tissue.

RESULTS

The control groups (groups 1 and 3) had average anastomotic bursting pressures of 33.0±9.49mmHg and 146.0±15.06mmHg respectively, whereas experimental groups (groups 2 and 4) had average anastomotic bursting pressures of 58.0±10.33mmHg and 190.0±25.82mmHg respectively. Mann-Whitney U-test analysis of the bursting pressure values indicates the differences between groups 1 and 2 (3rd day postoperatively) and groups 3 and 4 (7th day postoperatively) to be statistically significant (P=0.0001 and P=0.0003 respectively). Values obtained from histopathological staging conducted according to the Ehrlich-Hunt model where the evaluation criteria in this model are: amount of inflammatory cells, fibroblasts, neovascularization and collagen and which were analysed using the Mann-Whitney U-test have shown no significant difference between 3rd day postoperatively groups 1 and 2 (P=0.579) while the difference between 7th day postoperatively groups 3 and 4 was found to be significant (P=0.023). Average levels of hydroxyproline in the tissue were 88.18±8.04mg/l for group 1, 56.31±5.40mg/l for group 2, 135.0± 6.30mg/l for group 3 and 100.2±15.42mg/l for group 4. Analysis of values in the groups using the Mann-Whitney U-test indicate a significant difference (P < 0.0001) both between groups 1 and 2 and between groups 3 and 4.

CONCLUSION

The use of absorbable surgical barrier film without sutures for colocolic anastomosis in rats may be safe.

Increased serum levels of C-reactive protein precede anastomotic leakage in colorectal surgery

BACKGROUND

Anastomotic leakage (AL) is a severe complication following colorectal surgery. C-reactive protein (CRP) is considered to be an indicator of postoperative complications.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Between August 2002 and August 2005 342 colorectal resections with primary anastomosis were performed at the Department of General and Vascular Surgery. Johann Wolfgang Goethe-University Frankfurt. For this retrospective study serum CRP was measured daily until postoperative day 7, and in cases of AL it was excluded from statistical analysis beginning with the day on which the AL was diagnosed.

RESULTS

Twenty-six of 342 (7.6%) patients developed AL at a mean of 8.7 days postoperatively. The in-hospital mortality was 3.5% for all patients and was significantly higher in the AL group (11.5 versus 2.8%). The CRP level in the two groups showed a peak on day 2.5 and day 2.2, respectively. In case of postoperative AL the CRP level did not show a marked decline during the next few days. Compared to the cases where AL did not develop, there was a significantly higher increase in CRP from the preoperative level to the levels measured on postoperative day 3, 5, 6 and 7. Higher CRP levels were observed in patients experiencing pneumonia or urinary tract infection, but the decrease of CRP values was not as slow as in cases of AL.

CONCLUSIONS

This study shows serum CRP level to be a relevant marker in detecting postoperative complications in colorectal surgery. Prolonged elevation and a missing decline in CRP level precede the occurrence of AL.

Techniques for colorectal anastomosis

Colorectal anastomotic leak remains one of the most feared post-operative complications, particularly after anterior resection of the rectum with, the shift from abdomino-peritoneal resections to total mesorectal excision and primary anastomosis. The literature fails to demonstrate superiority of stapled over hand-sewn techniques in colorectal anastomosis, regardless of the level of anastomosis, although a high stricture rate was noted in the former technique. Thus, improvements in safety aspects of anastomosis and alternatives to hand-sewn and stapled techniques are being sought. Here, we review alternative anastomotic techniques used to fashion bowel anastomosis. Compression anastomosis using compression anastomotic clips, endoluminal compression anastomotic rings, AKA-2, biofragmental anastomotic rings, or Magnamosis all involve the concept of creating a sutureless end-to-end anastomosis by compressing two bowel ends together, leading to a simultaneous necrosis and healing process that joins the two lumens. Staple line reinforcement is a new approach that reduce the drawbacks of staplers used in colorectal practice, i.e. leakage, bleeding, misfiring, and inadequate tissue approximation. Various non-absorbable, semi or fully absorbable materials are now available. Two other techniques can provide alternative anastomotic support to the suture line: a colorectal drain and a polyester stent, which can be utilized in ultra-low rectal excision and can negate the formation of a defunctioning stoma. Doxycycline coated sutures have been used to overcome the post-operative weakness in anastomosis secondary to rapid matrix degradation mediated by matrix metalloproteinase. Another novel technique, the electric welding system, showed promising results in construction of a safe, neat, smooth sutureless bowel anastomosis. Various anastomotic techniques have been shown to be comparable to the standard techniques of suturing and stapling. However, most of these alternatives need to be accepted and optimized for future use.

A memory-shape temperature-dependent nickel-titanium device for colonic anastomosis in laparoscopic surgery

Minimally invasive surgery is a growing issue in medicine and is also increasingly being used for colonic surgery. With this procedure, the involved colon is dissected laparoscopically, exteriorized through a small incision and the segment containing the tumor is resected. The anastomosis is done extraperitoneally either by hand suture or with a stapler. Our study was designed to evaluate the feasibility of using a memory-shape compression anastomosis clip (CAC) to perform colonic anastomosis in laparoscopy. Ten patients who were scheduled for laparoscopic colonic surgery entered the study. In five patients, the anastomosis was performed with the CAC and in five patients, with a stapler. To perform anastomosis with CAC, the two edges of the resected colon are placed parallel. Two 5-mm incisions are made close to the edges, where the CAC is introduced in an open position after being cooled in ice water at 0 degrees C, using a special applier. The applier introduces the clip which clamps the two bowel loops together, creating a small incision through the clamped walls, and then releasing the clip inside the intestine. The two 5-mm incisions are then sutured. The clip is expelled with the stool within five to seven days after the operation, creating a perfect uniform anastomosis. Neither group had complications related to the anastomosis. Our study shows that the use of the CAC for colonic laparoscopic surgery is simple, very efficient and shortens operation time. It creates a uniform anastomosis, coming close to the no-touch concept in surgery, may prevent infection, and is low in cost compared to the stapler.

Diverting stoma after low anterior resection: more arguments in favor

PURPOSE

The necessity of a protective stoma in patients undergoing low anterior resection with total mesorectal excision for primary rectal cancer is discussed controversially. We conducted a randomized, controlled, pilot-study to evaluate the need for diverting ileostomy in patients undergoing low anterior resection [NCT00457327].

METHODS

Forty patients after elective sphincter-saving low anterior resection were eligible for intraoperative randomization. The primary objective of this trial was to demonstrate similar risks after the resection with both techniques. A priori stopping rules were defined for early termination of the trial.

RESULTS

Between July 4, 2006 and March 12, 2007, a total of 41 patients were screened and 34 patients were randomized. Eighteen patients were randomized to the stoma group and 16 patients to the nonstoma group The symptomatic anastomotic leakage rate was significantly higher in the nonstoma group (37.5 percent) than in the stoma group (5.5 percent, P = 0.02). In all six cases in the nonstoma group, reoperations were necessary. The study was stopped after 34 patients were included. A meta-analysis of the available data confirmed the value of a protective ostomy for patients undergoing low anterior resection.

CONCLUSIONS

The data demonstrate a high risk for patients undergoing low anterior resection without diverting ileostomy.

New concepts for a compression anastomosis: superelastic clips and rings

Gastrointestinal anastomosis is a crucial step in many operative procedures, and responsible for a major portion of early and late post-operative complications. In order to improve on the results of current tools to perform an anastomosis, such as sutures and staplers, new concepts are being developed. One of these concepts is compression anastomosis. Compression anastomosis has been tried in the past but did not become popular mostly because of technical reasons. Recently, trials to accomplish compression anastomosis using Nitinol devices were conducted. Two devices were made and tested in the past three years: a side-to-side device and an end-to-end device. The common principle in both devices is the compression of two bowel loops through the constant pressure of a Nitinol device, thus producing a dual process of necrosis and healing until the lumens of both bowels fuse, and the device falls into the lumen and is excreted. Both devices have been tested in animals and humans, with encouraging results. In animals, the anastomoses were shown to demonstrate minimal inflammation and no foreign body reaction, with perfect healing of the mucosa. The side-to-side device was tested in over 500 human patients, and the end-to-end device is currently used in a large, multi-centric human trial.

Circular 'superelastic' compression anastomosis: from the animal lab to clinical practice

The recent development of a compression device using shape memory Nitinol technology to create an end-to-end anastomosis has renewed the interest in sutureless anastomotic techniques. A phase II, prospective open label clinical trial was started in May 2007 to evaluate the feasibility and safety of this new anastomotic device. Fourty patients who need left colectomy or high anterior resection for either diverticular disease or adenocarcinoma will be recruited in two academic hospitals (Uppsala,Sweden and Leuven, Belgium). Clinical leakage is the primary endpoint. Only preliminary results are available to date as the recruitment is ongoing. The median age of the first ten patients is 57.5 years (44-72). No anastomotic leakage occurred. The median hospital stay was 4.0 days. Only three patients noticed the passage of the ring through the anal canal. By three weeks no ring was sustained in the gastrointestinal tract as was objectified by plain X-ray. First clinical use of this new anastomotic device seems promising. Final results for the total phase II trial are awaited. A prospective randomized trial to compare the efficacy of the EndoCar 28 with conventional stapling should be the next step.

Compression anastomosis clip for gastrointestinal anastomosis

AIM: To investigate the feasibility of compression anastomosis clip (CAC) for gastrointestinal anastomosis proximal to the ileocecal junction.

METHODS: Sixty-six patients undergoing gastrointe-stinal anastomosis proximal to the ileocecal junction were randomized into two groups according to the anastomotic method, CAC or stapler.

RESULTS: The postoperative recovery of patients in CAC and stapled anastomosis groups was similar. No postoperative complication related to the anastomotic method was found in either group. Both upper gastrointestinal contrast radiography at the early postoperative course and endoscopic examination after a 6-mo follow-up showed a better healing at the compression anastomosis.

CONCLUSION: CAC can be used not only in colonic surgery but also in gastrointestinal anastomosis. Our result strongly suggests that CAC anastomosis is safe in various complication circumstances. However, it should be further confirmed with a larger patient sample.

Compression anastomosis: history and clinical considerations

BACKGROUND

Despite the fact that the concept of compression anastomosis has been investigated for nearly 2 centuries, it has not yet achieved widespread acceptance. The aim of the current report is to review the literature regarding compression anastomoses.

DATA SOURCES

A multi-database search was conducted using PubMed, Ovid, and the Cochrane Databases (all until June 2007), in addition to electronic links to related articles and references of selected articles. The following terms were used for the search in various combinations: anastomosis, anastomoses, sutureless, compression, nickel-titanium; Nitinol; CAC; CAR; AKA-2, Valtrac biofragmentable anastomotic ring, BAR. Language restrictions were not applied.

CONCLUSIONS

The various methods of compression anastomosis have been shown to be at least comparable to the standard techniques of suturing and stapling. The measurement of outcomes, including cost, safety, and efficacy of treatment, indicated that compression anastomosis can save time, is cost-effective, and offers an acceptable cost/benefit ratio compared to both stapled and sutured anastomoses. However, compression anastomosis did not gain worldwide popularity.

Application of compression anastomosis clip in gastroenterostomy

AIM: To evaluate safety and efficacy of compression anastomosis clip (CAC) for gastrointestinal anastomosis.

METHODS: Forty patients who underwent subtotal gastrectomy and gastrojejunostomy were assigned randomly to use either CAC or a curved stapler. Anastomotic complications were observed; The first post-operation flatus and bowel movement and extrusion of clip device were recorded. All statistics were analyzed using SPSS software package.

RESULTS: Neither group had gastrointestinal anastomotic complications such as leakage or obstruction. The clip was evacuated with the stool within 10-30 days after operation in the experiment group, but no significant difference was detected between the two groups. Two groups had the similar results in recovery of bowel function.

CONCLUSION: CAC is safe and simple to use for gastroenterostomy.

Compression anastomosis for Roux-en-Y gastric bypass: observations in a large animal model

BACKGROUND

In the morbidly obese, laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RYGB) effectively achieves weight loss with the resolution of co-morbidities. The goal is to create a small-volume gastric pouch with a narrow gastrojejunal anastomosis (GJA). The procedure is associated with a GJA stricture rate of approximately 3%. The use of a compression anastomotic device to create a sutureless gastrointestinal anastomosis, replacing sutures or staples, might reduce tissue trauma and improve the GJA patency rate. A temperature-dependent, memory-shape, Nitinol Compression Anastomosis Clip (CAC) has been successfully used in intestinal anastomoses. Compression of the entrapped bowel leads to necrosis, with device expulsion after 7-10 days.

METHODS

We designed a pilot animal model study of open RYGB to examine the clip's safety in the performance of upper gastrointestinal anastomoses. Six 40-kg female pigs underwent RYGB. Group 1 (n = 3) underwent GJA with the CAC and a stapled jejunojejunal anastomosis (JJA). Group 2 (n = 3) underwent GJA and JJA with the CAC. One pig from each group was euthanized at 1, 4, and 8 weeks postoperatively.

RESULTS

Two pigs, one from each group, developed gastroparesis. At autopsy, all anastomoses were patent; the mean GJA diameter with the CAC was 1.6 cm (range 0.6-3), the mean JJA diameter with the stapler was 3.8 cm (range 35-40), and the mean JJA diameter with the CAC was 3 cm (range 3-3.2). Anastomotic burst pressures were similar between the stapled and CAC anastomoses. The device was passed per rectum by postoperative day 9 (range 8-12). Histologic examination of the CAC anastomoses demonstrated a complete mucosal lining with no evidence of stricture formation at 2 months.

CONCLUSION

The results of this small animal study have demonstrated the safety of sutureless compression anastomoses in an animal model of open RYGB.

Colonic anastomosis performed with a memory-shaped device

BACKGROUND

The present study was prompted by our previous successful experience with the compression anastomosis clip (CAC) on animals followed by a study on 20 patients scheduled for colonic resection.

METHODS

Sixty patients with colonic cancer were assigned randomly to undergo an anastomosis either with the CAC or a stapler. To perform anastomosis with CAC, the 2 edges of the resected colon are aligned. Two 5-mm incisions are made close to the edges, through which (using a special applier) the CAC, after being cooled in ice water, is introduced in an open position. In response to the body temperature, the clip resumes its original (closed) position, thereby clamping the 2 bowel segments together. At the same time, a small scalpel incorporated in the applier makes a small incision through the clamped walls for the passage of gas and feces. The clip is detached from the applier to be left inside the intestine. The 2 5-mm incisions are sutured. The clip is expelled with the stool within 5 to 7 days, creating a perfect uniform compression anastomosis.

RESULTS

Neither group had anastomotic complications such as leakage or obstruction. All the other parameters were better in the study group than in the control patients.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of the CAC for colonic surgery is safe, simple, efficient, shortens operation time, and is almost what we call the "no-touch concept" in surgery and may decrease infection.

A nickel-titanium memory-shape device for colonic anastomosis in laparoscopic surgery

BACKGROUND

Minimally invasive surgery is used increasingly for colonic resection. With this procedure, the involved colon is dissected laparoscopically and exteriorized through a small incision, and the segment containing the tumor is resected. The anastomosis is performed extraperitoneally either by hand suture or with a stapler. This study was designed to evaluate the feasibility of using a memory-shape compression anastomosis clip (CAC) to perform laparoscopically assisted colonic anastomosis. The study was prompted by the authors' successful experience with the CAC in an animal model and in 10 patients with diverse colonic cancers.

METHODS

The sample consisted of 10 patients who underwent laparoscopic colonic surgery at the authors' center. The anastomosis was performed with the CAC for five patients and with a stapler for five patients. To perform anastomosis with the CAC, the two edges of the resected colon are aligned. Two 5-mm incisions are made near the edges, through which the CAC, after cooling in ice water, is introduced in an open position using a special applier. In response to body temperature, the clip resumes its original (closed) position, thereby clamping the two bowel loops together. At the same time, the small scalpel incorporated in the applier makes a small incision through the clamped walls for the passage of gas and feces, and the clip is released into the intestine. The two 5-mm incisions are sutured. The clip is expelled with the stool within 5 to 7 days, creating a perfect uniform anastomosis.

RESULTS

Neither group had complications, except one patient from the control group who experienced a small bowel obstruction attributable to a wound suture problem, which required laparotomy. His recovery was uneventful.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of the CAC for colonic laparoscopic surgery is simple and very efficient, shortening operation time. It creates a uniform anastomosis, approximating the no-touch concept in surgery, and may prevent infection. It also is lower in cost than the stapler.

Anastomotic leakage following low anterior resection: results of a standardized diagnostic and therapeutic approach

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

This study analyzed the results of a standardized approach in anastomotic leakage following low anterior resection for rectal cancer without performance of a protective ileostomy during the primary operation.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The study included all 306 patients with rectal cancer electively undergoing low anterior resection with retroperitonealization of the anastomosis over 9 years. The diagnostic procedure for anastomotic leakage included serum laboratory investigations and abdominal CT together with contrast enema. Minor leakages, i.e., small leakages and pelvic abscess, were treated with rectoscopic lavage and/or CT-guided drainage of the abscess, respectively. Major leakage was defined as broad insufficiency with or without septicemia. Nonseptic patients were treated by ileostomy and rectoscopic treatment. In septic patients a revision of the anastomosis with loop ileostomy was performed.

RESULTS

Anastomotic leakage was diagnosed in 30 patients (overall 9.8%; 12 major, 18 minor leakages). Common clinical signs were pelvic pain and fever. No patient developed a peritonitis. The most accurate diagnostic instrument was CT (96.7%).

CONCLUSION

Retroperitonealization appears to prevent peritonitis in patients with anastomotic leakage following low anterior resection. A differential treatment leads to good results in terms of mortality and anorectal function.

Transluminal endosurgery: single lumen access anastomotic device for flexible endoscopy

BACKGROUND

Forming anastomoses between two hollow organs at flexible endoscopy might reduce the need for surgery for obstructing malignancy. Current methods require access to both lumens. The aim of this work was to develop methods of forming an anastomosis at flexible endoscopy, such as a gastrojejunostomy or cholecystoduodenostomy, when access to only one lumen is feasible.

METHODS

A modified needle was passed through a large-channel echoendoscope from the accessible lumen into the target hollow organ. An anastomotic device was formed by using two 7F catheter segments, which were pushed over a guidewire into the target, the less accessible lumen. When released, by withdrawing the guidewire, the catheters formed a cross shape and created an anastomosis when compressed against a plate from the accessible side.

OBSERVATIONS

These devices were tested in live animal experiments. With an echoendoscope in the stomach, it was repeatedly possible to place needles, threaded tags, and guidewires into the small intestine and gallbladder. In 4 to 7 days, anastomoses were formed in 16 pigs between the small intestine and the stomach, and between the gallbladder and the stomach. The initial diameter of the anastomoses ranged from 3 to 9 mm. No complication occurred.

CONCLUSIONS

It is feasible to form anastomoses at flexible endoscopy when access is limited to a single side.

Colonic anastomosis with the nickel-titanium temperature-dependent memory-shape device

BACKGROUND

This study was prompted by our successful experience with a compression anastomosis clip (CAC) in an animal model.

METHODS

The study sample included 20 patients scheduled for colonic resections, of whom 10 underwent anastomosis with the CAC and 10 with staplers.

RESULTS

Neither group had anastomotic or other complications, except for 1 patient in the CAC group in whom a subphrenic infected hematoma developed after left hemicolectomy with splenectomy.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study demonstrates that this CAC is safe and simple to use, coming close to the "no touch surgery concept" and is of low cost compared with the staples used today.