Gastric scirrhous carcinoma as a rare cause of aggressive fibromatosis in the neck

Tumor Classification Should Be Based on Biology and Not Consensus: Re-Defining Tumors Based on Biology May Accelerate Progress, An Experience of Gastric Cancer

Simple Summary

Rational treatment of diseases including cancers depends on knowledge of their cause as well as their development. The present review is based upon more than 40 years’ work in clinical gastroenterology, gastric physiology, and pathology. The central role of hormones as well as local endocrine cells in cancer development has become apparent. Moreover, the classification of tumors should focus not only on the organ of origin but also on the cell of origin. All cells with the ability to divide may give rise to tumors. Based upon knowledge of the growth regulation of the cell of origin, prophylaxis and treatment may be tailored. Presently, there is hope for individual treatment of cancer patients based upon genetic analyses of tumors. However, with correct identification of the cell of origin, this may not be necessary.

Abstract

Malignant tumors are a consequence of genetic changes mainly occurring during cell division, sometimes with a congenital component. Therefore, accelerated cell divisions will necessarily predispose individuals, whether due to conditions of chronic cell destruction or hormonal overstimulation. It has been postulated that two genetic hits are necessary for the development of malignancy (Knudson). The correct view is probably that the number of genetic changes needed depends on the role the mutated genes have in proliferation and growth control. Hormones should accordingly be regarded as complete carcinogens. In this review based upon experience of gastric cancer where gastrin is central in the pathogenesis, it is argued that oxyntic atrophy—and not metaplasia as postulated by Correa—is the central precancer change in gastric mucosa. Moreover, the target cell of gastrin, the enterochromaffin-like (ECL) cell, is central in gastric carcinogenesis and most probably the cell of origin of gastric carcinomas of the diffuse type according to Lauren (a classification probable in accordance with biology). The distinction between adenocarcinomas and neuroendocrine carcinomas based upon a certain percentage of cancer cells with neuroendocrine differentiation is questioned. To make progress in the treatment of cancer, a correct classification system and knowledge of the pathogenesis are necessary.

Towards Understanding of Gastric Cancer Based upon Physiological Role of Gastrin and ECL Cells

Simple Summary

Generally, we know that cancers represent genetic changes in tumour cells, but we most often do not know the causes of cancers or how they develop. Our knowledge of the regulation of gastric acid secretion is well known, with the gastric hormone gastrin maintaining gastric acidity by stimulation of the enterochromaffin-like (ECL) cell to release histamine, which subsequently augments acid secretion. Furthermore, it seems to be a general principle that stimulation of function (which, for the ECL cell, is release of histamine) in a parallel way stimulates the proliferation of the same cell. Long-term hyperstimulation of cell division predisposes to genetic changes and, thus, development of tumours. All conditions with reduced gastric acidity result in an increased risk of gastric tumours due to elevated gastrin in order to restore gastric acidity. It is probable that Helicobacter pylori infection (the most important cause of gastric cancer), as well as drugs inhibiting gastric acid secretion induce gastric cancer in the long-term, due to an elevation of gastrin caused by reduced gastric acidity. Gastric carcinomas have been shown to express ECL cell markers, further strengthening this relationship.

Abstract

The stomach is an ideal organ to study because the gastric juice kills most of the swallowed microbes and, thus, creates rather similar milieu among individuals. Combined with a rather easy access to gastric juice, gastric physiology was among the first areas to be studied. During the last century, a rather complete understanding of the regulation of gastric acidity was obtained, establishing the central role of gastrin and the histamine producing enterochromaffin-like (ECL) cell. Similarly, the close connection between regulation of function and proliferation became evident, and, furthermore, that chronic overstimulation of a cell with the ability to proliferate, results in tumour formation. The ECL cell has long been acknowledged to give rise to neuroendocrine tumours (NETs), but not to play any role in carcinogenesis of gastric adenocarcinomas. However, when examining human gastric adenocarcinomas with the best methods presently available (immunohistochemistry with increased sensitivity and in-situ hybridization), it became clear that many of these cancers expressed neuroendocrine markers, suggesting that some of these tumours were of neuroendocrine, and more specifically, ECL cell origin. Thus, the ECL cell and its main regulator, gastrin, are central in human gastric carcinogenesis, which make new possibilities in prevention, prophylaxis, and treatment of this cancer.

Types of Gastric Carcinomas

Gastric cancer has reduced prevalence, but poor prognoses. To improve treatment, better knowledge of carcinogenesis and cells of origin should be sought. Stomach cancers are typically localized to one of the three mucosae; cardial, oxyntic and antral. Moreover, not only the stem cell, but the ECL cell may proliferate and give rise to tumours. According to Laurén, the classification of gastric carcinomas seems to reflect biological important differences and possible different cell of origin since the two subtypes, intestinal and diffuse, do not transform into the other and show different epidemiology. The stem cell probably gives rise to the intestinal type, whereas the ECL cell may be important in the diffuse type. Elevation of gastrin may be the carcinogenic factor for Helicobacter pylori as well as the recently described increased risk of gastric cancer due to proton pump inhibitor treatment. Therefore, it is essential to determine the role of the gastrin target cell, the ECL cell, in gastric carcinogenesis. Clinical trials with gastrin antagonists could improve prognoses in those with gastrin receptor positive tumours. However, further studies on gastric carcinomas applying relative available methods and with the highest sensitivity are warranted to improve our knowledge of gastric carcinogenesis.