Defectors in bad circumstances possessing higher reputation can promote cooperation

Third party interventions promote cooperation on the interdependent networks: A perspective based on prospect theory

Third-party intervention is a beneficial means to alleviate conflicts and promote cooperation among disputants. The decision-making of disputants is closely related to the intensity of the impact of third-party intervention on their profits. Actually, disputants often decide whether to adopt cooperative strategies based on their own perceived rather than actual gains or losses brought about by third-party intervention. We, therefore, introduce prospect theory to explore the formation and maintenance of cooperation in a system composed of third parties and disputants, which, respectively, constitute two sub-networks of the interdependent networks. Both interveners and disputants participate in a prisoner's dilemma game, and the third-party intervener will pay a certain price to impose certain punishments on the defectors of the disputed layer. The simulation results show that the introduction of third-party intervention based on the prospect theory alleviates the conflicts in the dispute layer and promotes cooperation among disputants, which indicates that third parties such as governments or organizations should appropriately consider the risk attitudes of disputants when mediating their conflicts. The level of cooperation at the dispute layer is inversely proportional to the intervention cost and directly proportional to the intervention intensity. Our research may shed some new light on the study of the evolution of cooperation under third-party intervention.

Towards preferential selection in the prisoner's dilemma game

In previous works, the choice of learning neighbor for an individual has generally obeyed pure random selection or preferential selection rules. In this paper, we introduce a tunable parameter ε to characterize the strength of preferential selection and focus on the transition towards preferential selection in the spatial evolutionary game by controlling ε to guide the system from pure random selection to preferential selection. Our simulation results reveal that the introduction of preferential selection can hugely alleviate social dilemmas and enhance network reciprocity. A larger ε leads to a higher critical threshold of the temptation b for the extinction of cooperators. Moreover, we provide some intuitive explanations for the above results from the perspective of strategy transition and cooperative clusters. Finally, we examine the robustness of the results for noise K and different topologies, find that qualitative features of the results are unchanged.