[Results of therapy after primary conservative management of distal radius fractures in patients over 65 years of age]

Long-term clinical and socio-economic outcomes following wrist fracture: a systematic review and meta-analysis

A comprehensive review of studies shows that patients with wrist fracture, aged over 50 years, experience pain and functional limitation long after fracture. This is associated with increased healthcare costs, and reduced quality of life. Understanding factors that predict poor outcomes is important for future healthcare policy and planning.

PURPOSE

To summarise and appraise evidence on the prognosis and long-term clinical and socio-economic outcomes following wrist fracture among adults aged 50 years and over.

METHODS

Five databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, AMED, CINAHL-P and PsycINFO) were comprehensively searched (supplemented by a grey-literature search) from inception till June 2021 for prospective/retrospective cohort studies of patients (≥ 50 years) with a history of wrist fracture and reporting long-term (≥ 6 months) outcomes. Peer study selection, data extraction and risk of bias assessment were conducted. A random effects meta-analysis was used to summarise estimates of pain and function outcomes.

RESULTS

78 studies (n = 688,041 patients) were included. Patients report persistent moderate to severe pain (range: 7.5%-62%) and functional limitations (range: 5.5-78%) up to 12-months or later after wrist fracture. Mean Patient-Rated Wrist Evaluation (PRWE) score for pain and function (9 studies, n = 1759 patients) was 15.23 (95%CI 12.77, 17.69) at 6-months to 13-years follow-up. Mean disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand (DASH) score (9 studies, n = 1346 patients) was 13.82 (95%CI 12.71, 14.93)( at 6- to 17-months follow-up. A 10-20% increase in healthcare encounters in the first 12-months after fracture was observed. Twelve prognostic factors were associated with poor long-term outcomes.

CONCLUSION

Evidence shows that a high proportion of people aged over 50 years with wrist fracture experience pain and functional limitation > 6 months after fracture. This is associated with increased healthcare costs, and reduced quality of life. Exploratory evidence was found for several candidate prognostic factors. Their predictive performance needs to be investigated further.

PROSPERO

CRD42018116478.

A Randomized Trial Assessing the Muscle Strength and Range of Motion in Elderly Patients following Distal Radius Fractures Treated with 4- and 6-Week Cast Immobilization

BACKGROUND

There is no consensus among orthopedic surgeons as to the required period of cast immobilization in distal radius fractures in elderly patients. The purpose of this study was to assess muscle strength and range of motion symmetry in elderly patients after distal radius fractures with different periods of cast immobilization.

METHODS

This study evaluated 50 patients (33 women and 17 men), aged over 65 years, after cast immobilization treatment for distal radius fracture. The mean age at the beginning of treatment was 71 years. The mean duration of follow-up was 1 year and 3 months. The first subgroup (n = 24) comprised the patients whose fractures had been immobilized in a cast for 6 weeks, another subgroup (n = 26) comprised the patients with 4-week cast immobilization. We assessed: (1) muscle strength, (2) range of motion.

RESULTS

The mean grip strength in the treated limb was 71% and 81% of that in the healthy limb in the groups with 4-week and 6-week cast immobilization, respectively (p = 0.0432). The study groups showed no differences in the mean grip strength in the treated limbs or the mean grip strength in the healthy limbs. The mean treated limb flexion was 62° and 75° in the 4-week and 6-week immobilization groups, respectively (p = 0.025). The evaluated groups showed no differences in terms of any other range of motion parameters. The grip strength and range of motion values were significantly lower in the treated limb than in the healthy limb in both evaluated groups. Only the values of wrist radial deviation in the 6-week cast immobilization group showed no differences between the treated and healthy limbs.

CONCLUSION

Higher values of injured limb muscle strength and greater mean range of wrist flexion were achieved in the 6-week subgroup. Neither of the evaluated groups achieved a symmetry of muscle strength or range of motion after treatment. Full limb function did not return in any of the elderly distal radius fracture patients irrespective of cast immobilization duration.

Peripheral Nerve Compression Neuropathy after Fractures of the Distal Radius

Sixty patients with unilateral distal radius fractures were managed conservatively. Clinical assessment included objective and subjective evaluations of the outcome of treatment. Radiographic evaluation included fracture classification using the AO/ASIF system and measurement of volar tilt, radial inclination and radial height shortening at the end of treatment. Clinical signs of carpal tunnel syndrome were confirmed electrodiagnostically in 12 patients (20%) during the recovery period. Each patient had electrodiagnostic studies of both upper limbs performed to confirm the diagnosis. The mean time between injury and the onset of symptoms was 10 months (range 6.5 weeks–27 months). A statistically significant correlation between the final clinical results of treatment and post-traumatic median nerve compression neuropathy was found, but the occurrence of the neuropathy correlated with neither fracture type nor with the final radiographic findings. No clinical signs of ulnar or radial nerve compression occurred in this study.

Comparison of palmar fixed-angle plate fixation with K-wire fixation of distal radius fractures (AO A2, A3, C1) in elderly patients

The objective of this prospective, randomized, controlled trial was to compare the results of two operative techniques used for the treatment of unstable distal radius fractures in elderly patients classified as AO types A2, A3, and C1. Patients were treated with either fixed-angle volar plates or K-wires using a combined Kapandji and Willenegger technique. The functional results were determined after 3, 6, and 12 months. We included 40 patients aged over 65 years. Twenty-one patients were treated with plate fixation and 19 with K-wire fixation. The functional results, after 1 year, were nearly the same in both treatment groups, suggesting that either method is suitable for the treatment of unstable distal radius fractures of AO types A2, A3, and C1 in elderly patients. Sixteen of 21 patients with plate fixation and 17 of 19 patients with K-wire fixation present good results as assessed by the Castaing score. The median DASH score was three in both groups after 1 year. The patients with plate fixation were able to resume activities of daily living 4 weeks earlier. The most common complication was an intermediate post-traumatic median nerve irritation. Both methods are suitable for the treatment of elderly patients with unstable distal radius fractures of AO types A2, A3, and C1. If early functional post-operative care is important, palmar fixed-angle plate fixation is an ideal treatment approach. Otherwise, K-wire fixation is an effective, minimally invasive method with comparable clinical results.

A functional outcomes survey of elderly patients who sustained distal radius fractures

PURPOSE

This study aims to examine the subjective functional outcomes of patients 70 years or older who sustained distal radius fractures through the use of the Disability of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH) and Short Form-8 Health (SF-8) surveys.

METHODS

Patients at least 70 years old with a distal radius fracture between 2000 and 2004 were identified and their charts reviewed. They were contacted to answer the DASH and SF-8 surveys. The radiographic injury parameters examined were articular stepoff greater than 2 mm, dorsal tilt on the lateral radiograph, ulnar variance, and presence of an ulnar styloid fracture.

RESULTS

Fifty-eight patients answered the DASH and SF-8 surveys. The mean age at the time of injury in the survey group was 78 years old (range 70-94 years). Mean follow-up period was 33 months (range 13-65 months). Average DASH and SF-8 scores were 22.3 (SD 22.4) and 31.5 (SD 6.9), respectively. DASH scores were inversely correlated with SF-8 scores (R = -0.65, p < 0.01). Patients who sustained an associated ulnar styloid fracture demonstrated worse DASH scores than those without an ulnar styloid fracture (presence of ulnar styloid fracture: mean DASH 26.2, no ulnar styloid fracture: mean DASH 12.9, p = 0.04). There were no significant differences in functional outcome for any other radiographic parameters assessed. Males had statistically better DASH scores than the females (males: mean DASH 6.9, females: mean DASH 24.4, p = 0.003). No difference was found in functional outcome scores among different treatment groups.

CONCLUSION

In elderly patients with distal radius fractures, the only radiographic parameter we found that affects functional outcome is an associated ulnar styloid fracture. Additionally, females had worse functional outcomes than males.

Can the displacement of a conservatively treated distal radius fracture be predicted at the beginning of treatment?

The aim of this study was to investigate whether the final displacement of conservatively treated distal radius fractures can be predicted after primary reduction. We analysed the radiographic documents of 311 patients with a conservatively treated distal radius fracture at the time of injury, after reduction and after bony consolidation. We measured the dorsal angulation (DA), the radial angle (RA) and the radial shortening (RS) at each time point. The parameters were analysed separately for metaphyseally "stable" (A2, C1) and "unstable" (A3, C2, C3) fractures, according to the AO classification system. Spearman's rank correlations and regression functions were determined for the analysis. The highest correlations were found for the DA between the time points 'reduction' and 'complete healing' (r = 0.75) and for the RA between the time points 'reduction' and 'complete healing' (r = 0.80). The DA and the RA after complete healing can be predicted from the regression functions.

Distal radius fracture management in elderly patients: a literature review

Distal radius fracture management in elderly patients remains without consensus regarding the appropriate treatment or anticipated outcome. Forty-one studies that included at least 10 patients with a minimum mean age of 65 years and that were indexed in Medline or Embase were reviewed. Treatment methods included pins and plaster, external fixation, K-wires, bone cement, and open reduction and internal fixation with plates. The methodological quality of each study was evaluated through use of a grading scale. Despite study heterogeneity, higher rates of infection were noted with external fixation and K-wire stabilization. Stratifying patients into low-demand and high-demand groups may improve the management of distal radius fractures in elderly patients. In sedentary patients with low demands, functional outcomes are good despite the presence of deformity. Patients with higher demands may benefit from fracture stabilization with locking volar plates. Volar plating with fixed-angle screws may be particularly suitable for elderly patients who may take longer to heal a fracture, be more susceptible to pin-track infection, and demonstrate earlier tendon irritation leading to rupture.

Stellenwert der Kirschner-Draht-Osteosynthese in der Behandlung der distalen Radiusfraktur

The age distribution of patients with distal radius fractures shows a clear predominance of patients over 60. In such patients fractures must be treated with due consideration for the general condition, accompanying illnesses, such as osteoporosis, and the often lesser ambitions concerning the function of the wrist joint. Three cases of patients over 70 years of age are presented: two of these patients were suffering from dementia and one, from multiple morbidities and poor general condition: In all three, severe osteitis of the distal radius developed after K-wire pinning to treat distal radius fractures. In two cases, the treatment culminated in radiocarpal arthrodesis, while in the third the definitive treatment was resection of the metaphysis of the distal radius. The presented cases indicate that in distal radius fracture patients who are affected by dementia or have a poor general condition K-wire pinning with protruding K-wires should not be regarded as the therapy of first choice.

[Distal radius fracture. Correlation between radiological and functional results]

BACKGROUND

The purpose of the present study was to investigate the influence of the radiological parameters on the functional outcome of patients with a fracture of the distal radius and to find out to which extent a deformity can be tolerated.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A total of 344 patients with an isolated fracture of the distal radius were treated during a 3-year period; 211 of them were evaluated at an average of 16 months after the accident according to the score of Gartland and Werley as modified by Sarmiento. Furthermore, we developed our own score for evaluating the influence of radiological parameters on the functional outcome.

RESULTS

According to the AO classification, there were 20 patients with an A2, 71 an A3, 11 a B, 35 a C1, 44 a C2, and 30 a C3 fracture. Of 211 patients, 28 (13%) had a step-off in the articular surface of over 1 mm, resulting in a 24% reduction of the range of motion compared to the non-injured wrist (p<0.05). Patients with a radial shortening of more than 3 mm (n=12) had a 21% reduction of pro- and supination compared to the non-injured side (p<0.05). The radial tilt and the palmar inclination did not have a direct influence on the functional outcome. Patients treated with K-wire pinning and with an initial palmar inclination of less then -15 degrees had a significantly higher secondary loss of palmar inclination of 9 degrees compared to all others (p<0.05) at the final follow-up.

CONCLUSION

The main radiological factors influencing the functional outcome of fractures of the distal radius are radial shortening and a step-off in the articular surface.

Outcome after surgery of distal radius fractures: no differences between external fixation and ORIF

The purpose of this study was to determine the most appropriate surgical treatment from three procedures used for fractures of the distal radius. In a retrospective comparative study, 166 out of 237 patients who underwent surgery for AO/ASIF A3 or C2 distal radius fractures were evaluated. Surgical procedures were external fixation or open reduction and internal fixation with either palmar or dorsal plates. Radiological outcomes were palmar tilt, radial angle, radial length and ulnar variance. Functional outcomes were range of motion and grip strength. In addition, outcomes according to Gartland and Werley and the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand questionnaire were compared. Further outcome criteria were the treatment time and the number of complications. Data were analysed using an analysis of variance statistical procedure respective of the chi2-test. Open reduction and internal fixation, in particular palmar plate fixation, demonstrated the best radiological and functional results. Subjective assessment of ORIF proved better than that of external fixation as treatment time was shorter and complications were more rarely seen. However, most of the differences between groups were not significant. Although there were no significant differences between groups, our data indicates that most dorsally displaced distal radius fractures can be treated successfully by open reduction and internal fixation. Palmar plate fixation seems to have slight advantages compared to both the external fixation and dorsal plate fixation surgical procedure.

[Incorrect classification of extra-articular distal radius fractures by conventional X-rays. Comparison between biplanar radiologic diagnostics and CT assessment of fracture morphology]

Thirty-five displaced fractures of the distal radius, classified by standard radiographs as extra-articular type A2 and A3 fractures according to the AO classification, were investigated before operative treatment by computed tomography. The comparative analysis surprisingly revealed an involvement of the articular surface of the distal radius in 57%. The intra-articular fractures were classified after CT as C1 in 15%, C2 in 65%, and C3 in 20%. The distal radioulnar joint was involved in 80% of the type C injuries and showed a dorsal subluxation in 17% of all cases. Similar to the results of type A2 and A3 fractures, type B and C fractures of the distal radius also may be underestimated in standard radiographs. This concerns important components such as the involvement of the radiocarpal joint surface and concomitant injuries of the distal radioulnar joint. Since joint congruency is an important predictor of outcome, CT scanning should be used more generously for planning and controlling surgical therapy.