Über die Bedeutung der Konvektions-Hypothese Báránys für den thermischen Nystagmus

Three-dimensional analysis of caloric nystagmus in the rhesus monkey

The aim of this study was to investigate whether caloric nystagmus contains response components that can be attributed to a stimulation of the vertical semicircular canals. Three dimensional eye movement recordings with a dual search coil technique revealed important horizontal, vertical and torsional nystagmus components following irrigation of the external ear canal with cold water in various head positions relative to gravity. Horizontal nystagmus components, i.e. lateral semicircular canal vectors, followed a cosine function of both the pitch and yaw angle of the head relative to gravity, confirming a mainly thermovective mechanism for stimulation of the horizontal canals. Vertical and torsional nystagmus components behaved differently following left and right ear irrigations. Right-left symmetrical vectors emerged only when the vertical and torsional components were transposed into vectors of single semicircular canal directions. The intensity of these vertical semicircular canal vectors as a function of the position of the corresponding canal relative to gravity, however, excludes important thermovective mechanisms acting at the vertical canals. It remains an open question whether these vertical canal vectors represent a non-thermovective caloric stimulation of vertical canal afferents.

Body position and caloric nystagmus response

The observation that the caloric nystagmus response is dependent on body position has been repeated in several studies during the course of this century. For many, this position-dependent modulation of the caloric response has been interpreted as evidence in favour of the thermoconvection theory as originally proposed by Bárány. However, the adequacy of this theory has been put into question by recent observations of caloric nystagmus during weightlessness in orbital flight. These zero-g findings clearly demonstrate that any hypothesis based on thermoconvection alone must prove insufficient as a description of the caloric nystagmus response. In the light of these recent findings, it has also become necessary to reconsider the influence of body position on caloric nystagmus intensity and the physiological mechanisms involved. Caloric testing was performed with a group of 30 healthy test subjects. Each person was tested in eight different body positions in the sagittal plane. Caloric nystagmus response was registered by means of horizontal and vertical EOG. The observed modification of the caloric response (SPV) by assumed body position is discussed with reference to associated reports in the literature.

Caloric stimulation of the vestibular system of the pigeon under minimal influence of gravity

Vestibular microphonics in response to acoustical stimulation were recorded in cochlea-deprived pigeons. Endolymph flow in the semicircular canals alters this response. A caloric stimulus was applied to the horizontal canal or the posterior vertical canal close to the ampulla. To minimize the influence of gravity, the canal being studied was positioned in the horizontal plane. Local temperature changes were generated with an electrically heated miniature copper probe, producing an approximately trapezoidal temperature profile. Because of the opposite hair cell polarization in the horizontal and the vertical ampulla, we could prove that the observed effects were of (hydro-)mechanical origin and were not caused by a direct effect of sensory epithelium temperature change. The first effect of temperature increase was an utriculopetal endolymph flow, as predicted by the 'expansion theory'.

Thermal stimulation of the vestibular labyrinth during orbital flight

During the European Spacelab mission (SL1) in 1983, caloric testing was performed for the first time in long-term weightlessness. After 2 days into orbital flight an unequivocal caloric nystagmus was observed in both subjects tested which corresponded in both quality and intensity with that measured in one-g conditions on Earth. The subsequent D1 mission enabled the experiment to be repeated on further subjects and with improved measurement procedures. As with the SL1 findings, the observed caloric nystagmus response proved to be equivalent to that measured during baseline testing on Earth. Renewed consideration of peripheral and central mechanisms, which might be involved in the elicitation of the caloric response--both in one-g and zero-g environments--has led to the reopening of a number of associated issues. One important observation which has been addressed by various research groups concerns the influence of the labyrinth's orientation to the gravity vector on the caloric response. The present authors have examined a group of healthy subjects in various body positions in the sagittal plane. The interindividual variability in the response behavior was found to be high; indeed single cases were observed in which the nystagmus response did not invert from the supine to the prone positions. These findings are discussed together with earlier reports in the literature.