The Natural History of Facial Schwannomas: A Meta-Analysis of Case Series

[Analysis of the outcome of 12 cases of facial nerve tumors]

Objective:This study aims to provide a comprehensive summary of the pathogenesis, screening modalities, treatment strategies, repair modalities and preliminary results associated with facial nerve tumors. Methods:A retrospective analysis was conducted on the clinical data of 12 patients with facial nerve tumors who were admitted to our department between May 2018 and February 2023. The study population consisted of 5 males and 7 females, with ages ranging from 35 to 90 years. Clinical symptoms observed in these patients included facial nerve palsy, hearing loss, tinnitus, headache, and otalgia, etc. The severity of facial nerve dysfunction was assessed using the House-Brackmann（H-B） facial nerve function classification, with 3 cases classified as grade Ⅰ, 4 cases as grade Ⅲ, 2 cases as grade Ⅳ, and 3 cases as grade Ⅴ. There was a total of 11 patients who presented with hearing loss. Among these patients, 7 cases were diagnosed with conductive hearing loss, 2 cases with sensorineural hearing loss, and 2 cases with mixed hearing loss. The selection of the observation or surgical route for tumor localization was based on clinical symptoms, facial nerve function grading, and imaging examination results including temporal bone CT and enhanced MRI. Specifically, the location of the tumor was selected for observation or the best surgical route: 2 cases were followed up for observation, 1 case underwent biopsy, and 9 cases underwent tumor resection（7 cases of trans-mastoid approach, 2 cases of combined parotid-mastoidal approach）, concurrent repair of the facial nerve（4 cases of auricular nerve grafting, 3 cases of facial nerve diversion anastomosis, 2 cases of peroneal nerve grafting）. （4 cases of auricular nerve graft, 3 cases of facial nerve diversion anastomosis and 2 cases of peroneal nerve grafting）. Periodic postoperative evaluation of facial nerve function was conducted. Results:1-year follow-up was available. Intraoperatively, it was observed that 66.7%（6 out of 9） of the facial nerve tumors were present in multiple segments. Among these segments, the vertical segment had the highest proportion, accounting for 77.8%（7 out of 9）, followed by the labyrinthine segment/geniculate ganglion with 66.7%（6 out of 9） and the horizontal segment with 55.6%（5 out of 9）. Postoperative pathology confirmed 8 cases with nerve sheath meningioma, Ⅰ with seminal fibroma and 1 with hemangioma. Postoperative facial nerve function was graded as H-B grade I in one patient）, grade Ⅲ in three, grade Ⅳ in four, grade Ⅴ in 2, and grade Ⅵ in 2 patients. The auditory outcomes following surgery are as follows: 8 individuals experienced postoperative hearing loss, while 2 individuals demonstrated postoperative hearing preservation. Conclusion:In the case of patients presenting with facial nerve palsy as their initial symptom, it is imperative to consider the potential presence of a facial nerve tumor. To determine the appropriate course of action, it is necessary to ascertain the size and location of the tumors through imaging examinations. This information will aid in the decision making process regarding whether surgical intervention is warranted, and so, the most suitable approach. Additionally, the choice of repair method during the operation should be guided by the extent of facial nerve defect.

Extracranial Facial Nerve Schwannoma-Histological Surprise or Therapeutic Planning?

Schwannomas (neurilemomas) are benign, slow-growing, encapsulated, white, yellow, or pink tumors originating in Schwann cells in the sheaths of cranial nerves or myelinated peripheral nerves. Facial nerve schwannomas (FNS) can form anywhere along the course of the nerve, from the pontocerebellar angle to the terminal branches of the facial nerve. In this article, we propose a review of the specialized literature regarding the diagnostic and therapeutic management of schwannomas of the extracranial segment of the facial nerve, also presenting our experience in this type of rare neurogenic tumor. The clinical exam reveals pretragial swelling or retromandibular swelling, the extrinsic compression of the lateral oropharyngeal wall like a parapharyngeal tumor. The function of the facial nerve is generally preserved due to the eccentric growth of the tumor pushing on the nerve fibers, and the incidence of peripheral facial paralysis in FNSs is described in 20-27% of cases. Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) examination is the gold standard and describes a mass with iso signal to muscle on T1 and hyper signal to muscle on T2 and a characteristic "darts sign." The most practical differential diagnoses are pleomorphic adenoma of the parotid gland and glossopharyngeal schwannoma. The surgical approach to FNSs requires an experienced surgeon, and radical ablation by extracapsular dissection with preservation of the facial nerve is the gold standard for the cure. The patient's informed consent is important regarding the diagnosis of schwannoma and the possibility of facial nerve resection with reconstruction. Frozen section intraoperative examination is necessary to rule out malignancy or when sectioning of the facial nerve fibers is necessary. Alternative therapeutic strategies are imaging monitoring or stereotactic radiosurgery. The main factors which are considered during the management are the extension of the tumor, the presence or not of facial palsy, the experience of the surgeon, and the patient's options.

Transient profound hearing loss and severe facial nerve palsy in schwannomas within the internal acoustic canal: A case report

Vestibular schwannoma is the most common intracranial schwannoma and constitutes ~8% of all intracranial tumors in adults with an estimated incidence rate of ~1.3/100.000. Facial nerve schwannomas and cochlear nerve schwannomas are rare, and information regarding incidence rates of these is still missing in the literature. All three variants of nerve origin present most frequently with unilateral hearing loss, unilateral tinnitus and disequilibrium. Facial nerve palsy is a common finding in facial nerve schwannomas but a rare finding with vestibular schwannomas. The symptoms are normally persistent and often progress over time, leading to therapeutic interventions that predispose to quality of life-reducing morbidities, e.g., deafness and/or imbalance. The case report describes a 17-year-old male who, during a 1-month period, presented with profound unilateral hearing loss and severe facial nerve palsy followed by complete remission. An MRI scan showed a 5×8-mm schwannoma within the internal acoustic canal. Profound hearing loss together with concomitant severe peripheral facial nerve palsy in small schwannomas within the internal acoustic canal may show spontaneous and total remission within weeks of symptom debut. This knowledge, as well as possible remission of objective findings, should be considered before interventions with potential severe morbidity are suggested.

Features of postoperative hearing function changes in patients with cerebellopontine angle and intratemporal tumors other than vestibular schwannomas

OBJECTIVE

Tumors around the cerebellopontine angle (CPA) and temporal bone can potentially affect hearing function. In patients with such tumors other than vestibular schwannomas (VSs), auditory tests were investigated before and after surgery to characterize the auditory effect of each tumor and to determine prognostic factors.

METHODS

A total of 378 patients were retrospectively evaluated for hearing functions before and after surgery. These 378 patients included 168 with CPA meningioma, 40 with trigeminal schwannoma (TS), 55 with facial nerve schwannoma (FNS), 64 with jugular foramen schwannoma (JFS), and 51 with CPA epidermoid cyst (EPD).

RESULTS

Preoperative hearing loss was observed in 124 (33%) of the 378 patients. Of these 124 patients, 38 (31%) experienced postoperative hearing improvement. Postoperative hearing deterioration occurred in 67 (18%) of the 378 patients. The prognostic factors for postoperative hearing improvement were younger age and the retrocochlear type of preoperative hearing disturbance. Tumor extension into the internal auditory canal was correlated with preoperative hearing loss and postoperative hearing deterioration. Preoperative hearing loss was observed in patients with FNS (51%), JFS (42%), and MGM (37%), and postoperative hearing improvement was observed in patients with JFS (41%), MGM (31%), and FNS (21%). Postoperative hearing deterioration was observed in patients with FNS (27%), MGM (23%), and EPD (16%).

CONCLUSIONS

According to the results of this study in patients with CPA and intratemporal tumors other than VS, preoperative retrocochlear hearing disturbance was found to be a prognostic factor for hearing improvement after surgery. Among the tumor types, JFS and MGM had a particularly favorable hearing prognosis. The translabyrinthine approach and cochlear nerve section should be avoided for these tumors, regardless of the patient's preoperative hearing level.

Intracapsular Enucleation of Intraparotid Facial Nerve Schwannoma with Intratemporal Extension

Intraparotid facial nerve schwannoma is a rare condition, which is difficult to preoperatively diagnose without a definite biopsy, yet the diagnosis is important for surgical planning and avoiding accidental injury to the facial nerve. Considering the benign indolent nature of the schwannomas, the management should be prioritized on the long-term tumor control with special attention to the facial nerve function and facial cosmesis. Microscope-assisted intracapsular enucleation is an excellent treatment option for such lesions. Our patient showed House–Brackmann grade II facial function after the surgery. This technique is safe and offers a favorable outcome of facial nerve function.

Management of non-vestibular schwannomas in adult patients: a systematic review and consensus statement on behalf of the EANS skull base section Part II: Trigeminal and facial nerve schwannomas (CN V, VII)

BACKGROUND

Non-vestibular schwannomas are relatively rare, with trigeminal and jugular foramen schwannomas being the most common. This is a heterogenous group which requires detailed investigation and careful consideration to management strategy. The optimal management for these tumours remains unclear and there are several controversies. The aim of this paper is to provide insight into the main principles defining management and surgical strategy, in order to formulate a series of recommendations.

METHODS

A task force was created by the EANS skull base section committee along with its members and other renowned experts in the field to generate recommendations for the surgical management of these tumours on a European perspective. To achieve this, the task force performed an extensive systematic review in this field and had discussions within the group. This article is the second of a three-part series describing non-vestibular schwannomas (V, VII).

RESULTS

A summary of literature evidence was proposed after discussion within the EANS skull base section. The constituted task force dealt with the practice patterns that exist with respect to pre-operative radiological investigations, ophthalmological assessments, optimal surgical and radiotherapy strategies, and follow-up management.

CONCLUSION

This article represents the consensually derived opinion of the task force with respect to the treatment of trigeminal and facial schwannoma. The aim of treatment is maximal safe resection with preservation of function. Careful thought is required to select the appropriate surgical approach. Most middle fossa trigeminal schwannoma tumours can be safely accessed by a subtemporal extradural middle fossa approach. The treatment of facial nerve schwannoma remains controversial.

Less common extracerebral tumors

This chapter examines the results of GKNS on a variety of extraparenchymal skull base tumors some benign and some malignant. For the benign tumors there is good evidence on the effectiveness of the method for pretty much all diagnoses. For malignant extraparenchymal tumors the results are more limited and GKNS only has a supportive role in these lesions.

Surgery versus radiosurgery for facial nerve schwannoma: a systematic review and meta-analysis of facial nerve function, postoperative complications, and progression

OBJECTIVE

Intracranial facial nerve schwannomas (FNS) requiring treatment are frequently recommended for surgery or stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS). The objective of this study was to compare facial nerve function outcomes between these two interventions for FNS via a systematic review and meta-analysis.

METHODS

A search of the Ovid EMBASE, PubMed, SCOPUS, and Cochrane databases from inception to July 2019 was conducted following PRISMA guidelines. Articles were screened against prespecified criteria. Facial nerve outcomes were classified as improved, stabilized, or worsened by last follow-up. Incidence was pooled by random-effects meta-analysis of proportions.

RESULTS

Thirty-three articles with a pooled cohort of 519 patients with FNS satisfied all criteria. Twenty-five articles described operative outcomes in 407 (78%) patients; 10 articles reported SRS outcomes in 112 (22%). In the surgical cohort, facial nerve function improved in 23% (95% CI 15%-32%), stabilized in 41% (95% CI 32%-50%), and worsened in 30% (95% CI 21%-40%). In the SRS cohort, facial nerve function was improved in 20% (95% CI 9%-34%), stable in 66% (95% CI 54%-78%), and worsened in 9% (95% CI 3%-16%). Compared with SRS, microsurgery was associated with a significantly lower incidence of stable facial nerve function (p < 0.01) and a significantly higher incidence of worsened facial nerve function (p < 0.01). Tumor progression and complication rates were comparable. Outcome certainty assessments were very low to moderate for all parameters.

CONCLUSIONS

Unfavorable facial nerve function outcomes are associated with surgical treatment of intracranial FNS, whereas stable facial nerve function outcomes are associated with SRS. Therefore, SRS should be recommended to patients with FNS who require treatment, and surgery should be reserved for patients with another indication, such as decompression of the brainstem. Further study is required to definitively optimize and validate management strategies for these rare skull base tumors.

Facial Nerve Canal Paraganglioma

We report the case of a 72-year-old woman presenting with a progressive left peripheral facial paralysis and a facial canal mass extending through the stylomastoid foramen along the posterior edge of the parotid gland. On MRI, the early and intense enhancement was highly suggestive of paraganglioma but could not rule out a nonossifying hemangioma. Laboratory analysis showed normal plasma metanephrines. On F-FDOPA PET/CT, the mass exhibited a typical paraganglioma feature with a marked tumor uptake. Our case demonstrates that F-FDOPA plays a vital role in this rare entity and can avoid any further confirmatory invasive procedure.

Long-term results of Gamma Knife radiosurgery for facial nerve schwannomas

OBJECTIVE

Long-term outcomes of eleven cases of facial nerve schwannoma were evaluated and the related literature was reviewed to determine the efficacy of Gamma Knife radiosurgery for treating patients with facial nerve schwannoma.

METHODS

Eleven patients with facial nerve schwannoma (7 women and 4 men; mean age, 44.2 years; range, 19-73 years) underwent Gamma Knife radiosurgery. The most common symptoms were facial palsy (n = 10) and hearing loss (n = 7). Five patients presented with headache. Two patients had undergone prior resection. The patients' clinical and radiographic data were evaluated retrospectively.

RESULTS

For the 11 cases of facial nerve schwannoma, mean tumor volume was 3.1 cm³ (range, 0.4-7.4 cm³) and the mean marginal dose applied was 11.9 Gy (range, 11-13 Gy). The mean follow-up period was 84.3 months (range, 66-117 months). Tumor control was achieved in all patients. At the time of writing, four patients experienced tumor volume regression and the other seven were in stable condition. During follow-up, nine patients experienced no change in their facial function, two experienced deteriorated facial function, and none developed new facial palsy. Ten patients who had serviceable hearing prior to Gamma Knife radiosurgery retained their hearing.

CONCLUSIONS

Gamma Knife radiosurgery achieves excellent results with respect to tumor control for 7 years on average. In addition, Gamma Knife radiosurgery provides good results in facial nerve and hearing function at long term. Our series demonstrates that Gamma Knife radiosurgery is an effective and safe treatment for patients with either primary or residual facial nerve schwannoma.

Facial Schwannoma Management Outcomes: A Systematic Review of the Literature

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate facial nerve outcomes of various management strategies for facial schwannomas by assimilating individualized patient data from the literature to address controversies in management.

DATA SOURCES

PubMed-National Center for Biotechnology Information and Scopus databases.

REVIEW METHODS

A systematic review of the literature was performed for studies regarding facial schwannomas. Studies were included if they presented patient-level data, type of intervention, pre- and postintervention House-Brackmann (HB) grades, and tumor location by facial nerve segment.

RESULTS

Individualized data from 487 patients were collected from 31 studies. Eighty (16.4%) facial schwannomas were managed with observation, 25 (5.1%) with surgical decompression, 20 (4.1%) with stereotactic radiosurgery, 225 (46.2%) with total resection, and 137 (28.1%) with subtotal resection/stripping surgery. Stripping surgery/subtotal resection with good preoperative facial nerve function maintained HB grade 1 or 2 in 96% of cases. With a total resection of intradural tumors, preoperative HB grade did not significantly affect facial nerve outcome (n = 45, P = .46). However, a lower preoperative HB grade was associated with a better facial nerve outcome with intratemporal tumors (n = 56, P = .009). When stereotactic radiosurgery was performed, 40% of patients had improved, 35% were stable, and 25% had worsened facial function. Facial nerve decompression rarely affected short-term facial nerve status.

CONCLUSION

The data from this study help delineate which treatment strategies are best in which clinical scenarios. The findings can be used to develop a more definitive management algorithm for this complicated pathology.

Facial Nerve Schwannoma Complicated by Acute Hemorrhage After Treatment with Stereotactic Radiosurgery

BACKGROUND

Facial nerve schwannomas (FNSs) are rare benign tumors that arise from Schwann cells of the facial nerve. FNSs are similar to vestibular schwannomas in many aspects, yet their infiltrative nature into the facial nerve fascicles warrants a more conservative management approach. In the last decade, stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) has shown promise in stabilizing or shrinking FNSs.

CASE DESCRIPTION

A 71-year-old woman presented with mild facial paresis. Tumor growth after a period of watchful waiting warranted treatment with SRS, which was complicated by an acute posterior fossa hemorrhage and brainstem compression, necessitating microsurgical hematoma evacuation, tumor resection, and facial nerve substitution.

CONCLUSIONS

SRS has led to better facial nerve function and outcomes and is currently considered a reasonable alternative to microsurgical resection in patients with FNSs. This is the first report to our knowledge of an acute, life-threatening hemorrhage after SRS in a patient with FNS.