Differential expression of crown gall tumor markers in transformants obtained after in vitro Agrobacterium tumefaciens-induced transformation of cell wall regenerating protoplasts derived from Nicotiana tabacum

Protoplasts: From Isolation to CRISPR/Cas Genome Editing Application

In the clustered regulatory interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)/CRISPR associated protein (Cas) system, protoplasts are not only useful for rapidly validating the mutagenesis efficiency of various RNA-guided endonucleases, promoters, sgRNA designs, or Cas proteins, but can also be a platform for DNA-free gene editing. To date, the latter approach has been applied to numerous crops, particularly those with complex genomes, a long juvenile period, a tendency for heterosis, and/or self-incompatibility. Protoplast regeneration is thus a key step in DNA-free gene editing. In this report, we review the history and some future prospects for protoplast technology, including protoplast transfection, transformation, fusion, regeneration, and current protoplast applications in CRISPR/Cas-based breeding.

How to start your monocot CRISPR/Cas project: plasmid design, efficiency detection, and offspring analysis

The breakthrough CRISPR (clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeat)/Cas9-mediated genome-editing technology has led to great progress in monocot research; however, several factors need to be considered for the efficient implementation of this technology. To generate genome-edited crops, single guide (sg)RNA and Cas9 DNA are delivered into plant cells and expressed, and the predicted position is targeted. Analyses of successful targeted mutations have revealed that the expression levels, expression timing, and variants of both sgRNA and Cas9 need to be sophisticatedly regulated; therefore, the promoters of these genes and the target site positions are the key factors for genome-editing efficiency. Currently, various vectors and online tools are available to aid sgRNA design. Furthermore, to reduce the sequence limitation of the protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) and for other purposes, many Cas protein variants and base editors can be used in plants. Before the stable transformation of a plant, the evaluation of vectors and target sites is therefore very important. Moreover, the delivery of Cas9-sgRNA ribonucleoproteins (RNPs) is one strategy that can be used to prevent transgene issues with the expression of sgRNA and Cas proteins. RNPs can be used to efficiently generate transgene-free genome-edited crops that can reduce transgene issues related to the generation of genetically modified organisms. In this review, we introduce new techniques for genome editing and identifying marker-free genome-edited mutants in monocot crops. Four topics are covered: the design and construction of plasmids for genome editing in monocots; alternatives to SpCas9; protoplasts and CRISPR; and screening for marker-free CRISPR/Cas9-induced mutants. We have aimed to encompass a full spectrum of information for genome editing in monocot crops.

When plant virology met Agrobacterium: the rise of the deconstructed clones

In the early days of molecular farming, Agrobacterium-mediated stable genetic transformation and the use of plant virus-based vectors were considered separate and competing technologies with complementary strengths and weaknesses. The demonstration that 'agroinfection' was the most efficient way of delivering virus-based vectors to their target plants blurred the distinction between the two technologies and permitted the development of 'deconstructed' vectors based on a number of plant viruses. The tobamoviruses, potexviruses, tobraviruses, geminiviruses and comoviruses have all been shown to be particularly well suited to the development of such vectors in dicotyledonous plants, while the development of equivalent vectors for use in monocotyledonous plants has lagged behind. Deconstructed viral vectors have proved extremely effective at the rapid, high-level production of a number of pharmaceutical proteins, some of which are currently undergoing clinical evaluation.

Reliable transient transformation of intact maize leaf cells for functional genomics and experimental study

Maize (Zea mays) transformation routinely produces stable transgenic lines essential for functional genomics; however, transient expression of target proteins in maize cells is not yet routine. Such techniques are critical for rapid testing of transgene constructs and for experimental studies. Here, we report bombardment methods that depend on leaf developmental stage and result in successful expression with broad applications. Fluorescent marker genes were constructed and bombarded into five developmental regions in a growing maize leaf. Expression efficiency was highest in the basal-most 3 cm above the ligule of an approximately 50-cm growing adult leaf. Straightforward dissection procedures provide access to the receptive leaf regions, increasing efficiency from less than one transformant per cm(2) to over 21 transformants per cm(2). Successful expression was routine for proteins from full genomic sequences driven by native regulatory regions and from complementary DNA sequences driven by the constitutive maize polyubiquitin promoter and a heterologous terminator. Four tested fusion proteins, maize PROTEIN DISULFIDE ISOMERASE-Yellow Fluorescent Protein, GLOSSY8a-monomeric Red Fluorescent Protein and maize XYLOSYLTRANSFERASE, and maize Rho-of-Plants7-monomeric Teal Fluorescent Protein, localized as predicted in the endoplasmic reticulum, Golgi, and plasma membrane, respectively. Localization patterns were similar between transient and stable modes of expression, and cotransformation was equally successful. Coexpression was also demonstrated by transiently transforming cells in a stable line expressing a second marker protein, thus increasing the utility of a single stable transformant. Given the ease of dissection procedures, this method replaces heterologous expression assays with a more direct, native, and informative system, and the techniques will be useful for localization, colocalization, and functional studies.

A plant cell factor induces Agrobacterium tumefaciens vir gene expression

The virulence genes of Agrobacterium are required for this organism to genetically transform plant cells. We show that vir gene expression is specifically induced by a small (<1000 Da) diffusible plant cell metabolite present in limiting quantities in the exudates of a variety of plant cell cultures. Active plant cell metabolism is required for the synthesis of the vir-inducing factor, and the presence of bacteria does not stimulate this production. vir-inducing factor is (i) heat and cold stable; (ii) pH stable, although vir induction with the factor is sensitive above pH 6.0; and (iii) partially hydrophobic. Induction of vir gene expression was assayed by monitoring beta-galactosidase activity in Agrobacterium strains that carry gene fusions between each of the vir loci and the lacZ gene of Escherichia coli. vir-inducing factor (partially purified on a C-18 column) induces both the expression in Agrobacterium of six distinct loci and the production of T-DNA circular molecules, which are thought to be involved in the transformation process. vir-inducing factor potentially represents the signal that Agrobacterium recognizes in nature as a plant cell susceptible to transformation.

Transformation of rice mediated by Agrobacterium tumefaciens

Agrobacterium tumefaciens has been routinely utilized in gene transfer to dicotyledonous plants, but monocotyledonous plants including important cereals were thought to be recalcitrant to this technology as they were outside the host range of crown gall. Various challenges to infect monocotyledons including rice with Agrobacterium had been made in many laboratories, but the results were not conclusive until recently. Efficient transformation protocols mediated by Agrobacterium were reported for rice in 1994 and 1996. A key point in the protocols was the fact that tissues consisting of actively dividing, embryonic cells, such as immature embryos and calli induced from scutella, were co-cultivated with Agrobacterium in the presence of acetosyringonc, which is a potent inducer of the virulence genes. It is now clear that Agrobacterium is capable of transferring DNA to monocotyledons if tissues containing 'competent' cells are infected. The studies of transformation of rice suggested that numerous factors including genotype of plants, types and ages of tissues inoculated, kind of vectors, strains of Agrobacterium, selection marker genes and selective agents, and various conditions of tissue culture, are of critical importance. Advantages of the Agrobacterium-mediated transformation in rice, like on dicotyledons, include the transfer of pieces of DNA with defined ends with minimal rearrangements, the transfer of relatively large segments of DNA, the integration of small numbers of copies of genes into plant chromosomes, and high quality and fertility of transgenic plants. Delivery of foreign DNA to rice plants via A. tumefaciens is a routine technique in a growing number of laboratories. This technique will allow the genetic improvement of diverse varieties of rice, as well as studies of many aspects of the molecular biology of rice.

Localization of the T-DNA on marker chromosomes in transformed tobacco cells by in situ hybridization

Chromosome and molecular analyses were conducted on tobacco cells which had been transformed by the T-DNA of the Ti-plasmid. These analyses showed that there were specific chromosome rearrangements in the transformed cells (marker chromosomes). There was a positive correlation between the number of marker chromosomes per cell and the oncogenic potential of the transformed cells. However, we show, using the Southern hybridization method, that the TL fragment of T-DNA, but not the TR, clearly hybridizes with nuclear DNA. In situ hybridization was used to locate the insertion site of T-DNA: the hybridization signal was found on a small metacentric chromosome. This chromosome may occur single or translocated onto other chromosomes, to make marker chromosomes. Thus, by locating the T-DNA, we have confirmed the correlation between the marker chromosomes and the oncogenic potential.

Electroporation stimulates tranformation of freshly isolated cell suspension protoplasts ofSolanum dulcamara byAgrobacterium

Freshly isolated cell suspension protoplasts ofSolanum dulcamara were mixed withAgrobacterium rhizogenes, allowed to settle for 2 h, exposed to electrical pulses and further incubated for 2h. Two pulses of 600 V cm(-1) for 2 msec separated by 15 sec produced transformed colonies at relative and absolute transformation frequencies which were 3-4 and 10 fold greater than those obtained by co-cultivation of 3 days old protoplast-derived cells with bacteria. Transformed colonies were not produced when freshly isolated protoplasts were mixed withAgrobacterium but not electroporated. Biochemical analysis confirmed the transgenic nature of plants regenerated from protoplast-derived tissues.

Mass-spectrometric quantitation of cytokinins in tobacco crown-gall tumours induced by mutated octopine Ti plasmids of Agrobacterium tumefaciens

The levels of the major cytokinins, zeatin, zeatin riboside, zeatin riboside-5'-monophosphate and zeatin-7-glucoside were measured in tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) crown-gall tissues carrying insertion and deletion mutations in the T-DNA. Measurements were made by combined gas chromatography-mass spectrometry using selected ion monitoring with (15)N- and (2)H-labelled internal standards. The results demonstrate that, relative to wild-type tumour tissue, cytokinin levels are considerably elevated in tissues lacking functional T-DNA auxin-biosynthetic genes. From a detailed analysis of the major cytokinin metabolites it is concluded that a reduction in the extent of cytokinin degradation via N(6)-side-chain cleavage is an important factor leading to increased cytokinin levels in these tissues.

Structure, organization and expression of transferred DNA in Nicotiana plumbaginifolia crown-gall tissues

Data are provided which show that transferred DNA (T-DNA) present in Nicotiana plumbaginifolia crown-gall lines in most cases was scrambled and not intact. Both wild-type, and 'rooter'- and 'shooter'-type mutants of octopine-type Agrobacterium tumefaciens were used to infect N. plumbaginifolia plantlets, cultured in vitro. Resulting tumors were excised from the plantlets and cultured for more than three years. During subculturing the tumor lines were scored for the following phenotypic traits: phytohormone autonomous growth in vitro (Aut(+)), spontaneous shoot regeneration (Reg(+)), root deficiency of shoots (Rod(+)), octopine production (Ocs(+)) and mannopine and agropine production (Mas(+)Ags(+)). An unexpectedly large variety of phenotypes was observed. For instance, two out of three tumor lines induced on haploid plantlets by the rooter mutant LBA4210 regenerated shoots, a phenomenon which is not observed for octopine tobacco tumor lines. Fifty percent of the crown-gall lines studied did not contain octopine. Only one line out of six independent lines analyzed was found to have a 'regular' T-DNA structure. Occurrence of aberrant T-DNA structures was not correlated with the ploidy level of infected plantlets, nor with the T-region structure of the inciting bacterial strain. The pattern of TL-DNA transcripts was studied for one line and correlated well with the aberrant T-DNA structure detected. Segments of TR-DNA, having irregular structures as well, were detected in two out of the six lines studied. The scrambled nature of the TR-DNA explained the absence of mannopine and agropine in these two lines. In addition, it was observed that N. plumbaginifolia tissue lines which did not carry T-DNA, became readily phytohormone autotrophic (habituated) at an early stage in tissue culture.

Phenotypic and genetic variations in crown-gall tumour cells of tobacco

Phenotypic and genetic variations of tumour cells were analysed both quantitatively and qualitatively in clones and subclones of a crown-gall strain. Thus, growth rates, grafting tests, octopine synthesis, estimations of the T-DNA contents, modifications in the numbers, and structures of chromosomes were examined. Phenotypic variations are closely associated with genetic changes, including variation in chromosome number (which is shown to be non-specific to the tumoral state) and, above all, variation in the copy-number of T-DNA sequences per cell, and structural rearrangements of chromosomes. Such rearrangements are characterized by specific marker chromosomes in the tumour cells and they correlate with the degree of oncogenicity of the cells.

Clones from a shooty tobacco crown gall tumor I: deletions, rearrangements and amplifications resulting in irregular T-DNA structures and organizations

Transformed clones from a shooty tobacco crown gall tumor, induced byAgrobacterium tumefaciens strain LBA1501, having a Tn1831 insertion in the auxin locus, were investigated for their T-DNA structure and expression. In addition to clones with the expected phenotype, i.e. phytohormone autonomy, regeneration of non-rooting shoots and octopine synthesis (Aut(+)Reg(+)Ocs(+) 'type I' clones), clones were obtained with an aberrant phenotype. Among these were the Aut(-)Reg(-)Ocs(+) 'type II' clones. Two shooty type I clones and three type II callus clones (all randomly chosen) as well as a rooting shoot regenerated from a type II clone via a high kinetin treatment, all had a T-DNA structure which differed significantly from 'regular' T-DNA structures. No Tn1831 DNA sequences were detected in these clones. The two type I clones were identical: they both contained the same highly truncated T-DNA segments. One TL-DNA segment of approximately 0.7 kb, originating form the left part of the TL-region, was present at one copy per diploid tobacco genome. Another segment with a maximum size of about 7 kb was derived from the right hand part of the TL-region and was present at minimally two copies. Three copies of a truncated TR-DNA segment were detected, probably starting at the right TR-DNA border repeat and ending halfway the regular TR-region. Indications have been obtained that at least some of the T-DNA segments are closely linked, sometimes via intervening plant DNA sequences. The type I clones harbored TL-DNA transcripts 4, 6a/b and 3 as well as TR-DNA transcript 0'. The type II clones harbored three to six highly truncated T-DNA segments, originating from the right part of the TL-region. In addition they had TR-DNA segments, similar to those of the type I clones. On Northern blots TR-DNA transcripts 0' and 1' were detected as well as the TL-DNA transcripts 3 and 6a/b and an 1800 bp hybrid transcript (tr.Y) containing gene 6b sequences. Possible origins of the observed irregularities in T-DNA structures are discussed in relation to fidelity of transformation of plant cells viaAgrobacterium.

Shoot regeneration of mesophyll protoplasts transformed by Agrobacterium tumefaciens, not achievable with untransformed protoplasts

Alternative methods for shoot regeneration in protoplast derived cultures were developed in Nicotiana paniculata and Physalis minima. In both species protoplast derived callus is not regeneratable to shoots by conventional methods, e.g. hormone treatment. Leaf discs and stem segments of N. paniculata and P. minima were incubated with Agrobacterium tumefaciens "shooter" strains harbouring pGV 2215 or pGV 2298 or wildtype strain B6S3. After 36 h of co-incubation protoplasts were prepared. (Leaf disc and stem segment cloning). Co-cultivation experiments were also undertaken with protoplasts of both species. Transformed clones, characterized by their hormone independent growth and octopine production, could be isolated after about two months. Transformation frequencies of "leaf disc and stem segment cloning" and co-cultivation experiments varied from 5×10(-3) to 5×10(-5). After about one year of cultivation on hormone-free culture medium, shoots could be recovered from colonies of N. paniculata, transformed by the strain harbouring pGV 2298. In protoplast derived colonies of P. minima, shoot induction was obtained only after transformation by bacteria carrying pGV 2215. This demonstrates the importance of the particular "shooter" mutant, as well as the response of the host plant. Transformed shoots of P. minima produced octopine, whereas octopine production in transformed shoots and callus of N. paniculata was undetectable after one year of cultivation, though T-DNA was still present in the plant genome. Transformed shoots of N. paniculata and P. minima do not produce any roots. Shoots of N. paniculata have an especially tumerous phenotype. Shoots of both species were successfully grafted to normal donor plants of N. tabacum.

Electric field mediated stable transformation of carrot protoplasts with naked DNA

We have developed an electroporation procedure for the transformation of carrot protoplasts with Ti-plasmid DNA from Agrobacterium tumefaciens. The uptake of pTiC58 into carrot protoplasts was mediated by high voltage electrical pulses at field strengths from 0.5 to 3.8 kV/cm. Protoplast regeneration, somatic embryogenesis and plantlet regeneration were unaffected by the electroporation conditions selected for DNA uptake. Uptake of plasmid pTiC58 resulted in hormone independent regeneration of carrot protoplasts. Transformed somatic embryos were detected in carrot cultures 45 days after electroporation. The transformed somatic embryos developed into teratomas which synthesized nopaline. Hybridization was obtained between a labeled T-DNA fragment from pTiC58 and DNA fragments from 4 month old teratomas regenerated from electro-transformed protoplasts. Based on the number of somatic embryos regenerated after electro-transformation, a frequency of 1.6×10(2) transformants/10(4) somatic embryos/μg pTiC58 DNA was obtained.

The role of bacterial attachment in the transformation of cell-wall-regenerating tobacco protoplasts by Agrobacterium tumefaciens

The presence of a newly formed primary cell wall was shown to be required for attachment and subsequent transformation of tobacco leaf protoplasts by Agrobacterium tumefaciens in cocultivation experiments. In these experiments both protoplasts at different stages after their isolation and cell-wall inhibitors were used. The specificity of Agrobacterium attachment was shown by using other kinds of bacteria that did not attach. By diminishing the concentration of divalent cations using ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid, neither attachment nor transformation was found; however, when more specifically the Ca(2+)concentration was lowered by ethylene glycol-bis (β-aminoethyl ether)-N,N,N',N'-tetraacetic acid, both phenomena occurred. Commercial lectins had no effect on binding, but this observation does not exclude the involvement of other lectins. Protoplasts isolated from various crown-gall callus tissues also developed binding sites, but when they were at the stage of dividing cells, attachment of agrobacteria was no longer observed. In this respect, cells from protoplasts of normal tobacco leaves behaved differently. Even 16 d after protoplast isolation, the dividing cells were still able to bind A. tumefaciens, while transformation was not detected. For transformation of 3-d-old tobacco protoplasts, a minimal co-cultivation period of 24 h was required, while optimal attachment took place within 5 h. It is concluded that the primary cell wall was sufficiently well formed that certain functional receptor molecules were available for attachment of Agrobacterium as the first step of a multistep process leading to the transformation of cells. The expression of bacterial functions required for attachment, moreover, was independent of the presence of Ti-plasmid.

Expression of genes transferred into monocot and dicot plant cells by electroporation

We have developed a general method for electrically introducing DNA into plant cells. Gene transfer occurs when a high-voltage electric pulse is applied to a solution containing protoplasts and DNA. Carrot protoplasts were used as a model system to optimize gene-transfer efficiency, which was measured 24-48 hr after electroporation by the amount of chloramphenicol acetyltransferase activity resulting from the expression of the introduced chimeric plasmids. Gene-transfer efficiency increased with the DNA concentration and was affected by the amplitude and duration of the electric pulse as well as by the composition of the electroporation medium. Our optimized gene-transfer conditions were effective when applied to tobacco and maize protoplasts, demonstrating that the method is applicable to both monocot and dicot protoplasts.

Structure and expression of DNA transferred to tobacco via transformation of protoplasts with Ti-plasmid DNA: co-transfer of T-DNA and non T-DNA sequences

The T-DNA structure and organization in tissues obtained via transformation of tobacco protoplasts with Ti-plasmid DNA was found to be completely different from the T-DNA introduced via Agrobacterium tumefaciens. It is often fragmented. Overlapping copies of T-DNA, having various sizes, as well as separated fragments of T-DNA were detected. The border sequences of 23 basepairs (bp), flanking the T-region in the Ti-plasmid as direct repeats are not used as preferred sequences for integration. Similar results were obtained with a T-region clone lacking one of the TL-borders. This clone, which carried the cytokinin locus and only the right border sequence of TL and the left border sequence of TR, still had the capacity to transform protoplasts. Also the Vir-region of the Ti-plasmid is not required for integration of foreign DNA via DNA transformation. This is demonstrated by the results with the T-region clone mentioned and by the transforming capacity of a Ti-plasmid carrying a mutated Vir-region. Nevertheless, in a number of Ti-plasmid DNA transformants Vir-region fragments were found to be stably integrated. Furthermore, it has been established that co-transformation can occur with plant cells. Besides the detection of Ti-plasmid fragments from outside the T-region also DNA sequences originating from two DNA sources, which were both independently present in transformation experiments, have been found in some DNA transformants, e.g. calf thymus DNA, which was used as carrier DNA. No expression of the co-transferred DNA was observed. In total three phenotypical classes of DNA transformants were isolated. Although the T-DNA was often scrambled, polyA(+) mRNA studies indicated that the different phenotypes studied can be explained by the presence of active T-DNA genes with known functions.

Analysis of transfer of tumor-inducing plasmids from Agrobacterium tumefaciens to Petunia protoplasts

Petunia protoplasts were infected with the virulent Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain A348 or the avirulent strain A136 (lacking a Ti plasmid). The infection process was stopped at various time intervals up to 24 h after inoculation, and the DNA from the plant cells was isolated. Southern blot analysis indicated that the DNA isolated from infected Petunia cells was not detectably contaminated by bacterial DNA from lysed Agrobacterium cells. Analysis of the DNA from the virulent infections suggested that the transferred DNA (T-DNA) may be transferred to the plant cell rapidly (within 2 to 6 h) after the bacteria bind to the cell wall and that the T-DNA may exist in a rearranged state which is stable over the time period investigated. Dot blot analysis indicated that regions far outside the T-DNA may be transferred to the plant cell. Most of the DNA transferred to the plant cell during the initial hours of infection is rapidly degraded.

Further evidence for the transformation ofVinca rosea protoplasts byAgrobacterium tumefaciens spheroplasts

Protoplasts ofVinca rosea were transformed by spheroplasts ofAgrobacterium tumefaciens harboring nopalinetype Ti plasmids according to the procedure of Hasezawa et al. (1981). These transformants frequently differentiated tracheids, but further differentiation to teratomata has not so far been observed. Transformation was confirmed by the improved detection of nopaline synthase, where the sensitivity and specificity of the enzyme reaction was increased by employing(14)C-α-ketoglutaric acid and(3)H-arginine as substrates. The nopaline synthase activity was identified by the comigration of these two radioisotopes in the cnromatogram. Furthermore, the T-DNA structure of one of these transformants was examined by Southern hybridization according to Thomashow et al. (1980) and compared with that ofVinca rosea crown gall.

A Tn3 lacZ transposon for the random generation of beta-galactosidase gene fusions: application to the analysis of gene expression in Agrobacterium

The construction and use of a Tn3-lac transposon, Tn3-HoHo1, is described. Tn3-HoHo1 can serve as a transposon mutagen and provides a new and useful system for the random generation of both transcriptional and translational lacZ gene fusions. In these fusions the production of beta-galactosidase, the lacZ gene product, is placed under the control of the gene into which Tn3-HoHo1 has inserted. The expression of the gene can thus be analyzed by monitoring beta-galactosidase activity. Tn3-HoHo1 carries a non-functional transposase gene; consequently, it can transpose only if transposase activity is supplied in trans, and is stable in the absence of this activity. A system for the insertion of Tn3-HoHo1 into sequences specifically contained within plasmids is described. The applicability of Tn3-HoHo1 was demonstrated studying three functional regions of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens A6 Ti plasmid. These regions code for octopine catabolism, virulence and plant tumor phenotype. The regulated expression of genes contained within each of these regions was analyzed in Agrobacterium employing Tn3-HoHo1 generated lac fusions.

In vitro transformation of petunia cells by an improved method of co-cultivation with A. tumefaciens strains

A method (termed co-cultivation) for transforming plant cells in vitro with A. tumefaciens strains, which was originally developed by Marton et al. (1978) Nature 277: 129-131, has been modified by the incorporation of a novel feeder plate culture system and been extended to use with petunia protoplasts. Using efficient cell plating and selection conditions for phytohormone-independent growth, large numbers of independent transformed calli can be obtained efficiently (∼10(-1)) and in less than 3 weeks following protoplast isolation. Southern hybridization analysis has confirmed that the majority of the resulting in vitro transformants contain a single copy of full length T-DNA.The high efficiency of this procedure allows simple screening to identify plant cells transformed by Ti plasmids attenuated by deletion of internal T-DNA regions. Results are presented that demonstrate the co-cultivation method can be used in conjunction with short term assays for monitoring plant gene expression.

Tumor formation on plants by mixtures of attenuated Agrobacterium tumefaciens T-DNA mutants

The inoculation of plants with mixtures consisting of an A. tumefaciens mutant with a mutation in the auxin-locus of the T-DNA and a mutant with a mutation in the cytokinin-locus of the T-DNA invariably led to full tumor induction, in spite of the low oncogenicity of each of the mutants when inoculated separately. A similar complementation was observed when mixtures of certain auxin-locus mutants were used for infection. In these experiments the auxin-locus mutants fell into two classes. One class appeared to have mutations in the T-DNA region for transcript 1, while the other class had a mutation in the region for transcript 2. The intra-locus complementation observed suggests that the T-DNA genes in the auxin-locus together determine the production of a trans-acting product.

Fusion of Agrobacterium and E. coli spheroplasts with Nicotiana tabacum protoplasts - Direct gene transfer from microorganism to higher plant

Spheroplasts of Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains and E. coli were fused with protoplasts of Nicotiana tabacum. Fusion products were cultured in the presence of antibiotics to eliminate remaining bacterial spheroplasts. On hormone free medium, tobacco protoplasts treated with wild type Agrobacterium-strains formed colonies with an average frequency of 10(-4). Opine synthesis was detected in the tissues. Some calli derived from protoplasts treated with A. tumefaciens C58C1pRi15834 formed typical hairy roots. Kanamycin resistant calli were obtained after fusion with A. tumefaciens containing pLGVTi23 neo (frequency=10(-3)). Fusion of E. coli spheroplasts containing a virulent pTiB6S3::RP4 co-integrate with tobacco protoplasts yielded two hormone independent growing calli producing octopine out of 10(5) microcalli.

Expression of bacterial genes in plant cells

Chimeric bacterial genes conferring resistance to aminoglycoside antibiotics have been inserted into the Agrobacterium tumefaciens tumor-inducing (Ti) plasmid and introduced into plant cells by in vitro transformation techniques. The chimeric genes contain the nopaline synthase 5' and 3' regulatory regions joined to the genes for neomycin phosphotransferase type I or type II. The chimeric genes were cloned into an intermediate vector, pMON120, and inserted into pTiB6S3 by recombination and then introduced into petunia and tobacco cells by cocultivating A. tumefaciens cells with protoplast-derived cells. Southern hybridization was used to confirm the presence of the chimeric genes in the transformed plant tissues. Expression of the chimeric genes was determined by the ability of the transformed cells to proliferate on medium containing normally inhibitory levels of kanamycin (50 micrograms/ml) or other aminoglycoside antibiotics. Plant cells transformed by wild-type pTiB6S3 or derivatives carrying the bacterial neomycin phosphotransferase genes with their own promoters failed to grow under these conditions. The significance of these results for plant genetic engineering is discussed.

Chimeric genes as dominant selectable markers in plant cells

Opine synthases are enzymes produced in dicotyledonous plants as the result of a natural gene transfer phenomenon. Agrobacteria contain Ti plasmids that direct the transfer, stable integration and expression of a number of genes in plants, including the genes coding for octopine or nopaline synthase. This fact was used as the basis for the construction of a number of chimeric genes combining the 5' upstream promoter sequences and most of the untranslated leader sequence of the nopaline synthase (nos) gene with the coding sequence of two bacterial genes: the aminoglycoside phosphotransferase (APH(3')II) gene of Tn5 and the methotrexate-insensitive dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR Mtx) of the R67 plasmid. The APH(3')II enzyme inactivates a number of aminoglycoside antibiotics such as kanamycin, neomycin and G418. Kanamycin, G418 and methotrexate are very toxic to plants. The chimeric NOS-APH(3')II gene, when transferred to tobacco cells using the Ti plasmid as a gene vector, was expressed and conferred resistance to kanamycin to the plant cells. Kanamycin-resistant tobacco cells were shown to contain a typical APH(3')II phosphorylase activity. This chimeric gene can be used as a potent dominant selectable marker in plants. Similar results were also obtained with a NOS-DHFR Mtx gene. Our results demonstrate that foreign genes are not only transferred but are also functionally expressed when the appropriate constructions are made using promoters known to be active in plant cells.

Studies on the structure of cointegrates between octopine and nopaline Ti-plasmids and their tumour-inducing properties

Stable cointegrates between incRh-1 octopine (Ach5) and nopaline (C58) Ti-plasmids, present in ten independently isolated Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains, showed identical restriction endonuclease patterns. Each cointegration event had taken place in the common sequence between the T-regions of both Ti-plasmids. This illustrates a high preference for this region when used in the formation of cointegrates. Four crown gall tissues, obtained after transformation of Nicotiana tabacum cells by one of the mutants, were analysed by using Southern blot analysis for their T-DNA structure. The borders of T-DNA frequently appeared to differ from T-DNA borders previously detected in tumour tissues that had been induced by Agrobacterium strain C58 or Ach5. Therefore, it was concluded that possibly a less stringent mechanism exists for the integration into plant DNA of T-DNA, derived from a composite (octopine/nopaline) T-region than for integration of T-DNA from a normal (octopine or nopaline) T-region.

The lysopinedehydrogenase gene used as a marker for the selection of octopine crown gall cells

Plant cells transformed into octopine-synthesizing tumour cells by the bacterium Agrobacterium tumefaciens survive when cultured in the presence of homo-arginine (HA), whereas both normal plant cells and nopaline producing plant tumour cells do not. Survival of octopine crown gall cells is due to the activity of the enzyme lysopinedehydrogenase (LpDH) in these cells, which converts toxic homo-arginine into non-toxic homo-octopine. The selective toxicity of homo-arginine for normal cells can be applied for the enrichment of octopine Ti plasmid transformed plant cells vs normal plant cells in mixed cultures.