Multistate structures of the MLL1-WRAD complex bound to H2B-ubiquitinated nucleosome

WD repeat domain 5 (WDR5) inhibitors: a patent review (2016-present)

INTRODUCTION

WDR5 is an epigenetic scaffolding protein that has attracted significant interest as an anti-cancer drug target, especially in MLL-rearranged leukemias. The most druggable 'WIN-site' on WDR5, which tethers WDR5 to chromatin, has been successfully targeted with multiple classes of exquisitely potent small-molecule protein-protein interaction inhibitors. Earlier progress has also been made on the development of WDR5 degraders and inhibitors at the 'WBM-site' on the opposite face of WDR5.

AREAS COVERED

Based on an international survey of the patent literature using SciFinder from 2016-2024, herein we provide a comprehensive account of the chemical matter targeting WDR5, with a particular focus on proprietary compounds that are underreported in the existing academic literature. Our survey illuminates challenges for the field to overcome: a broad lack of chemical diversity, confusion about the molecular mechanism of WIN-site inhibitors, a paucity of brain-penetrant scaffolds despite emerging evidence of activity in brain cancers, sparse pharmacokinetic, metabolic, and disposition characterization, and the absence of safety or efficacy data in humans.

EXPERT OPINION

It is our opinion that the best-in-class WIN-site inhibitors (from the imidazole class) merit advancement into clinical testing, likely against leukemia, which should provide much-needed clarity about the exciting but unproven potential of WDR5 as a next-generation therapeutic target.

The N-terminal region of DNMT3A engages the nucleosome surface to aid chromatin recruitment

DNA methyltransferase 3A (DNMT3A) plays a critical role in establishing and maintaining DNA methylation patterns in vertebrates. Here we structurally and biochemically explore the interaction of DNMT3A1 with diverse modified nucleosomes indicative of different chromatin environments. A cryo-EM structure of the full-length DNMT3A1-DNMT3L complex with a H2AK119ub nucleosome reveals that the DNMT3A1 ubiquitin-dependent recruitment (UDR) motif interacts specifically with H2AK119ub and makes extensive contacts with the core nucleosome histone surface. This interaction facilitates robust DNMT3A1 binding to nucleosomes, and previously unexplained DNMT3A disease-associated mutations disrupt this interface. Furthermore, the UDR-nucleosome interaction synergises with other DNMT3A chromatin reading elements in the absence of histone ubiquitylation. H2AK119ub does not stimulate DNMT3A DNA methylation activity, as observed for the previously described H3K36me2 mark, which may explain low levels of DNA methylation on H2AK119ub marked facultative heterochromatin. This study highlights the importance of multivalent binding of DNMT3A to histone modifications and the nucleosome surface and increases our understanding of how DNMT3A1 chromatin recruitment occurs.

Histone ubiquitination: Role in genome integrity and chromatin organization

Maintenance of genome integrity is a precise but tedious and complex job for the cell. Several post-translational modifications (PTMs) play vital roles in maintaining the genome integrity. Although ubiquitination is one of the most crucial PTMs, which regulates the localization and stability of the nonhistone proteins in various cellular and developmental processes, ubiquitination of the histones is a pivotal epigenetic event critically regulating chromatin architecture. In addition to genome integrity, importance of ubiquitination of core histones (H2A, H2A, H3, and H4) and linker histone (H1) have been reported in several cellular processes. However, the complex interplay of histone ubiquitination and other PTMs, as well as the intricate chromatin architecture and dynamics, pose a significant challenge to unravel how histone ubiquitination safeguards genome stability. Therefore, further studies are needed to elucidate the interactions between histone ubiquitination and other PTMs, and their role in preserving genome integrity. Here, we review all types of histone ubiquitinations known till date in maintaining genomic integrity during transcription, replication, cell cycle, and DNA damage response processes. In addition, we have also discussed the role of histone ubiquitination in regulating other histone PTMs emphasizing methylation and acetylation as well as their potential implications in chromatin architecture. Further, we have also discussed the involvement of deubiquitination enzymes (DUBs) in controlling histone ubiquitination in modulating cellular processes.

To Ub or not to Ub: The epic dilemma of histones that regulate gene expression and epigenetic cross-talk

A dynamic array of histone post-translational modifications (PTMs) regulate diverse cellular processes in the eukaryotic chromatin. Among them, histone ubiquitination is particularly complex as it alters nucleosome surface area fostering intricate cross-talk with other chromatin modifications. Ubiquitin signaling profoundly impacts DNA replication, repair, and transcription. Histones can undergo varied extent of ubiquitination such as mono, multi-mono, and polyubiquitination, which brings about distinct cellular fates. Mechanistic studies of the ubiquitin landscape in chromatin have unveiled a fascinating tapestry of events that orchestrate gene regulation. In this review, we summarize the key contributors involved in mediating different histone ubiquitination and deubiquitination events, and discuss their mechanism which impacts cell transcriptional identity and DNA damage response. We also focus on the proteins bearing epigenetic reader modules critical in discerning site-specific histone ubiquitination, pivotal for establishing complex epigenetic crosstalk. Moreover, we highlight the role of histone ubiquitination in different human diseases including neurodevelopmental disorders and cancer. Overall the review elucidates the intricate orchestration of histone ubiquitination impacting diverse cellular functions and disease pathogenesis, and provides insights into the current challenges of targeting them for therapeutic interventions.

Quantitative Hydrogen-Deuterium Exchange Mass Spectrometry for Simultaneous Structural Characterization and Affinity Indexing of Single Target Drug Candidate Libraries

Hydrogen-deuterium eXchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) is increasingly used in drug development to locate binding sites and to identify allosteric effects in drug/target interactions. However, the potential of this technique to quantitatively analyze drug candidate libraries remains largely unexplored. Here, a collection of 13 WDR5-targeting small molecules with surface plasmon resonance (SPR) dissociation coefficients (KD) ranging from 20 nM to ∼116 μM were characterized using differential HDX-MS (ΔHDX-MS). Conventional qualitative analysis of the ΔHDX-MS data set revealed the binding interfaces for all compounds and allosteric effects where present. We then demonstrated that ΔHDX-MS signal-to-noise (S/N) not only can rank library-relative affinity but also can accurately predict KD from a calibration curve constructed from high-quality SPR data. Three methods for S/N calculation are explored, each suitable for libraries with different characteristics. Our results demonstrate the potential for ΔHDX-MS use in drug candidate library affinity validation and/or determination while simultaneously characterizing structure.

Approaching the catalytic mechanism of protein lysine methyltransferases by biochemical and simulation techniques

Protein lysine methyltransferases (PKMTs) transfer up to three methyl groups to the side chains of lysine residues in proteins and fulfill important regulatory functions by controlling protein stability, localization and protein/protein interactions. The methylation reactions are highly regulated, and aberrant methylation of proteins is associated with several types of diseases including neurologic disorders, cardiovascular diseases, and various types of cancer. This review describes novel insights into the catalytic machinery of various PKMTs achieved by the combined application of biochemical experiments and simulation approaches during the last years, focusing on clinically relevant and well-studied enzymes of this group like DOT1L, SMYD1-3, SET7/9, G9a/GLP, SETD2, SUV420H2, NSD1/2, different MLLs and EZH2. Biochemical experiments have unraveled many mechanistic features of PKMTs concerning their substrate and product specificity, processivity and the effects of somatic mutations observed in PKMTs in cancer cells. Structural data additionally provided information about the substrate recognition, enzyme-substrate complex formation, and allowed for simulations of the substrate peptide interaction and mechanism of PKMTs with atomistic resolution by molecular dynamics and hybrid quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics methods. These simulation technologies uncovered important mechanistic details of the PKMT reaction mechanism including the processes responsible for the deprotonation of the target lysine residue, essential conformational changes of the PKMT upon substrate binding, but also rationalized regulatory principles like PKMT autoinhibition. Further developments are discussed that could bring us closer to a mechanistic understanding of catalysis of this important class of enzymes in the near future. The results described here illustrate the power of the investigation of enzyme mechanisms by the combined application of biochemical experiments and simulation technologies.

Breaking the K48-chain: linking ubiquitin beyond protein degradation

The discovery of ubiquitin conjugation to lysines and the role of K48-linked polyubiquitin in targeting substrates for proteasomal degradation was followed by revelation of non-degradative roles of ubiquitination and, more recently, of non-canonical covalent ubiquitin linkages. Here we summarize findings of the ever-expanding array of ubiquitin signals and their biological roles.

The Core Complex of Yeast COMPASS and Human Mixed-Lineage Leukemia (MLL), Structure, Function, and Recognition of the Nucleosome

Yeast COMPASS (complex of proteins associated with Set1) and human MLL (mixed-lineage leukemia) complexes are histone H3 lysine 4 methyltransferases with critical roles in gene regulation and embryonic development. Both complexes share a conserved C-terminal SET domain, responsible for catalyzing histone H3 K4 methylation on nucleosomes. Notably, their catalytic activity toward nucleosomes is enhanced and optimized with assembly of auxiliary subunits. In this review, we aim to illustrate the recent X-ray and cryo-EM structures of yeast COMPASS and human MLL1 core complexes bound to either unmodified nucleosome core particle (NCP) or H2B mono-ubiquitinated NCP (H2Bub.NCP). We further delineate how each auxiliary component of the complex contributes to the NCP and ubiquitin recognition to maximize the methyltransferase activity.

New advances in cross-linking mass spectrometry toward structural systems biology

Elucidating protein-protein interaction (PPI) networks and their structural features within cells is central to understanding fundamental biology and associations of cell phenotypes with human pathologies. Owing to technological advancements during the last decade, cross-linking mass spectrometry (XL-MS) has become an enabling technology for delineating interaction landscapes of proteomes as they exist in living systems. XL-MS is unique due to its capability to simultaneously capture PPIs from native environments and uncover interaction contacts though identification of cross-linked peptides, thereby permitting the determination of both identity and connectivity of PPIs in cells. In combination with high resolution structural tools such as cryo-electron microscopy and AI-assisted prediction, XL-MS has contributed significantly to elucidating architectures of large protein assemblies. This review highlights the latest developments in XL-MS technologies and their applications in proteome-wide analysis to advance structural systems biology.

Phase separation promotes a highly active oligomeric scaffold of the MLL1 core complex for regulation of histone H3K4 methylation

Enzymes that regulate the degree of histone H3 lysine 4 (H3K4) methylation are crucial for proper cellular differentiation and are frequently mutated in cancer. The Mixed lineage leukemia (MLL) family of enzymes deposit H3K4 mono-, di-, or trimethylation at distinct genomic locations, requiring precise spatial and temporal control. Despite evidence that the degree of H3K4 methylation is controlled in part by a hierarchical assembly pathway with key subcomplex components, we previously found that the assembled state of the MLL1 core complex is not favored at physiological temperature. To better understand this paradox, we tested the hypothesis that increasing the concentration of subunits in a biomolecular condensate overcomes this thermodynamic barrier via mass action. Here, we demonstrate that MLL1 core complex phase separation stimulates enzymatic activity up to 60-fold but not primarily by concentrating subunits into droplets. Instead, we found that stimulated activity is largely due to the formation of an altered oligomeric scaffold that greatly reduces substrate Km. We posit that phase separation-induced scaffolding of the MLL1 core complex is a potential "switch-like" mechanism for spatiotemporal control of H3K4 methylation through the rapid formation or dissolution of biomolecular condensates within RNA Pol II transcription factories.

Diverse modes of regulating methyltransferase activity by histone ubiquitination

Post-translational modification of histones plays a central role in regulating transcription. Methylation of histone H3 at lysines 4 (H3K4) and 79 (H3K79) play roles in activating transcription whereas methylation of H3K27 is a repressive mark. These modifications, in turn, depend upon prior monoubiquitination of specific histone residues in a phenomenon known as histone crosstalk. Earlier work had provided insights into the mechanism by which monoubiquitination histone H2BK120 stimulates H3K4 methylation by COMPASS/MLL1 and H3K79 methylation by DOT1L, and monoubiquitinated H2AK119 stimulates methylation of H3K27 by the PRC2 complex. Recent studies have shed new light on the role of individual subunits and paralogs in regulating the activity of PRC2 and how additional post-translational modifications regulate yeast Dot1 and human DOT1L, as well as provided new insights into the regulation of MLL1 by H2BK120ub.

The expedient, CAET-assisted synthesis of dual-monoubiquitinated histone H3 enables evaluation of its interaction with DNMT1

Site-selective conjugation chemistry has proven effective to synthesize homogenously ubiquitinated histones. Recently, a powerful strategy using 2-((2-chloroethyl) amino) ethane-1-thiol (CAET) as a bifunctional handle was developed to generate chemically stable ubiquitin chains without racemization and homodimerization. Herein, we extend this strategy to the expedient synthesis of ubiquitinated histones, exemplifying its utility to not only synthesize single-monoubiquitinated histones, but dual-monoubiquitinated histones as well. The synthetic histones enabled us to evaluate the binding of DNMT1 to ubiquitinated nucleosomes and map the hotspots of this interaction. Our work highlights the potential of modern chemical protein synthesis to synthesize ubiquitinated histones for epigenetic studies.

Structural insights on the KMT2-NCP interaction

The MLL/KMT2 family enzymes are frequently mutated in human cancers and congenital diseases. They deposit the majority of histone 3 lysine 4 (H3K4) mono-, di-, or tri-methylation in mammals and are tightly associated with gene activation. Structural and biochemical studies in recent years provide in-depth understanding of how the MLL1 and homologous yeast SET1 complexes interact with the nucleosome core particle (NCP) and how their activities for H3K4 methylation are regulated by the conserved core components. Here, we will discuss the recent single molecule cryo-EM studies on the MLL1 and ySET1 complexes bound on the NCP. These studies highlight the dynamic regulation of the MLL/SET1 family lysine methyltransferases with unique features as compared with other histone lysine methyltransferases. These studies provide insights for loci-specific regulation of H3K4 methylation states in cells. The mechanistic studies on the MLL1 complex have already led to the development of the MLL1 inhibitors that show efficacy in acute leukemia and metastatic breast cancers. Future studies on the MLL/SET1 family enzymes will continue to bring to light potential therapeutic opportunities.

Hierarchical assembly of the MLL1 core complex regulates H3K4 methylation and is dependent on temperature and component concentration

Enzymes of the mixed lineage leukemia (MLL) family of histone H3 lysine 4 (H3K4) methyltransferases are critical for cellular differentiation and development and are regulated by interaction with a conserved subcomplex consisting of WDR5, RbBP5, Ash2L, and DPY30. While pairwise interactions between complex subunits have been determined, the mechanisms regulating holocomplex assembly are unknown. In this investigation, we systematically characterized the biophysical properties of a reconstituted human MLL1 core complex and found that the MLL1-WDR5 heterodimer interacts with the RbBP5-Ash2L-DPY30 subcomplex in a hierarchical assembly pathway that is highly dependent on concentration and temperature. Surprisingly, we found that the disassembled state is favored at physiological temperature, where the enzyme rapidly becomes irreversibly inactivated, likely because of complex components becoming trapped in nonproductive conformations. Increased protein concentration partially overcomes this thermodynamic barrier for complex assembly, suggesting a potential regulatory mechanism for spatiotemporal control of H3K4 methylation. Together, these results are consistent with the hypothesis that regulated assembly of the MLL1 core complex underlies an important mechanism for establishing different H3K4 methylation states in mammalian genomes.