Der Terroranschlag von Berlin – Die Vorgeschichte, der Einsatz und die Konsequenzen aus präklinischer Sicht

Lernen und üben wir das Richtige?

Der Massenanfall von Verletzten (MANV) ist eine Ausnahmesituation für Rettungsdienst und andere Einsatzkräfte. Trotz niedriger Inzidenz müssen sich die Einsatzkräfte sowohl auf ärztlicher als auch auf nichtärztlicher Seite auf diesen Einsatzfall vorbereiten. In der vorliegenden Pilotstudie wurden anhand einer Fehlermöglichkeits- und -einflussanalyse (FMEA) die kritischen Einsatzfaktoren im MANV ermittelt und mit den Ausbildungscurricula verglichen. Die herangezogenen Curricula waren Notfallsanitäter:in, organisatorische:r Leiter:in, Konzept zur katastrophenmedizinischen Ausbildung im studentischen Unterricht an deutschen Hochschulen, Nationaler Kompetenz-basierter Lernzielkatalog Medizin (NKLM), Zusatz-Weiterbildung Notfallmedizin und Fortbildung zum:zur leitenden Notarzt:ärztin. Die Ergebnisse lassen vermuten, dass in der praktischen Ausbildung der MANV eine eher untergeordnete Rolle spielt. Weitere empirische Untersuchungen sind aus Sicht der Autoren notwendig.

Terrorist incidents: strategic treatment objectives, tactical diagnostic procedures and the estimated need of blood and clotting products

BACKGROUND

Terrorism-related incidents that are associated with mass casualties (mass-casualty terrorist incidents) are a medical and organisational challenge for every hospital because of the special injury patterns involved, the time of the incident, the development of the situation, the initial lack of information, the number of injured, and the number of uninjured survivors who self-refer to a hospital.

METHODS

The Terror and Disaster Surgical Care (TDSC®) - Course was developed in order to address mass-casualty terrorist incidents and to provide surgeons with the specialist medical and surgical knowledge and skills required for these special situations. The focus of the TDSC® course is on how to provide surgical care and how to deploy scarce resources in a particular tactical situation in such a way that the number of survivors is maximised.

RESULTS

The effective management of such a tactical situation must be based on priorities and first and foremost requires the standardised sorting and categorisation of the injured at the hospital. The aim of triage, or the sorting of the injured, is to immediately identify patients with life-threatening injuries in environments with strained resources. The medical management of mass-casualty terrorist incidents requires tactical abbreviated surgical care (TASC) teams that have the skills needed to perform a primary survey and to provide care for casualties who need immediate surgery (triage category 1-T1). Initial fluid therapy should be restrictive (permissive hypotension) unless contraindicated. Clotting products are replaced in a standardised manner on the basis of patient requirements, which are calculated using rapidly available surrogates (blood gas analysis). Blood products can be administered or kept available depending on risks and triage categories. The highest priority should be given to the identification and management of haemodynamically unstable patients who require immediate surgery for injuries associated with bleeding into body cavities (T1 + +).

CONCLUSION

The recommendations and approaches described here should be considered as proposals for hospitals to develop standards or modify well-established standards that enable them to prepare themselves successfully for situations (e.g. mass-casualty terrorist or shooter incidents) in which their resources are temporarily overwhelmed.

Death scene investigation and autopsy proceedings in identifying the victims of the terror attack on the Breitscheidplatz in Berlin 19th December 2016

We describe and discuss the forensic mission after the terrorist attack on the Breitscheidplatz in Berlin on 19th December 2016, focusing on co-operation with police authorities, and the injury patterns of the deceased. Even after massive blunt trauma, severe injury patterns are often unrecognizable by visual inspection of the body (“Casper’s sign”), which could instill false security among rescuers or, as happened on the Breitscheidplatz, may lead to distress or even trauma in rescue personnel when obviously primarily uninjured patients die suddenly.

[Handling posttraumatic stress disorder : Showing weakness means you lose]

BACKGROUND

In prehospital medicine, psychological stress is common and part of the profession. On the one hand, this implies resilience; on the other hand, posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) can develop under the high psychological strain.

OBJECTIVES

The goal was to obtain an overview of the problem awareness among health care workers in prehospital medicine and identify possible networks for psychological trauma in Germany. The authors searched the internet in general and MEDLINE using key words.

RESULTS

PTSD among health care workers in prehospital medicine is rare but can be severe. Generally speaking, help for traumatized helpers is possible in Germany and several institutions offer help. Most victims do not use the offered help, which is not well organized for health care workers. The German Interdisciplinary Association for Intensive Care and Emergency Medicine founded a new section "perspective resilience" in order to offer better help.

CONCLUSIONS

Stress and psychological strain are common in health care workers in prehospital medicine, although most of the symptoms will resolve spontaneously. Nevertheless, after a psychological event, it is not possible to predict the course of the symptoms and the awareness among helpers is still low. To find the right therapy at the right time is critical. We still need better education and better networks in this area. Furthermore, research in this field is rare.

[Distribution of triage categories in terrorist attacks with mass casualties : Analysis and evaluation of European results from 1985 to 2017]

BACKGROUND

The incidence and character of civil mass casualty incidents (MCI) has changed in the last decades, in particular because of the rising number of terrorist attacks. As a result, the question arises whether commonly used tools of prevention and prehospital planning, including the distribution of triage categories (T1 severely injured/T2 seriously injured/T3 slightly injured) with 15%/20%/60% have to be modified. The rescue workers make the classification of the triage categories in MCIs at the scene. The aim of this article is to verify the planning size of variable distribution of the triage categories.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A total of 244 MCI with >9 casualties from 1 January 1985 to 31 May 2017 in Europe and Turkey were identified by a systematic literature search and analyzed with respect to the distribution of T in the first 24 h.

RESULTS

An incidence of 10% T1, 17% T2, 49% T3 and 5% deaths was detected (median). Due to the previously use of the average of the triage categories in the contingency plan, the calculation showed a slightly different distribution from 15%/30%/55%. Of the events 7 were natural disasters, 227 terrorist attacks, 9 accidents and 1 mass panic. Natural disasters showed a higher than average death rate (11%), especially landslide incidents (67%). Civilian accidents showed a distribution of T of 10%/17%/55%, with train derailments having twice as many T1 patients and plane crashes just under twice as many T2 patients. In the case of terrorist attacks, the expected planning parameters were not quite achieved with 14%/15%/39%. Especially "combined hits" and amok driving had high incidences of T1 patients (18% and 21%, respectively). In addition, the T2 patients with 42% in amok driving and 48% in mass panics were well above the planning size of 20% and 30%, respectively. Calculation of the severity factor according to deBoer for amok driving and the result that at S ≥ 1.5 many seriously injured persons can be suspected, amok driving showed the highest degree of severity (S = 1.8) in our study. This indicates the severity of a disaster depending on the number of casualties per triage category.

DISCUSSION

[Approaches to pre-hospital bleeding management : Current overview on civilian emergency medicine]

Severe bleeding is a typical result of traumatic injuries. Hemorrhage is responsible for almost 50% of deaths within the first 6 h after trauma. Appropriate bleeding control and coagulation therapy depends on an integrated concept of local hemostasis by primary pressure with the hands, compression, and tourniquets accompanied by prevention of hypothermia, acidosis and hypocalcemia. Additionally, permissive hypotension is accepted for suitable patients and tranexamic acid should be administered early. Multiple publications prove that prehospital transfusion of blood products (e. g. red blood cells and plasma) and coagulation factors (e. g. fibrinogen) is feasible and safe, but only required for <5% of polytrauma patients in the civilian setting.

[Comparison of two models of a treatment area with respect to treatment times in critically ill patients : A pilot study]

BACKGROUND

In the case of a mass casualty incident an advanced medical post (AMP) plays a central role in the medical care by ambulance service and civil protection units. Besides the traditional organization with one triage category per medical services tent, it can also be structured in a mixed form (i.e. a defined number of patients with different triage categories are assigned to each medical services tent). To date it remains unclear which organization format is better in order to rapidly evacuate those patients with the highest priority.

METHODS

The Medical Task Force of Lower Franconia treated 50 identical and standardized training patients including 18 triage category red/emergency (36%), 12 triage category yellow/urgent (24%), 18 triage category green/non-urgent (36%) and 2 triage category black/dead (4%) in the course of a scheduled field exercise within two consecutive training sessions (first session: classical structure, second session: mixed structure). The training patients were represented by a dynamic patient simulation, whereby simulation cards showed injury patterns and the external appearance of the patients at a defined point which required certain interventions. The patients' conditions changed when these measures were accomplished or neglected. The length of stay of the patients with the triage category red/emergency at the AMP (start of triage to start evacuation) as well as the overall number of evacuated patients were collated and compared.

RESULTS

Out of 18 patients with the triage category red/emergency, 13 patients in each session were evacuated in one pass. During the first session the mean evacuation time at the AMP was 25 min and during the second session the mean evacuation time was 18 min. After the end of the 90 min of exercise time in the first session 14 non-critical patients (triage categories yellow/urgent and green/non-urgent, n = 30) were still left at the AMP (16 evacuated) and in the second session 12 (18 evacuated).

CONCLUSION

Depending on the mission requirements the mixed form of AMP organization can provide several advantages. In addition to rapid operational readiness and high flexibility the patient distribution by triage category could be processed better and the evacuation time of critical patients could be shortened.