Time-resolved electrometric and optical studies on cytochrome bd suggest a mechanism of electron-proton coupling in the di-heme active site

Interplay of acidic residues in the proton channel of E. coli cytochrome bd-I oxidase to promote oxygen reduction and NO release

The reduction of oxygen to water is crucial to life under aerobic conditions. Cytochrome bd oxidases perform this reaction with a very high oxygen affinity. Members of this protein family are solely found in prokaryotes and some archaea playing an important role in bacterial virulence and antibiotic resistance. Here, we combine mutagenesis, electrocatalysis, nitric oxide binding and release experiments as well as FTIR spectroscopy to demonstrate that proton delivery to the active site is essentially rate limiting in Cyt bd-I electrocatalysis. D58 and D105 of subunit CydB are crucial residues in this proton path and communicate via a hydrogen bond network. Oxygen reduction depends on proton delivery to the active site, which also influences NO release.

Carbon Monoxide and Prokaryotic Energy Metabolism

Carbon monoxide (CO) plays a multifaceted role in both physiology and pathophysiology. At high levels, it is lethal to humans due to its tight binding to globins and cytochrome c oxidase. At low doses, CO can exhibit beneficial effects; it serves as an endogenous signaling molecule and possesses antibacterial properties, which opens up possibilities for its use as an antimicrobial agent. For this purpose, research is in progress to develop metal-based CO-releasing molecules, metal-free organic CO prodrugs, and CO-generating hydrogel microspheres. The energy metabolism of prokaryotes is a key point that may be targeted by CO to kill invading pathogens. The cornerstone of prokaryotic energy metabolism is a series of membrane-bound enzyme complexes, which constitute a respiratory chain. Terminal oxidases, at the end of this chain, contain hemes and are therefore potential targets for CO. However, this research area is at its very early stage. The impact of CO on bacterial energy metabolism may also provide a basis for biotechnological applications in which this gas is present. This review discusses the molecular basis of the effects of CO on microbial growth and aerobic respiration supported by different terminal oxidases in light of recent findings.

Inhibitory effects of nitrite and sulfite/peroxymonosulfate on bacteria are mediated respectively through respiration and intracellular GSH homeostasis

As nitrite, sulfite has been used in food preservation for centuries but how it inhibits bacterial growth remains underexplored. To address this issue, in this study, we set out to test if cytochrome (cyt) c proteins protect bacteria from the damage of certain reactive sulfur species (RSS) because they do so in the case of reactive nitrogen species (RNS). We show that some reactive sulfur species, such as sulfite and peroxymonosulfate (PMS), inhibit growth of bacterial strains devoid of cytochrome (cyt) c proteins. Subsequent investigations link the inhibition of sulfite/PMS to activity of cbb3-type heme-copper oxidase (cbb3-HCO). However, in vitro comparative analysis rules out that either cbb3-HCO or cyt bd oxidase is the primary target of sulfite/PMS. Instead, we found that sulfite/PMS and the cbb3-HCO loss regulate intracellular redox status in a similar manner, by affecting GSH/GSSG homeostasis. The link between the GSH/GSSG homeostasis and sulfite/PMS is further substantiated by using the mutants with enhanced GSSG generation. Furthermore, we present the data to show that inhibitory effects of nitrite and sulfite/PMS are additive although the overall effects may vary depending on species. Our results open an avenue to control bacteria by developing more robust agents that modulating intracellular redox status, which may be used in combination with nitrite as a promising antimicrobial strategy.

Proton transfer in cytochrome bd-I from E. coli involves Asp-105 in CydB

Cytochrome bds are bacterial terminal oxidases expressed under low oxygen conditions, and they are important for the survival of many pathogens and hence potential drug targets. The largest subunit CydA contains the three redox-active cofactors heme b558, heme b595 and the active site heme d. One suggested proton transfer pathway is found at the interface between the CydA and the other major subunit CydB. Here we have studied the O2 reduction mechanism in E. coli cyt. bd-I using the flow-flash technique and focused on the mechanism, kinetics and pathway for proton transfer. Our results show that the peroxy (P) to ferryl (F) transition, coupled to the oxidation of the low-spin heme b558 is pH dependent, with a maximum rate constant (~104 s-1) that is slowed down at higher pH. We assign this behavior to rate-limitation by internal proton transfer from a titratable residue with pKa ~ 9.7. Proton uptake from solution occurs with the same P➔F rate constant. Site-directed mutagenesis shows significant effects on catalytic turnover in the CydB variants Asp58B➔Asn and Asp105B➔Asn variants consistent with them playing a role in proton transfer. Furthermore, in the Asp105B➔Asn variant, the reactions up to P formation occur essentially as in the wildtype bd-I, but the P➔F transition is specifically inhibited, supporting a direct and specific role for Asp105B in the functional proton transfer pathway in bd-I. We further discuss the possible identity of the high pKa proton donor, and the conservation pattern of the Asp-105B in the cyt. bd superfamily.

Cytochrome bd-type oxidases and environmental stressors in microbial physiology

Cytochrome bd is a tri-haem copper-free terminal oxidase of many respiratory chains of prokaryotes with unique structural and functional characteristics. As the other membrane-bound terminal oxidases, this enzyme couples the four-electron reduction of oxygen to water with the generation of a proton motive force used for ATP synthesis but the molecular mechanism does not include proton pumping. Beyond its bioenergetic role, cytochrome bd is involved in resistance to several stressors and affords protection against oxidative and nitrosative stress. These features agree with its expression in many bacterial pathogens. The importance for bacterial virulence and the absence of eukaryotic homologues make this enzyme an ideal target for new antimicrobial drugs. This review aims to provide an update on the current knowledge about cytochrome bd in light of recent advances in the structural characterisation of this enzyme, focussing on its reactivity with environmental stressors.

Generation of Membrane Potential by Cytochrome bd

An overview of current notions on the mechanism of generation of a transmembrane electric potential difference (Δψ) during the catalytic cycle of a bd-type triheme terminal quinol oxidase is presented in this work. It is suggested that the main contribution to Δψ formation is made by the movement of H+ across the membrane along the intra-protein hydrophilic proton-conducting pathway from the cytoplasm to the active site for oxygen reduction of this bacterial enzyme.

Mutating the environment of heme b595 of E. coli cytochrome bd-I oxidase shifts its redox potential by 200 mV without inactivating the enzyme

Cytochrome bd-I catalyzes the reduction of oxygen to water with the aid of hemes b₅₅₈, b₅₉₅ and d. Here, effects of a mutation of E445, a ligand of heme b₅₉₅ and of R448, hydrogen bonded to E445 are studied electrochemically in the E. coli enzyme. The equilibrium potential of the three hemes are shifted by up to 200 mV in these mutants. Strikingly the E445D and the R448N mutants show a turnover of 41 ± 2 % and 20 ± 4 %, respectively. Electrocatalytic studies confirm that the mutants react with oxygen and bind and release NO. These results point towards the ability of cytochrome bd to react even if the electron transfer is less favorable.

QM Calculations Revealed that Outer-Sphere Electron Transfer Boosted O-O Bond Cleavage in the Multiheme-Dependent Cytochrome bd Oxygen Reductase

The cytochrome bd oxygen reductase catalyzes the four-electron reduction of dioxygen to two water molecules. The structure of this enzyme reveals three heme molecules in the active site, which differs from that of heme-copper cytochrome c oxidase. The quantum chemical cluster approach was used to uncover the reaction mechanism of this intriguing metalloenzyme. The calculations suggested that a proton-coupled electron transfer reduction occurs first to generate a ferrous heme b₅₉₅. This is followed by the dioxygen binding at the heme d center coupled with an outer-sphere electron transfer from the ferrous heme b₅₉₅ to the dioxygen moiety, affording a ferric ion superoxide intermediate. A second proton-coupled electron transfer produces a heme d ferric hydroperoxide, which undergoes efficient O-O bond cleavage facilitated by an outer-sphere electron transfer from the ferrous heme b₅₉₅ to the O-O σ* orbital and an inner-sphere proton transfer from the heme d hydroxyl group to the leaving hydroxide. The synergistic benefits of the two types of hemes rationalize the highly efficient oxygen reduction repertoire for the multi-heme-dependent cytochrome bd oxygen reductase family.

Identification of 2-Aryl-Quinolone Inhibitors of Cytochrome bd and Chemical Validation of Combination Strategies for Respiratory Inhibitors against Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Mycobacterium tuberculosis cytochrome bd quinol oxidase (cyt bd), the alternative terminal oxidase of the respiratory chain, has been identified as playing a key role during chronic infection and presents a putative target for the development of novel antitubercular agents. Here, we report confirmation of successful heterologous expression of M. tuberculosis cytochrome bd. The heterologous M. tuberculosis cytochrome bd expression system was used to identify a chemical series of inhibitors based on the 2-aryl-quinolone pharmacophore. Cytochrome bd inhibitors displayed modest efficacy in M. tuberculosis growth suppression assays together with a bacteriostatic phenotype in time-kill curve assays. Significantly, however, inhibitor combinations containing our front-runner cyt bd inhibitor CK-2-63 with either cyt bcc-aa3 inhibitors (e.g., Q203) and/or adenosine triphosphate (ATP) synthase inhibitors (e.g., bedaquiline) displayed enhanced efficacy with respect to the reduction of mycobacterium oxygen consumption, growth suppression, and in vitro sterilization kinetics. In vivo combinations of Q203 and CK-2-63 resulted in a modest lowering of lung burden compared to treatment with Q203 alone. The reduced efficacy in the in vivo experiments compared to in vitro experiments was shown to be a result of high plasma protein binding and a low unbound drug exposure at the target site. While further development is required to improve the tractability of cyt bd inhibitors for clinical evaluation, these data support the approach of using small-molecule inhibitors to target multiple components of the branched respiratory chain of M. tuberculosis as a combination strategy to improve therapeutic and pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic (PK/PD) indices related to efficacy.

E. coli cytochrome bd-I requires Asp58 in the CydB subunit for catalytic activity

The reduction of oxygen to water is crucial to life and a central metabolic process. To fulfill this task, prokaryotes use among other enzymes cytochrome bd oxidases (Cyt bds) that also play an important role in bacterial virulence and antibiotic resistance. To fight microbial infections by pathogens, an in-depth understanding of the enzyme mechanism is required. Here, we combine bioinformatics, mutagenesis, enzyme kinetics and FTIR spectroscopy to demonstrate that proton delivery to the active site contributes to the rate limiting steps in Cyt bd-I and involves Asp58 of subunit CydB. Our findings reveal a previously unknown catalytic function of subunit CydB in the reaction of Cyt bd-I.

Preparations of Terminal Oxidase Cytochrome bd-II Isolated from Escherichia coli Reveal Significant Hydrogen Peroxide Scavenging Activity

Cytochrome bd-II is one of the three terminal quinol oxidases of the aerobic respiratory chain of Escherichia coli. Preparations of the detergent-solubilized untagged bd-II oxidase isolated from the bacterium were shown to scavenge hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) with high rate producing molecular oxygen (O₂). Addition of H2O2 to the same buffer that does not contain enzyme or contains thermally denatured cytochrome bd-II does not lead to any O2 production. The latter observation rules out involvement of adventitious transition metals bound to the protein. The H2O2-induced O2 production is not susceptible to inhibition by N-ethylmaleimide (the sulfhydryl binding compound), antimycin A (the compound that binds specifically to a quinol binding site), and CO (diatomic gas that binds specifically to the reduced heme d). However, O2 formation is inhibited by cyanide (IC₅₀ = 4.5 ± 0.5 µM) and azide. Addition of H2O2 in the presence of dithiothreitol and ubiquinone-1 does not inactivate cytochrome bd-II and apparently does not affect the O2 reductase activity of the enzyme. The ability of cytochrome bd-II to detoxify H2O2 could play a role in bacterial physiology by conferring resistance to the peroxide-mediated stress.

Bioenergetics and Reactive Nitrogen Species in Bacteria

The production of reactive nitrogen species (RNS) by the innate immune system is part of the host's defense against invading pathogenic bacteria. In this review, we summarize recent studies on the molecular basis of the effects of nitric oxide and peroxynitrite on microbial respiration and energy conservation. We discuss possible molecular mechanisms underlying RNS resistance in bacteria mediated by unique respiratory oxygen reductases, the mycobacterial bcc-aa3 supercomplex, and bd-type cytochromes. A complete picture of the impact of RNS on microbial bioenergetics is not yet available. However, this research area is developing very rapidly, and the knowledge gained should help us develop new methods of treating infectious diseases.

Recent Advances in Structural Studies of Cytochrome bd and Its Potential Application as a Drug Target

Cytochrome bd is a triheme copper-free terminal oxidase in membrane respiratory chains of prokaryotes. This unique molecular machine couples electron transfer from quinol to O₂ with the generation of a proton motive force without proton pumping. Apart from energy conservation, the bd enzyme plays an additional key role in the microbial cell, being involved in the response to different environmental stressors. Cytochrome bd promotes virulence in a number of pathogenic species that makes it a suitable molecular drug target candidate. This review focuses on recent advances in understanding the structure of cytochrome bd and the development of its selective inhibitors.

Mechanistic and structural diversity between cytochrome bd isoforms of Escherichia coli

The treatment of infectious diseases caused by multidrug-resistant pathogens is a major clinical challenge of the 21st century. The membrane-embedded respiratory cytochrome bd-type oxygen reductase is a critical survival factor utilized by pathogenic bacteria during infection, proliferation and the transition from acute to chronic states. Escherichia coli encodes for two cytochrome bd isoforms that are both involved in respiration under oxygen limited conditions. Mechanistic and structural differences between cydABX (Ecbd-I) and appCBX (Ecbd-II) operon encoded cytochrome bd variants have remained elusive in the past. Here, we demonstrate that cytochrome bd-II catalyzes oxidation of benzoquinols while possessing additional specificity for naphthoquinones. Our data show that although menaquinol-1 (MK1) is not able to directly transfer electrons onto cytochrome bd-II from E. coli, it has a stimulatory effect on its oxygen reduction rate in the presence of ubiquinol-1. We further determined cryo-EM structures of cytochrome bd-II to high resolution of 2.1 Å. Our structural insights confirm that the general architecture and substrate accessible pathways are conserved between the two bd oxidase isoforms, but two notable differences are apparent upon inspection: (i) Ecbd-II does not contain a CydH-like subunit, thereby exposing heme b ₅₉₅ to the membrane environment and (ii) the AppB subunit harbors a structural demethylmenaquinone-8 molecule instead of ubiquinone-8 as found in CydB of Ecbd-I Our work completes the structural landscape of terminal respiratory oxygen reductases of E. coli and suggests that structural and functional properties of the respective oxidases are linked to quinol-pool dependent metabolic adaptations in E. coli.

Impact of Hydrogen Sulfide on Mitochondrial and Bacterial Bioenergetics

This review focuses on the effects of hydrogen sulfide (H2S) on the unique bioenergetic molecular machines in mitochondria and bacteria-the protein complexes of electron transport chains and associated enzymes. H2S, along with nitric oxide and carbon monoxide, belongs to the class of endogenous gaseous signaling molecules. This compound plays critical roles in physiology and pathophysiology. Enzymes implicated in H2S metabolism and physiological actions are promising targets for novel pharmaceutical agents. The biological effects of H2S are biphasic, changing from cytoprotection to cytotoxicity through increasing the compound concentration. In mammals, H2S enhances the activity of FoF1-ATP (adenosine triphosphate) synthase and lactate dehydrogenase via their S-sulfhydration, thereby stimulating mitochondrial electron transport. H2S serves as an electron donor for the mitochondrial respiratory chain via sulfide quinone oxidoreductase and cytochrome c oxidase at low H2S levels. The latter enzyme is inhibited by high H2S concentrations, resulting in the reversible inhibition of electron transport and ATP production in mitochondria. In the branched respiratory chain of Escherichia coli, H2S inhibits the bo3 terminal oxidase but does not affect the alternative bd-type oxidases. Thus, in E. coli and presumably other bacteria, cytochrome bd permits respiration and cell growth in H2S-rich environments. A complete picture of the impact of H2S on bioenergetics is lacking, but this field is fast-moving, and active ongoing research on this topic will likely shed light on additional, yet unknown biological effects.

Proton Pumping and Non-Pumping Terminal Respiratory Oxidases: Active Sites Intermediates of These Molecular Machines and Their Derivatives

Terminal respiratory oxidases are highly efficient molecular machines. These most important bioenergetic membrane enzymes transform the energy of chemical bonds released during the transfer of electrons along the respiratory chains of eukaryotes and prokaryotes from cytochromes or quinols to molecular oxygen into a transmembrane proton gradient. They participate in regulatory cascades and physiological anti-stress reactions in multicellular organisms. They also allow microorganisms to adapt to low-oxygen conditions, survive in chemically aggressive environments and acquire antibiotic resistance. To date, three-dimensional structures with atomic resolution of members of all major groups of terminal respiratory oxidases, heme-copper oxidases, and bd-type cytochromes, have been obtained. These groups of enzymes have different origins and a wide range of functional significance in cells. At the same time, all of them are united by a catalytic reaction of four-electron reduction in oxygen into water which proceeds without the formation and release of potentially dangerous ROS from active sites. The review analyzes recent structural and functional studies of oxygen reduction intermediates in the active sites of terminal respiratory oxidases, the features of catalytic cycles, and the properties of the active sites of these enzymes.

The transferred translocases: An old wine in a new bottle

The role of translocases was underappreciated and was not included as a separate class in the enzyme commission until August 2018. The recent research interests in proteomics of orphan enzymes, ionomics, and metallomics along with high-throughput sequencing technologies generated overwhelming data and revamped this enzyme into a separate class. This offers a great opportunity to understand the role of new or orphan enzymes in general and specifically translocases. The enzymes belonging to translocases regulate/permeate the transfer of ions or molecules across the membranes. These enzyme entries were previously associated with other enzyme classes, which are now transferred to a new enzyme class 7 (EC 7). The entries that are reclassified are important to extend the enzyme list, and it is the need of the hour. Accordingly, there is an upgradation of entries of this class of enzymes in several databases. This review is a concise compilation of translocases with reference to the number of entries currently available in the databases. This review also focuses on function as well as dysfunction of translocases during normal and disordered states, respectively.

Effect of Membrane Environment on the Ligand-Binding Properties of the Terminal Oxidase Cytochrome bd-I from Escherichia coli

Cytochrome bd-I is a terminal oxidase of the Escherichia coli respiratory chain. This integral membrane protein contains three redox-active prosthetic groups (hemes b₅₅₈, b₅₉₅, and d) and couples the electron transfer from quinol to molecular oxygen to the generation of proton motive force, as one of its important physiological functions. The study was aimed at examining the effect of the membrane environment on the ligand-binding properties of cytochrome bd-I by absorption spectroscopy. The membrane environment was found to modulate the ligand-binding characteristics of the hemoprotein in both oxidized and reduced states. Absorption changes upon the addition of exogenous ligands, such as cyanide or carbon monoxide (CO), to the detergent-solubilized enzyme were much more significant and heterogeneous than those observed with the membrane-bound enzyme. In the native membranes, both cyanide and CO interacted mainly with heme d. An additional ligand-binding site (heme b₅₅₈) appeared in the isolated enzyme, as was evidenced by more pronounced changes in the absorption in the Soret band. This additional reactivity could also be detected after treatment of E. coli membranes with a detergent. The observed effect did not result from the enzyme denaturation, since reconstitution of the isolated enzyme into azolectin liposomes restored the ligand-binding pattern close to that observed for the intact membranes.

Bacterial Oxidases of the Cytochrome bd Family: Redox Enzymes of Unique Structure, Function, and Utility As Drug Targets

Significance: Cytochrome bd is a ubiquinol:oxygen oxidoreductase of many prokaryotic respiratory chains with a unique structure and functional characteristics. Its primary role is to couple the reduction of molecular oxygen, even at submicromolar concentrations, to water with the generation of a proton motive force used for adenosine triphosphate production. Cytochrome bd is found in many bacterial pathogens and, surprisingly, in bacteria formally denoted as anaerobes. It endows bacteria with resistance to various stressors and is a potential drug target. Recent Advances: We summarize recent advances in the biochemistry, structure, and physiological functions of cytochrome bd in the light of exciting new three-dimensional structures of the oxidase. The newly discovered roles of cytochrome bd in contributing to bacterial protection against hydrogen peroxide, nitric oxide, peroxynitrite, and hydrogen sulfide are assessed. Critical Issues: Fundamental questions remain regarding the precise delineation of electron flow within this multihaem oxidase and how the extraordinarily high affinity for oxygen is accomplished, while endowing bacteria with resistance to other small ligands. Future Directions: It is clear that cytochrome bd is unique in its ability to confer resistance to toxic small molecules, a property that is significant for understanding the propensity of pathogens to possess this oxidase. Since cytochrome bd is a uniquely bacterial enzyme, future research should focus on harnessing fundamental knowledge of its structure and function to the development of novel and effective antibacterial agents.

ROS Defense Systems and Terminal Oxidases in Bacteria

Reactive oxygen species (ROS) comprise the superoxide anion (O₂^•−), hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂), hydroxyl radical (^•OH), and singlet oxygen (¹O₂). ROS can damage a variety of macromolecules, including DNA, RNA, proteins, and lipids, and compromise cell viability. To prevent or reduce ROS-induced oxidative stress, bacteria utilize different ROS defense mechanisms, of which ROS scavenging enzymes, such as superoxide dismutases, catalases, and peroxidases, are the best characterized. Recently, evidence has been accumulating that some of the terminal oxidases in bacterial respiratory chains may also play a protective role against ROS. The present review covers this role of terminal oxidases in light of recent findings.

Terminal Oxidase Cytochrome bd Protects Bacteria Against Hydrogen Sulfide Toxicity

Hydrogen sulfide (H2S) is often called the third gasotransmitter (after nitric oxide and carbon monoxide), or endogenous gaseous signaling molecule. This compound plays important roles in organisms from different taxonomic groups, from bacteria to animals and humans. In mammalian cells, H2S has a cytoprotective effect at nanomolar concentrations, but becomes cytotoxic at higher concentrations. The primary target of H2S is mitochondria. At submicromolar concentrations, H2S inhibits mitochondrial heme-copper cytochrome c oxidase, thereby blocking aerobic respiration and oxidative phosphorylation and eventually leading to cell death. Since the concentration of H2S in the gut is extremely high, the question arises - how can gut bacteria maintain the functioning of their oxygen-dependent respiratory electron transport chains under such conditions? This review provides an answer to this question and discusses the key role of non-canonical bd-type terminal oxidases of the enterobacterium Escherichia coli, a component of the gut microbiota, in maintaining aerobic respiration and growth in the presence of toxic concentrations of H2S in the light of recent experimental data.

Electrocatalytic evidence of the diversity of the oxygen reaction in the bacterial bd oxidase from different organisms

Cytochrome bd oxidase is a bacterial terminal oxygen reductase that was suggested to enable adaptation to different environments and to confer resistance to stress conditions. An electrocatalytic study of the cyt bd oxidases from Escherichia coli, Corynebacterium glutamicum and Geobacillus thermodenitrificans gives evidence for a different reactivity towards oxygen. An inversion of the redox potential values of the three hemes is found when comparing the enzymes from different bacteria. This inversion can be correlated with different protonated glutamic acids as evidenced by reaction induced FTIR spectroscopy. The influence of the microenvironment of the hemes on the reactivity towards oxygen is discussed.

An Engineered Glutamate in Biosynthetic Models of Heme-Copper Oxidases Drives Complete Product Selectivity by Tuning the Hydrogen-Bonding Network

Efficiently carrying out the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) is critical for many applications in biology and chemistry, such as bioenergetics and fuel cells, respectively. In biology, this reaction is carried out by large, transmembrane oxidases such as heme-copper oxidases (HCOs) and cytochrome bd oxidases. Common to these oxidases is the presence of a glutamate residue next to the active site, but its precise role in regulating the oxidase activity remains unclear. To gain insight into its role, we herein report that incorporation of glutamate next to a designed heme-copper center in two biosynthetic models of HCOs improves O2 binding affinity, facilitates protonation of reaction intermediates, and eliminates release of reactive oxygen species. High-resolution crystal structures of the models revealed extended, water-mediated hydrogen-bonding networks involving the glutamate. Electron paramagnetic resonance of the cryoreduced oxy-ferrous centers at cryogenic temperature followed by thermal annealing allowed observation of the key hydroperoxo intermediate that can be attributed to the hydrogen-bonding network. By demonstrating these important roles of glutamate in oxygen reduction biochemistry, this work offers deeper insights into its role in native oxidases, which may guide the design of more efficient artificial ORR enzymes or catalysts for applications such as fuel cells.

In Escherichia coli Ammonia Inhibits Cytochrome bo3 But Activates Cytochrome bd-I

Interaction of two redox enzymes of Escherichia coli, cytochrome bo₃ and cytochrome bd-I, with ammonium sulfate/ammonia at pH 7.0 and 8.3 was studied using high-resolution respirometry and absorption spectroscopy. At pH 7.0, the oxygen reductase activity of none of the enzymes is affected by the ligand. At pH 8.3, cytochrome bo₃ is inhibited by the ligand, with 40% maximum inhibition at 100 mM (NH₄)₂SO₄. In contrast, the activity of cytochrome bd-I at pH 8.3 increases with increasing the ligand concentration, the largest increase (140%) is observed at 100 mM (NH₄)₂SO₄. In both cases, the effector molecule is apparently not NH₄⁺ but NH₃. The ligand induces changes in absorption spectra of both oxidized cytochromes at pH 8.3. The magnitude of these changes increases as ammonia concentration is increased, yielding apparent dissociation constants K_dapp of 24.3 ± 2.7 mM (NH₄)₂SO₄ (4.9 ± 0.5 mM NH₃) for the Soret region in cytochrome bo₃, and 35.9 ± 7.1 and 24.6 ± 12.4 mM (NH₄)₂SO₄ (7.2 ± 1.4 and 4.9 ± 2.5 mM NH₃) for the Soret and visible regions, respectively, in cytochrome bd-I. Consistently, addition of (NH₄)₂SO₄ to cells of the E. coli mutant containing cytochrome bd-I as the only terminal oxidase at pH 8.3 accelerates the O₂ consumption rate, the highest one (140%) being at 27 mM (NH₄)₂SO₄. We discuss possible molecular mechanisms and physiological significance of modulation of the enzymatic activities by ammonia present at high concentration in the intestines, a niche occupied by E. coli.

Features and Functional Importance of Key Residues of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis Cytochrome bd Oxidase

Cytochrome bd (cyt-bd) oxygen reductases have a high affinity to oxygen and use the two electrons provided by ubiquinol or menaquinol, like in mycobacteria, to reduce oxygen to water. Although they do not pump protons from the cytoplasmic to the periplasmic side, they generate a proton motive force due to the release of protons after quinol oxidation. Here, we show that the mycobacterial cyt-bd has a number of specific features, including a 17-residue stretch (₃₀₇SGVTLQGIRDLQQEYQQ₃₂₃) near the Q-loop of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis subunit CydA and a ₄₁₂QLVRLTVKA₄₂₀ region on the periplasmic side. Site directed mutagenesis and whole-bacteria assays demonstrated that these mycobacteria-specific stretches are essential for the oxidase's function. Single amino acid substitutions around the ₃₀₇SGVTLQGIRDLQQEYQQ₃₂₃ stretch revealed the importance of the aromatic residue Y330 in oxygen consumption and consequently in ATP synthesis. A moderate reduction and no effect was observed for mutants F325 and Y321, respectively, while the double mutant CydA_Y321/F325 drastically reduced enzyme activity. In addition, single mutants of the mycobacterial cyt-bd were generated to probe the role of proposed critical residues for proton shuffling. Further data demonstrate that amino acids W64 and F18 in the CydB subunit might be important as any slight destabilization of the hydrophobic environment near them makes the enzyme inactive. Finally, the potential of the mycobacterial cyt-bd as a drug target is discussed.

Targeting the menaquinol binding loop of mycobacterial cytochrome bd oxidase

Mycobacteria have shown enormous resilience to survive and persist by remodeling and altering metabolic requirements. Under stringent conditions or exposure to drugs, mycobacteria have adapted to rescue themselves by shutting down their major metabolic activity and elevate certain survival factor levels and efflux pathways to survive and evade the effects of drug treatments. A fundamental feature in this adaptation is the ability of mycobacteria to vary the enzyme composition of the electron transport chain (ETC), which generates the proton motive force for the synthesis of adenosine triphosphate via oxidative phosphorylation. Mycobacteria harbor dehydrogenases to fuel the ETC, and two terminal respiratory oxidases, an aa3-type cytochrome c oxidase (cyt-bcc-aa3) and a bacterial specific cytochrome bd-type menaquinol oxidase (cyt-bd). In this study, we employed homology modeling and structure-based virtual screening studies to target mycobacteria-specific residues anchoring the b558 menaquinol binding region of Mycobacterium tuberculosis cyt-bd oxidase to obtain a focused library. Furthermore, ATP synthesis inhibition assays were carried out. One of the ligands MQL-H₂ inhibited both NADH₂- and succinate-driven ATP synthesis inhibition of Mycobacterium smegmatis inside-out vesicles in micromolar potency. Similarly, MQL-H₂ also inhibited NADH₂-driven ATP synthesis in inside-out vesicles of the cytochrome-bcc oxidase deficient M. smegmatis strain. Since neither varying the electron donor substrates nor deletion of the cyt-bcc oxidase, a major source of protons, hindered the inhibitory effects of the MQL-H₂, reflecting that MQL-H₂ targets the terminal oxidase cytochrome bd oxidase, which was consistent with molecular docking studies. Characterization of novel cytochrome bd oxidase Menaquinol binding domain inhibitor (MQL-H2) using virtual screening and ATP synthesis inhibition assays.

Homologous bd oxidases share the same architecture but differ in mechanism

Cytochrome bd oxidases are terminal reductases of bacterial and archaeal respiratory chains. The enzyme couples the oxidation of ubiquinol or menaquinol with the reduction of dioxygen to water, thus contributing to the generation of the protonmotive force. Here, we determine the structure of the Escherichia coli bd oxidase treated with the specific inhibitor aurachin by cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM). The major subunits CydA and CydB are related by a pseudo two fold symmetry. The heme b and d cofactors are found in CydA, while ubiquinone-8 is bound at the homologous positions in CydB to stabilize its structure. The architecture of the E. coli enzyme is highly similar to that of Geobacillus thermodenitrificans, however, the positions of heme b₅₉₅ and d are interchanged, and a common oxygen channel is blocked by a fourth subunit and substituted by a more narrow, alternative channel. Thus, with the same overall fold, the homologous enzymes exhibit a different mechanism.

Cytochrome bd oxidases couple quinol oxidation and the release of protons to the periplasmic side with proton uptake from the cytoplasmic side to reduce dioxygen to water and they are the terminal reductases in bacterial and archaeal respiratory chains. Here the authors present the cryo-EM structure of Escherichia coli bd oxidase and discuss mechanistic implications.

In the respiratory chain of Escherichia coli cytochromes bd-I and bd-II are more sensitive to carbon monoxide inhibition than cytochrome bo3

Bacteria can not only encounter carbon monoxide (CO) in their habitats but also produce the gas endogenously. Bacterial respiratory oxidases, thus, represent possible targets for CO. Accordingly, host macrophages were proposed to produce CO and release it into the surrounding microenvironment to sense viable bacteria through a mechanism that in Escherichia (E.) coli was suggested to involve the targeting of a bd-type respiratory oxidase by CO. The aerobic respiratory chain of E. coli possesses three terminal quinol:O₂-oxidoreductases: the heme-copper oxidase bo₃ and two copper-lacking bd-type oxidases, bd-I and bd-II. Heme-copper and bd-type oxidases differ in the mechanism and efficiency of proton motive force generation and in resistance to oxidative and nitrosative stress, cyanide and hydrogen sulfide. Here, we investigated at varied O₂ concentrations the effect of CO gas on the O₂ reductase activity of the purified cytochromes bo₃, bd-I and bd-II of E. coli. We found that CO, in competition with O₂, reversibly inhibits the three enzymes. The inhibition constants K_i for the bo₃, bd-I and bd-II oxidases are 2.4 ± 0.3, 0.04 ± 0.01 and 0.2 ± 0.1 μM CO, respectively. Thus, in E. coli, bd-type oxidases are more sensitive to CO inhibition than the heme-copper cytochrome bo₃. The possible physiological consequences of this finding are discussed.

Active site rearrangement and structural divergence in prokaryotic respiratory oxidases

Cytochrome bd–type quinol oxidases catalyze the reduction of molecular oxygen to water in the respiratory chain of many human-pathogenic bacteria. They are structurally unrelated to mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidases and are therefore a prime target for the development of antimicrobial drugs. We determined the structure of theEscherichia colicytochrome bd-I oxidase by single-particle cryo–electron microscopy to a resolution of 2.7 angstroms. Our structure contains a previously unknown accessory subunit CydH, the L-subfamily–specific Q-loop domain, a structural ubiquinone-8 cofactor, an active-site density interpreted as dioxygen, distinct water-filled proton channels, and an oxygen-conducting pathway. Comparison with another cytochrome bd oxidase reveals structural divergence in the family, including rearrangement of high-spin hemes and conformational adaption of a transmembrane helix to generate a distinct oxygen-binding site.

Functional importance of Glutamate-445 and Glutamate-99 in proton-coupled electron transfer during oxygen reduction by cytochrome bd from Escherichia coli

The recent X-ray structure of the cytochrome bd respiratory oxygen reductase showed that two of the three heme components, heme d and heme b₅₉₅, have glutamic acid as an axial ligand. No other native heme proteins are known to have glutamic acid axial ligands. In this work, site-directed mutagenesis is used to probe the roles of these glutamic acids, E445 and E99 in the E. coli enzyme. It is concluded that neither glutamate is a strong ligand to the heme Fe and they are not the major determinates of heme binding to the protein. Although very important, neither glutamate is absolutely essential for catalytic function. The close interactions between the three hemes in cyt bd result in highly cooperative properties. For example, mutation of E445, which is near heme d, has its greatest effects on the properties of heme b₅₉₅ and heme b₅₅₈. It is concluded that 1) O₂ binds to the hydrophilic side of heme d and displaces E445; 2) E445 forms a salt bridge with R448 within the O₂ binding pocket, and both residues play a role to stabilize oxygenated states of heme d during catalysis; 3) E445 and E99 are each protonated accompanying electron transfer to heme d and heme b₅₉₅, respectively; 4) All protons used to generate water within the heme d active site come from the cytoplasm and are delivered through a channel that must include internal water molecules to assist proton transfer: [cytoplasm] → E107 → E99 (heme b₅₉₅) → E445 (heme d) → oxygenated heme d.

Spectral-Kinetic Analysis of Recombination Reaction of Heme Centers of bd-Type Quinol Oxidase from Escherichia coli with Carbon Monoxide

Recombination of the isolated, fully reduced bd-type quinol oxidase from Escherichia coli with carbon monoxide was studied by pulsed absorption spectrophotometry with microsecond time resolution. Analysis of the kinetic phases of recombination was carried out using the global analysis of multiwavelength kinetic data ("Global fitting"). It was found that the unresolved photodissociation of CO is followed by a stepwise (with four phases) recombination with characteristic times (τ) of about 20 µs, 250 µs, 1.1 ms, and 24 ms. The 20-µs phase most likely reflects bimolecular recombination of CO with heme d. Two subsequent kinetic transitions, with τ ~ 250 µs and 1.1 ms, were resolved for the first time. It is assumed that the 250-µs phase is heterogeneous and includes two different processes: recombination of CO with ~7% of heme b₅₉₅ and transition of heme d from a pentacoordinate to a transient hexacoordinate state in this enzyme population. The 24-ms transition probably reflects a return of heme d to the pentacoordinate state in the same protein fraction. The 1.1-ms phase can be explained by recombination of CO with ~15% of heme b₅₅₈. Possible models of interaction of CO with different heme centers are discussed.

Cytochrome bd Displays Significant Quinol Peroxidase Activity

Cytochrome bd is a prokaryotic terminal oxidase that catalyses the electrogenic reduction of oxygen to water using ubiquinol as electron donor. Cytochrome bd is a tri-haem integral membrane enzyme carrying a low-spin haem b₅₅₈, and two high-spin haems: b₅₉₅ and d. Here we show that besides its oxidase activity, cytochrome bd from Escherichia coli is a genuine quinol peroxidase (QPO) that reduces hydrogen peroxide to water. The highly active and pure enzyme preparation used in this study did not display the catalase activity recently reported for E. coli cytochrome bd. To our knowledge, cytochrome bd is the first membrane-bound quinol peroxidase detected in E. coli. The observation that cytochrome bd is a quinol peroxidase, can provide a biochemical basis for its role in detoxification of hydrogen peroxide and may explain the frequent findings reported in the literature that indicate increased sensitivity to hydrogen peroxide and decreased virulence in mutants that lack the enzyme.

Structure of a bd oxidase indicates similar mechanisms for membrane-integrated oxygen reductases

The cytochrome bd oxidases are terminal oxidases that are present in bacteria and archaea. They reduce molecular oxygen (dioxygen) to water, avoiding the production of reactive oxygen species. In addition to their contribution to the proton motive force, they mediate viability under oxygen-related stress conditions and confer tolerance to nitric oxide, thus contributing to the virulence of pathogenic bacteria. Here we present the atomic structure of the bd oxidase from Geobacillus thermodenitrificans, revealing a pseudosymmetrical subunit fold. The arrangement and order of the heme cofactors support the conclusions from spectroscopic measurements that the cleavage of the dioxygen bond may be mechanistically similar to that in the heme-copper-containing oxidases, even though the structures are completely different.

Evidence for Fast Electron Transfer between the High-Spin Haems in Cytochrome bd-I from Escherichia coli

Cytochrome bd-I is one of the three proton motive force-generating quinol oxidases in the O₂-dependent respiratory chain of Escherichia coli. It contains one low-spin haem (b₅₅₈) and the two high-spin haems (b₅₉₅ and d) as the redox-active cofactors. In order to examine the flash-induced intraprotein reverse electron transfer (the so-called ''electron backflow''), CO was photolyzed from the ferrous haem d in one-electron reduced (b₅₅₈³⁺b₅₉₅³⁺d²⁺-CO) cytochrome bd-I, and the fully reduced (b₅₅₈²⁺b₅₉₅²⁺d²⁺-CO) oxidase as a control. In contrast to the fully reduced cytochrome bd-I, the transient spectrum of one-electron reduced oxidase at a delay time of 1.5 μs is clearly different from that at a delay time of 200 ns. The difference between the two spectra can be modeled as the electron transfer from haem d to haem b₅₉₅ in 3–4% of the cytochrome bd-I population. Thus, the interhaem electron backflow reaction induced by photodissociation of CO from haem d in one-electron reduced cytochrome bd-I comprises two kinetically different phases: the previously unnoticed fast electron transfer from haem d to haem b₅₉₅ within 0.2–1.5 μs and the slower well-defined electron equilibration with τ ~16 μs. The major new finding of this work is the lack of electron transfer at 200 ns.

Real-time kinetics of electrogenic Na(+) transport by rhodopsin from the marine flavobacterium Dokdonia sp. PRO95

Discovery of the light-driven sodium-motive pump Na⁺-rhodopsin (NaR) has initiated studies of the molecular mechanism of this novel membrane-linked energy transducer. In this paper, we investigated the photocycle of NaR from the marine flavobacterium Dokdonia sp. PRO95 and identified electrogenic and Na⁺-dependent steps of this cycle. We found that the NaR photocycle is composed of at least four steps: NaR₅₁₉ + hv → K₅₈₅ → (L₄₅₀↔M₄₉₅) → O₅₈₅ → NaR₅₁₉. The third step is the only step that depends on the Na⁺ concentration inside right-side-out NaR-containing proteoliposomes, indicating that this step is coupled with Na⁺ binding to NaR. For steps 2, 3, and 4, the values of the rate constants are 4×10⁴ s^–1, 4.7 × 10³ M^–1 s^–1, and 150 s^–1, respectively. These steps contributed 15, 15, and 70% of the total membrane electric potential (Δψ ~ 200 mV) generated by a single turnover of NaR incorporated into liposomes and attached to phospholipid-impregnated collodion film. On the basis of these observations, a mechanism of light-driven Na⁺ pumping by NaR is suggested.

Oxygen as Acceptor

Like most bacteria, Escherichia coli has a flexible and branched respiratory chain that enables the prokaryote to live under a variety of environmental conditions, from highly aerobic to completely anaerobic. In general, the bacterial respiratory chain is composed of dehydrogenases, a quinone pool, and reductases. Substrate-specific dehydrogenases transfer reducing equivalents from various donor substrates (NADH, succinate, glycerophosphate, formate, hydrogen, pyruvate, and lactate) to a quinone pool (menaquinone, ubiquinone, and dimethylmenoquinone). Then electrons from reduced quinones (quinols) are transferred by terminal reductases to different electron acceptors. Under aerobic growth conditions, the terminal electron acceptor is molecular oxygen. A transfer of electrons from quinol to O₂ is served by two major oxidoreductases (oxidases), cytochrome bo₃ encoded by cyoABCDE and cytochrome bd encoded by cydABX. Terminal oxidases of aerobic respiratory chains of bacteria, which use O₂ as the final electron acceptor, can oxidize one of two alternative electron donors, either cytochrome c or quinol. This review compares the effects of different inhibitors on the respiratory activities of cytochrome bo₃ and cytochrome bd in E. coli. It also presents a discussion on the genetics and the prosthetic groups of cytochrome bo₃ and cytochrome bd. The E. coli membrane contains three types of quinones that all have an octaprenyl side chain (C₄₀). It has been proposed that the bo₃ oxidase can have two ubiquinone-binding sites with different affinities. "WHAT'S NEW" IN THE REVISED ARTICLE: The revised article comprises additional information about subunit composition of cytochrome bd and its role in bacterial resistance to nitrosative and oxidative stresses. Also, we present the novel data on the electrogenic function of appBCX-encoded cytochrome bd-II, a second bd-type oxidase that had been thought not to contribute to generation of a proton motive force in E. coli, although its spectral properties closely resemble those of cydABX-encoded cytochrome bd.

Cytochrome bd from Escherichia coli catalyzes peroxynitrite decomposition

Cytochrome bd is a prokaryotic respiratory quinol oxidase phylogenetically unrelated to heme-copper oxidases, that was found to promote virulence in some bacterial pathogens. Cytochrome bd from Escherichia coli was previously reported to contribute not only to proton motive force generation, but also to bacterial resistance to nitric oxide (NO) and hydrogen peroxide (H2O2). Here, we investigated the interaction of the purified enzyme with peroxynitrite (ONOO(-)), another harmful reactive species produced by the host to kill invading microorganisms. We found that addition of ONOO(-) to cytochrome bd in turnover with ascorbate and N,N,N',N'-tetramethyl-p-phenylenediamine (TMPD) causes the irreversible inhibition of a small (≤15%) protein fraction, due to the NO generated from ONOO(-) and not to ONOO(-) itself. Consistently, addition of ONOO(-) to cells of the E. coli strain GO105/pTK1, expressing cytochrome bd as the only terminal oxidase, caused only a minor (≤5%) irreversible inhibition of O2 consumption, without measurable release of NO. Furthermore, by directly monitoring the kinetics of ONOO(-) decomposition by stopped-flow absorption spectroscopy, it was found that the purified E. coli cytochrome bd in turnover with O2 is able to metabolize ONOO(-) with an apparent turnover rate as high as ~10 mol ONOO(-) (mol enzyme)(-1) s(-1) at 25°C. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time that the kinetics of ONOO(-) decomposition by a terminal oxidase has been investigated. These results strongly suggest a protective role of cytochrome bd against ONOO(-) damage.

Microsecond time-resolved absorption spectroscopy used to study CO compounds of cytochrome bd from Escherichia coli

Cytochrome bd is a tri-heme (b558, b595, d) respiratory oxygen reductase that is found in many bacteria including pathogenic species. It couples the electron transfer from quinol to O2 with generation of an electrochemical proton gradient. We examined photolysis and subsequent recombination of CO with isolated cytochrome bd from Escherichia coli in one-electron reduced (MV) and fully reduced (R) states by microsecond time-resolved absorption spectroscopy at 532-nm excitation. Both Soret and visible band regions were examined. CO photodissociation from MV enzyme possibly causes fast (τ<1.5 µs) electron transfer from heme d to heme b595 in a small fraction of the protein, not reported earlier. Then the electron migrates to heme b558 (τ∼16 µs). It returns from the b-hemes to heme d with τ∼180 µs. Unlike cytochrome bd in the R state, in MV enzyme the apparent contribution of absorbance changes associated with CO dissociation from heme d is small, if any. Photodissociation of CO from heme d in MV enzyme is suggested to be accompanied by the binding of an internal ligand (L) at the opposite side of the heme. CO recombines with heme d (τ∼16 µs) yielding a transient hexacoordinate state (CO-Fe2+-L). Then the ligand slowly (τ∼30 ms) dissociates from heme d. Recombination of CO with a reduced heme b in a fraction of the MV sample may also contribute to the 30-ms phase. In R enzyme, CO recombines to heme d (τ∼20 µs), some heme b558 (τ∼0.2-3 ms), and finally migrates from heme d to heme b595 (τ∼24 ms) in ∼5% of the enzyme population. Data are consistent with the recent nanosecond study of Rappaport et al. conducted on the membranes at 640-nm excitation but limited to the Soret band. The additional phases were revealed due to differences in excitation and other experimental conditions.

Subunit CydX of Escherichia coli cytochrome bd ubiquinol oxidase is essential for assembly and stability of the di-heme active site

Cytochrome bd ubiquinol oxidase uses the electron transport from ubiquinol to oxygen to establish a proton gradient across the membrane. The enzyme complex consists of subunits CydA and B and contains two b- and one d-type hemes as cofactors. Recently, it was proposed that a third subunit named CydX is essential for the function of the complex. Here, we show that CydX is indeed a subunit of purified Escherichia coli cytochrome bd oxidase and that the small protein is needed either for the assembly or the stability of the active site di-heme center and, thus, is essential for oxidase activity.

Cytochrome bd oxidase and bacterial tolerance to oxidative and nitrosative stress

Cytochrome bd is a prokaryotic respiratory quinol:O2 oxidoreductase, phylogenetically unrelated to the extensively studied heme-copper oxidases (HCOs). The enzyme contributes to energy conservation by generating a proton motive force, though working with a lower energetic efficiency as compared to HCOs. Relevant to patho-physiology, members of the bd-family were shown to promote virulence in some pathogenic bacteria, which makes these enzymes of interest also as potential drug targets. Beyond its role in cell bioenergetics, cytochrome bd accomplishes several additional physiological functions, being apparently implicated in the response of the bacterial cell to a number of stress conditions. Compelling experimental evidence suggests that the enzyme enhances bacterial tolerance to oxidative and nitrosative stress conditions, owing to its unusually high nitric oxide (NO) dissociation rate and a notable catalase activity; the latter has been recently documented in one of the two bd-type oxidases of Escherichia coli. Current knowledge on cytochrome bd and its reactivity with O2, NO and H2O2 is summarized in this review in the light of the hypothesis that the preferential (over HCOs) expression of cytochrome bd in pathogenic bacteria may represent a strategy to evade the host immune attack based on production of NO and reactive oxygen species (ROS). This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: 18th European Bioenergetic Conference.

A biochemical approach to study the role of the terminal oxidases in aerobic respiration in Shewanella oneidensis MR-1

The genome of the facultative anaerobic γ-proteobacterium Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 encodes for three terminal oxidases: a bd-type quinol oxidase and two heme-copper oxidases, a A-type cytochrome c oxidase and a cbb₃-type oxidase. In this study, we used a biochemical approach and directly measured oxidase activities coupled to mass-spectrometry analysis to investigate the physiological role of the three terminal oxidases under aerobic and microaerobic conditions. Our data revealed that the cbb₃-type oxidase is the major terminal oxidase under aerobic conditions while both cbb₃-type and bd-type oxidases are involved in respiration at low-O₂ tensions. On the contrary, the low O₂-affinity A-type cytochrome c oxidase was not detected in our experimental conditions even under aerobic conditions and would therefore not be required for aerobic respiration in S. oneidensis MR-1. In addition, the deduced amino acid sequence suggests that the A-type cytochrome c oxidase is a ccaa₃-type oxidase since an uncommon extra-C terminal domain contains two c-type heme binding motifs. The particularity of the aerobic respiratory pathway and the physiological implication of the presence of a ccaa₃-type oxidase in S. oneidensis MR-1 are discussed.

Cytochrome bd oxidase from Escherichia coli displays high catalase activity: an additional defense against oxidative stress

Cytochrome bd oxygen reductase from Escherichia coli has three hemes, b558, b595 and d. We found that the enzyme, as-prepared or in turnover with O2, rapidly decomposes H2O2 with formation of approximately half a mole of O2 per mole of H2O2. Such catalase activity vanishes upon cytochrome bd reduction, does not compete with the oxygen-reductase activity, is insensitive to NO, CO, antimycin-A and N-ethylmaleimide (NEM), but is inhibited by cyanide (Ki ~2.5μM) and azide. The activity, possibly associated with heme-b595, was also observed in catalase-deficient E. coli cells following cytochrome bd over-expression suggesting a protective role against oxidative stress in vivo.