Revertant seedlings from crown gall tumors retain a portion of the bacterial Ti plasmid DNA sequences

Natural Agrobacterium Transformants: Recent Results and Some Theoretical Considerations

Agrobacterium rhizogenes causes hairy root growth on a large number of plant species. It does so by transferring specific DNA fragments (T-DNA) from its root-inducing plasmid (pRi) into plant cells. Expression of T-DNA genes leads to abnormal root growth and production of specific metabolites (opines) which are taken up by the bacterium and used for its growth. Recent work has shown that several Nicotiana, Linaria, and Ipomoea species contain T-DNA genes from A. rhizogenes in their genomes. Plants carrying such T-DNAs (called cellular T-DNA or cT-DNA) can be considered as natural transformants. In the Nicotiana genus, seven different T-DNAs are found originating from different Agrobacterium strains, and in the Tomentosae section no <4 successive insertion events took place. In several cases cT-DNA genes were found to be expressed. In some Nicotiana tabacum cultivars the opine synthesis gene TB-mas2' is expressed in the roots. These cultivars were found to produce opines. Here we review what is known about natural Agrobacterium transformants, develop a theoretical framework to analyze this unusual phenomenon, and provide some outlines for further research.

Localization of the T-DNA on marker chromosomes in transformed tobacco cells by in situ hybridization

Chromosome and molecular analyses were conducted on tobacco cells which had been transformed by the T-DNA of the Ti-plasmid. These analyses showed that there were specific chromosome rearrangements in the transformed cells (marker chromosomes). There was a positive correlation between the number of marker chromosomes per cell and the oncogenic potential of the transformed cells. However, we show, using the Southern hybridization method, that the TL fragment of T-DNA, but not the TR, clearly hybridizes with nuclear DNA. In situ hybridization was used to locate the insertion site of T-DNA: the hybridization signal was found on a small metacentric chromosome. This chromosome may occur single or translocated onto other chromosomes, to make marker chromosomes. Thus, by locating the T-DNA, we have confirmed the correlation between the marker chromosomes and the oncogenic potential.

Segregation of T-DNA copies in the progeny of a regenerant plant from a mannopine-positive hairy root line

We have analyzed opine content, T-DNA content, and developmental features of one hairy root culture line and its progeny. Opine-positive progeny still have the hairy root phenotype and have essentially the same T-DNA structure as the parental plant. Opineless progeny do not exhibit the hairy root phenotype. Some of them do not contain any T-DNA sequences, whereas others contain only the left part of T-DNA. These results are compatible with the hypothesis that, in the hairy root line analyzed, the left part of T-DNA is integrated independently from the core T-DNA and can therefore segregate during sexual reproduction.

Phenotypic and genetic variations in crown-gall tumour cells of tobacco

Phenotypic and genetic variations of tumour cells were analysed both quantitatively and qualitatively in clones and subclones of a crown-gall strain. Thus, growth rates, grafting tests, octopine synthesis, estimations of the T-DNA contents, modifications in the numbers, and structures of chromosomes were examined. Phenotypic variations are closely associated with genetic changes, including variation in chromosome number (which is shown to be non-specific to the tumoral state) and, above all, variation in the copy-number of T-DNA sequences per cell, and structural rearrangements of chromosomes. Such rearrangements are characterized by specific marker chromosomes in the tumour cells and they correlate with the degree of oncogenicity of the cells.

T-DNA rearrangements due to tissue culture: somaclonal variation in crown gall tissues

After three years of apparent stability in tissue culture, the single cell derived shooty crown gall line sNT1.013 produced a revertant shoot which had switched from non-rooting (Rod(+)) and octopine synthesizing (Ocs(+)) to Rod(-) Ocs(-), indicating that in this revertant TL-DNA genes 4 (causing the Rod(+) trait) and gene 3 (causing the Ocs(+) trait) had been inactivated. Southern blots revealed that the inactivation of these T-DNA genes was the result of a considerable rearrangement of DNA sequences, accompanied by deletions and possibly also by DNA amplifications. This study for the first time unambiguously proves that foreign genes which have been introduced via Agrobacterium tumefaciens can, at a low frequency, be inactivated after T-DNA integration because of reorganization of T-DNA sequences during tissue culture. This can be considered as an event of somaclonal variation.

A disarmed binary vector from Agrobacterium tumefaciens functions in Agrobacterium rhizogenes : Frequent co-transformation of two distinct T-DNAs

Binary Ti plasmid vector systems consist of two plasmids in Agrobacterium, where one plasmid contains the DNA that can be transferred to plant cells and the other contains the virulence (vir) genes which are necessary for the DNA transfer but are not themselves stably transferred. We have constructed two nononcogenic vectors (pARC4 and pARC8) based on the binary Ti plasmid system of Agrobacterium tumefaciens for plant transformation. Each vector contains the left and right termini sequences from pTiT37. These sequences, which determine the extent of DNA transferred to plant cells, flank unique restriction enzyme sites and a marker gene that functions in the plant (nopaline synthase in pARC4 or neomycin phosphotransferase in pARC8). After construction in vitro, the vectors can be conjugatively transferred from E. coli to any of several Agrobacterium strains containing vir genes. Using A. rhizogenes strain A4 containing the resident Ri plasmid plus a vector with the nopaline synthase marker, we found that up to 50% of the hairy roots resulting from the infection of alfalfa or tomato synthesized nopaline. Thus, vector DNA encoding an unselected marker was frequently co-transferred with Ri plasmid DNA to an alfalfa or a tomato cell. In contrast, the frequency of co-transfer to soybean cells was difficult to estimate because we encountered a high background of non-transformed roots using this species. Up to five copies of the vector DNA between the termini sequences were faithfully transferred and maintained in most cases suggesting that the termini sequences and the vir genes from the Ri and Ti plasmids are functionally equivalent.

Transformation of cultivated tomato by a binary vector in Agrobacterium rhizogenes: transgenic plants with normal phenotypes harbor binary vector T-DNA, but no Ri-plasmid T-DNA

Cultivated tomato was genetically transformed using two procedures. In the first procedure, punctured cotyledons were infected with "disarmed" Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain LBA4404 or with A. rhizogenes strain A4, each containing the binary vector pARC8. The chimeric neomycin phosphotransferase (NPT II) gene on pARC8 conferred on transformed plant cells the ability to grow on medium containing kanamycin. Transformation reproducible yielded kanamycin-resistant transformants in different tomato genotypes. NPT II activity was detected in transformed calli and in transgenic plants. All of these plants were phenotypically normal, fertile and set seeds. Using the second procedure, inverted cotyledons, we recovered transformed tomato plants from A. rhizogenes-induced hairy roots. In this case, all of the transgenic plants exhibited phenotypes similar to hairy root-derived plants reported for other species. Southern blot analysis on these plants revealed that the plant DNA hybridized with both probes representing pARC8-T-DNA, and the T-DNAs of the A4 Ri-plasmid. However, southern analysis on those phenotypically normal transgenic plants from the first procedure revealed that only the pARC8-T-DNA was present in the plant genome, thus indicating that the pARC8-T-DNA integrated into the plant genome independently of the pRi A4-T-DNA. Genetic analysis of these phenotypically normal transgenic plants for the kanamycin-resistance trait showed Mendelian ratios, 3∶1 and 1∶1, for selfed (R1) and in crossed progeny, respectively.

Changes in T-DNA methylation and expression are associated with phenotypic variation and plant regeneration in a crown gall tumor line

Phenotypic variation of an octopine-type crown gall tumor line resulting from changes in the pattern of T-DNA methylation and expression is described. Variants that grow as unorganized callus always express T-DNA transcripts 1 and 2. In shoot-forming variants (teratomas) only T-DNA transcript 4 is expressed. This line also regenerates normal-appearing, rooted plants in which all T-DNA expression is suppressed. Tissues from these plants require phytohormones for growth in vitro. These plants are self-fertile and transmit T-DNA through meiosis, and T-DNA suppression is maintained in the next generation. After treatment of regenerated plant tissue with 5-azacytidine, an inhibitor of DNA methylation, T-DNA transcription and phytohormone-independent tumorous growth resume. The T-DNA of cell lines in which T-DNA is not expressed is highly methylated, whereas the level of T-DNA methylation is reduced in 5-azacytidine treated cells that resume T-DNA expression and phytohormone-independent growth. The correlation between the degree of T-DNA methylation and the level of T-DNA expression indicates that hypermethylation is responsible for the suppression of T-DNA transcription.

Hairy-root-inducing plasmid: physical map and homology to tumor-inducing plasmids

A physical map was constructed for the 250-kilobase plasmid pRiA4b, which confers the virulence properties of a strain of Agrobacterium rhizogenes for hairy root disease in plants. The complete HindIII and KpnI restriction map was determined from a collection of overlapping HindIII partial digest clones. Homologous regions with two well-characterized plasmids that confer virulence for crown gall disease, plasmids pTiA6 and pTiT37, were mapped on pRiA4b. As much as 160 kilobases of pRiA4b had detectable homology to one or both of these crown-gall-tumor-inducing plasmids. About 33 kilobases of pRiA4b hybridized to the vir region of pTiA6, a segment of DNA required for virulence of Agrobacterium tumefaciens. Portions of pTiA6 and pTiT37 transferred into plant cells in crown gall disease (T-DNA), shared limited homology with scattered regions of pRiA4b. The tumor morphology loci tms-1 and tms-2 from the T-DNA of pTiA6 hybridized to pRiA4b. A T-DNA fragment containing the tml and tmr tumor morphology loci also hybridized to pRiA4b, but the homology has not been defined to a locus and is probably not specific to tmr. A segment of pRiA4b T-DNA which was transferred into plant cells in hairy root disease lacked detectable homology to pTiA6 and had limited homology at one end to the T-DNA of pTiT37.

From tumour to tuber; tumour cell characteristics and chromosome numbers of crown gall-derived tetraploid potato plants (Solanum tuberosum cv. 'Maris Bard')

Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains, known to induce tobacco crown galls that spontaneously develop shoots, were used to induce galls on cultured shoots of a tetraploid potato cultivar (Solanum tuberosum cv. 'Maris Bard'). Shoots also appeared spontaneously from the induced potato galls, although only after 2-4 months. The shoots were excised and cultured separately. Some of these frequently developed side-shoots from their axillary buds. They did not form roots and they produced opines, a strong indication that they were transformed and carried T-DNA. Grafts of the transformed plants were still able to develop tubers. Most of the tumour-derived shoots, however, formed roots, did not produce opines and were indistinguishable from the parental plants on the basis of morphology and chromosome numbers (48 chromosomes per cell). The results are discussed in relation to the origin of previously described variation among protoplast-derived potato plants and with respect to genetic engineering of tetraploid potato cultivars.

Studies on the structure of cointegrates between octopine and nopaline Ti-plasmids and their tumour-inducing properties

Stable cointegrates between incRh-1 octopine (Ach5) and nopaline (C58) Ti-plasmids, present in ten independently isolated Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains, showed identical restriction endonuclease patterns. Each cointegration event had taken place in the common sequence between the T-regions of both Ti-plasmids. This illustrates a high preference for this region when used in the formation of cointegrates. Four crown gall tissues, obtained after transformation of Nicotiana tabacum cells by one of the mutants, were analysed by using Southern blot analysis for their T-DNA structure. The borders of T-DNA frequently appeared to differ from T-DNA borders previously detected in tumour tissues that had been induced by Agrobacterium strain C58 or Ach5. Therefore, it was concluded that possibly a less stringent mechanism exists for the integration into plant DNA of T-DNA, derived from a composite (octopine/nopaline) T-region than for integration of T-DNA from a normal (octopine or nopaline) T-region.