Modeling Molecular Interactions in Water: From Pairwise to Many-Body Potential Energy Functions

Almost 50 years have passed from the first computer simulations of water, and a large number of molecular models have been proposed since then to elucidate the unique behavior of water across different phases. In this article, we review the recent progress in the development of analytical potential energy functions that aim at correctly representing many-body effects. Starting from the many-body expansion of the interaction energy, specific focus is on different classes of potential energy functions built upon a hierarchy of approximations and on their ability to accurately reproduce reference data obtained from state-of-the-art electronic structure calculations and experimental measurements. We show that most recent potential energy functions, which include explicit short-range representations of two-body and three-body effects along with a physically correct description of many-body effects at all distances, predict the properties of water from the gas to the condensed phase with unprecedented accuracy, thus opening the door to the long-sought "universal model" capable of describing the behavior of water under different conditions and in different environments.

Biomolecular electrostatics and solvation: a computational perspective

An understanding of molecular interactions is essential for insight into biological systems at the molecular scale. Among the various components of molecular interactions, electrostatics are of special importance because of their long-range nature and their influence on polar or charged molecules, including water, aqueous ions, proteins, nucleic acids, carbohydrates, and membrane lipids. In particular, robust models of electrostatic interactions are essential for understanding the solvation properties of biomolecules and the effects of solvation upon biomolecular folding, binding, enzyme catalysis, and dynamics. Electrostatics, therefore, are of central importance to understanding biomolecular structure and modeling interactions within and among biological molecules. This review discusses the solvation of biomolecules with a computational biophysics view toward describing the phenomenon. While our main focus lies on the computational aspect of the models, we provide an overview of the basic elements of biomolecular solvation (e.g. solvent structure, polarization, ion binding, and non-polar behavior) in order to provide a background to understand the different types of solvation models.

Continuum polarizable force field within the Poisson-Boltzmann framework

We have developed and tested a complete set of nonbonded parameters for a continuum polarizable force field. Our analysis shows that the new continuum polarizable model is consistent with B3LYP/cc-pVTZ in modeling electronic response upon variation of dielectric environment. Comparison with experiment also shows that the new continuum polarizable model is reasonable, with accuracy similar to that of B3LYP/cc-pVTZ in reproduction of dipole moments of selected organic molecules in the gas phase. We have further tested the validity to interchange the Amber van der Waals parameters between the explicit and continuum polarizable force fields with a series of dimers. It can be found that the continuum polarizable model agrees well with MP2/cc-pVTZ, with deviations in dimer binding energies less than 0.9 kcal/mol in the aqueous dielectric environment. Finally, we have optimized atomic cavity radii with respect to experimental solvation free energies of 177 training molecules. To validate the optimized cavity radii, we have tested these parameters against 176 test molecules. It is found that the optimized Poisson-Boltzmann atomic cavity radii transfer well from the training set to the test set, with an overall root-mean-square deviation of 1.30 kcal/mol, an unsigned average error of 1.07 kcal/mol, and a correlation coefficient of 92% for all 353 molecules in both the training and test sets. Given the development documented here, the next natural step is the construction of a full protein/nucleic acid force field within the new continuum polarization framework.

Anisotropic, Polarizable Molecular Mechanics Studies of Inter- and Intramolecular Interactions and Ligand-Macromolecule Complexes. A Bottom-Up Strategy

We present an overview of the SIBFA polarizable molecular mechanics procedure, which is formulated and calibrated on the basis of quantum chemistry (QC). It embodies nonclassical effects such as electrostatic penetration, exchange-polarization, and charge transfer. We address the issues of anisotropy, nonadditivity, and transferability by performing parallel QC computations on multimolecular complexes. These encompass multiply H-bonded complexes and polycoordinated complexes of divalent cations. Recent applications to the docking of inhibitors to Zn-metalloproteins are presented next, namely metallo-beta-lactamase, phosphomannoisomerase, and the nucleocapsid of the HIV-1 retrovirus. Finally, toward third-generation intermolecular potentials based on density fitting, we present the development of a novel methodology, the Gaussian electrostatic model (GEM), which relies on ab initio-derived fragment electron densities to compute the components of the total interaction energy. As GEM offers the possibility of a continuous electrostatic model going from distributed multipoles to densities, it allows an inclusion of short-range quantum effects in the molecular mechanics energies. The perspectives of an integrated SIBFA/GEM/QM procedure are discussed.

Unravelling the Origin of Intermolecular Interactions Using Absolutely Localized Molecular Orbitals

An energy decomposition analysis (EDA) method is proposed to isolate physically relevant components of the total intermolecular interaction energies such as the contribution from interacting frozen monomer densities, the energy lowering due to polarization of the densities, and the further energy lowering due to charge-transfer effects. This method is conceptually similar to existing EDA methods such as Morokuma analysis but includes several important new features. The first is a fully self-consistent treatment of the energy lowering due to polarization, which is evaluated by a self-consistent field calculation in which the molecular orbital coefficients are constrained to be block-diagonal (absolutely localized) in the interacting molecules to prohibit charge transfer. The second new feature is the ability to separate forward and back-donation in the charge-transfer energy term using a perturbative approximation starting from the optimized block-diagonal reference. The newly proposed EDA method is used to understand the fundamental aspects of intermolecular interactions such as the degree of covalency in the hydrogen bonding in water and the contributions of forward and back-donation in synergic bonding in metal complexes. Additionally, it is demonstrated that this method can be used to identify the factors controlling the interaction of the molecular hydrogen with open metal centers in potential hydrogen storage materials and the interaction of methane with rhenium complexes.

Prediction and rationalization of protein pKa values using QM and QM/MM methods

We describe the development and application of a computational method for the prediction and rationalization of pKa values of ionizable residues in proteins, based on ab initio quantum mechanics (QM) and the effective fragment potential (EFPs) method (a hybrid QM/MM method). The theoretical developments include (1) a covalent boundary method based on frozen localized orbitals, (2) divide-and-conquer methods for the ab initio computation of protein EFPs consisting of multipoles up to octupoles and dipole polarizability tensors, (3) a method for computing vibrational free energies for a localized molecular region, and (4) solutions of the polarized continuum model of bulk solvation equations for protein-sized systems. The QM-based pKa prediction method is one of the most accurate methods currently available and can be used in cases where other pKa prediction methods fail. Preliminary analysis of the computed results indicate that many pKa values (1) are primarily determined by hydrogen bonds rather than long-range charge-charge interactions and (2) are relatively insensitive to large-scale dynamical fluctuations of the protein structure.

A CSOV study of the difference between HF and DFT intermolecular interaction energy values: The importance of the charge transfer contribution

Intermolecular interaction energy decompositions using the Constrained Space Orbital Variation (CSOV) method are carried out at the Hartree-Fock level on the one hand and using DFT with usual GGA functionals on the other for a number of model complexes to analyze the role of electron correlation in the intermolecular stabilization energy. In addition to the overall stabilization, the results provide information on the variation, with respect to the computational level, of the different contributions to the interaction energy. The complexes studied are the water linear dimer, the N-methylformamide dimer, the nucleic acid base pairs, the benzene-methane and benzene-N2 van der Waals complexes, [Cu+ -(ImH)3]2, where "ImH" stands for the Imidazole ligand, and ImH-Zn++. The variation of the frozen core energy (the sum of the intermolecular electrostatic energy and the Pauli repulsion energy) calculated from the unperturbed orbitals of the interacting entities indicates that the intramolecular correlation contributions can be stabilizing as well as destabilizing, and that general trends can be derived from the results obtained using usual density functionals. The most important difference between the values obtained from HF and DFT computations concerns the charge transfer contribution, which, in most cases, undergoes the largest increase. The physical meaning of these results is discussed. The present work gives reference calculations that might be used to parametrize new correlated molecular mechanics potentials.

Intraprotein electrostatics derived from first principles: Divide-and-conquer approaches for QM/MM calculations

Two divide-and-conquer (DAQ) approaches for building multipole-based molecular electrostatic potentials of proteins are presented and evaluated for use in QM/MM calculations. One approach is a further development of the neutralization method of Bellido and Rullmann (J Comput Chem 1989, 10, 479-487) while the other is based on removing part of the electron density before performing the multipole expansion. Both methods create systems with integer charges without using charge renormalization. To determine their performance in terms of location of cuts and distance to QM region, the new DAQ approaches are tested in calculations of the proton affinity of N(zeta) of Lys55 in the inhibitor turkey ovomucoid third domain. Finally, the two methods are used to build a variety of MM regions, applied to calculations of the pK(a) of Lys55, and compared to other computational methodologies in which force field charges are employed.

Binding of D- and L-captopril inhibitors to metallo-beta-lactamase studied by polarizable molecular mechanics and quantum mechanics

The bacterial Zn2+ metallo-beta-lactamase from B. fragilis is a zinc-enzyme with two potential metal ion binding sites. It cleaves the lactam ring of antibiotics, thus contributing to the acquired resistance of bacteria against antibiotics. The present study bears on the binuclear form of the enzyme. We compare several possible binding modes of captopril, a mercaptocarboxamide inhibitor of several zinc-metalloenzymes. Two diastereoisomers of captopril were considered, with either a D- or an L-proline residue. We have used the polarizable molecular mechanics procedure SIBFA (Sum of Interactions Between Fragments ab initio computed). Two beta-lactamase models were considered, encompassing 104 and 188 residues, respectively. The energy balances included the inter and intramolecular interaction energies as well as the contribution from solvation computed using a continuum reaction field procedure. The thiolate ion of the inhibitor is binding to both metal ions, expelling the bridging solvent molecule from the uncomplexed enzyme. Different competing binding modes of captopril were considered, either where the inhibitor binds in a monodentate mode to the zinc cations only with its thiolate ion, or in bidentate modes involving additional zinc binding by its carboxylate or ketone carbonyl groups. The additional coordination by the inhibitor's carboxylate or carbonyl group always occurs at the zinc ion, which is bound by a histidine, a cysteine, and an aspartate side chain. For both diastereomers, the energy balances favor monodentate binding of captopril via S-. The preference over bidentate binding is small. The interaction energies were recomputed in model sites restricted to captopril, the Zn2+ cations, and their coordinating end side chains from beta-lactamase (98 atoms). The interaction energies and their ranking among competing arrangements were consistent with those computed by ab initio HF and DFT procedures.

Theoretical Investigations of the Influence of Pressure on the Selectivity of the Michael Addition of Diphenylmethaneamine to Stereogenic Crotonates

SIBFA (sum of interactions between fragments ab initio computed) molecular mechanics systematics has been modified to take into account the effect of pressure on intra- and intermolecular energies. The van der Waals radii are related to the pressure, using Bridgman results on the variation of crystal volume, on one hand, and the relation between the volume of an atom and its van der Waals radius on the other. This procedure produces a decrease of the volume of the systems considered. The modified systematics is used for the study of the conformation at 1 atm and 15 kbar of two stereogenic crotonates and of the complexes formed by these two molecules with the diphenylmethaneamine and the three solvent molecules present in the experiment. The results obtained show that in the case of NMECC 1a the diastereoselectivity induced by high pressure and by the presence of methanol proceeds from an important stabilization of the pro-R reactive complex in which the crotonate has a stacked-transoid conformation. This stabilization is mainly due to intermolecular interactions. In the case of the second crotonate considered, NMCC 1b, our results indicate that pressure induces a stabilization of the pro-R and pro-S complexes having the axial conformation for which the reaction exhibits little diastereoselectivity in qualitative agreement with experimental data. This study tends to show that it is possible to account theoretically for the influence of pressure on molecular conformation and/or complex structure, using a molecular mechanics method that is able to take into account the variation of volumes of the different entities present in the system studied.