An Umbrella Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Systematic Reviews on the Topic of Foot and Ankle Arthrodesis Nonunion Rates

Beta-tricalcium phosphate combined with native bone proteins (β-TCP - NBP): a novel bone graft substitute for ankle and hindfoot arthrodesis

PURPOSE

The purpose of this prospective, multi-centre study was to assess the performance and safety of a combination of osteoconductive β-tricalcium phosphate and osteoinductive native bone proteins (β-TCP - NBP) used as alternative for autograft in ankle and hindfoot arthrodesis.

METHODS

Thirty-four patients enrolled underwent ankle or hindfoot arthrodesis with β-TCP - NBP and were evaluated radiographically, clinically, and functionally up to fifty-two weeks. The primary performance endpoint was fusion rate evaluated with CT at six months. Safety was assessed based on the severity and incidence of adverse events. Functional evaluation was performed using the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) ankle-hindfoot score and pain was recorded using the Visual Analogue Scale (VAS).

RESULTS

CT at 6 months showed that 85.3% had osseous bridging of the joint of ≥ 25%, 52.9% ≥50%, 8.8% <25% and 5.9% showed no bridging. The AOFAS score increased significantly from 60.4 ± 17.6 points at operation to 68.6 ± 17.2 points at six months and to 73.5 ± 17.7 points at 12 months. The group with fusion rate ≥25% showed significantly higher AOFAS score than that with fusion rate < 25% at 12 months. The mean VAS pain score at rest and during weight bearing decreased significantly (p < 0.0001) from operation to six and 12 months.

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrated that β-TCP - NBP is a valuable bone graft substitute for fusion of ankle and hindfoot due to debilitating osteoarthritis and offers an alternative for autograft.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level II.

Minimally Invasive Cartilage Resection of the Subtalar Joint: An Anatomical Study

Background

Subtalar arthrodesis is a commonly performed procedure for the treatment of posttraumatic or primary osteoarthritis and several hindfoot deformities. The primary objective of this study is to evaluate the efficacy and safety of a minimally invasive technique for cartilage removal of the subtalar joint using a modified sinus tarsi approach.

Methods

An anatomical study was performed on 8 pairs of fresh frozen cadaveric feet. A modified 2.5-cm sinus tarsi approach was used to access the subtalar joint. Cartilage removal was performed in 2 groups using either a 13-mm Shannon burr (GB) or a curette (GC) with subsequent systematic dissection. Standardized scaled photographs of the resected articular surfaces were analyzed in ImageJ software to quantify cartilage removal. Nearby vulnerable anatomical structures such as the intermediate and lateral dorsal cutaneous nerves, peroneal, tibialis posterior, flexor digitorum longus, and flexor hallucis longus tendons were assessed for injury.

Results

The area of completely removed cartilage in GC was median 79.7% talar and 76.6% calcaneal. In GB, median 67.8% of the talar cartilage and 76.8% of the calcaneal cartilage was removed. The overall mean of cartilage resection was 73% (±7.7). There was no statistically significant difference between the groups. Anatomical structures at risk were not inadvertently injured.

Conclusion

Subtalar cartilage resection can be performed safely using a minimally invasive modified sinus tarsi approach and either a Shannon burr or curettes. The amount of cartilage resection is less than that reported in the literature for open cartilage resection, but may be beneficial in select patient populations at increased risk for wound healing compromise and infection.

Level of Evidence

Level III, comparative cadaver study.

Nonunion in Foot and Ankle Arthrodesis Surgery: Review of Risk Factors, Identification of High-risk Patients, and a Guide to Perioperative Testing and Optimization

Foot and ankle arthrodesis surgery is often associated with high rates of nonunion ranging from 8% to 40%. This complication can result in individual patient burden and system burden in the management of these complex patients. Biologic factors contribute greatly to the development of a nonunion, including patient-related modifiable risk factors, metabolic and endocrine factors, systemic disease, previous surgeries, medications, weight loss treatments, and posttraumatic and postsurgical factors. Despite the high nonunion rate, there is a lack of high-level evidence in the identification of high-risk patients, strategies to minimize nonunion, and the management of patients with nonunion. An accepted standard of practice has not been established. This review aims to provide foot and ankle surgeons with (1) a comprehensive review of risk factors for nonunion, (2) a tool to identify high-risk patients using a preoperative patient questionnaire, (3) a clinical practice guide to preoperative and intraoperative testing that aims to improve preoperative counselling and patient optimization, and (4) perioperative strategies to minimize nonunion risk. With the above framework, our goal is to minimize nonunion risk in patients undergoing foot and ankle arthrodesis surgery to improve patient care and outcomes.

Takedown of Ankle Arthrodesis and Conversion to Total Ankle Arthroplasty: A Systematic Review

Management of the nonunited or painful ankle arthrodesis remains a difficult challenge. The aim of this systematic review was to investigate the clinical outcomes and complications of conversion of an ankle fusion to a total ankle replacement (TAR). The PRISMA statement guidelines were followed. A literature search was performed in PubMed, Science Direct and Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trails (CENTRAL) from their inception up to October 10th, 2023. The quality of the included studies was assessed using the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) Critical Appraisal tool and the Methodological Index for NonRandomized Studies (MINORS). Seven studies with 220 patients (223 ankles) with a mean follow-up of 64.9 months were included. Takedown of an ankle fusion and conversion to a TAR led to a significant improvement in all functional and clinical scores and with an acceptable range of motion. Most common complications were malleolar fractures (12.8%) and arthrofibrosis (5.6%). The revision rate was 8% and 4 cases resulted in a below-knee amputation. Cases with an insufficient fibula had a good outcome when a fibular reconstruction was performed. In conclusion, takedown of an ankle fusion and conversion to a TAR has satisfactory clinical outcomes and with a limited number of complications. Future well-designed studies are needed to validate the results of the present study.

Efficacy and safety of carbon fiber retrograde intramedullary nailing in tibio-talar-calcaneal fusion: a single-centre retrospective study

INTRODUCTION

Tibio-talar-calcaneal (TTC) fusion is a salvage procedure designated for treating various severe hindfoot pathologies. While traditional methods have been effective, the advantage of carbon fiber (CF) retrograde intramedullary nailing (RIMN) presents a potentially superior technique. This study evaluates the efficacy and safety of CF RIMN in TTC fusion, focusing on union rates, complication rates, and patient-reported outcomes.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Conducted as a single-center, retrospective study, this research involved 21 patients who underwent TTC with CF RIMN from 2015 to 2021. Patient selection excluded those with active infections or those needing significant bone allografts. Patient follow-up was conducted at multiple intervals postoperatively, with a minimum follow-up of 24 months, assessing for union complications and using tools like the VAS, SF12, and AOFAS for patient-reported outcomes.

RESULTS

The study observed a 90% union rate among patients. Complication rates included a 14% incidence of iatrogenic fractures to the anterior tibial cortex and 19% postoperative complications. Significant improvement was noted in VAS scores but not in SF12 and AOFAS scores. The use of 200 mm RIMN was identified as requiring careful consideration due to associated complications.

CONCLUSION

CF RIMN in TTC fusion demonstrates a high union rate with notable complications. The significant improvement in VAS scores indicates patient satisfaction, but the lack of statistical significance in SF12 and AOFAS scores warrants attention. The findings advocate for the cautious use of 200 mm RIMN and highlight the need for further research, suggesting prospective, multicenter studies to validate these findings and explore long-term outcomes.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

Results of Total Ankle Arthroplasty Versus Ankle Arthrodesis

No differences have been found between total ankle arthroplasty (TAA) and ankle arthrodesis (AA) with respect to patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs), although both interventions were shown to improve PROMs with respect to the preoperative situation. That is, both interventions (AA and TAA) were effective in improving preoperative symptoms. On the other hand, 2-year complication rates were higher after AA (27%) than after TAA (16%); however, infection rates were similar (4%). The published revision rate after AA is 16% versus 11% after TAA. In short, TAA and AA appear to offer the same PROMs, but TAA has a lower rate of complications (except for infection) and revisions.

Open vs Minimally Invasive Resection of the First Metatarsocuneiform Joint: An Anatomical Study

BACKGROUND

The modified Lapidus arthrodesis is a standard procedure to correct middle to severe hallux valgus (HV) deformities. Recently, minimally invasive techniques of first metatarsocuneiform joint (MCJ) resection using a Shannon burr were described. The primary goal of this study is to compare the anatomical efficacy and safety of first MCJ resection using a straight 2 × 13-mm Shannon burr and minimally invasive technique (MIS) vs an open technique using an oscillating saw.

METHODS

Ten pairs of fresh frozen cadaveric feet were randomly assigned to open or MIS first MCJ resection with subsequent systematic dissection. For the MIS procedure, a dorsomedial approach was used and for the open procedure a medioplantar approach was used. Cartilage removal was investigated by analyzing standardized scaled photographs of the resected articular surfaces with ImageJ software. Nearby structures at risk were analyzed for iatrogenic violation: tibialis anterior (TA), extensor hallucis longus (EHL) and peroneus longus (PL) tendons, and the Lisfranc ligament complex (LLC).

RESULTS

In the MIS group, the median cartilage resection was 85.9% at the cuneiform and 85.6% at the metatarsal bone compared to 100% cartilage resection in open technique (P < .01). Iatrogenic damage of the LLC, EHL, and TA tendons was not found in any group. The PL tendon was thinned out (<25% of tendon thickness) in 4 cases (40%) in the open group and in 1 case (10%) in the MIS group. A safe zone of 3.0 mm between the articular surface of the cuneiform bone and the LLC was identified, which can be resected without putting the LLC at risk when performing lateral-based wedge resections.

CONCLUSION

In this cadaver study with the procedures performed by an experienced foot and ankle surgeon, and using 2 different surgical approaches, we found general parity between the Shannon burr MIS technique vs oscillating saw open technique techniques with more risk to the PL with our open technique and approximately 15% less cartilage resection with our MIS technique.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level V, cadaver study.