Psychogenic Nonepileptic Seizures in Women

Psychogenic non-epileptic seizures with and without epilepsy: Exploring the influence of co-existing psychiatric disorders on clinical characteristics and outcomes

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Psychogenic non-epileptic seizures (PNES) are commonly associated with co-existing psychiatric disorders. The relationship between psychiatric factors and PNES episodes with and without epilepsy remains understudied. We reviewed co-existing psychiatric disorders in PNES-only, PNES with epilepsy aiming to examine whether these co-existing disorders associated with PNES clinical presentation and long-term outcomes.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective, longitudinal cohort study of patients with PNES diagnosed at our EMU from May 2000 to April 2008, with follow-up clinical data until September 2015. We categorized patients into three groups: PNES-only, PNES+ definite epilepsy, and PNES+ possible/probable epilepsy.

RESULTS

In total, 271 patients with PNES were identified: 194 had PNES-only, 30 had PNES+ possible or probable epilepsy, and 47 had PNES+ definite epilepsy. No significant differences were observed in the prevalence of depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), substance abuse, or suicidal thoughts among the three groups. Similarly, no differences in co-existing psychiatric disorders characteristics were discovered among patients grouped by various durations and frequencies of PNES episodes. At EMU admission, for PNES-only patients total of 130/194 patients (67%) were on ASMs, and 64/194 (32.9%) were not. PNES-only not on ASM were the most likely to report at least two of the three main psychiatric disorders (depression, anxiety, and PTSD; p = 0.01). At the final follow-up, 68/130 (52.3%) and 92/130 (70.8%) patients were able to discontinue or reduce their ASM intake, respectively, with no significant differences in co-existing psychiatric disorders among them (p < 0.001). Overall, 51.6% or 31.3% of patients reported reduced or resolved PNES episodes, respectively. Further, this reduction and resolution of PNES episode were not affected by any psychological variable.

CONCLUSIONS

Co-existing psychiatric disorders prevalence did not differ between patients with PNES-only and those with coexisting epilepsy. Further, co-existing psychiatric disorders characteristics did not reliably predict PNES episode duration, frequency, reduction, or resolution. For patients with PNES-only, the presence of co-existing psychiatric disorders did not predict the rate at which ASMs could be reduced or discontinued.

The neuropsychological presentation of women with epilepsy: clinical considerations and future directions

Objective: Cognitive, mood, and behavioral changes are common among persons with epilepsy (PWE), resulting in a complex neuropsychological presentation. Women with epilepsy (WWE) represent a distinct cohort within the broader epilepsy population due to sex and gender-specific factors impacting epilepsy semiology and treatment. However, unique neuropsychological profiles among WWE have not been established. This narrative review aims to further define neuropsychological correlates in WWE and promote meaningful discussion related to enhancing the provision of neuropsychological care within this clinical population. Method: Current literature in PWE examining differences in cognitive function, mental health, and quality of life (QoL) between women and men was critically reviewed, emphasizing considerations for neuropsychological practice. Results: WWE demonstrate a preservation of verbal learning and memory compared to men both pre- and post-surgically, with sex-based, neurobiological mechanisms likely contributing to this association. WWE also have elevated risk for affective disorder psychopathology, suicidality, and traumatic experiences. Epidemiology related to psychotic and bipolar spectrum disorders is less clear, and findings are mixed regarding sex-specific behavioral side effects of antiseizure and psychotropic medication. Finally, hormonal and obstetric factors are highlighted as important contributors to neuropsychological symptoms in WWE, with elevated risk for low QoL and increased stigma associated with greater medical and psychiatric comorbidities compared to men. Conclusions: While emerging literature has begun to characterize the neuropsychological presentation of WWE, future research is needed to define sex and gender differences in neuropsychological sequalae among PWE to ensure consistency and quality of care for WWE.

Life Stressors During Pregnancy in Women With Epilepsy: Results From the Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

To compare specific life stressors and domestic abuse that pregnant women and others with epilepsy (WWE) experience compared with pregnant women and others without epilepsy (WWoE).

METHODS

The Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System (PRAMS) is an annual weighted survey of randomly sampled postpartum women administered by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. We used data from the PRAMS from 2012 to 2020 in 13 states to assess the life stressors reported by WWE compared with WWoE. We adjusted the data for maternal age, race, ethnicity, marital status, education, and socioeconomic status (SES; using income, Women, Infants, and Children program [WIC], and Medicaid use). We also examined reported abuse in WWE compared with WWoE.

RESULTS

This study included data from 64,951 postpartum women, representing 4,072,189 women through weighted sampling. Of these, 1,140 reported having a diagnosis of epilepsy in the 3 months before their pregnancies (representing 81,021 WWE). WWE experienced a higher number of stressors compared with WWoE. WWE were more likely to have experienced 9 of the 14 stressors asked in the PRAMS questionnaire: severe illness of a close family member, separation or divorce, homelessness, loss of a partner's job, cut in work hours or pay, arguing more than usual with their partner, serving jail time, substance abuse problem in a close contact, and death of a close contact. After adjusting for demographics (age, race, and SES), epilepsy was still associated with a higher number of stressors in pregnant women. Other factors associated with stressors were younger age, Indigenous or mixed race, non-Hispanic ethnicity, lower income, and WIC or Medicaid use. Those who were married were less likely to report stressors. WWE were also more likely to report abuse before or during their pregnancies.

DISCUSSION

Although managing stress is important in both epilepsy and pregnancy, WWE experience more stressors than do WWoE. After adjusting for maternal age, race, and SES, this increase in stressors persisted. Women who were younger, with lower income, on WIC or Medicaid, or not married were also more likely to experience life stressors. Alarmingly, reported abuse was also higher in WWE compared with WWoE. Attention from clinicians and support services for WWE are needed to optimize good pregnancy outcomes.

The neurobiology of functional neurological disorders characterised by impaired awareness

We review the neurobiology of Functional Neurological Disorders (FND), i.e., neurological disorders not explained by currently identifiable histopathological processes, in order to focus on those characterised by impaired awareness (functionally impaired awareness disorders, FIAD), and especially, on the paradigmatic case of Resignation Syndrome (RS). We thus provide an improved more integrated theory of FIAD, able to guide both research priorities and the diagnostic formulation of FIAD. We systematically address the diverse spectrum of clinical presentations of FND with impaired awareness, and offer a new framework for understanding FIAD. We find that unraveling the historical development of neurobiological theory of FIAD is of paramount importance for its current understanding. Then, we integrate contemporary clinical material in order to contextualise the neurobiology of FIAD within social, cultural, and psychological perspectives. We thus review neuro-computational insights in FND in general, to arrive at a more coherent account of FIAD. FIAD may be based on maladaptive predictive coding, shaped by stress, attention, uncertainty, and, ultimately, neurally encoded beliefs and their updates. We also critically appraise arguments in support of and against such Bayesian models. Finally, we discuss implications of our theoretical account and provide pointers towards an improved clinical diagnostic formulation of FIAD. We suggest directions for future research towards a more unified theory on which future interventions and management strategies could be based, as effective treatments and clinical trial evidence remain limited.

Characterizing differences in psychiatric profiles between male and female veterans with epilepsy and psychogenic non-epileptic seizures

OBJECTIVE

While previous studies have described psychiatric profiles in patients with psychogenic non-epileptic seizures (PNES) and epileptic seizures (ES), a well-matched comparison between males and females has been lacking. To address this shortcoming, the present study sought to explore sex differences between male and female Veterans with ES and PNES in terms of psychiatric diagnoses, trauma histories, and psychiatric treatment.

METHODS

A male Veteran sample (PNES n = 87, ES n = 28) was identified matching age and seizure diagnosis with our previously-gathered female Veteran sample (PNES n = 90, ES n = 28). Retrospective chart review was used to obtain demographic, psychiatric, and seizure-related variables. Group differences between PNES and ES were first assessed among males followed by differences between males and females.

RESULTS

Males with PNES were more likely to receive psychiatric treatment (82.6 % vs. 60.7 %, p = 0.017), be prescribed more psychotropics (1.6 vs. 0.9, p = 0.003), and more likely to have childhood physical abuse (27.9 % vs. 3.6 %, p = 0.007) than those with ES. Compared to PNES, males with ES presented to the epilepsy monitoring unit (EMU) significantly later (12.8 years vs. 6.1 years, p = 0.009), and were prescribed more anti-seizure medications (ASMs) previously (2.1 vs. 0.8, p = 0.009) and currently (1.6 vs. 1.0, p = 0.001). Between males and females with PNES, females evidenced more depression (76.7 % vs. 26.3 %, p < 0.001), borderline personality disorder (18.9 % vs. 4.7 %, p = 0.004), suicidality (65.6 % vs. 33.7 %, p < 0.001), and childhood sexual abuse (37.8 % vs. 11.6 %, p < 0.001), while males had higher rates of substance use disorders (37.2 % vs. 8.9 %, p < 0.001).

SIGNIFICANCE

A greater psychiatric burden is seen among females compared to males with PNES, especially diagnoses of borderline personality disorder and depression. Higher rates of suicidality and inpatient psychiatric hospitalization may warrant particular consideration in screening and intervention efforts among female Veterans with PNES.

Quality of Life in Psychogenic Nonepileptic Seizures: An Evolutionary Concept Analysis

Psychogenic nonepileptic seizures (PNES) pose a serious threat to quality of life (QOL) in patients who battle the disorder. As psychological treatment options have progressed, improvement in QOL has become a more common desired outcome. Despite its relevance in PNES research and treatment, QOL has not been defined in the PNES population. Rodgers' Evolutionary Method of concept analysis was used to analyze 47 articles and clarify the concept of QOL in PNES. QOL in PNES is subjective, multidimensional, associated with symptoms, and dynamic in nature. This conceptualization of QOL in PNES may be useful in future PNES research and treatment.

Promoting gender-informed mentorship in neuropsychology: Reflections and suggestions from early career women

INTRODUCTION

While women now represent a majority of neuropsychology trainees, men remain prominent in senior positions. As such, female mentees are often paired with senior male mentors, a practice referred to as "cross-gender mentorship." Although cross-gender mentoring dynamics have inherent potential for missteps due to implicit power differentials, when approached through a gender-informed lens, they can be optimized and lead to personal and professional growth for women neuropsychologists. The present article provides a framework for promoting gender-informed mentorship by cataloging first-hand accounts of early career women and discussing resultant lessons and concrete suggestions for mentorship.

METHOD

The authors provide first-hand accounts of experiences related to cross-gender mentorship across a variety of settings and professional contexts. From these accounts, the following steps offer a framework to encourage effective mentorship: 1) Set appropriate expectations and boundaries, 2) Address challenging clinical interactions through a gender-informed lens, 3) Foster personal and professional development, 4) Understand the intersection between gender and multicultural traits, 5) Advocate for advancement of women in the field, and 6) Maintain knowledge of women's issues.

CONCLUSIONS

Providing effective mentorship for women in neuropsychology is crucial to promote ascension of women to leadership positions and close long-established disparities in the field. The authors hope that our shared experiences can serve as useful tools for both women trainees and their mentors as they embark on mentoring relationships. Practically, we envision that mentoring dyads may discuss this article at the outset of their relationship to understand potential challenges and collaboratively establish a groundwork for optimal mentoring.

Characterizing women veterans receiving seizure care in the veterans affairs healthcare system

OBJECTIVE

The number and proportion of women served by the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) is rapidly expanding, necessitating better characterization of factors unique to this population. While nascent literature has begun to better characterize women within the broader seizure population, women Veterans remain an understudied sample. To expand our clinical understanding of women with seizures, we assessed demographic and clinical characteristics, as well as psychiatric/military histories in women receiving care from an Epilepsy Center of Excellence within the VA Healthcare System.

METHODS

The sample included 90 women with psychogenic nonepileptic seizures (PNES) and 28 women with epileptic seizures (ES) as the final diagnosis after epilepsy monitoring at a large VA medical center between 2010 and 2020. Retrospective chart review gathered demographics, including age, marital status, and work status; clinical characteristics, including history of traumatic brain injury (TBI) or migraines, gynecological history, and use of anti-seizure medications (ASM); psychiatric information, including trauma history, psychiatric diagnoses, and treatment; and military history related to service or service connection. Group differences were assessed between women with PNES and ES.

RESULTS

The ES group was significantly older than the PNES group (47.8 v. 41.9 years, p = 0.02) and had a non-significantly longer diagnosis duration (12.3 vs. 8.6 years, p = 0.17). Clinically, the PNES group had a significantly higher rate of migraines (76.7% v. 57.1%, p = 0.04) and hysterectomy (40% v. 17.9%, p = 0.03). Many psychiatric factors differentiated the two groups, with significantly higher rates of psychotropic medication use (86.7% v. 60.7%, p = 0.002), psychiatric hospitalization (42.2% v. 21.4%, p = 0.047), and suicide attempts (42.2% v. 14.3%, p = 0.005), alongside trends toward higher rates of military sexual trauma (47.8% vs. 28.6%, p = 0.07) and childhood sexual trauma (37.8% vs. 17.9%, p = 0.05) among those with PNES.

SIGNIFICANCE

This is the largest study to date characterizing women veterans with seizures seeking comprehensive seizure care and provides an update to previously published information on Veteran samples with seizures. Several characteristics differ between women Veterans with PNES and ES, spanning demographic, clinical, and psychiatric factors. Understanding the unique profile of women Veterans with epilepsy seeking care through the VA system is a crucial step in providing optimal care, including making informed diagnosis and providing appropriate treatment.

[Psychogenic non-epileptic seizures]

The review provides epidemiological data and discuss the associated burden of non-epileptic seizures (PNES). Data on the prevalence, socio-demographic and clinical risk factors for the development of PNES are presented. The hypotheses of the PNES origin, including the contribution of psychological trauma, are considered. We also describe contemporary methods for differential diagnosis of epileptic seizures and PNES, including biomarkers and the use of diagnostic questionnaires. Special attention is given to the issues of the psychiatric comorbidity of PNES.

Recognition of Psychogenic Versus Epileptic Seizures Based on Videos

OBJECTIVE

Ictal semiology interpretation for differentiating psychogenic nonepileptic seizures (PNESs) and epileptic seizures (ESs) is important for the institution of appropriate treatment. Our objective was to assess the ability of different health care professionals (HCPs) or students to distinguish PNES from ES based on video-recorded seizure semiology.

METHODS

This study was designed following the Standards for Reporting of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies (STARD) guidelines. We showed in a random mix 36 videos of PNES or ES (18 each) and asked 558 participants to classify each seizure. The diagnostic accuracy of various groups of HCPs or students for PNES versus ES was assessed, as well as the effect of patient age and sex. Measures of diagnostic accuracy included sensitivity, specificity, and area under the curve (AUC).

RESULTS

The descending order of diagnostic accuracy (AUC) was the following (p ≤ 0.001): (1) neurologists and epileptologists; (2) neurology residents; (3) other specialists and nurses with experience in epilepsy; and (4) undergraduate medical students. Although there was a strong trend toward statistical difference, with AUC 95% confidence intervals (CIs) that were not overlapping, between epileptologists (95% CI 93, 97) compared to neurologists (95% CI 88, 91), and neurologists compared to electroencephalography technicians (95% CI 82, 87), multiple pairwise comparisons with the conservative Tukey-Kramer honest significant difference test revealed no statistical difference (p = 0.25 and 0.1, respectively). Patient age and sex did not have an effect on diagnostic accuracy in neurology specialists.

CONCLUSION

Visual recognition of PNES by HCPs or students varies overall proportionately with the level of expertise in the field of neurology/epilepsy.

Relationship between neural responses to stress and mental health symptoms in psychogenic nonepileptic seizures after traumatic brain injury

OBJECTIVE

To utilize traumatic brain injury (TBI) as a model for investigating functioning during acute stress experiences in psychogenic nonepileptic seizures (PNES) and to identify neural mechanisms underlying the link between changes in processing of stressful experiences and mental health symptoms in PNES.

METHODS

We recruited 94 participants: 50 with TBI only (TBI-only) and 44 with TBI and PNES (TBI + PNES). Participants completed mood (Beck Depression Inventory-II), anxiety (Beck Anxiety Inventory), and posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptom (PTSD Checklist-Specific Event) assessments before undergoing functional magnetic resonance imaging during an acute psychosocial stress task. Linear mixed-effects analyses identified clusters of significant interactions between group and neural responses to stressful math performance and stressful auditory feedback conditions within limbic brain regions (volume-corrected α = .05). Spearman rank correlation tests compared mean cluster signals to symptom assessments (false discovery rate-corrected α = .05).

RESULTS

Demographic and TBI-related measures were similar between groups; TBI + PNES demonstrated worse clinical symptom severity compared to TBI-only. Stressful math performance induced relatively greater reactivity within dorsomedial prefrontal cortex (PFC) and right hippocampal regions and relatively reduced reactivity within left hippocampal and dorsolateral PFC regions for TBI + PNES compared to TBI-only. Stressful auditory feedback induced relatively reduced reactivity within ventral PFC, cingulate, hippocampal, and amygdala regions for TBI + PNES compared to TBI-only. Changes in responses to stressful math within hippocampal and dorsal PFC regions were correlated with increased mood, anxiety, and PTSD symptom severity.

SIGNIFICANCE

Corticolimbic functions underlying processing of stressful experiences differ between patients with TBI + PNES and those with TBI-only. Relationships between these neural responses and symptom assessments suggest potential pathophysiologic mechanisms in PNES.

Sex Effects on Coping, Dissociation, and PTSD in Patients With Non-epileptic Seizures

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Sex differences in non-epileptic seizures (NES) are of interest, as the diagnosis is more frequent in women than men (3:1 ratio). This paper reviews clinical findings regarding sex differences in NES through selective literature review and compares coping measures between women and men in our NES clinic.

RECENT FINDINGS

Some distinguishing clinical features of NES in women and men are reported in the literature. However, we found few sex differences in demographics and coping. In our population, avoidance and dissociation were strongly related to one another and significantly related to co-occurring PTSD diagnosis, which was seen in over 50% in both sexes. Our findings confirm a high prevalence of PTSD in patients with NES, suggesting that comorbid PTSD may override sex differences in accounting for use of avoidant and dissociative coping. These findings raise the possibility that NES may, at times, represent an extreme variant in dysfunctional coping in patients with PTSD.

Heart Rate Variability Parameters During Psychogenic Non-epileptic Seizures: Comparison Between Patients With Pure PNES and Comorbid Epilepsy

Introduction: Psychogenic non-epileptic seizures (PNES) may resemble epileptic seizures. There are few data about ictal ANS activity alterations induced by PNES in patients with pure PNES (pPNES) compared to PNES with comorbid epilepsy (PNES/ES). We aimed to compare heart rate variability (HRV) parameters and hence autonomic regulation in PNES in epileptic and non-epileptic patients.

Methods: We obtained HRV data from video-electroencephalography recordings in 22 patients presenting PNES (11 pPNES and 11 PNES/ES) in awake, and supine states. We calculated HRV parameters in both time and frequency domains including low frequency (LF) power, high frequency power (HF), LF/HF ratio, square root of the mean of the sum of the squares of differences between adjacent R wave intervals (RMSSD) and the standard deviation of all consecutive R wave intervals (SDNN). We also evaluated approximate entropy (ApEn), cardiosympathetic index (CSI), and cardiovagal index (CVI). Four conditions were considered: basal condition (BAS), before PNES (PRE), during PNES (ICT) and after PNES (POST).

Results: HRV analysis showed significantly higher ICT LF and LF/HF ratio vs. each condition. We also found higher POST HF vs. PRE and BAS, lower RRI in ICT vs. each condition and PRE vs. BAS. POST RMSSD was significantly higher compared to all other states. ICT CSI was significantly higher compared to all other states, whereas CSI was significantly lower in POST vs. PRE and PRE CVI lower than ICT and higher in POST vs. BAS and PRE. Also, ICT ApEn was lower than in all other states. Higher LF in pPNES vs. PNES/ES was also evident when compared across groups.

Significance: A few studies examined HRV alterations in PNES, reporting high sympathetic tone (although less evident than in epileptic seizures). Our data suggest a sympathetic overdrive before and during PNES followed by a post-PNES increase in vagal tone. A sympathovagal imbalance was more evident in pPNES as compared to PNES/ES.

Clinical characteristics of psychogenic nonepileptic seizures across the lifespan: An international retrospective study

PURPOSE

Previous studies from a few countries have reported semiological differences in younger children compared with adolescents or adults with psychogenic nonepileptic seizures (PNESs). This study tested the hypothesis that semiological, demographic, and historical risk factors vary with different ages of PNES onset in a large cohort from different countries.

METHODS

In this retrospective study, we investigated patients consecutively referred for PNES, who were admitted to epilepsy monitoring units in Iran, Brazil, Venezuela, Canada, Argentina, and USA. Age, gender, age at seizure onset, seizure semiology, and factors predisposing to PNES (abuse, stressors) were documented according to routine diagnostic practices at each center. Participants were grouped according to their age at onset (i.e., childhood, adolescence, or adulthood).

RESULTS

A total of 448 patients were studied. Female predominance was associated with adolescent- (85/122, 70%) and adult-onset (190/270, 70%) but not in childhood-onset PNES (28/56, 50%) (p = 0.011). Event frequency in the month preceding the diagnosis was higher in the childhood- [x¯ = 50, standard deviation (sd) = 82, p = 0.025] versus adolescent- (x¯ = 24, sd = 36) or adult-onset groups (x¯ = 29, sd = 61). Significant between-group differences were observed for generalized body movements (p = 0.0001) and ictal injury (p = 0.027), suggesting more severe ictal presentations in adult-onset PNES compared with younger ages. Adult-onset patients were also more likely to be taking an unnecessary antiepileptic medication (p = 0.010).

CONCLUSION

While PNES may present at any age, there appear to be notable differences across the lifespan with respect to some of the clinical characteristics. Further international and cross-cultural studies may reveal other interesting characteristics of PNES.

Pins and PNES: Systematic content analysis of Pinterest for information on psychogenic nonepileptic seizures (PNES)

Pinterest is a visual search based, the fourth largest social networking site in the U.S. with 81% of its users being women. Because of Pinterest's popularity and the high incidence of psychogenic nonepileptic seizures (PNES) among women, the aim of our current study was to perform a thorough content analysis of information available about PNES on Pinterest. The systematic search of Pinterest using various PNES related keywords revealed 57 unique pins. This was followed by content analysis by two independent reviewers. Most (87.7%) pins included in the final analysis reported at least one factor indicative of PNES. Most common were the consistent association of PNES with emotional triggers (61.4%), history of current or remote abuse (57.9%), and seizure's unresponsiveness to antiepileptic drugs (38.6%). Semiology of PNES was reported in 77.2% pins and two-thirds (66.6%) mentioned diagnostic procedures. Psychogenic nonepileptic seizure treatment and prognosis were reported in 68.4% and 56.1% pins, respectively. Around one-third of pins were from academic resources. More than 80% of pins targeted lay people with the primary aim of education and awareness and used a neutral or positive tone. To our knowledge, even though most pins have scientifically sound information, this widely popular web-based resource seems to be underutilized by academia, healthcare workers, and stakeholders for the dissemination of awareness about PNES.