Jugular foramen schwannomas: surgical approaches and outcome of treatment

Outcomes after Surgical Resection of Jugular Foramen Schwannomas: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Objectives  We sought to perform a systematic review and meta-analysis of outcomes after surgical resection of jugular foramen schwannomas (JFSs). Design  A systematic review of the literature was performed according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. Setting  PubMed, Scopus, and Embase databases were searched. Participants  Case series of at least five patients undergoing surgical resection of JFSs were included. Main Outcome Measures  Primary outcomes included gross total resection (GTR) and near total resection (NTR) rates, as well as a composite of the two (GTR + NTR). Additional outcomes included new or worsening cranial nerve (CN) palsies and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leak. Random effects models were used to generate pooled outcomes. Results  A total of 25 studies comprising 567 patients were included in the study. The proportions of each tumor grade were the following: grade A (33.1%), grade B (16.1%), grade C (9.2%), and grade D (41.6%). The pooled rate of GTR was 81% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 70-88; I 2  = 78.9%) and the composite GTR + NTR rate was 88% (95% CI: 81-93; I 2  = 66.4%). Rates of new or worsening CN palsies were the following: 12% hearing loss (95% CI: 7-20; I 2  = 69.4%), 27% dysphagia (95% CI: 20-36; I 2  = 66%), 20% hoarseness (95% CI: 14-28; I 2  = 62.6%), and 19% facial palsy (95% CI: 13-28; I 2  = 64.6%). The pooled rate of CSF leak was 9% (95% CI: 6-15; I 2  = 43.9%). Conclusion  The literature suggests high GTR rates of JFSs can be achieved. However, new CN deficits are not uncommon.

The investigation of cranial fossae in the intracranial cavity of fixed cadaveric skull bases: associations with sex, laterality, and clinical significance

PURPOSE

Our study aims to investigate three parts of the intracranial cavity, their distances to essential anatomical landmarks, and the correlations between these distances with sex, laterality, and surgical significance.

METHODS

The cranial nerve foraminae and essential surgical landmarks of each fossa were investigated bilaterally in 30 adult formalin-fixed cadaveric heads. Measurements, including lengths, depths, diameters, and horizontal distances to each other, to the midline of the skull, and to the outer lateral margin of the skull, were recorded on both sides.

RESULTS

The optic canal (OC) depth, internal auditory meatus (IAM) width, CNVII and CNIX diameters, and accessory hypoglossal canal (HC) distance were significantly greater on the left side (p < 0.05). CNVI length, CNV diameter, CNXI length, and the distances of the HC and accessory HC from the skull were significantly greater on the right side (p < 0.05). In males, correlations were found between the length of the left CNVIII and the right IAM diameter (r = 0.864, p = 0.001), right CNVIII length (r = 0.709, p = 0.022), right accessory HC length (r = 0.847, p = 0.016), and right-sided skull distance (r = 0.829, p = 0.042). In females, correlations were noted between IAM depth and length, right IAM location relative to the skull, left CNIX and CNX lengths, left CNXII length, left accessory HC location relative to the skull, and accessory HC length.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings of the current study indicate inherent asymmetry, sexual dimorphism, and variability in certain cranial nerves among cadaveric heads, which could have implications for surgical procedures, neuroanatomical studies, and clinical assessments. The study revealed side disparities and correlations within cranial fossa formations and essential surgical landmarks in both genders.

Lower Cranial Nerve Schwannomas: Cohort Study and Systematic Review

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Schwannomas originating from the lower cranial nerves (LCNS) are rare and pose a significant surgical challenge. Resection is the mainstay treatment; however, risk of treatment morbidity is considerable, and the available literature regarding differential treatment outcomes in this vulnerable population is sparse.

METHODS

A single-institution cohort study and systematic literature review of LCNS were performed.

RESULTS

Fifty-eight patients were included: 34 underwent surgical resection and 24 underwent stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS). The median age at diagnosis was 48 years (range 17-74). Presenting symptoms were dysphagia (63%), dysarthria/hypophonia (47%), imbalance (33%), and hearing loss/tinnitus (30%). Tumor size was associated with surgical resection, as compared with initial SRS (4.1 cm vs 1.5 cm, P = .0001). Gross total resection was obtained in 52%, with tumor remnants predominantly localized to the jugular foramen (62%). Post-treatment worsening of symptoms occurred in 68% of surgical and 29% of SRS patients ( P = .003). Postoperative symptoms were mostly commonly hypophonia/hoarseness (63%) and dysphagia (59%). Seven patients (29%) had new neurological issues after SRS treatment, but symptoms were overall milder. The median follow-up was 60 months (range 12-252); 98% demonstrated meaningful clinical improvement. Eighteen surgical patients (53%) underwent adjuvant radiation at a median of 5 months after resection (range 2-32). At follow-up, tumor control was 97% in the surgical cohort and 96% among SRS patients.

CONCLUSION

Although LCNS resection is potentially morbid, most postoperative deficits are transient, and patients achieve excellent tumor control-particularly when paired with adjuvant SRS. For minimally symptomatic patients undergoing surgical intervention, we advise maximally safe resection with intracapsular dissection to preserve nerve integrity where possible. For residual or as a primary treatment modality, SRS is associated with low morbidity and high rates of long-term tumor control.

Purely intracranial vagal schwannoma: A case report of a rare lesion

We present a rare intracranial vagal schwannoma along with its preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative course.

Cranial Nerve Foramina: Part II - A Review of the Anatomy and Pathology of Cranial Nerve Foramina of the Posterior Cranial Fossa

Cranial nerve foramina are integral exits from the confines of the skull. Despite their significance in cranial nerve pathologies, there has been no comprehensive anatomical review of these structures. Owing to the extensive nature of this topic we have divided our review into two parts; Part II, presented here, focuses on the foramina of the posterior cranial fossa and discusses each foramen's shape, orientation, size, surrounding structures, and structures that pass through it. Furthermore, by comparing foramen sizes against the cross-sectional areas of their contents, we determine the amount of free space available within each. We also review lesions that can obstruct each foramen and discuss the clinical consequences.

Dumbbell-Shaped Jugular Foramen Tumors Extending to the Neck: Surgical Considerations Based on Imaging Findings

OBJECTIVE

Dumbbell-shaped jugular foramen tumors (DSJFTs) extending to the neck present diagnostic and management difficulties because of their rarity, various pathologies, and multidisciplinary involvement. Accurate imaging findings are of great importance for surgical planning and clinical outcomes. However, few articles have discussed this issue to date.

METHODS

Thirty-one patients with DSJFTs extending to the neck were surgically treated in a single stage at our institute. Their clinical and radiologic features, operative procedures, and outcomes were retrospectively reviewed.

RESULTS

Preoperative correct diagnosis of DSJFTs extending to the neck was made in all cases of benign tumor and in only 3 cases of malignant tumors in this series. All tumors were removed via a craniocervical approach by a multidisciplinary skull base team because of both their intracranial and neck extensions. Total removal was achieved in 26 patients (83.9%). Preoperative symptoms were improved in 18 patients, whereas new or worsening lower cranial nerve deficits occurred in 4 patients postoperatively. Follow-up (1-132 months, mean 64.4 months) was available in 90.3% of the patients. No clinical or radiologic signs of tumor recurrence were observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Preoperative radiologic evaluation of DSJFTs extending to the neck is essential for differential diagnosis, patient selection, and surgical planning. Favorable surgical outcomes can be achieved via a craniocervical approach, and some detailed imaging findings are helpful to increase the safety of tumor resection and reduce the morbidity of lower cranial nerve deficits and cerebrospinal fluid leakage.

Complete morphometric analysis of jugular foramen and its clinical implications

INTRODUCTION

Tumors affecting structures in the vicinity of jugular foramen such as glomus jugulare require microsurgical approach to access this region. These tumors tend to alter the normal architecture of the jugular foramen by invading it. Therefore, it is not feasible to have correct anatomic visualization of the foramen in the presence of such pathologies. Hence, a comprehensive knowledge of the jugular foramen is needed by all the neurosurgeons while doing surgery in this region.

AIM

Due to the inadequate knowledge of the accurate morphology of the jugular foramen in different sexes, the aim of this osteological study was to provide a complete morphometry including gender differences and describe some morphological characteristics of the jugular foramen in an adult Indian population.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study was done on 114 adult human dry skulls (63 males and 51 females) collected from the osteology museum in the department. Various dimensions of both endo- and exocranial aspect of jugular foramen were measured. Presence and absence of domed bony roof of jugular fossa and compartmentalization of jugular foramen were also noticed. Statistical analysis was done using Chi-square test and Student's t-test in SPSS version 23.

RESULTS

All the parameters of right jugular foramen were greater than the left side, except the distance of stylomastoid foramen from lateral margin of jugular foramen (SMJF) which was greater on the left side. Gender differences between various measurements of jugular foramen, presence of dome of jugular fossa, and compartmentalization patterns were reported.

CONCLUSION

This study gives knowledge about the various parameters, anatomical variations of jugular foramen in both sexes of an adult Indian population, and its clinical impact on the surgeries of this region.

A Single-Institution Retrospective Study of Jugular Foramen Schwannoma Management: Radical Resection Versus Subtotal Intracranial Resection Through a Retrosigmoid Suboccipital Approach Followed by Radiosurgery

BACKGROUND

Despite advances in skull base surgery, achieving effective surgical management of jugular foramen schwannomas (JFSs) that avoids postoperative cranial nerve (CN) deficits remains a challenge. Subtotal resection followed by radiosurgery (rather than radical resection) is increasingly being viewed as a better treatment strategy. Here, an institutional database was retrospectively analyzed for outcomes after surgical treatment of JFSs to evaluate the optimal strategy for managing JFSs.

METHODS

Twenty-two patients with JFSs were operated on by either radical resection (n = 13) or conservative resection plus radiosurgery (n = 9). These 2 different groups were compared in terms of early (≤4 weeks after surgery) and late postoperative functional outcome and oncologic control.

RESULTS

No deaths occurred in either group, but there were 3 surgery-related complications in the radical resection group. Postoperative CN deficits and additional procedures related to CN morbidity were generally higher in the radical resection group, but the differences were not statistically significant. The conservative surgery group showed a statistically significant improvement in the level of dysphagia and dysphagia-related functional state in the late postoperative period. There was 1 case of recurrence after radical resection over a mean follow-up period of 73 months. All tumors in the conservative surgery group were controlled over a mean period of 34 months.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that conservative resection of JFSs via a familiar intracranial approach plus radiosurgery may be an effective surgical alternative for improving functional outcome with adequate oncologic control.

Diagnostic Approach, Treatment, and Outcomes of Cervical Sympathetic Chain Schwannomas

Objective

This review examined the diagnostic approach, surgical treatment, and outcomes of cervical sympathetic chain schwannomas (CSCS) to guide clinical decision making.

Data Sources

Medline, EMBASE, and Cochrane databases.

Review Methods

A literature review from 1998 to 2013 identified 156 articles of which 51 representing 89 CSCS cases were evaluated in detail. Demographic, clinical, and outcomes data were extracted by 2 independent reviewers with high interrater reliability (κ = .79). Cases were mostly international (82%), predominantly from Asia (50%) and Europe (27%).

Conclusions

On average, patients were 42.6 years old (SD = 13.3) and had a neck mass ranging between 2 to 4 cm (52.7%) or >4 cm (43.2%). Nearly 70% of cases were asymptomatic at presentation. Presurgical diagnosis relied on CT (63.4%), MRI (59.8%), or both (19.5%), supplemented by cytology (33.7%), which was nearly always inconclusive (96.7%). US-treated cases were significantly more likely to receive presurgical MRI than internationally treated cases but less likely to have cytology ( P < .05). Presurgical diagnosis was challenging, with only 11% confirmatory accuracy postsurgically. Irrespective of mass size, extracapsular resection (ie, complete resection with nerve sacrifice) was the most frequently (87.6%) performed surgical procedure. Common postsurgical adverse events included Horner’s syndrome (91.1%), first bite syndrome (21.1%), or both (15.7%), with higher prevalence when mass size was >4 cm. Adverse events persisted in 82.3% of cases at an average 30.0 months (SD = 30.1) follow-up time.

Implications for Practice

Given the typical CSCS patient is young and asymptomatic and the likelihood of persistent morbidity is high with standard surgical approaches, less invasive treatment options warrant consideration.

Imaging review of the temporal bone: part I. Anatomy and inflammatory and neoplastic processes

From a clinical-radiologic standpoint, there are a limited number of structures and disease entities in the temporal bone with which one must be familiar in order to proficiently interpret a computed tomographic or magnetic resonance imaging study of the temporal bone. It is helpful to examine the region in an organized and systematic fashion, going through the same checklist of key structures each time. This is the first of a two-part review that provides a practical approach to understanding temporal bone anatomy, localizing a pathologic process with a focus on inflammatory and neoplastic processes, identifying pertinent positives and negatives, and formulating a differential diagnosis.

Navigated minimally invasive presigmoidal suprabulbar infralabyrinthine approach to the jugular foramen without rerouting of the facial nerve

BACKGROUND

Jugular foramen tumors are rare and challenging lesions for skull base surgeons because of their difficult operative accessibility. Various surgical approaches to the jugular foramen have been described to overcome the morbidity of standard petrosectomy.

OBJECTIVE

To describe the surgical anatomy of a novel route to the jugular foramen without opening the fallopian canal, the navigated tailored presigmoidal suprabulbar infralabyrinthine approach.

METHODS

Ten cadaver heads were dissected under navigational guidance on both sides to examine the advantages and limitations of the presigmoidal suprabulbar infralabyrinthine approach without opening the fallopian canal. Mastoidectomy was performed by using a high-speed drill. Under navigation guidance, the sigmoid sinus, jugular bulb, posterior semicircular canal, and fallopian canal were located and preserved. The jugular foramen with the extradural part of the IXth, Xth, and XIth nerve were identified.

RESULTS

Measurements of the surgical corridor and exposed petrous bone area on high-resolution computed tomography showed that the navigated presigmoidal suprabulbar infralabyrinthine approach without opening the fallopian canal is a suitable route for extradural jugular foramen lesions with limited extension (approach height 5.59 ± 0.16 mm; approach width 7.68 ± 0.18 mm; approach surface 33.73 ± 1.37 mm; approach depth 32.92 ± 0.21 mm; vertical angle α of the surgical approach 41.3° ± 0.9°; horizontal angle β of the surgical approach 40.5° ± 0.6°).

CONCLUSION

The navigation-guided presigmoidal suprabulbar infralabyrinthine approach is a minimally invasive approach for selected lesions of the jugular foramen with preservation of the fallopian canal, labyrinthine block, and sigmoid sinus. This approach is suited for C1, De1, De2, Di1, and Di2 tumors according to the Fisch classification.

Microsurgical Management of Jugular Foramen Schwannomas

BACKGROUND:

Jugular foramen schwannomas are uncommon and surgically challenging lesions.

OBJECTIVE:

To determine the importance of surgical technique on morbidity and recurrence of jugular foramen schwannomas.

METHODS:

A retrospective review and case-control analysis of a single-senior-surgeon series of 81 patients with surgically treated jugular foramen schwannomas was performed, focusing on operative technique. Patients undergoing an aggressive, total tumor resection (series 1) were compared with those undergoing more conservative resection focusing on preserving the pars nervosa (series 2).

RESULTS:

There was a statistically significant (P = .04) decrease in permanent deficits of the cranial nerve 9/10 complex with a conservative technique. Recurrence was seen in 3 patients (5.7%) in series 1 and in 3 patients (10.7%) in series 2 (P = .36). Recurrence was treated with reoperation in 1 patient, radiation in 1 patient, and observation in the others.

CONCLUSION:

Although radical gross total resection is desirable, it is not optimal for cranial nerve preservation in patients with jugular foramen schwannomas. A more conservative approach resulted in a statistically significant decrease in lower cranial nerve deficits. There was a nonstatistically significant trend toward increasing recurrence, which may be treated with multiple modality therapy in the modern era.

Schwannoma of the Cervical Symphathetic Chain: First case report from Oman

Schwannomas are benign, encapsulated and slow-growing nerve sheath tumours arising from Schwann cells. The schwannoma arising from the cervical sympathetic chain (SCSC) is a very rare tumour. It usually presents as a slow growing, painless and asymptomatic neck mass, hence preoperative clinical diagnosis is difficult. Radiological investigation and fine needle aspiration cytology make only a small contribution to its preoperative diagnosis, histopathological examination being much more useful. We report here the first case report of SCSC from Oman. It occurred in a 45 year-old female and was successfully excised.

Dumbbell-shaped jugular foramen schwannomas: surgical management, outcome and complications on a series of 16 patients

Schwannomas of the lower cranial nerves are very rare and the dumbbell-shaped ones are even rarer. The authors report their experience in managing such lesions, usually presenting either with intra- and/or extra-cranial extension through an enlarged jugular foramen. The juxtacondylar approach without sacrificing the labyrinth was used; clinical, radiological and complication features are discussed and analysed. This is a case series study on 16 consecutive patients with lower cranial nerves schwannomas surgically managed during a 14-year period using the juxtacondylar approach. In 13 cases, a complete resection has been achieved whereas in three, the excision was near total. The tumour nerve origin has been identified only in ten cases (62.5%). No death or additional post-operative cranial nerve deficits occurred. Aspiration pneumonia developed in one patient and cerebrospinal fluid leak in another. Pre-operative lower cranial nerve deficits improved in all patients. At a mean follow-up of 6.6 years (range 2-14 years), no radiological tumour recurrence was recorded amongst the patients having complete resection as well as no tumour progression in the group of near total removal. Jugular foramen schwannomas can be radically and safely resected with no additional neurological deficit if a careful pre-operative evaluation and the appropriate surgical approach is implemented. Finally, full cranial nerve functional recovery may be expected after complete resection.

The jugular foramen schwannomas: review of the large surgical series

OBJECTIVE

Jugular foramen schwannomas are uncommon pathological conditions. This article is constituted for screening these tumors in a wide perspective.

MATERIALS

One-hundred-and-ninty-nine patients published in 19 articles between 1984 to 2007 years was collected from Medline/Index Medicus.

RESULTS

The series consist of 83 male and 98 female. The mean age of 199 operated patients was 40.4 years. The lesion located on the right side in 32 patients and on the left side in 60 patients. The most common presenting clinical symptoms were hearing loss, tinnitus, disphagia, ataxia, and hoarseness. Complete tumor removal was achieved in 159 patients. In fourteen patients tumor reappeared unexpectedly. The tumor was thought to originate from the glossopharyngeal nerve in forty seven cases; vagal nerve in twenty six cases; and cranial accessory nerve in eleven cases. The most common postoperative complications were lower cranial nerve palsy and facial nerve palsy. Cerebrospinal fluid leakage, meningitis, aspiration pneumonia and mastoiditis were seen as other complications.

CONCLUSION

This review shows that jugular foramen schwannomas still have prominently high morbidity and those complications caused by postoperative lower cranial nerve injury are life threat.

Retro-tympanic pulsatile mass originating from dumb-bell jugular foramen schwannoma

BACKGROUND

Jugular foramen (JF) tumours are uncommon with paraganglioma, schwannoma and meningioma occurring most commonly in this location. JF schwannoma with extension to the retro-tympanic area has been described only once.

METHODS

20-year-old man presented with headache, blurred vision, vomiting and diplopia.

FINDINGS

A left pulsatile retro-tympanic mass was seen at otoscopy. A jugular foramen tumour was found on CT and MR images. The intracranial portion of the tumour later diagnosed as schwannoma was removed. Control ENT examination confirmed that the residual retro-tympanic mass was no-longer pulsatile.

CONCLUSIONS

Jugular foramen schwannomas may also extend into the retro-tympanic area.

Clinical characteristics and treatment outcome for nonvestibular schwannomas of the head and neck

PURPOSE

Studies involving head and neck schwannomas have focused predominantly on involvement of the vestibulocochlear nerve complex (acoustic neuroma) because of the associated morbidity related to lesions involving that region. However, the majority of head and neck schwannomas are not of vestibular nerve origin and may also produce significant morbidity due to involvement of the orbit, skull base, and cranial nerves. The purpose of this study is to examine the presenting signs and symptoms, location, nerve of origin, and outcome after treatment of patients with nonvestibular schwannomas of the head and neck.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The medical and pathological records of all patients with nonvestibular head and neck schwannomas treated at a single institution between 1979 and 1999 were retrospectively reviewed.

RESULTS

Eighteen (69%) of 26 patients presented with symptoms secondary to mass effect or nerve deficit. The parapharyngeal space was the most common site of tumor origin occurring in 8 patients (31%). The nerve of origin was identified in 16 patients (62%). Twenty-three patients (88%) had complete surgical excision, and 3 patients (12%) had subtotal resection. Postoperative nerve injury occurred in 16 patients (62%) with resolution in 7 patients (44%).

CONCLUSIONS

Nonvestibular head and neck schwannomas occur most commonly in the parapharyngeal space, and presenting signs or symptoms are usually related to mass effect or neural deficit. Complete tumor removal is often achieved, but subtotal or near-total resection may be indicated for patients with extensive skull base, middle ear, or facial nerve involvement. Postoperative morbidity is associated with nerve injury from the surgical approach and/or resection of the involved nerve.

Surgical tactics and outcome of treatment in jugular foramen schwannomas

Seven patients with schwannomas of the jugular foramen were included our study in Samsung Medical Center between 1995 and 1999. Patients with neurofibromatosis were excluded. The records of the seven patients (six surgical case and one nonsurgical case) were retrospectively reviewed. There were six women and one man (mean age, 47 years) with a symptom duration ranging from 3 months to 14 years (mean, 47 months). The predominant symptoms were hearing difficulty, hemifacial spasm and hoarseness. Preoperative audiologic evaluation, computerised tomography (CT), magnetic resonance (MR) imaging, and angiography were performed in most patients. We classified tumours into four types using Kaye and Pellet classification on the basis of radiological and surgical findings. The tumours were: Type A (at cerebellopontine angle) in one; Type B (foraminal) in two; Type C (extracranial and/or foraminal) in two; and Type D (intra- and extracranial) in two cases. We used various surgical approaches such as retrosigmoid suboccipital craniectomy for Type A tumours, infratemporal fossa type A approach (ITFA) for Type C tumours, petro-occipital transsigmoid approach or modified transcochear approach for Type D tumours and ITFA with partial labyrinthectomy for Type B. In the selection of surgical approaches, we took consideration of tumour extension, tumour size, and preoperative hearing function. Facial nerve transposition was not used only in one case of ITFA because of small tumour size (1.5cm). Gross total removal was achieved in five cases, and subtotal removal in one case (Type D tumour) with a single-stage operation. Stereotactic radiosurgery was performed on residual mass in the subtotally removed case. Follow-up period ranged from 13 to 49 months (mean, 27.5 months). There was neither postoperative mortality nor recurrence on follow-up MR imaging. There were two cases of temporary facial nerve palsy and one aggravation of pre-existing low cranial palsy. Two case of sustained vocal cord palsy underwent thyroplasty, but there was no aspiration pneumonia. Persistent cerebrospinal fluid collection was improved with lumboperitoneal shunt. The surgical approaches of each case should be tailored according to their shape and the clinical manifestation. We obtain acceptable outcomes from one-stage operation.

The Department of Neurosurgery at Seoul National University: past, present, and future

The Department of Neurosurgery at Seoul National University College of Medicine is one of the oldest neurosurgical departments in Korea, and it is a center of academic leadership in neurosurgery. In September 1957, the department was established by Bo Sung Sim, and it has produced many leaders of neurosurgery in Korea. Chairmen Bo Sung Sim, Kil Soo Choi, Dae Hee Han, and Byung-Kyu Cho each brought special skills and talents to the development of the department. The current and fifth chair, Hyun Jib Kim, assumed the chairmanship in July 2000. The department comprises 11 full-time faculty members, 5 fellows, and 14 residents. More than 1,700 neurosurgical procedures are performed annually in four operating theaters. A gamma knife was installed in 1997, and approximately 200 gamma knife procedures are performed each year. In addition to clinical activities, research and education for graduate and postgraduate students are also particular strengths of the department. This article traces the clinical, academic, and scientific development of the department, its present activities, and its future direction.