Femtosecond infrared spectroscopy of channelrhodopsin-1 chromophore isomerization

Time-resolved photoacoustics of channelrhodopsins: early energetics and light-driven volume changes

In biological photoreceptors, the energy stored in early transient species is a key feature to drive the photocycle or a chain of reactions. Time-resolved photoacoustics (PA) can explore the energy landscape of transient species formed within few ns after photoexcitation, as well as volumetric changes (ΔV) of these intermediates with respect to the parental state. In this work, PA identified these important parameters for several channelrhodopsins, namely CaChR1 from Chlamydomonas augustae and CrChR2 from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii and various variants. PA has access to the sub-ns formation of the early photoproduct P1 and to its relaxation, provided that this latter process occurs within a few μs. We found that ΔVP1 for CaChR1 is ca. 12 mL/mol, while it is much smaller for CrChR2 (4.7 mL/mol) and for H. salinarum bacteriorhodopsin (HsBR, ΔVK = 2.8 mL/mol). PA experiments on variants strongly indicate that part of this large ΔVP1 value for CaChR1 is caused by the protonation dynamics of the Schiff base counterion complex involving E169 and D299. PA data further show that the energy level of P1 is higher in CrChR2 (ca. 96 kJ/mol) than in CaChr1 (ca. 46 kJ/mol), comparable to the energy level of the K state of HsBR (60 kJ/mol). Instrumental to gain these molecular values from the raw PA data was the estimation of the quantum yield (Φ) for P1 formation via transient spectroscopy; for both channelrhodopsins, ΦP2 was evaluated as ca. 0.4.

Graphical Abstract

Impact of Ultrafast Electric Field Changes on Photoreceptor Protein Dynamics

Studies on photoreceptors provide a wealth of information on cofactor and protein dynamics on the microsecond to seconds time-scale. Up to now, ultrafast dynamics addresses mainly the cofactor or chromophore, but ultrafast protein dynamics are poorly understood. Increasing evidence show that protein responses can occur even faster than the cofactor dynamics. The causal reason for the ultrafast protein response cannot be explained by the localized cofactor excitation or its excited-state decay, alone. We propose a Coulomb interaction mechanism started by a shock wave and stabilized by a dipole moment change at least partially responsible for coherent oscillations in proteins, protonation changes, water dislocations, and protein changes prior to and beyond chromophore's excited-state decay. Photoexcitation changes the electron density distribution of the chromophore within a few femtoseconds: The Coulomb shock wave affects polar groups, hydrogen bonds, and protein bound water molecules. The process occurs on a time-scale even faster than excited-state decay of the chromophore. We discuss studies on selected photoreceptors in light of this mechanism and its impact on a detailed understanding of protein dynamics.

Ultrafast Backbone Protonation in Channelrhodopsin-1 Captured by Polarization Resolved Fs Vis-pump-IR-Probe Spectroscopy and Computational Methods

Channelrhodopsins (ChR) are light-gated ion-channels heavily used in optogenetics. Upon light excitation an ultrafast all-trans to 13-cis isomerization of the retinal chromophore takes place. It is still uncertain by what means this reaction leads to further protein changes and channel conductivity. Channelrhodopsin-1 in Chlamydomonas augustae exhibits a 100 fs photoisomerization and a protonated counterion complex. By polarization resolved ultrafast spectroscopy in the mid-IR we show that the initial reaction of the retinal is accompanied by changes in the protein backbone and ultrafast protonation changes at the counterion complex comprising Asp299 and Glu169. In combination with homology modelling and quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) geometry optimization we assign the protonation dynamics to ultrafast deprotonation of Glu169, and transient protonation of the Glu169 backbone, followed by a proton transfer from the backbone to the carboxylate group of Asp299 on a timescale of tens of picoseconds. The second proton transfer is not related to retinal dynamics and reflects pure protein changes in the first photoproduct. We assume these protein dynamics to be the first steps in a cascade of protein-wide changes resulting in channel conductivity.

Nonadiabatic Photodynamics of Retinal Protonated Schiff Base in Channelrhodopsin 2

Channelrhodopsin 2 (ChR2) is a light-gated ion channel and an important tool in optogenetics. Photoisomerization of retinal protonated Schiff base (RPSB) in ChR2 triggers channel activation. Despite the importance of ChR2 in optogenetics, the detailed mechanism for photoisomerization and channel activation is still not fully understood. Here, we report on computer simulations to investigate the photoisomerization mechanism and its effect on the activation of ChR2. Nonadiabatic dynamics simulation of ChR2 was carried out using the ab initio multiple spawning (AIMS) method and quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) with a restricted ensemble Kohn-Sham (REKS) treatment of the QM region. Our results agree well with spectroscopic measurements and reveal that the RPSB isomerization is highly specific around the C₁₃=C₁₄ bond and follows the "aborted bicycle-pedal" mechanism. In addition, RPSB photoisomerization facilitates its deprotonation and partially increases the hydration level in the channel, which could trigger subsequent channel opening and ion conduction.

Influence of Heterogeneity on the Ultrafast Photoisomerization Dynamics of Pfr in Cph1 Phytochrome

Photoisomerization of a protein-bound chromophore is the basis of light sensing and signaling in many photoreceptors. Phytochrome photoreceptors can be photoconverted reversibly between the Pr and Pfr states through photoisomerization of the methine bridge between rings C and D. Ground-state heterogeneity of the chromophore has been reported for both Pr and Pfr. Here, we report ultrafast visible (Vis) pump-probe and femtosecond polarization-resolved Vis pump-infrared (IR) probe studies of the Pfr photoreaction in native and ¹³ C/¹⁵ N-labeled Cph1 phytochrome with unlabeled PCB chromophore, demonstrating different S₀ substates, Pfr-I and Pfr-II, with distinct IR absorptions, orientations and dynamics of the carbonyl vibration of ring D. We derived time constants of 0.24 ps, 0.7 ps and 6 ps, describing the complete initial photoreaction. We identified an isomerizing pathway with 0.7 ps for Pfr-I, and silent dynamics with 6 ps for Pfr-II. We discuss different origins of the Pfr substates, and favor different facial orientations of ring D. The model provides a quantum yield for Pfr-I of 38%, in line with ~35% ring D rotation in the electronic excited state. We tentatively assign the silent form Pfr-II to a dark-adapted state that can convert to Pfr-I upon light absorption.

Reaction dynamics of the chimeric channelrhodopsin C1C2

Channelrhodopsin (ChR) is a key protein of the optogenetic toolkit. C1C2, a functional chimeric protein of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii ChR1 and ChR2, is the only ChR whose crystal structure has been solved, and thus uniquely suitable for structure-based analysis. We report C1C2 photoreaction dynamics with ultrafast transient absorption and multi-pulse spectroscopy combined with target analysis and structure-based hybrid quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics calculations. Two relaxation pathways exist on the excited (S₁) state through two conical intersections CI₁ and CI₂, that are reached via clockwise and counter-clockwise rotations: (i) the C13=C14 isomerization path with 450 fs via CI₁ and (ii) a relaxation path to the initial ground state with 2.0 ps and 11 ps via CI₂, depending on the hydrogen-bonding network, hence indicating active-site structural heterogeneity. The presence of the additional conical intersection CI₂ rationalizes the relatively low quantum yield of photoisomerization (30 ± 3%), reported here. Furthermore, we show the photoreaction dynamics from picoseconds to seconds, characterizing the complete photocycle of C1C2.

The Grateful Infrared: Sequential Protein Structural Changes Resolved by Infrared Difference Spectroscopy

The catalytic activity of proteins is a function of structural changes. Very often these are as minute as protonation changes, hydrogen bonding changes, and amino acid side chain reorientations. To resolve these, a methodology is afforded that not only provides the molecular sensitivity but allows for tracing the sequence of these hierarchical reactions at the same time. This feature article showcases results from time-resolved IR spectroscopy on channelrhodopsin (ChR), light-oxygen-voltage (LOV) domain protein, and cryptochrome (CRY). All three proteins are activated by blue light, but their biological role is drastically different. Channelrhodopsin is a transmembrane retinylidene protein which represents the first light-activated ion channel of its kind and which is involved in primitive vision (phototaxis) of algae. LOV and CRY are flavin-binding proteins acting as photoreceptors in a variety of signal transduction mechanisms in all kingdoms of life. Beyond their biological relevance, these proteins are employed in exciting optogenetic applications. We show here how IR difference absorption resolves crucial structural changes of the protein after photonic activation of the chromophore. Time-resolved techniques are introduced that cover the time range from nanoseconds to minutes along with some technical considerations. Finally, we provide an outlook toward novel experimental approaches that are currently developed in our laboratories or are just in our minds ("Gedankenexperimente"). We believe that some of them have the potential to provide new science.

Femtosecond spectroscopic study of photochromic reactions of bacteriorhodopsin and visual rhodopsin

Photochromic ultrafast reactions of bacteriorhodopsin (H. salinarum) and bovine rhodopsin were conducted with a femtosecond two-pump probe pulse setup with the time resolution of 20-25fs. The dynamics of the forward and reverse photochemical reactions for both retinal-containing proteins was compared. It is demonstrated that when retinal-containing proteins are excited by femtosecond pulses, dynamics pattern of the vibrational coherent wave packets in the course of the reaction is different for bacteriorhodopsin and visual rhodopsin. As shown in these studies, the low-frequencies that form a wave packets experimentally observed in the dynamics of primary products formation as a result of retinal photoisomerization have different intensities and are clearer for bovine rhodopsin. Photo-reversible reactions for both retinal proteins were performed from the stage of the relatively stable photointermediates that appear within 3-5ps after the light pulse impact. It is demonstrated that the efficiency of the reverse phototransition K-form→bacteriorhodopsin is almost five-fold higher than that of the Batho-intermediate→visual rhodopsin phototransition. The results obtained indicate that in the course of evolution the intramolecular mechanism of the chromophore-protein interaction in visual rhodopsin becomes more perfect and specific. The decrease in the probability of the reverse chromophore photoisomerization (all-trans→11-cis retinal) in primary photo-induced rhodopsin products causes an increase in the efficiency of the photoreception process.