Interferon alfa plus chemotherapy for non-Hodgkin's lymphoma: five-year follow-up

Recombinant interferon-alpha2b added to oral cyclophosphamide either as induction or maintenance in treatment-naive follicular lymphoma: final analysis of CALGB 8691

Recombinant interferon alpha-2b (IFN-alpha2) has direct and indirect antiproliferative effects in lymphoma, and may augment cytotoxicity when combined with chemotherapy. CALGB 8691 is a randomized study of daily oral cyclophosphamide (CPA) at 100 mg/m2 with or without IFN-alpha2 at 2 x 106 IU/m2 three times per week, followed by a second randomization between IFN-alpha2 maintenance (2 x 106 IU/m2 three times weekly) versus observation in treatment-naïve patients with follicular lymphoma (FL). Five hundred eighty-one patients were randomized to either CPA (n = 293) or CPA plus IFN-alpha2 (n = 288). One hundred five responding patients were randomized to observation and 99 to maintenance IFN-alpha2. With a median follow-up of 11.5 years, the median event-free and overall survival (OS) for CPA induction alone were 2.5 years (95% CI 2.2, 3.0) and 9 years (95% CI 7.7, 10.2), compared to 2.4 years (95% CI 2.1, 3.1) and 8.4 years (95% CI 7.5, 11.1) for the combination arm (p = NS). Patients with a partial response (PR) and randomized to observation had the worst outcome (event-free survival (EFS) 1.8 years versus 3.9 years; p = 0.002). Patients with a PR randomized to IFN-alpha2 had a similar EFS to compared to patients with complete response (CR), but this did not translate into a survival advantage. Myelosuppression was increased in IFN-alpha2-containing arms. Despite the small benefit in EFS in patients with PR randomized to IFN-alpha2 maintenance, we conclude that the addition of low dose IFN-alpha2 did not significantly improve the response rate, duration of response, event-free, or OS obtained with single-agent daily oral CPA in patients with previously untreated FL.

Follicular lymphoma: a historical overview

Lymphoma was first described in 1862 and follicular lymphoma in 1925. Initially considered a benign disorder, and named Brill - Symmers disease after the authors of the original papers, it was rapidly recognized as a malignancy with a variable but often indolent course. Most of its clinical features were described by the early 1940s. Despite discussion about its cell of origin, and in contrast to many other lymphoma subtypes, follicular lymphoma could always be accurately recognized and diagnosed using light microscopy morphological features. B-cell origin was demonstrated in the 1970s and the important role of t(14;18) and bcl-2 gene rearrangement in the pathogenesis of follicular lymphoma was established shortly thereafter. The etiology of follicular lymphoma, the reason for marked geographic variation in its incidence, the role of alternative molecular pathways in its pathogenesis, and the cause for its variable clinical behavior all remain unknown. Several observations suggest an important role for the normal immune response in regulating the clinical behavior of follicular lymphoma. From the earliest descriptions, radiation therapy was shown to be very effective in follicular lymphoma, but not curative. Combination chemotherapy was tested in the 1970s, but despite high rates of response, there was only minimal impact on survival. Interferon combined with anthracycline based chemotherapy was the first treatment to improve survival, but was not widely adopted in the USA. Randomized studies have shown an impact of autologous transplantation on progression free survival. Allogeneic transplantation is a curative therapy, but is too toxic for widespread application. Targeted therapies, particularly rituximab have revolutionized the treatment of follicular lymphoma. A convergence of technological and biological advances will likely lead to further dramatic progress in the next decade. For the first time consistent improvements in survival of follicular lymphoma are reported.

Meta-Analysis to Evaluate the Role of Interferon in Follicular Lymphoma

Purpose

To determine whether interferon (IFN) -α2, when given with or following chemotherapy, influences response rate, remission duration, and survival in newly diagnosed patients with follicular lymphoma.

Patients and Methods

Ten phase III studies evaluating the role of IFN-α2 in 1,922 newly diagnosed patients with follicular lymphoma were analyzed. Updated individual patient data were used to perform meta-analyses for response, survival, and remission duration.

Results

The addition of IFN-α2 to initial chemotherapy did not significantly influence response rate. An overall meta-analysis for survival showed a significant difference in favor of IFN-α2, but also showed significant heterogeneity between studies. Further analyses were carried out in order to explain this heterogeneity, and to define the circumstances in which IFN-α2 prolonged survival. The survival advantage was seen when IFN-α2 was given: (1) in conjunction with relatively intensive initial chemotherapy (2P = .00005), (2) at a dose ≥ 5 million units (2P = .000002), (3) at a cumulative dose ≥ 36 million units per month (2P = .000008), and (4) with chemotherapy rather than as maintenance therapy (P = .004). With regard to remission duration, there was also a significant difference in favor of IFN-α2, irrespective of the intensity of chemotherapy used, IFN dose, or whether IFN was given as a maintenance strategy or with chemotherapy.

Conclusion

When given in the context of relatively intensive initial chemotherapy, and at a dose ≥ 5 million units (≥ 36 × 106 units per month), IFN-α2 prolongs survival and remission duration in patients with follicular lymphoma.

Phase II study of autologous transplantation with interleukin-2-incubated peripheral blood stem cells and posttransplantation interleukin-2 in relapsed or refractory non-Hodgkin lymphoma

Previous work suggested that interleukin (IL)-2 can be used for eradicating residual disease in autologous grafts and for preventing recurrence. We report a phase II study of autologous peripheral blood stem cell transplantation with in vitro IL-2 incubation of peripheral blood stem cells and posttransplantation IL-2 in patients with recurrent or refractory non-Hodgkin lymphoma. Salvage chemotherapy consisted of ifosfamide and etoposide. Responding patients underwent autologous peripheral blood stem cell transplantation. IL-2-incubated stem cells were infused on day 0. IL-2 1 mIU/m2 was given from day 1 until day 28. Four monthly maintenance cycles of IL-2 4 mIU/m2 subcutaneously twice daily days 1 to 5 and days 8 to 11 were administered thereafter. Eighty-four evaluable patients were enrolled, and 60 proceeded to transplantation, of which 56 received IL-2-incubated stem cells. The average received dose of posttransplantation IL-2 was 30% to 50% of planned. Only 42 patients received maintenance IL-2. The average received maintenance dose of IL-2 was also approximately 30% of planned. Most dose reductions were due to toxicity or patient refusal. Three-year survival and progression-free survival for all registered patients were 43% (95% confidence interval [CI], 33%-53%) and 31% (95% CI, 21%-41%), respectively. For the 60 patients undergoing transplantation, they were 59% (95% CI, 46%-72%) and 44% (95% CI, 31%-57%), respectively. There was no relation between the dose of IL-2 received and outcome. Survival and disease-free survival of the study group were similar to those of a previous study cohort that received unmanipulated stem cells and no systemic IL-2. Administration of IL-2-incubated peripheral blood stem cells and intensive posttransplantation IL-2 was associated with considerable but rapidly reversible toxicity. No effect on long-term outcome was observed.

A randomized controlled trial to evaluate the role of interferon as initial and maintenance therapy in patients with follicular lymphoma

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the role of interferon as initial and maintenance therapy in patients with newly diagnosed follicular lymphoma. Between 1984 and 1994, 204 patients with newly diagnosed Stage III or Stage IV follicular lymphoma were randomized to receive either, Chlorambucil (CB): 10 mg daily for 6 weeks, followed by a 2-week interval, with 3 subsequent 2-week treatment periods at the same dose, separated by 2-week intervals, or, CB given concurrently with interferon (IFN). IFN was given at a dose of 3 x 10(6)units thrice weekly, subcutaneously, throughout the 18-week treatment period. Responding patients were subsequently randomized to receive maintenance IFN at the dose and schedule described above, or to expectant management. The overall response rate was 161/204 (78%), complete remission being achieved in 24% of patients. Neither the addition of IFN to the initial treatment, nor the use of maintenance IFN influenced response rate, remission duration or survival. This study was undertaken to determine whether IFN, given in combination with, and then subsequent to, CB would alter the clinical course of patients with follicular lymphoma. Disappointingly, this objective was not achieved, no advantage having been demonstrated for the addition of IFN.

Final analysis of the ECOG I-COPA trial (E6484) in patients with non-Hodgkin's lymphoma treated with interferon alfa (IFN-alpha2a) plus an anthracycline-based induction regimen

The Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group (ECOG) performed a prospectively randomized study (E6484) evaluating the use of interferon alfa 2a (IFN-alpha2a) in patients with aggressive low-grade or with intermediate-grade non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL) accruing close to 300 patients between 1985 and 1988. Patients were eligible for study if they had bulky or symptomatic low-grade lymphoma or defined intermediate-grade subtypes. Of 291 patients enrolled, 249 were eligible for analysis. All patients were randomized to receive a four-drug cytotoxic chemotherapy regimen including cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, vincristine and prednisone in 4-week cycles with or without IFN-alpha2a in addition (COPA vs I-COPA). Treatment was given for up to 8-10 months. This report, at a time when the median follow-up among survivors has reached 12 years, updates the analysis of time to treatment failure (TTF), duration of disease-free survival (DFS), and overall survival. Patients randomized to receive IFN-alpha2a had a prolonged TTF (P= 0.008; median 2.4 vs 1.6 years). DFS for those patients who had complete responses was also longer if IFN-alpha2a had been given (P = 0.035; median 2.7 vs 1.8 years). There was a clinically but not a statistically significant prolongation of overall survival by IFN-alpha2a (P= 0.107; median 7.8 vs 5.7 years). There were fewer deaths over time due to lymphoma in patients receiving IFN-alpha2a (67 vs 80 deaths). A subset analysis, based on disease histology (low-grade, follicular, intermediate-grade), revealed a significant prolongation of TTF in patients receiving IFN-alpha2a with either low-grade (P = 0.002; median 2.4 vs 1.6 years) or follicular (P= 0.01; median 2.5 vs 1.7 years) NHL but not intermediate grade (P = 0.622; median 2.3 vs 1.6 years) NHL. This analysis, performed approximately 12 years after closure of the study to accrual, supports the addition of interferon alfa to an induction cytotoxic chemotherapy regimen including cyclophosphamide and doxorubicin in the treatment of follicular NHL.

Cost-Effectiveness of interferon alfa-2b added to chemotherapy for high-tumor-burden follicular non-Hodgkin's lymphoma

Recent data from GELF (Groupe d'Etude des Lymphomes Folliculaires) have shown that the addition of interferon alfa-2b (IFN) to a doxorubicin-containing regimen (CHVP: cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, teniposide and prednisone) prolongs both progression-free survival and overall survival in high-tumor-burden follicular non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. This gain must be weighed against the incremental toxicity and cost of IFN over CHVP alone and the objective here was, to determine the marginal cost-effectiveness of additive IFN in the specific setting of high-tumor-burden follicular non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. Meta-analysis of GELF trial results employing a Markov model was used with three health states: No Progression, Progressive Disease, and Death. Treatment response, survival and toxicity data are drawn from the GELF study. The current study is based on the final analysis of 242 patients (J Clin Oncol 1998;16:2332-2338), with a six year median follow-up for overall survival (median overall survival: not reached for CHVP + IFN vs 5.6 years for CHVP Only, p = 0.008).

MEASUREMENTS

Quality of life data (utilities) are taken from studies with similar dosing of IFN, from Q-TwiST (quality adjusted time without symptoms or toxicity) analysis of the GELF data and from a panel of experts gathered to develop treatment models for high-tumor-burden follicular non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. Costs and quality-adjusted years of life saved were discounted at 3% per annum.

SETTING

Costs determined for university medical centers in the United States. Results showed that, at the median cohort age of 52, IFN add 9.9 quality-adjusted months at an added cost of $13,900 (marginal cost-effectiveness of $16,900 per quality-adjusted life year, or QALY). A more complex, two-stage model approximates the actual cohort survival curves much better than a simple, one-stage model, but both models yield essentially the same marginal cost-effectiveness. Sensitivity analysis to quality of life on IFN shows marginal cost-effectiveness ranging from $15,200/QALY (no penalty for IFN) to $21,300/QALY (20% quality adjustment, greater than that reported). The model is quite insensitive to the probability of IFN toxicity. The model is moderately sensitive to the efficacy of IFN in delaying progression, particularly in the first 18 months (pProgI), but the marginal cost-effectiveness does not rise to $50,000/QALY until pProgI increases 220% from the baseline. Although the model is moderately sensitive to the cost of IFN (cIFN), marginal cost-effectiveness is below $50,000/QALY for values of cIFN below $2580/month (baseline cIFN = $850/month, corresponding to a marginal cost-effectiveness of $16,900/QALY in the baseline case). If the model is modified to reflect the 14% overall survival advantage at five years found in trials utilizing more intensive initial chemotherapy (including the GELF trial), then the marginal cost-effectiveness drops to $11,900/QALY in the baseline case. In condusion, based on data from the GELF study, low-dose interferon alfa-2b is cost-effective when added to CHVP therapy in the treatment of high-tumor-burden follicular non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. The analysis is robust: the model employs very conservative assumptions, and additive IFN remains cost-effective over wide ranges of variables in sensitivity analyses. The marginal cost-effectiveness is best expressed as being in the range of $12,000/QALY to $17,000/QALY in the baseline case. A simple Markov model can be used to describe treatment regimens with distinct periods of therapy.

A prospective randomized study of Chop versus Chop plus alpha-2B interferon in patients with intermediate and high grade non-Hodgkin's lymphoma: the International Oncology Study Group NHL1 Study

The addition of a brief alpha interferon regimen to each CHOP induction cycle, plus one year of alpha interferon thrice weekly maintenance therapy, has no early effect on response rates or survival in patients with Intermediate or High grade cell NHL.

BACKGROUND

The CHOP (Cyclophosphamide, Adriamycin. Vincristine, Prednisone) regimen is the most widely used first-line therapy for patients with Intermediate or High Grade (IG/HG) non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL). Alpha 2b interferon (INF) enhances response rates and improves survival in low-grade NHL. The International Oncology Study Group (IOSG) conducted a prospective randomized study comparing CHOP alone or combined with INF in patients with IG/HG-NHL. The primary study aim was to compare the objective response rates in these patient cohorts.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Patients with a confirmed diagnosis of measurable NHL of International Working Formulation (IWF) groups D to H histology were randomized to receive CHOP alone or CHOP with 5Mu INF s.c. for 5 days on days 22 to 26 of each 28 day cycle with INF 5 million units (Mu) given three times per week subcutaneously for 52 weeks in those patients who responded to CHOP plus INF.

RESULTS

The overall response rates were equivalent in both groups: CHOP alone (214 patients) 81% (complete 55%, partial 26%); CHOP plus INF (221 patients) 80% (complete 54%, partial 26%). At 36 months, the actuarial survival rate was equivalent in both groups.

CONCLUSIONS

There is no apparent early advantage in terms of response or survival conferred by adding the study INF regimen to CHOP therapy for patients with IG/HG-NHL.

Follicular lymphomas--a review of treatment modalities

Follicular lymphoma is the most common low-grade non Hodgkin's lymphoma and represent an homogeneous entity as defined by pathological, molecular and clinical data. This indolent disease is characterised by a slow growth pattern with possible spontaneous regression, is often disseminated but remains incurable with available treatments when disseminated. For localised stages, involved field radiotherapy remains the standard choice but other approaches remain to be investigated. In advanced disease, chemotherapy has been demonstrated to produce high response rates but recent trials with new treatment strategies including interferon and monoclonal antibodies may improve the current situation. In this article, we will review treatment of follicular lymphomas, specially emphasising published phase III trials.

Novel biologic approaches to hematologic malignancies

Biologic agents have made a major impact on the treatment of hematologic malignancies and will continue to play a major role as we better understand their function in normal and malignant cell regulation. The examples provided in this chapter are a brief introduction to the potential of these agents. Many have yet to be used in conjunction with current cytotoxic therapy in these diseases, and perhaps combinations will prove even more successful. This possibility provides substantial ground for further investigation and therapy.

Non-Hodgkin lymphoma: A urological case with retroperitoneal localisation. Retrospective study and literature review

Urological involvement by a non-Hodgkin lymphoma, once rare, is becoming more frequent. A clinical case is described where the urological onset was a volumetric increase in the lumbar-aortic lymph nodes and functional exclusion of the left kidney. Having ascertained the lymphomatous nature of the mass, chemotherapy cycles were carried out (CVP) and ureteral stenting to conserve renal function.

The role of interferon in the therapy of malignant lymphoma

As a single agent, interferon-alpha (IFN-alpha) can induce remissions, mostly partial, in a large fraction of patients with indolent lymphomas, including the low grade B-cell lymphomas and cutaneous T-cell lymphoma. In aggressive lymphomas, IFN has minimal activity, and in Hodgkin's disease the limited available experience suggests only modest activity. In indolent B-cell lymphomas, IFN has been integrated with chemotherapy in several large trials: the majority of these trials indicate a favorable impact on failure-free survival; a survival benefit of IFN has been reported by the French-Belgian group. Updated results are now available from a previously reported trial from the MD Anderson Cancer Center that also indicate an apparent survival benefit when IFN is used in conjunction with chemotherapy in patients with indolent B-cell lymphoma.

Non-Hodgkin's lymphoma

Lymphoid neoplasia is a complex area comprising multiple diseases with varied pathology, treatment, and outcome. The non-Hodgkin's lymphomas are reviewed here. Non-Hodgkin's lymphomas, collectively, represent the sixth most common cancer in the United States as well as the sixth most common cause of cancer deaths. The overall incidence of non-Hodgkin's lymphoma has risen steadily over the past four decades. Although some of this is attributable to human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-associated lymphoma, HIV-associated disease accounts for only a small part of the increase in lymphoma. As our knowledge of normal as well as neoplastic lymphoid development has expanded on the basis of histopathology as well as adjunct cellular and molecular techniques, multiple classifications have been proposed to take these into account. The clinical relevance to our understanding of non-Hodgkin's lymphoma is the concept that various lymphoid cancers are counterparts of stages of normal lymphoid development. Stages of lymphoid development in terms of cell surface markers and immunoglobulin gene rearrangements have been well characterized. These are particularly applicable to the early B-cell development, which is antigen-independent and occurs in the bone marrow. Diseases correlating with these stages are largely acute lymphocytic and lymphoblastic leukemia/lymphoma and high-grade lymphomas, such as Burkitt's lymphomas. Much has been learned recently about subsequent antigen-dependent B-cell development in secondary lymphoid organs to improve our understanding of the corresponding stages of B-cell neoplasia. Many of these stages correlate with more recently described entities such as mantle cell and marginal zone lymphomas. Histologic study remains crucial in determining the subtype of NHLs, whereas immunohistochemistry, surface phenotype, and molecular studies are useful in selected cases. Although some lymphoma classifications may be better in terms of understanding the lymphoma biology, the working formulation remains useful to guide clinical decision making. Lymphomas classified as low grade are considered incurable with standard therapy when diagnosed, as is usual, at advanced stages. Different subtypes may have different median survivals, but the goal has typically been palliation, whereas experimental approaches are clearly needed. Intermediate and high-grade lymphomas are potentially curable with aggressive combination chemotherapy. Recent evidence suggests that CHOP chemotherapy is as effective as more complex regimens. Still, 40% to 50% of patients are cured. Prognostic factor analysis has allowed separation of subgroups with much better survival in whom CHOP is adequate versus those with much poorer survival in whom experimental approaches are rational. Additional subtypes of lymphomas have been described and characterized since the working formulation was developed, including mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue tumors (MALT-oma), mantle zone lymphoma, anaplastic large cell lymphoma and AILD-like T-cell lymphoma. Approaches to these entities are still being optimized. Newer approaches, including high-dose therapy with stem cell support, biologic agents, and newer chemotherapeutic agents are discussed, as are special situations such as localized lymphoma of certain sites and lymphoma in immunosuppressed patients.

Cytokines in the pathophysiology and treatment of chronic B-cell malignancies. A review

Chronic B-cell malignancies are characterized by accumulation of transformed B cells of low proliferative index in lymphatic and extralymphatic tissues. Cytokines do not appear to play a role in the primary step of transformation. However, proliferation as well as inhibition of apoptosis of malignant B cells can readily be explained by cytokine effects. Clinical trials of interferons (IFN) and interleukin-2 alone or in combination have been performed in patients with hairy cell leukemia (HCL), CLL, and low- and intermediate-grade non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. While IFN alpha became standard therapy of HCL, responses in other entities were variable, ranging from 0 to 70% in selected populations. Combination of IFN and cytotoxic chemotherapy in general revealed no additional benefit as compared to chemotherapy alone. Perspectives for future clinical testing of cytokines in low-grade B-cell lymphomas are discussed.

Current status and future perspectives in the treatment of low-grade non-Hodgkin's lymphomas

Low-grade non-Hodgkin lymphomas (NHL) comprise a heterogeneous group of disorders both in terms of their cellular and histological composition as well as in terms of their clinical course. The most usually applied classification systems, the Working Formulation and the Kiel classification as well as the recently proposed Revised European American Lymphoma classification, discriminate between low-, intermediate- and high-grade subtypes. In general, low-grade NHL are characterized by a low to moderate proliferative activity and a long clinical course with median survival times ranging from approximately 3 years for centrocytic (CC) or mantle-cell lymphomas (MCL) to 5-8 years for centroblastic-centrocytic (CB-CC) or follicular lymphomas (FL). Recent cytogenetic and molecular biologic analyses indicate that these differences may result from distinct genetic abnormalities such as the translocation t(14;18), which is frequently observed in FL-NHL and is associated with a bcl-2 overexpression and inhibition of apoptosis, or the deregulation of PRAD1 in MCL-NHL induced by the translocation t(11;14). Therapy of low-grade lymphomas depends mainly on the extent of the disease. In the early stages I and II, at which approximately 15 to 20% of low-grade NHL are diagnosed, radiotherapy may be applied with curative intention. The treatment of patients with more advanced stages III and IV is controversial. The currently available information justifies a conservative approach of observing the natural course of the disease until therapeutic intervention is required due to the occurrence of B-symptoms, hematopoietic insufficiency or lymphoma progression.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)