[Long-term outcome of Swanson prosthesis management of the rheumatic wrist joint]

Total Wrist Arthroplasty—A Systematic Review of the Outcome, and an Introduction of FreeMove—An Approach to Improve TWA

The Swanson silicone prosthesis was one of the first devices to realize total wrist arthroplasty (TWA). It has been used regularly since the early 1960s. This systematic review of the literature evaluated the status quos of TWA. The present study was conducted according to the PRISMA guidelines. A literature search was made in Medline, PubMed, Google Scholar, and the Cochrane Library databases. The focus of the present study was on implant survivorship and related functional outcomes. Data from 2286 TWA (53 studies) were collected. Fifteen studies were included for the analysis of implant survivorship. Fifteen studies were included for the analysis of pain. Twenty-eight studies were included for the analysis of the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH) score. Grip strength was tracked in 16 studies. The range of motion (RoM) was evaluated in 46 studies. For supination and pronation, 18 articles were available. Despite some methodological heterogeneities, TWA may be effective and safe in pain reduction and improving function and motion. There is still a range for a future improvement of the procedure.

[Research progress of artificial wrist joint prosthesis]

Objective

To summarize the research progress of the artificial wrist joint prosthesis.

Methods

Domestic and abroad literature concerning artificial wrist joint prosthesis was reviewed and analyzed thoroughly.

Results

Artificial wrist joint prosthesis has been developed to the 4th generation. The artificial wrist joint arthroplasty has advantages of pain relief and functional improvement and can achieve ideal short-term effectiveness. But there are some problems, such as loosening, subsidence, fracture, and dislocation of prosthesis. The long-term effectiveness of the 3rd and 4th generation prosthesis still need to be followed up.

Conclusion

The biomechanics of wrist joint is extremely complicated, which results in less application and slow development of artificial wrist joint prosthesis. Early-term effectiveness of artificial wrist joint arthroplasty is basically satisfactory, but there are still some long-term complications. So the artificial wrist joint prosthesis remains to be developed.

Current European Practice in Wrist Arthroplasty

The results of wrist arthroplasty for severely destroyed and painful wrists are generally good in pain reduction, increased grip strength, and upper limb function. The wrist range of motion is usually preserved but not improved. Implant survival seems better than it was with earlier implant designs; however, there are problems of carpal component loosening. Patient selection plays an important role, requiring experience, careful patient information, and discussing the pros and cons of arthroplasty and partial or total wrist arthrodesis.

Wrist arthroplasty: where do we stand today? A review of historic and contemporary designs

Earlier generations of wrist arthroplasty were limited to low demand patients. Bone fixation problems, excessive wear, and adverse designs resulting in loosening, imbalance, and dislocation led to the withdrawal of a number of models. Contemporary wrist prostheses aim at replacing wrist arthrodesis in the majority of patients with radiocarpal destruction, including high demand cases. Contraindications are wrist imbalance, insufficient soft tissue, or bone stock and infection. Various designs, fixation principles, bearing materials, and articulations have been employed. Some of the devises (RE-MOTION™, Motec(®)) demonstrate promising short- to midterm results, and calls for cautious optimism.

Favorable results after total wrist arthroplasty: 65 wrists in 60 patients followed for 5–9 years

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

During the past 40 years, several attempts have been made with total wrist arthroplasty to avoid fusion in severely destroyed wrists. The results have often been disappointing. There is only modest clinical documentation due to the small number of patients (especially non-rheumatoid cases) and short follow-up times. Here we report a multicenter series using a third-generation implant with a minimum follow-up time of 5 years.

METHODS

In 2012, data were retrieved from a registry of consecutive wrist operations at 7 centers with units specialized in hand surgery, between 2003 and 2007. The wrists had been reviewed annually and analysis was done on the latest follow-up data.

RESULTS

60 patients had been operated (5 bilaterally), 5 wrists had been revised, and 52 were available for follow-up (with the revised cases excluded). The pain scores, QuickDASH scores, ulnar flexion, and supination for the whole group were statistically significantly better at follow-up. There were no statistically significant differences between the rheumatoid and the non-rheumatoid patients except for motion, which was better in the non-rheumatoid group. The motion obtained depended on the preoperative motion. Implant survival was 0.9 at 5-9 years.

INTERPRETATION

The clinical results in terms of pain, motion, strength, and function were similar to those in previous reports. The implant survival was 0.9 at 9 years, both in rheumatoid and non-rheumatoid cases, which is an important improvement compared to the earlier generations of total wrist arthroplasty.

Promising one- to six-year results with the Motec wrist arthroplasty in patients with post-traumatic osteoarthritis

The Motec cementless modular metal-on-metal ball-and-socket wrist arthroplasty was implanted in 16 wrists with scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse (SNAC; grades 3 or 4) and 14 wrists with scapholunate advanced collapse (SLAC) in 30 patients (20 men) with severe (grades 3 or 4) post-traumatic osteoarthritis of the wrist. The mean age of the patients was 52 years (31 to 71). All prostheses integrated well radiologically. At a mean follow-up of 3.2 years (1.1 to 6.1) no luxation or implant breakage occurred. Two wrists were converted to an arthrodesis for persistent pain. Loosening occurred in one further wrist at five years post-operatively. The remainder demonstrated close bone–implant contact. The clinical results were good, with markedly decreased Disabilities of the Arm Shoulder and Hand (DASH) and pain scores, and increased movement and grip strength. No patient used analgesics and most had returned to work.

Good short-term function was achieved using this wrist arthroplasty in a high-demand group of patients with post-traumatic osteoarthritis.

[Endoprosthetic replacement of the rheumatoid wrist]

For patients with rheumatoid arthritis preventive and reconstructive surgery of the hand provide better functional results and higher patient satisfaction when surgery is done adequately before the inflammatory stage, especially when multiple joints are affected. Synovectomy, arthrodesis and prosthetic reconstruction are able to guarantee maintenance of function even in late stages and severe destruction, when modern drug therapy cannot prevent further inflammatory attacks and increasing destruction.

[Operative differential therapy of rheumatic wrists]

The wrists are affected in the long-term in 90% of people with rheumatism and are often (42%) the first manifestation of a destructive disease. The functionality of the wrist and the whole hand is of great importance because in many cases loss of function of the wrists leads to severe limitations. Local and operative treatment of the wrist in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is one of the main duties in rheuma-orthopaedics. For operative treatment there is a finely tuned differential therapeutic spectrum available. The diagnostic indications take the local and total pattern of affection, the current systemic therapy as well as patient wishes and patient compliance into consideration. In the early stages according to LDE (Larsen, Dale, Eek), soft tissues operations such as articulo-tenosynovectomy (ATS) are most commonly carried out. In further advanced stages osseus stabilisation must often be performed. At this point a smooth transition from partial arthrodesis to complete fixation is possible. After initial euphoria, arthroplasty of the wrist is being increasingly less used for operative treatment due to the unconvincing long-term results and high complication rate. With reference to the good long-term results of all operative procedures, in particular early ATS with respect to pain, function and protection of tendons, after failure of medicinal treatment and persistence of inflammatory activity in the wrist, patients should be transferred to an experienced rheuma-orthopaedic surgeon.

Le poignet rhumatoïde

Wrist involvement in Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA) is frequent, variable in its presentation, heterogeneous in its evolution and has an important impact on the function of the affected hand. Surgery must be indicated within the framework of a structured medical and surgical approach that considers the whole patient. Surgical treatment at the wrist level is indicated in cases of resistant chronic pain, persistent articular synovitis, or chronic tenosynovitis and also in cases of painful limitation of supination, risk of complications due to wrist deformity and tendinous or neurological complications. The surgical goal in RA is to restore correct function but not neccessarily normal anatomy, with the goal of achieving a painless, stable wrist, correctly positioned. Motion depends on the status of the different joints and on the bone stock. Knowledge of the natural progression of the disease helps in the surgical decision making process. The pathogenesis and patterns of deformity, the clinical and X-ray appearances and the various techniques applied to the surgery of the rheumatoid wrist are studied and discussed including palmar wrist and dorsal wrist procedures, conservative and non-conservative options.

Long-term results of silicone wrist arthroplasty in patients with rheumatoid arthritis

PURPOSE

The surgical treatment of the rheumatoid wrist is key in managing the affected hand. Wrist fusion is often the treatment of choice in cases of severe destruction and deformation although most patients would prefer a motion-preserving procedure. The implantation of a wrist prosthesis might be an alternative to partial arthrodesis for selected cases. In this series we analyzed the long-term results (minimum follow-up period, 10 y) of the Swanson silicone spacer for the wrist in patients with rheumatoid arthritis.

METHODS

Sixteen patients with rheumatoid arthritis with 18 silicone spacers for the wrists were reviewed after a minimum follow-up period of 10 years (average, 15 y). Subjective evaluation, clinical examination, and radiographic analysis were included. An additional 9 patients (9 wrists) were interviewed by telephone.

RESULTS

In 12 of the patients the subjective result was good or very good, mostly because of adequate pain relief. The average range of motion for flexion (average, 28 degrees )/extension (average, 15 degrees ) was 43 degrees with a wide variation within the series. Radiologically all wrists had diminished residual carpal height at follow-up evaluation and 9 of the wrists had evidence of osteolysis and foreign-body granuloma. The initial good correction of the ulnar translation of the wrist was lost partially in the follow-up period (1.1 vs 4.0 mm). Three of the patients needed surgical revision within the follow-up period; all were converted to wrist fusion.

CONCLUSIONS

These long-term results suggest that the silicone wrist spacer still may be considered as an alternative to wrist fusion or more complex wrist joint prostheses in patients with rheumatoid arthritis, especially in severe cases and in patients with low demands. In the long term osteolysis caused by foreign-body granulation is to be expected and has to be considered.

Hand surgery in rheumatoid arthritis: state of the art and suggestions for research

OBJECTIVE

The role of surgery in the clinical management of patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA)-associated hand dysfunction is still a subject of controversy. The efficacy of surgery in RA-associated hand dysfunction is assessed through an exhaustive review of published studies.

METHODS

A high-sensitivity search strategy was used to identify in MedLine and CENTRAL original studies related to hand and wrist surgery in RA patients. We selected articles including at least two adult RA patients which evaluated clinical outcomes through an observational or experimental design. Eligible studies were evaluated by standardized criteria. Two investigators independently used a pre-defined form to extract data about patient population, intervention, follow-up and clinical outcomes. Disagreements were discussed and resolved.

RESULTS

One hundred and ninety-six papers met inclusion criteria. Only five were randomized trials, while most studies followed an observational design, often of poor quality. As such, we could not pool data for statistical analysis; however, we were still able to provide a best evidence synthesis. A positive trend suggesting the efficacy of total carpal arthrodesis and metacarpophalangeal arthroplasty in reducing pain and improving function seemed to emerge from the published studies.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite recent advances in medical treatment, surgery still plays a role in the clinical management of RA-associated hand dysfunction. However, the majority of the available studies showed methodological flaws that prevented a clear definition of both surgical indications and criteria for choosing any specific procedure. Suggestions for further investigations are also provided.

Prothesenoperationen an der rheumatischen Hand

In rheumatoid arthritis the complex biomechanics of the hand is impaired due to elongation of ligaments and displacement of tendons. This results in eccentric transfer of high loads to the arthritic joints. This pathological load transmission remains frequently after joint replacement. This is the main reason for the high failure rate after arthroplasty in the hand. Therefore, most of the endoprostheses are no longer in use. As long as techniques for reliable reconstruction of the periarticular structures have not been established, silicon arthroplasty will remain the golden standard. Arthroplasty of the wrist and the PIP joints is seldom performed. After arthrodesis of these joints, the function of the hand is sufficient and complications are seldom. Midterm results after resectional arthroplasty of the CMC-I joint show less complications and results comparable with silicon arthroplasty.