Reply to Liang and Gornish: Climate and livestock grazing jointly regulate grassland ecosystem multifunctionality

Differential effects of grazing intensity on carbon sequestration in arid versus humid grasslands across China

Livestock grazing, as a primary utilization practice for grasslands, plays a crucial role in carbon cycling process and its budget. Whether the impacts of different grazing intensities on carbon sequestration vary with precipitation over a broad geographic scales across China's grasslands remains unclear. In the context of striving for carbon neutrality, we carried out a meta-analysis based on 156 peer-reviewed journal articles to synthesize the general impacts of different grazing intensities on carbon sequestration with different precipitations. Our results showed that light, moderate, and heavy grazing dramatically reduced the soil organic carbon stocks by 3.43 %, 13.68 %, and 16.77 % in arid grasslands, respectively (P < 0.05), while light and moderate grazing did not alter soil organic carbon stocks in humid grasslands (P > 0.05). Moreover, the change rates of soil organic carbon stocks were all tightly positively associated with those of soil water content under different grazing intensities (P < 0.05). Further analysis revealed strong positive relationships between mean annual precipitation with the change rates of above- and belowground biomasses, soil microbial biomass carbon, and soil organic carbon stocks under moderate grazing intensity (P < 0.05). These findings imply that carbon sequestration is relatively less tolerant to grazing disturbance in arid grasslands than humid grasslands, which may be primary due to the grazing-intensified water limitation for plant growth and soil microbial activities under low precipitation. Our study is of implication to predict carbon budget of China's grasslands and help adopt sustainable management to strive for carbon neutrality.