Chemical accuracy from quantum Monte Carlo for the benzene dimer

Diffusion Monte Carlo method for barrier heights of multiple proton exchanges and complexation energies in small water, ammonia, and hydrogen fluoride clusters

Proton exchange reactions are of key importance in many processes in water. However, it is nontrivial to achieve reliable barrier heights for multiple proton exchanges and complexation energies in hydrogen-bonded systems theoretically. Performance of the fixed-node diffusion quantum Monte Carlo (FN-DMC) with the single-Slater-Jastrow trial wavefunction on total energies, barrier heights of multiple proton exchanges, and complexation energies of small water, ammonia, and hydrogen fluoride clusters is investigated in this study. Effects of basis sets and those of locality approximation (LA), T-move approximation (T-move), and determinant localization approximation (DLA) schemes in dealing with the nonlocal part of pseudopotentials on FN-DMC results are evaluated. According to our results, diffuse basis functions are important in achieving reliable barrier heights and complexation energies with FN-DMC, although the cardinal number of the basis set is more important than diffuse basis functions on total energies of these systems. Our results also show that the time step bias with DLA and LA is smaller than T-move; however, the time step bias of DMC energies with respect to time steps using the T-move is roughly linear up to 0.06 a.u., while this is not the case with LA and DLA. Barrier heights and complexation energies with FN-DMC using these three schemes are always within chemical accuracy. Taking into account the fact that T-move and DLA are typically more stable than LA, FN-DMC calculations with the T-move or DLA scheme and basis sets containing diffuse basis functions are suggested for barrier heights of multiple proton exchanges and complexation energies of hydrogen-bonded clusters.

Towards the ground state of molecules via diffusion Monte Carlo on neural networks

Diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) based on fixed-node approximation has enjoyed significant developments in the past decades and become one of the go-to methods when accurate ground state energy of molecules and materials is needed. However, the inaccurate nodal structure hinders the application of DMC for more challenging electronic correlation problems. In this work, we apply the neural-network based trial wavefunction in fixed-node DMC, which allows accurate calculations of a broad range of atomic and molecular systems of different electronic characteristics. Our method is superior in both accuracy and efficiency compared to state-of-the-art neural network methods using variational Monte Carlo (VMC). We also introduce an extrapolation scheme based on the empirical linearity between VMC and DMC energies, and significantly improve our binding energy calculation. Overall, this computational framework provides a benchmark for accurate solutions of correlated electronic wavefunction and also sheds light on the chemical understanding of molecules.

A critical comparison of CH⋯π versus π⋯π interactions in the benzene dimer: obtaining benchmarks at the CCSD(T) level and assessing the accuracy of lower scaling methods

We have established CCSD(T)/CBS (Complete Basis Set) limits for 3 stationary points on the benzene dimer potential energy surface, corresponding to the π⋯π (parallel displaced or PD(C_2h), minimum) and CH⋯π (T-shaped or T(C_2v), transition state) and tilted T-shaped (or TT(C_s), minimum) bonding scenarios considering both the structure and binding energy. The CCSD(T)/CBS binding energies are -2.65 ± 0.02 (PD), -2.74 ± 0.03 (T), and -2.83 ± 0.01 kcal mol^-1 (TT). To this end, the CH⋯π is ∼0.2 kcal mol^-1 stronger than the π⋯π interaction, whereas the tilting of the CH donating benzene molecule with respect to the other benzene is worth 0.1 kcal mol^-1. As previously discussed in the literature, the MP2 level of theory does not provide a close match for either the energy or structure, yet the SCS-MP2 yields structures in excellent agreement with respect to the CCSD(T) result. It is found that the SCS-MI-MP2 also gives optimized structures very close to SCS-MP2 (within ∼0.01 Å of the benchmark). Despite the closer match in structure, the spin-biased MP2 methods (SCS-, SCS-MI-, and SOS-MP2) incorrectly predict the relative stabilities of the isomers. That said, none of the spin biased MP2 methods offers a good compromise between energy and structure for the systems examined. Finally, the CCSD(T)/CBS benchmarks were used to assess the performance of 13 DFT functionals selected from different rungs of Jacob's ladder. Several functionals such as TPSS-D3, B3LYP-D3, B97-D, B97-D3, and B2PLYP-D3 provided a good description of the binding energies for both CH⋯π and π⋯π interactions, yielding values within 6% of the CCSD(T)/CBS benchmark values. Unlike the MP2 methods, these functionals correctly predict the relative stability of the PD(C_2h) and T(C_2v) dimers. Further, we find that there is no systematic improvement as Jacob's ladder is ascended (increased complexity of functional). The best functionals that result in a good compromise between structure and energy accuracy are B97-D3 and B2PLYP-D3 for both the CH⋯π and π⋯π interaction. Despite the impressive performance of these functionals, a challenge that remains is ensuring the transferability of these density functionals in accurately describing the interaction between dimers of larger aromatic molecules, the latter requiring high-level benchmarks for these systems.

Interactions between large molecules pose a puzzle for reference quantum mechanical methods

Quantum-mechanical methods are used for understanding molecular interactions throughout the natural sciences. Quantum diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) and coupled cluster with single, double, and perturbative triple excitations [CCSD(T)] are state-of-the-art trusted wavefunction methods that have been shown to yield accurate interaction energies for small organic molecules. These methods provide valuable reference information for widely-used semi-empirical and machine learning potentials, especially where experimental information is scarce. However, agreement for systems beyond small molecules is a crucial remaining milestone for cementing the benchmark accuracy of these methods. We show that CCSD(T) and DMC interaction energies are not consistent for a set of polarizable supramolecules. Whilst there is agreement for some of the complexes, in a few key systems disagreements of up to 8 kcal mol^-1 remain. These findings thus indicate that more caution is required when aiming at reproducible non-covalent interactions between extended molecules.

General Correlated Geminal Ansatz for Electronic Structure Calculations: Exploiting Pfaffians in Place of Determinants

We propose here a single Pfaffian correlated variational ansatz that dramatically improves the accuracy with respect to the single determinant one, while remaining at a similar computational cost. A much larger correlation energy is indeed determined by the most general two electron pairing function, including both singlet and triplet channels, combined with a many-body Jastrow factor, including all possible spin-spin, spin-density, and density-density terms. The main technical ingredient to exploit this accuracy is the use of the Pfaffian for antisymmetrizing a highly correlated pairing function, thus recovering the Fermi statistics for electrons with an affordable computational cost. Moreover, the application of the diffusion Monte Carlo, within the fixed node approximation, allows us to obtain very accurate binding energies for the first preliminary calculations reported in this study: C2, N2, and O2 and the benzene molecule. This is promising and remarkable, considering that they represent extremely difficult molecules even for computationally demanding multideterminant approaches, and opens therefore the way for realistic and accurate electronic simulations with an algorithm scaling at most as the fourth power of the number of electrons.

Quantum Monte Carlo Study of the Water Dimer Binding Energy and Halogen-π Interactions

Halogen-π systems are involved with competition between halogen bonding and π-interaction. Using the diffusion quantum Monte Carlo (DMC) method, we compare the interaction of benzene with diatomic halogens (X₂: Cl₂/Br₂) with the typical hydrogen bonding in the water dimer, taking into account explicit correlations of up to three bodies. The benzene-Cl₂/Br₂ binding energies (13.07 ± 0.42/16.62 ± 0.02 kJ/mol) attributed to both halogen bonding and dispersion are smaller than but comparable to the typical hydrogen bonding in the water dimer binding energy (20.88 ± 0.27 kJ/mol). All of the above values are in good agreement with those from the coupled-cluster with single, double, and noniterative triple excitations (CCSD(T)) results at the complete basis set limit (benzene-Cl₂/Br₂: 12.78/16.17 kJ/mol; water dimer: 21.0 kJ/mol).

A Computational Scheme To Evaluate Hamaker Constants of Molecules with Practical Size and Anisotropy

We propose a computational scheme to evaluate Hamaker constants, A, of molecules with practical sizes and anisotropies. Upon the increasing feasibility of diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) methods to evaluate binding curves for such molecules to extract the constants, we discussed how to treat the averaging over anisotropy and how to correct the bias due to the nonadditivity. We have developed a computational procedure for dealing with the anisotropy and reducing statistical errors and biases in DMC evaluations, based on possible validations on predicted A. We applied the scheme to cyclohexasilane molecule, Si₆H₁₂, used in "printed electronics" fabrications, getting A ≈ 105 ± 2 zJ, being in plausible range supported even by other possible extrapolations. The scheme provided here would open a way to use handy ab initio evaluations to predict wettabilities as in the form of materials informatics over broader molecules.

Bias cancellation in one-determinant fixed-node diffusion Monte Carlo: Insights from fermionic occupation numbers

The accuracy of the fixed-node diffusion Monte Carlo (FNDMC) depends on the node location of the supplied trial state Ψ_{T}. The practical FNDMC approaches available for large systems rely on compact yet effective Ψ_{T}, most often containing an explicitly correlated single Slater determinant (SD). However, SD nodes may be better suited to one system than to another, which may possibly lead to inaccurate FNDMC energy differences. It remains a challenge how to estimate nonequivalence or appropriateness of SDs. Here we use the differences of a measure based on the Euclidean distance between the natural orbital occupation number (NOON) vector of the SD and the exact solution in the NOON vector space, which can be viewed as a measure of SD nonequivalence and as a qualitative measure of the expected degree of nondynamic-correlation-related bias in FNDMC energy differences. This is explored on a set of small noncovalent complexes and covalent bond breaking of Si_{2} vs N_{2}. It turns out that NOON-based measures well reflect the magnitude and sign of the bias present in the data available, thus providing insights into the nature of bias cancellation in SD FNDMC energy differences.

The role of van der Waals and exchange interactions in high-pressure solid hydrogen

Our study of the van der Waals interactions in solid molecular hydrogen structures indicates two candidates for phase III.