A prospective randomized study comparing absorbable and nonabsorbable staples in constructing antireflux valves of urethral hemi-Kock pouches

Totally laparoscopic creation of a novel stapled orthotopic neobladder in the porcine model

PURPOSE

Laparoscopic urinary diversion remains difficult and time consuming even when performed by experienced laparoscopists. Here we describe a novel procedure that quickly creates an ileal orthotopic neobladder with an afferent tubular segment using a laparoscopic stapling device.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Laparoscopic cystectomy and stapled ileal neobladder were performed in five domestic juvenile pigs. Following cystectomy, 30 to 40 cm of terminal ileum was harvested, and ileal continuity restored. The harvested ileum was made into a J configuration, and three to seven laparoscopic staple firings were used to create a spherical pouch with an afferent limb modeled after the Studer-type neobladder. An aperture was created in the dependent portion of the neobladder, and urethral anastomosis was performed using six interrupted absorbable sutures. Ureterointestinal anastomosis was performed using a Wallace technique. Postoperative cystography and intravenous pyelography were performed. A 1-month survival study was completed in one pig.

RESULTS

All five procedures were completed successfully without conversion to open surgery. The majority of the steps of the procedures were performed by second- and third-year urology residents (PGY 3-4). Neobladder stapling, ureterointestinal anastomosis, and the first three urethral sutures were performed by an endourology fellow. Average time for neobladder creation and entire procedure was 78 and 355 minutes, respectively. Postoperative cystography revealed spherical orthotopic neobladder with minimal or no leakage in all animals. Average neobladder capacity was 100 mL, and no obstruction was visualized on intravenous pyelography immediately after the procedures. One pig successfully survived the 1-month study period. There was excellent neobladder storage, no clinically apparent renal obstruction, and no postoperative complications.

CONCLUSIONS

Total laparoscopic urinary diversion and specifically orthotopic neobladder remains one of the frontiers of minimally invasive urologic surgery. Our technique for stapled ileal neobladder provides substantial advantages in terms of the operative time required for orthotopic neobladder reconstruction. This may offer an avenue to foster the development of more feasible techniques for laparoscopic urinary tract reconstructive surgery.

IS ORTHOTOPIC BLADDER REPLACEMENT THE NEW GOLD STANDARD? EVIDENCE FROM A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW

PURPOSE

In this systematic review we determined whether the outcome of orthotopic bladder replacement is superior to that of continent and incontinent urinary diversion.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We searched MEDLINE, PubMed, EMBASE, CINAHL and the Cochrane Library from January 1990 to January 2003. A total of 3,370 abstracts were reviewed, including all types of studies from prospective, randomized, controlled studies to small, retrospective series. All relevant articles with at least 10 patients and a mean followup of at least 1 year were retrieved. There were no language restrictions. NonEnglish articles were translated. Comparisons were made between the major surgery types, including ileal conduit, continent diversion, bladder reconstruction and bladder replacement. All studies were scored using a predetermined quality assessment checklist to assess internal validity (bias and confounding) and external validity.

RESULTS

A total of 405 studies met inclusion criteria. There were 32 prospective and 373 retrospective studies describing a total of 32,795 patients. The majority of studies were incompletely or poorly described and outcomes were often not defined. When they were defined, definitions varied. In clinical outcomes ileal conduit diversions had the lowest operative complications rate but highest reported postoperative morbidity. They also had a higher reported incidence of symptomatic urinary tract infections. The rates of postoperative morbidity, mortality and need for reoperation varied widely among studies even for the same procedure. Of physiological outcomes metabolic acidosis was the most commonly reported metabolic complication in patients with various urinary diversions. The quality of the reported literature was poor. There were no studies of the health economic implications of performing 1 type of surgery vs another type.

CONCLUSIONS

While enthusiasts regard orthotopic bladder replacement as the new gold standard when lower urinary tract function must be replaced, the level and quality of current evidence are poor. The immediate concern must be to rectify this paucity of evidence with well designed and well reported prospective studies, ideally in a randomized setting, comparing the various major forms of urinary diversion and bladder replacement surgery.

The urethral Kock pouch: long-term functional and oncological results in men

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate our experience with men who underwent radical cystectomy and urethral Kock pouch construction between January 1986 and January 1996.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Complications were classified as early (within the first 3 months after surgery) or late. Continence was assessed by interviewing the patient; they were considered continent if they were completely dry with no need of protection by pads, condom catheter or medication. The patients were followed oncologically and Kaplan-Meier survival curves constructed. Urodynamic studies were used to define the possible causes of enuresis.

RESULTS

Three patients died after surgery from pulmonary embolism. There were 67 early complications in 63 patients. The mean (SD) follow-up was 87.8 (49.1) months. There were 111 treatment failures from cancer; of these, four men only had an isolated local recurrence in the urethra. Late complications included 72 pouch stones in 55 patients, and 36 deteriorated renal units caused by reflux (17), uretero-ileal stricture (11), nipple valve eversion (four) or stenosis (four). Interestingly, 65 renal units that were dilated before surgery improved significantly afterward. Ileo-urethral strictures occurred in seven men and anterior urethral strictures in six. Nine patients were totally incontinent and two had chronic urinary retention. Daytime continence was complete in 94% of men, with nocturnal enuresis in 55; the latter had significantly more residual urine, and a higher amplitude and duration of phasic contractions.

CONCLUSIONS

Orthotopic bladder substitution after cystectomy for cancer is feasible, with good functional and oncological outcomes in properly selected patients. Nevertheless, the use of a hemi-Kock pouch is associated with many valve-related complications.

Stones in urinary diversions: update on medical and surgical issues

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Patients who undergo urinary tract diversion are at an increased risk of urolithiasis for various reasons. The purpose of this article is to provide an up-to-date summary of the progress that has been made in the pathogenesis, diagnosis and treatment of stones in patients with urinary diversions. Finally, we will provide recommendations for follow-up in patients with urinary diversions who develop urinary tract calculi.

RECENT FINDINGS

In contemporary studies, the incidence of urolithiasis in patients with urinary diversion appears to be decreasing. Computed tomography scanning has been shown to be superior to ultrasound in the diagnosis of calculi in such patients. Endourological procedures have become the mainstay of therapy for stones in patients with urinary diversions. Since the introduction of extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy, percutaneous nephrolithotripsy and ureteroscopy, the need for open surgery has decreased, even in this anatomically unique and surgically challenging patient population.

SUMMARY

Urolithiasis is an established long-term complication of urinary diversion. In recent years, significant advances have been made in the pathogenesis, diagnosis and treatment of such stones. As a result of potential stone-related complications, we recommend lifelong surveillance for all patients with urinary stones and diversions, with medical therapy when indicated, in order to minimize these complications.

Urinary diversion and reconstruction

Orthotopic bladder augmentation and substitution has been established as the standard procedure for urinary diversion in many institutions, with current studies reporting mainly on continence rates and procedure-associated complications, such as the risk of impairment of neobladder function by local tumor recurrences in the small pelvis. Similarly, in other types of continent diversion, such as continent cutaneous diversion and rectal reservoirs, current interest is primarily directed towards minimization of surgery-associated complications.