Tafenoquine versus Primaquine to Prevent Relapse of Plasmodium vivax Malaria

Genotype-phenotype association and biochemical analyses of glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase variants: Implications for the hemolytic risk of using 8-aminoquinolines for radical cure

Background: Plasmodium vivax remains the malaria species posing a major threat to human health worldwide owing to its relapse mechanism. Currently, the only drugs of choice for radical cure are the 8-aminoquinolines (primaquine and tafenoquine), which are capable of killing hypnozoites and thus preventing P. vivax relapse. However, the therapeutic use of primaquine and tafenoquine is restricted because these drugs can cause hemolysis in individuals with glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) deficiency. This study aimed to assess and understand the hemolytic risk of using 8-aminoquinolines for radical treatment in a malaria endemic area of Thailand. Methods: The prevalence of G6PD deficiency was determined using a quantitative test in 1,125 individuals. Multiplexed high-resolution meltinging (HRM) assays were developed and applied to detect 12 G6PD mutations. Furthermore, biochemical and structural characterization of G6PD variants was carried out to understand the molecular basis of enzyme deficiency. Results: The prevalence of G6PD deficiency was 6.76% (76/1,125), as assessed by a phenotypic test. Multiplexed HRM assays revealed G6PD Mahidol in 15.04% (77/512) of males and 28.38% (174/613) of females, as well as G6PD Aures in one female. G6PD activity above the 30% cut-off was detected in those carrying G6PD Mahidol, even in hemizygous male individuals. Two variants, G6PD Murcia Oristano and G6PD Songklanagarind + Viangchan, were identified for the first time in Thailand. Biochemical characterization revealed that structural instability is the primary cause of enzyme deficiency in G6PD Aures, G6PD Murcia Oristano, G6PD Songklanagarind + Viangchan, and G6PD Chinese 4 + Viangchan, with double G6PD mutations causing more severe enzyme deficiency. Conclusion: In western Thailand, up to 22% of people may be ineligible for radical cure. Routine qualitative tests may be insufficient for G6PD testing, so quantitative tests should be implemented. G6PD genotyping should also be used to confirm G6PD status, especially in female individuals suspected of having G6PD deficiency. People with double G6PD mutations are more likely to have hemolysis than are those with single G6PD mutations because the double mutations significantly reduce the catalytic activity as well as the structural stability of the protein.

Eficacia de la tafenoquina en la profilaxis y tratamiento de la malaria por Plasmodium vivax, revisión sistemática y metaanálisis

Introducción.

La tafenoquina fue aprobada en el 2018 por la Food and Drug Administration de Estados Unidos y, en el 2019, por la Therapeutic Goods Administration en Australia. Su administración en dosis única y su mecanismo de acción en las fases aguda y latente han sido objeto de estudio para cambiar el esquema de tratamiento de la malaria por Plasmodium vivax.

Objetivo.

Evaluar la evidencia científica disponible sobre la eficacia de la tafenoquina en la profilaxis y el tratamiento de la malaria por P. vivax, entre el 2009 y el 2019.

Materiales y métodos.

Se establecieron los descriptores MeSH y DeCS. Se utilizó la sintaxis ((Malaria Vivax) AND (tafenoquine) AND (prophylaxis)) OR [(Malaria Vivax) AND (tafenoquine) AND (relapse)] en las siguientes bases de datos: Pubmed, The Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Clinical Trials (CENTRAL), ISIS Web of Science, Lilacs y Scopus. Los resultados obtenidos se sometieron a análisis crítico (matriz CASPE). El análisis cuantitativo se realizó utilizando la diferencia de riesgos en análisis de supervivencia (Kaplan-Meier) en los tres artículos finales.

Resultados.

Se sometieron tres estudios a metaanálisis (Llanos-Cuentas, 2014; Llanos- Cuentas, 2019, y Lacerda, 2019) para evaluar la eficacia del tratamiento con tafenoquina en comparación con primaquina. Se obtuvo una diferencia de riesgo global de 0,04 (IC95% 0-0,08; p=0,07). La tafenoquina no mostró inferioridad en la eficacia del tratamiento frente al esquema de primaquina.

Conclusión.

La tafenoquina es una alternativa que mejora el cumplimiento del tratamiento, lo que podría acercar a Colombia a las metas de la Estrategia Técnica Mundial contra la Malaria, 2016-2030.

Impact of CYP2D6 Genetic Variation on Radical Cure of Plasmodium vivax Malaria

Plasmodium vivax (P. vivax) is the most widespread human malaria parasite, with 2.5 billion people at risk of infection worldwide. P. vivax forms liver hypnozoites, which trigger further symptomatic episodes (relapses) weeks or months after the initial episode. Radical cure of vivax malaria requires hypnozoitocide therapy to prevent relapses. The two US Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved hypnozoiticides for human use, primaquine, and tafenoquine, are pro-drugs, that require in vivo conversion into metabolites with redox activity. This mini-review focuses on the association between CYP2D6-mediated hydroxylation and hypnozoitocide efficacy of primaquine and tafenoquine. Studies in murine models show that the antimalarial activity of primaquine and tafenoquine is abolished by CYP2D knock-out and partially restored by knock-in of humanized CYP2D6. Human studies explored the impact of CYP2D6 genetic variation and genotype-inferred CYP2D6 phenotype on anti-relapse efficacy. Most, but not all, studies with primaquine report higher rates of relapse in patients with decreased CYP2D6 activity (activity scores (AS) ≤ 1) compared to normal activity (AS ≥ 1.5). Potential factors for discordance among studies include risk of reinfection in endemic areas, adherence to primaquine-treatment, assignment of CYP2D6 phenotypes based on CYP2D6 polymorphism and choice of AS values for dichotomizing the study cohorts. Tafenoquine anti-relapse efficacy did not differ between patients with AS < 1 vs. AS ≥ 1.5 in 2 studies. Absence/small number of poor CYP2D6 metabolizers in AS ≤ 1 groups, combined with lesser dependence of tafenoquine on CYP2D6-mediated conversion into active redox metabolites may account for this result. Additional tafenoquine studies with larger representation of poor CYP2D6 metabolizers are warranted.

Functional and structural analysis of double and triple mutants reveals the contribution of protein instability to clinical manifestations of G6PD variants

Glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) deficiency is the most common polymorphism and enzymopathy in humans, affecting approximately 400 million people worldwide. Over 200 point mutations have been identified in g6pd and the molecular mechanisms underlying the severity of G6PD variants differ. We report the detailed functional and structural characterization of 11 recombinant human G6PD variants: G6PD Asahi, G6PD A, G6PD Guadalajara, G6PD Acrokorinthos, G6PD Ananindeua, G6PD A-(202), G6PD Sierra Leone, G6PD A-(680), G6PD A-(968), G6PD Mount Sinai and G6PD No name. G6PD Guadalajara, G6PD Mount Sinai and G6PD No name are inactive variants and, correlating with the observed clinical manifestations, exhibit complete loss of enzyme activity. Protein structural instability, causing a reduction in catalytic efficiency, contributes to the clinical phenotypes of all variants. In double and triple mutants sharing the G6PD A mutation, we observed cooperative interaction between two and three mutations to cause protein dysfunction. The G6PD A (Asn126Asp) mutation exhibits no effect on protein activity and stability, indicating that the additional mutations in these G6PD variants significantly contribute to enzyme deficiency. We provide insight into the molecular basis of G6PD deficiency, which can explain the severity of clinical manifestations observed in individuals with G6PD deficiency.