[Local catheter-mediated lysis of the femoral artery: rt-PA versus urokinase]

Recombinant tissue plasminogen activator versus urokinase for local thrombolysis of femoropopliteal occlusions: a prospective, randomized multicenter trial

PURPOSE

To report the outcome of a prospective, randomized, open multicenter trial comparing (1) the effects of local thrombolysis with recombinant tissue plasminogen activator (rtPA) or urokinase (UK) and (2) 2 administration techniques.

METHODS

Two hundred thirty-four patients with thromboembolic occlusions in 223 native femoral or popliteal arteries (95%) and 11 bypass grafts (5%) were randomized to rtPA (n = 124) or UK (n = 110) administered either through an endhole catheter (Hess technique) in 81 patients or a microporous balloon catheter (Schneider technique) in 153 patients. When lysis was incomplete, additional catheter interventions were applied to achieve patency. Results were analyzed by fluoroscopy during intervention and by angiography evaluated by independent experts blinded to the methods applied.

RESULTS

The only significant difference between rtPA and UK was found at the end of lysis using the Hess technique. Complete reperfusion (TIMI grade 3) was produced in 60% of patients by rtPA versus 37% by UK (p = 0.045). By both techniques TIMI grade 3 was achieved in 62% with rtPA and in 50% with UK (p = 0.18). Independent of delivery technique, thrombolytic agent, or additional catheter interventions, TIMI grade 3 was achieved in 81% and angiographic patency in 88%. Primary patency at 6 months was 66%, which was increased by secondary interventions to 75%. Major amputations were performed in 6%, all in patients with initial Fontaine stage III/IV ischemia.

CONCLUSIONS

With local thrombolysis alone, rtPA appears to be more effective than UK; however, additional catheter interventions further improved patency, abolishing the difference between the lytic agents.

Predictive Factors for the Removal of "Soft" Femoropopliteal Occlusions with Intraarterial Short-term and High-Dose Urokinase Treatment

To date, intraarterial lysis is a widely accepted form of treatment for femoropopliteal occlusions. However, the outcome of therapy has been difficult to predict. Therefore, the present study dealt with two parameters likely to influence the occlusion removal rate. These are the outflow condition distal of the occlusion, and the occlusion length. Fifty patients with subacute femoropopliteal occlusions were treated with intraarterial thrombolysis and, in case residual obstructions were left, with subsequent catheter dilation. Only "soft" occlusions that were probed by a guide wire and proved to be penetrable were chosen for treatment. The occlusion age was 3.79 +/- 4.57 weeks with 90% of cases in the range of 1 day to 6 weeks. Fibrinolytic therapy consisted of one to three one-hour series of 300,000 IU urokinase instillation directly into the occlusion material. The complete clearance rate was 34/50 = 68%. In successfully treated patients, both the pressure gradient (difference between systemic and ankle pressure) and the walking distance improved significantly. Most important factors for success or failure of treatment were the quality of calf outflow and the length of obstruction. Thus, patients with at least one calf artery open and an occlusion length of under 10 cm presented with an opening rate of 88.5%, whereas patients with no calf arteries patent and an occlusion length over 20 cm presented with an opening rate of only 20%. The age of the occlusions, all penetrable by a guide wire prior to treatment, did not influence the rate of recanalization. Intraarterial short-term and high-dose urokinase infusion is an excellent form of treatment for subacute femoropopliteal occlusions. Especially good results with a 88.5% clearance rate were achieved in patients who presented with at least one calf artery open and an occlusion length below 10 cm.

Retrospective analysis of Rt-pa thrombolysis combined with PGE1 in patients with peripheral arterial occlusions

Although thrombolysis has been established for recanalization of acute and in part chronic peripheral artery occlusions, only smaller studies exist regarding the use of long-term rt-pa infiltration-thrombolysis. The objective of this study was to evaluate the benefit of additional long-term thrombolysis in patients with peripheral arterial occlusions for whom acute thrombolysis failed. From 1992 to 1997, 323 patients with peripheral arterial occlusions were treated with rt-pa (recombinant tissue-type plasminogen activator). When the thrombolysis failed during the first 3 hours, the thrombolytic therapy was continued as a long-term treatment with 3 mg rt-pa alternated by PGE1 (2.1 mL/hr for 3 hours, concentration: 20 microg/50 mL NaCl) every 3 hours. Additional heparin was applied in doses of 15,000 IE/24 hr or more to slightly increase the partial thromboplastin time. Angiographic controls were performed every 24 hours. If necessary, a final angioplasty was performed. In 142 of the 323 patients the occlusions were recanalized during the first 3 hours; 119 patients were treated with a long-term thrombolysis and in 72 (61%) a recanalization was ultimately achieved. Thus, the recanalization rate increased to 214 of 323 patients (p < 0.02). Mean treatment time was 2.8 +/- 2.2 days, range: 1 to 13 days. The rates of recanalization were not different in iliac, femoral, or crural arteries. Fibrinogen levels did not decrease during thrombolysis. Severe bleeding (with a decrease of more than 3 g/dL hemoglobin requiring transfusion) occurred in four patients after finishing the thrombolysis with short-term and in six with long-term therapy; two required surgical treatment. The 1-, 2-, and 3-year cumulative patency rates were respectively 90.1%, 74.2% and 64.9%. Patency rates in patients with acute or long-term thrombolysis were not different. A composite thrombolytic treatment using low-dose rt-pa in combination with PGE1 offers significantly better results than an acute thrombolytic treatment alone. It can be an effective and practicable regimen in about 60% of patients in whom acute thrombolysis fails.

Thrombolytic therapy with use of alteplase (rt-PA) in peripheral arterial occlusive disease: review of the clinical literature. The Advisory Panel

PURPOSE

The clinical literature describing the use of alteplase in the treatment of peripheral arterial occlusive (PAO) disease is reviewed.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The literature database was acquired by a MEDLINE search using the Boolean keyword string: tissue plasminogen activator and/or rt-PA and peripheral not animal. A review was performed to identify the dose range of alteplase, technique of infusion, use of anticoagulation, clinical success rates, and risk of complications.

RESULTS

Forty-six clinical studies were identified. There are few prospective, randomized clinical trials and a lack of standardized protocols and endpoints. Use of catheter-directed infusions of recombinant tissue plasminogen activator (rt-PA) may be beneficial versus surgery in the initial management of acute limb ischemia (< 14 days) and in reducing the magnitude of subsequent surgical or percutaneous revascularization. For patients with chronic limb ischemia (> 14 days), irreversible acute limb ischemia, or advanced diabetic arteriopathy, catheter-directed infusion of rt-PA or other plasminogen activators may be unsuitable. The risk of adverse bleeding appears related to the overall dose and duration of infusion. These risks appear similar to those of urokinase. The role of heparin in increasing adverse bleeding during rt-PA therapy is unclear.

CONCLUSIONS

There is no generally accepted dose or technique for administering catheter-directed thrombolysis using alteplase; however, several studies have demonstrated its clinical safety and efficacy. Formal studies will be required to determine the optimal dose, technique of infusion, the role of anticoagulation, and complication rates when alteplase is used for PAO disease.

Comparison of tissue plasminogen activator and urokinase in the local infiltration thrombolysis of peripheral arterial occlusions

Recanalization of the vascular lumen by means of local fibrinolysis is of major importance in the treatment of peripheral arterial occlusive disease. While urokinase and streptokinase have been extensively used for local fibrinolysis, there have been few studies of infiltration thrombolysis with genetically engineered tissue plasminogen activator (rt-PA). The aim of the investigation reported here was to establish whether there is any difference between urokinase and rt-PA in the short- and long-term outcome of local fibrinolytic therapy. One-hundred twenty patients (70 men, 50 women) with acute or subacute femoral (n = 21), femoropopliteal (n = 33), popliteal (n = 13) or popliteocrural (n = 53) thrombotic occlusions were randomized to local lysis using urokinase or rt-PA, and 6 months later follow-up investigations took place. Recanalization of thrombotically occluded vessels, particularly in the lower leg, was found more frequently, and after treatment of shorter duration, with rt-PA. Large local haematomas occurred in 8% of cases in the urokinase group and 15% in the rt-PA group. No serious haemorrhages were encountered in either group. Six months after treatment, the rt-PA group showed lower rates of Fontaine stage III and IV disease and amputation than the urokinase group, with a higher number of patients in Fontaine stage IIb. This study shows that local lysis with rt-PA yields better results than urokinase, not only in the short term but also 6 months later.