Molecular crowding effect on dynamics of DNA-binding proteins search for their targets

Influence of Nonspecific Interactions between Proteins and In Vivo Cytoplasmic Crowders in Facilitated Diffusion of Proteins: Theoretical Insights

The binding of proteins to their respective specific sites on the DNA through facilitated diffusion serves as the initial step of various important biological processes. While this search process has been thoroughly investigated via in vitro studies, the cellular environment is complex and may interfere with the protein's search dynamics. The cytosol is heavily crowded, which can potentially modify the search by nonspecifically interacting with the protein that has been mostly overlooked. In this work, we probe the target search dynamics in the presence of explicit crowding agents that have an affinity toward the protein. We theoretically investigate the role of such protein-crowder associations in the target search process using a discrete-state stochastic framework that allows for the analytical description of dynamic properties. It is found that stronger nonspecific associations between the crowder and proteins can accelerate the facilitated diffusion of proteins in comparison with a purely inert, rather weakly interacting cellular environment. This effect depends on how strong these associations are, the spatial positions of the target with respect to the crowders, and the size of the crowded region. Our theoretical results are also tested with Monte Carlo computer simulations. Our predictions are in qualitative agreement with existing experimental observations and computational studies.

Disparity in anomalous diffusion of proteins searching for their target DNA sites in a crowded medium is controlled by the size, shape and mobility of macromolecular crowders

Using extensive computer simulations, we analyzed the role of physical properties of molecular crowding agents such as size, shape and mobility in the target search dynamics of DNA binding proteins. Our main result is that the sub-diffusive dynamics of a protein inside a crowded medium strongly depends on the crowder properties and also on the protein's mode of diffusion. For instance, while scanning the DNA one-dimensionally, the protein dynamics does not vary with the change in crowder properties. Conversely, the diffusion exponent varies non-monotonically during 3D diffusion and is maximally affected when the crowders match the protein physically. The investigation shows that the effect stems from the ruggedness of the associated potential energy landscape, which is regulated by the protein-crowder and DNA-crowder interactions. Our findings have broad significance in understanding the target search dynamics of proteins on DNA in crowded cellular milieu and selecting appropriate crowding agents when designing in vitro experiments.

Intersegmental transfer of proteins between DNA regions in the presence of crowding

Intersegmental transfer that involves direct relocation of a DNA-binding protein from one nonspecific DNA site to another was previously shown to contribute to speeding up the identification of the DNA target site. This mechanism is promoted when the protein is composed of at least two domains that have different DNA binding affinities and thus show a degree of mobility. In this study, we investigate the effect of particle crowding on the ability of a multi-domain protein to perform intersegmental transfer. We show that although crowding conditions often favor 1D diffusion of proteins along DNA over 3D diffusion, relocation of one of the tethered domains to initiate intersegmental transfer is possible even under crowding conditions. The tendency to perform intersegmental transfer by a multi-domain protein under crowding conditions is much higher for larger crowding particles than smaller ones and can be even greater than under no-crowding conditions. We report that the asymmetry of the two domains is even magnified by the crowders. The observations that crowding supports intersegmental transfer serve as another example that in vivo complexity does not necessarily slow down DNA search kinetics by proteins.

Role of Macromolecular Crowding on the Intracellular Diffusion of DNA Binding Proteins

Recent experiments suggest that cellular crowding facilitates the target search dynamics of proteins on DNA, the mechanism of which is not yet known. By using large scale computer simulations, we show that two competing factors, namely the width of the depletion layer that separates the crowder cloud from the DNA molecule and the degree of protein-crowder crosstalk, act in harmony to affect the target search dynamics of proteins. The impacts vary from nonspecific to specific target search regime. During a nonspecific search, dynamics of a protein is only minimally affected, whereas, a significantly different behaviour is observed when the protein starts forming a specific protein-DNA complex. We also find that the severity of impacts largely depends upon physiological crowder concentration and deviation from it leads to attenuation in the binding kinetics. Based on extensive kinetic study and binding energy landscape analysis, we further present a comprehensive molecular description of the search process that allows us to interpret the experimental findings.

Facilitated diffusion in the presence of obstacles on the DNA

Biological functions of DNA depend on the sequence-specific binding of DNA-binding proteins to their corresponding binding sites. Binding of these proteins to their binding sites occurs through a facilitated diffusion process that combines three-dimensional diffusion in the cytoplasm with one-dimensional diffusion (sliding) along the DNA. In this work, we use a lattice model of facilitated diffusion to study how the dynamics of binding of a protein to a specific site (e.g., binding of an RNA polymerase to a promoter or of a transcription factor to its operator site) is affected by the presence of other proteins bound to the DNA, which act as 'obstacles' in the sliding process. Different types of these obstacles with different dynamics are implemented. While all types impair facilitated diffusion, the extent of the hindrance depends on the type of obstacle. As a consequence of hindrance by obstacles, more excursions into the cytoplasm are required for optimal target binding compared to the case without obstacles.

How nonspecifically DNA-binding proteins search for the target in crowded environments

We investigate how a tracer particle searches a target located in DNA modeled by a stiff chain in crowded environments using theoretical analysis and Langevin dynamics simulations. First, we show that the three-dimensional (3D) diffusion coefficient of the tracer only depends on the density of crowders ϕ, while its one-dimensional (1D) diffusion coefficient is affected by not only ϕ but also the nonspecific binding energy ε. With increasing ϕ and ε, no obvious change in the average 3D diffusion time is observed, while the average 1D sliding time apparently increases. We propose theoretically that the 1D sliding of the tracer along the chain could be well captured by the Kramers' law of escaping rather than the Arrhenius law, which is verified directly by the simulations. Finally, the average search time increases monotonously with an increase in ϕ while it has a minimum as a function of ε, which could be understood from the different behaviors of the average number of search rounds with the increasing ϕ or ε. These results provide a deeper understanding of the role of facilitated diffusion in target search of proteins on DNA in vivo.

Rad4 recognition-at-a-distance: Physical basis of conformation-specific anomalous diffusion of DNA repair proteins

Since Robert Brown's first observations of random walks by pollen particles suspended in solution, the concept of diffusion has been subject to countless theoretical and experimental studies in diverse fields from finance and social sciences, to physics and biology. Diffusive transport of macromolecules in cells is intimately linked to essential cellular functions including nutrient uptake, signal transduction, gene expression, as well as DNA replication and repair. Advancement in experimental techniques has allowed precise measurements of these diffusion processes. Mathematical and physical descriptions and computer simulations have been applied to model complicated biological systems in which anomalous diffusion, in addition to simple Brownian motion, was observed. The purpose of this review is to provide an overview of the major physical models of anomalous diffusion and corresponding experimental evidence on the target search problem faced by DNA-binding proteins, with an emphasis on DNA repair proteins and the role of anomalous diffusion in DNA target recognition.

Crowding on DNA in Protein Search for Targets

Proteins searching and recognizing specific sites on DNA is required for initiating all major biological processes. While the details of the protein search for targets on DNA in purified in vitro systems are reasonably well understood, the situation in real cells is much less clear. The presence of other types of molecules on DNA should prevent reaching the targets, but experiments show that, surprisingly, the molecular crowding on DNA influences the search dynamics much less than expected. We develop a theoretical method that allowed us to clarify the mechanisms of the protein search on DNA in the presence of crowding. It is found that the dimensionality of the search trajectories specifies whether the crowding will affect the target finding. For 3D search pathways it is minimal, while the strongest effect is for 1D search pathways when the crowding particle can block the search. In addition, for 1D search we determined that the critical parameter is a mobility of crowding agents: highly mobile molecules do not affect the search dynamics, while the slow particles can significantly slow down the process. Physical-chemical explanations of the observed phenomena are presented. Our theoretical predictions thus explain the experimental observations, and they are also supported by extensive numerical simulations.