Early Weight-Bearing After Arthrodesis of the First Metatarsal-Phalangeal Joint: A Systematic Review of the Incidence of Non-Union

First cuneo-metatarsal arthrodesis (Modified Lapidus) with plantar plate for the treatment of hallux valgus: clinical and radiological outcomes at one year follow-up

INTRODUCTION

The modified Lapidus arthrodesis, involving the first cuneo-metatarsal joint, is a well-established surgical method and widely utilized for treating moderate to severe hallux valgus deformities with hypermobility in the first tarsometatarsal joint. The purpose of this study was to assess the rate of union following the Lapidus procedure using a plantar plate and an immediate full weight-bearing protocol. Secondary objectives included examining radiological corrections and potential associated complications.

METHODS

A retrospective study included 66 patients (80 feet) who underwent a modified Lapidus procedure for the treatment of hallux valgus associated with hypermobility of the first ray, performed by a single senior surgeon at our institution between May 2013 and November 2019. All patients had a minimum follow-up of 12 months. Patients were clinically assessed at 3 weeks, 3 months, and 1 year. Radiological measurements were taken on weight-bearing dorsoplantar views preoperatively, at 3 months, and at 12 months postoperatively.

RESULTS

Bone union was achieved in 79 cases (98.75%). There was one case of non-union, two wound complications (one infection and one dehiscence), two cases of symptomatic hardware requiring hardware removal, and one stress fracture associated with recurrence of hallux valgus that required revision. The mean hallux valgus angle (HVA) improved from 30.5 ° ±10.4 ° to 10.1 ° ±6.6 ° (p < .001), the mean intermetatarsal angle (IMA) improved from 13.4 ° ±3.6 ° to 5.6 ° ±2.9 (p < .001), The average sesamoid position improved from stage 5.9 ± 1.6 to stage 2.6 ± 1.2 (p < .001). The mean shortening of the first metatarsal was 3.6 mm ± 1.8. There was no significant difference between measurements at 3 and 12 months postoperatively.

CONCLUSION

Modified Lapidus with a planter plate and compression screw is a reliable method of fixation with a high union rate, permit an immediate protected weight bearing and a low complications rate.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV; Retrospective study.

The Surgical Learning Curve for Modified Lapidus Procedure for Hallux Valgus Deformity

BACKGROUND

Hallux valgus is one of the most common orthopaedic deformities of the foot, affecting as much as 23% of the population age 18 to 65. In addition to its high prevalence, it has a complex multifactorial pathogenesis. Surgical correction options have variable rates of success and new techniques are being developed. The modified Lapidus procedure attempts to correct in 3 planes of deformity, which may create a steeper learning curve for those newly adopting the technique.

METHODS

A retrospective review was performed on patients who underwent hallux valgus reconstruction with a modified Lapidus procedure between March 2018 and July 2020. Exclusion criteria included revision surgery, 6 or more concurrent procedures, or a flexor digitorum longus tendon transfer for adult acquired flatfoot correction.

RESULTS

There were a total of 81 modified Lapidus procedures for hallux valgus within the study time frame and 68 were included in the study. Over a period of 2 years there was a significant decrease in overall surgery duration from 78.93 minutes at month 0 to 61.80 minutes at 24 months (P = .036). The average preoperative/postoperative intermetatarsal angles were 15.08° and 4.91°, respectively. There was an average decrease of 10.17°. The rate of nonunion was 4.41% (3/68), and the rate of recurrence at 6 months was 5.88% (4/68). There was not a significant difference in the rate of recurrence (P = .394) or the rate of nonunion (P = .817) as the surgeon increased in experience.

CONCLUSION

Although there is a significant learning curve for the modified Lapidus procedure, it is largely overcome by the 23rd case. Additionally, experience with the technique does not appear to affect the patient outcomes of nonunion or recurrence.

LEVELS OF EVIDENCE

Level IV: Retrospective.

Immediate Weightbearing Following First Metatarsal Phalangeal Joint Arthrodesis With 2 Nickel Titanium Alloy Staples

The use of staples has been shown to be a reasonable fixation technique to achieve stability of a first MTPJ arthrodesis. Although it has been shown to be a weaker construct than crossed screws or plate and screw combinations, their ease of insertion, low profile, and stability make them a desirable choice for first MTPJ arthrodesis fixation. However, because of this relative weakness, the question remains whether immediate weightbearing when using staples is advisable. The aim of this study is to determine whether the use of 2 nickel-titanium alloy (NITINOL) staples, placed at 90 degrees to one another is a stable enough construct to support full, immediate weightbearing following first MTPJ arthrodesis. We performed a retrospective chart review of patients undergoing first MTPJ arthrodesis by a single surgeon utilizing 2 NITINOL staples placed at 90 degrees to one another. Patients were allowed to be fully weightbearing immediately postoperatively. Forty-seven of 50 (94%) patients achieved complete radiologic consolidation of fusion at 12 weeks, with only 3 requiring revision surgery for nonunion. All of the patients requiring revision surgery for nonunion, had preoperative diagnosis of hallux abducto valgus. We concluded that the use of 2 NITINOL staples placed at 90 degrees to one another is a viable option for first MTPJ arthrodesis, and immediate weightbearing does not increase rate of nonunion or incidence of revision surgery when compared to other fixation techniques.

Early Functional Rehabilitation in Foot and Ankle Surgery

The traditional postoperative management of common foot and ankle procedures has involved a prolonged period of immobilization and nonweight bearing. The concern was loss of correction and fixation failure. However, it has been shown that a prolonged period of nonweight bearing can predispose patients possible deep vein thrombosis, disuse osteopenia, cardiovascular complications, and generalized deconditioning. The authors' institution has published studies reviewing the efficacy of early weight bearing after first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis, modified Lapidus bunionectomy, and open reduction and internal fixation of ankle fractures. This article highlights the literature and rationale supporting the safety of early weight-bearing protocols.

Analysis of the Costs and Complications of First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Arthrodesis Comparing Locked and Non-locked Plate Fixation Constructs

BACKGROUND

The ideal fixation method for the first metatarsophalangeal joint (first MTP) remains uncertain. This study compares nonunion and revision surgery rates of first MTP arthrodesis between nonlocking semitubular plates and precontoured locking plates.

METHODS

Demographics, fixation technique, and complications of all patients who underwent primary first MTP arthrodesis between 2013 and 2018 were determined from radiographs and clinical records. Cost data were from a 1-year subset of isolated first MTP fusion surgeries. The primary outcome measures of this study were the nonunion and complication rates, with associated costs of patients undergoing first metatarsophalangeal arthrodesis with either a noncontoured semitubular plate or a precontoured locking plate.

RESULTS

The study included 189 patients, with a mean follow-up of 18.7 months. The overall nonunion rate was 10.1%, with no difference between the locking and nonlocking plates. The prevalence of a painful implant was also similar. Surgeries using locking plates cost an average of $1,500 more than those using nonlocked plates.

CONCLUSIONS

Because there was no difference in revision between locking and nonlocking plate fixation for primary first MTP arthrodesis, routine use of the more expensive locking plates may not be justified.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III (Retrospective cohort study).

Achieving high union rates after first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis: Radiographic outcomes and technical pitfalls

BACKGROUND

Fusion of the first metatarsophalangeal (MTP1) joint is a common surgery performed to correct hallux rigidus, hallux rigidus et valgus and other painful degenerative diseases of the MTP1.

AIM

To assess outcomes of our surgical technique including non-union rates, accuracy and aims of correction.

METHODS

Between September 2011 and November 2020 a total 72 of MTP1 fusions were performed using a low profile, pre-contoured dorsal locking plate and a plantar compression screw. Union and revision rates were analyzed with a minimum clinical and radiological follow up of at least 3 mo (range 3-18 mo). The following parameters were evaluated on pre- and postoperative conventional radiographs: Intermetatarsal angle, Hallux-valgus angle, dorsal extension of the proximal phalanx (P1) in relation to the floor and the angle between the Metatarsal 1 and the P1 (MT1-P1 angle). Descriptive statistical analysis was performed. Pearson analysis was used to assess for correlations between radiographic parameters and achievement of fusion.

RESULTS

An overall union rate of 98.6% (71/72) was achieved. Two out of 72 patients did not primarily fuse with one patient suffering from a non-union, whilst the other demonstrating a radiological delayed union without clinical symptoms, with eventually complete fusion after 18 mo. There was no correlation between the measured radiographic parameters and the achievement of fusion. We believe the reason for the non-union was mainly attributed to the patient’s incompliance without wearing the therapeutic shoe leading to a fracture of the P1. Furthermore, we didn`t find any correlation between fusion and the degree of correction.

CONCLUSION

With our surgical technique, high union rates (98%) can be achieved using a compression screw and a dorsal variable-angle locking plate to treat degenerative diseases of the MTP1.

Factors Associated With Nonunion in Arthrodesis of the First Metatarsophalangeal Joint: A Multicenter Retrospective Cohort Study

BACKGROUND

Arthrodesis of the first metatarsophalangeal joint is the current treatment of choice for symptomatic advanced hallux rigidus and moderate-to-severe hallux valgus. There are different methods to perform arthrodesis, yet no consensus on the best approach. Therefore, this study aimed to determine the effects of preoperative and postoperative hallux valgus angle (HVA), joint preparation and fixation technique, and postoperative immobilization on the incidence of nonunion.

METHODS

A retrospective multicenter cohort study was performed that included 794 patients. Univariate and multiple logistic regression was conducted to determine associations between joint preparation, fixation techniques, postoperative immobilization, weightbearing, and pre- and postoperative HVA with nonunion.

RESULTS

Nonunion incidence was 15.2%, with 11.1% symptomatic and revised. Joint preparation using hand instruments (OR 3.75, CI 1.90-7.42) and convex/concave reamers (OR 2.80, CI 1.52-5.16) were associated with greater odds of a nonunion compared to planar cuts. Joint fixation with crossed screws was associated with greater odds of nonunion (OR 2.00, CI 1.11-3.42), as was greater preoperative HVA (OR 1.02, CI 1.00-1.03). However, the latter effect disappeared after inclusion of postoperative HVA in the model, with a small association identified between residual postoperative HVA and nonunion (OR 1.04, CI 1.01-1.08). Similarly, we found an association between odds of nonunion and higher body weight (OR 1.02, CI 1.01-1.04) but not of body mass index.

CONCLUSION

Based on our results, first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis with planar cuts and fixation with a plate and interfragmentary screw is associated with the lowest odds of resulting in a nonunion. Higher body weight and greater preoperative HVA were associated with slight increase in rates of nonunion. It is crucial to properly correct the hallux valgus deformity during surgery.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, retrospective case control study.

General Considerations About Foot and Ankle Arthrodesis. Any Way to Improve Our Results?

Nonunion and adjacent joint osteoarthritis (OA) are known complications after a fusion procedure, and foot and ankle surgeons are commonly exposed to such disabling complications. Determining who is at risk of developing nonunion is essential to reducing nonunion rates and improving patient outcomes. Several evidenced-based modifiable risk factors related to adverse outcomes after foot and ankle arthrodesis have been identified. Patient-related risk factors that can be improved before surgery include smoking cessation, good diabetic control (HbAc1 <7%) and vitamin D supplementation. Intraoperatively, using less invasive techniques, avoiding joint preparation with power tools, using bone grafts or orthobiologics in more complex cases, high-risk patients, nonunion revision surgeries, and filling in bone voids at the arthrodesis site should be considered. Postoperatively, pain management with NSAIDs should be limited to a short period (<2 weeks) and avoided in high-risk patients. Furthermore, early postoperative weight-bearing has shown to be beneficial, and it does not seem to increase postoperative complications. The incidence of surrounding joint OA after foot and ankle fusion seems to increase progressively with time. Owing to its progression and high probability of being symptomatic, patients must be informed consequently, as they may require additional joint fusions, resulting in further loss of ankle/foot motion. In patients with symptomatic adjacent joint OA and unsatisfactory results after an ankle arthrodesis, conversion to total ankle arthroplasty (TAA) has become a potential option in managing these complex and challenging situations.

Two Orthogonal Nitinol Staples and Combined Nitinol Staple-Screw Constructs for a First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Arthrodesis: A Biomechanical Cadaver Study

BACKGROUND

End-stage hallux metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint arthritis is commonly treated with arthrodesis using stainless steel or titanium implants. These implants provide static compression that is maximal at the time of implant insertion. Alternatively, nitinol staples are capable of dynamic compression. They have most frequently been used for midfoot arthrodesis procedures. However, their biomechanical performance during hallux MTP arthrodesis has not been described.

METHODS

8 matched pairs of cadaveric feet (4 female, 4 male) were prepared for hallux MTP arthrodesis using cup and cone reamers. Cadaveric pairs were then instrumented with either (1) a transarticular lag screw and dorsal nitinol staple or (2) orthogonal nitinol staples placed dorsally and medially. Walking in a short leg cast for 6 weeks was simulated by applying 90-N forces at 3 Hz to the plantar proximal phalanx for up to 250 000 cycles. Failure was defined as catastrophic implant failure or plantar gapping beyond 7 mm.

RESULTS

15 of 16 specimens failed cyclic loading. All 8 specimens fixed with orthogonal staples failed at an average of 37 ± 81 cycles. 7 of 8 specimens fixed with a dorsal staple and crossed screw failed at 14 900 ± 39 000 cycles. Collectively, 5 specimens failed because of bone fracture (1 in orthogonal staples, 4 in staple-screw group) and 10 failed because of excessive gap formation (7 in orthogonal staples, 3 in staple-screw group). The number of cycles to failure was significantly lower (P = .0469) in the orthogonal staple constructs compared with the dorsal staple and crossed screw constructs.

CONCLUSION

The tested constructs permit significant motion at the first MTP fusion surface during simulated protected weightbearing. Although multiple in vivo factors should be considered when extrapolating results from this cadaveric study, this motion may result in clinical failure with early postoperative weightbearing protocols.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

We report the first biomechanical evaluation of hallux MTP arthrodesis using modern nitinol staples in 2 separate constructs.

First metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis/fusion: a systematic review of modern fixation techniques

Background

First metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis is commonly performed for symptomatic end-stage hallux rigidus. It has been postulated to produce good results in the literature. Various fixation techniques offer differences in union rates, complications and functional outcomes, stirring debates about which produces the best outcomes for patients. Therefore, this review aims to synthesise and compare the outcomes of modern fixation techniques used for first metatarsophalangeal joint (FMPJ) arthrodesis.

Methods

The electronic database searched were PubMed, CINAHL, Cochrane Library, and Google Scholar. The critical appraisal skills programme tool for cohort study was used. The interventions consisted of screw(s), plate(s), and staple(s). Studies comprising outdated fixation techniques such as suture, metallic wire, external fixation, Rush rods or Steinmann pins were excluded. Participants were adults over 18 years, undergoing FMPJ arthrodesis in the UK. Studies with the population consisting primarily of revision cases, patients with rheumatoid arthritis or diabetes were excluded.

Results

Seven UK studies included 277 feet and a 95.7% overall union rate at a mean union time of 83.5 days. Staples had the highest union rate of 98.2% at mean union time of 84 days, followed by plates (95.2%, 92 days), and finally screws (94.9%, 71 days). The overall complication incidence is 5.8%. All of the fixation techniques produced good functional outcomes postoperatively.

Conclusions

Whilst staple techniques showed the highest union rate, plating techniques are preferable over screws or staples for better results across several outcome measures, including reduced complication incidence, stability, early ambulation, and good functional outcome. The Manchester-Oxford Foot Questionnaire and EuroQol-5Dimensional are recommended as measurement tools to assess functional outcomes following FMPJ arthrodesis.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13047-022-00540-9.

Crossed Screw Fixation Versus Dorsal Plating for First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Arthrodesis: A Retrospective Cohort Study

Multiple fixation techniques for first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis have been described with an average fusion rate of 93.5%. This retrospective cohort study assesses the association between crossed screws (vs dorsal plating) and medical comorbidities and the outcome radiographic union. Bivariate tests of association and multivariable logistic regression were employed to assess differences across fixation type and outcomes. We identified 305 patients who underwent a first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis during the study period. Crossed screw fixation was used in 158 (51.8%) patients while dorsal plating (tubular or anatomic locking plate) was used in 147 (48.2%) patients. Dorsal plating was utilized more often in patients with rheumatoid arthritis (p = .019) and history of smoking (p = .044). At 12 weeks post-operatively there were no significant differences in fusion rates between the two groups (crossed screw group = 95.3% vs dorsal plate group (referent) = 93.5%, Adjusted odds ratio (AOR) 1.39, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.45-4.26). Not smoking was associated with a greater odds of fusion at 12 weeks (96.2% for nonsmokers vs 75.0% for smokers (referent), AOR 0.07, 95% CI 0.02-0.28). Lower body mass index was associated with a greater odds of fusion at 12 weeks (AOR 0.90, 95% CI 0.82-0.99). Surgeons allowed weightbearing earlier with dorsal plate fixation (2 weeks (interquartile range [IQR] 2.6) versus 5 weeks (IQR 2.6) for crossed screw fixation, p = .001). Patients with multiple medical comorbidities were more likely to require revision surgery than patients having 0-1 comorbidities (p < .05). Crossed screws can provide an inexpensive yet effective option for first metatarsophalangeal joint arthrodesis.