Interaction between RNA polymerase and RapA, a bacterial homolog of the SWI/SNF protein family

Recycling of bacterial RNA polymerase by the Swi2/Snf2 ATPase RapA

Free-living bacteria have regulatory systems that can quickly reprogram gene transcription in response to changes in the cellular environment. The RapA ATPase, a prokaryotic homolog of the eukaryotic Swi2/Snf2 chromatin remodeling complex, may facilitate such reprogramming, but the mechanisms by which it does so are unclear. We used multiwavelength single-molecule fluorescence microscopy in vitro to examine RapA function in the Escherichia coli transcription cycle. In our experiments, RapA at <5 nM concentration did not appear to alter transcription initiation, elongation, or intrinsic termination. Instead, we directly observed a single RapA molecule bind specifically to the kinetically stable post termination complex (PTC)-consisting of core RNA polymerase (RNAP)-bound sequence nonspecifically to double-stranded DNA-and efficiently remove RNAP from DNA within seconds in an ATP-hydrolysis-dependent reaction. Kinetic analysis elucidates the process through which RapA locates the PTC and the key mechanistic intermediates that bind and hydrolyze ATP. This study defines how RapA participates in the transcription cycle between termination and initiation and suggests that RapA helps set the balance between global RNAP recycling and local transcription reinitiation in proteobacterial genomes.

Recycling of Bacterial RNA Polymerase by the Swi2/Snf2 ATPase RapA.. [DOI: 10.1101/2023.03.22.533849] [Citation(s) in RCA: 0] [Impact Index Per Article: 0]

Free-living bacteria have regulatory systems that can quickly reprogram gene transcription in response to changes in cellular environment. The RapA ATPase, a prokaryotic homolog of the eukaryote Swi2/Snf2 chromatin remodeling complex, may facilitate such reprogramming, but the mechanisms by which it does so is unclear. We used multi-wavelength single-molecule fluorescence microscopy in vitro to examine RapA function in theE. colitranscription cycle. In our experiments, RapA at < 5 nM concentration did not appear to alter transcription initiation, elongation, or intrinsic termination. Instead, we directly observed a single RapA molecule bind specifically to the kinetically stable post-termination complex (PTC) -- consisting of core RNA polymerase (RNAP) bound to dsDNA -- and efficiently remove RNAP from DNA within seconds in an ATP-hydrolysis-dependent reaction. Kinetic analysis elucidates the process through which RapA locates the PTC and the key mechanistic intermediates that bind and hydrolyze ATP. This study defines how RapA participates in the transcription cycle between termination and initiation and suggests that RapA helps set the balance between global RNAP recycling and local transcription re-initiation in proteobacterial genomes.

SIGNIFICANCE

RNA synthesis is an essential conduit of genetic information in all organisms. After transcribing an RNA, the bacterial RNA polymerase (RNAP) must be reused to make subsequent RNAs, but the steps that enable RNAP reuse are unclear. We directly observed the dynamics of individual molecules of fluorescently labeled RNAP and the enzyme RapA as they colocalized with DNA during and after RNA synthesis. Our studies show that RapA uses ATP hydrolysis to remove RNAP from DNA after the RNA is released from RNAP and reveal essential features of the mechanism by which this removal occurs. These studies fill in key missing pieces in our current understanding of the events that occur after RNA is released and that enable RNAP reuse.

On the stability of stalled RNA polymerase and its removal by RapA

Stalling of the transcription elongation complex formed by DNA, RNA polymerase (RNAP) and RNA presents a serious obstacle to concurrent processes due to the extremely high stability of the DNA-bound polymerase. RapA, known to remove RNAP from DNA in an ATP-dependent fashion, was identified over 50 years ago as an abundant binding partner of RNAP; however, its mechanism of action remains unknown. Here, we use single-molecule magnetic trapping assays to characterize RapA activity and begin to specify its mechanism of action. We first show that stalled RNAP resides on DNA for times on the order of 10⁶ seconds and that increasing positive torque on the DNA reduces this lifetime. Using stalled RNAP as a substrate we show that the RapA protein stimulates dissociation of stalled RNAP from positively supercoiled DNA but not negatively supercoiled DNA. We observe that RapA-dependent RNAP dissociation is torque-sensitive, is inhibited by GreB and depends on RNA length. We propose that stalled RNAP is dislodged from DNA by RapA via backtracking in a supercoiling- and torque-dependent manner, suggesting that RapA’s activity on transcribing RNAP in vivo is responsible for resolving conflicts between converging polymerase molecular motors.

Structural basis of RNA polymerase recycling by the Swi2/Snf2 family of ATPase RapA in Escherichia coli

After transcription termination, cellular RNA polymerases (RNAPs) are occasionally trapped on DNA, impounded in an undefined post-termination complex (PTC), limiting the free RNAP pool and subsequently leading to inefficient transcription. In Escherichia coli, a Swi2/Snf2 family of ATPase called RapA is known to be involved in countering such inefficiency through RNAP recycling; however, the precise mechanism of this recycling is unclear. To better understand its mechanism, here we determined the structures of two sets of E. coli RapA–RNAP complexes, along with the RNAP core enzyme and the elongation complex, using cryo-EM. These structures revealed the large conformational changes of RNAP and RapA upon their association that has been implicated in the hindrance of PTC formation. Our results along with DNA-binding assays reveal that although RapA binds RNAP away from the DNA-binding main channel, its binding can allosterically close the RNAP clamp, thereby preventing its nonspecific DNA binding and PTC formation. Taken together, we propose that RapA acts as a guardian of RNAP by which RapA prevents nonspecific DNA binding of RNAP without affecting the binding of promoter DNA recognition σ factor, thereby enhancing RNAP recycling.

The bacterial protein Hfq: Stable modifications and growth phase-dependent changes in SPAM profiles

In bacteria transcription is coupled to translation, and while it is broadly accepted that transcription-translation complexes (TTCs) are formed in growing bacterial cells, the exact spatial organization of these macromolecular assemblies is not known with certainty. Recent studies indicated the formation of orderly cytosolic superstructures in growing E. coli cells. The bacterial nucleic acid (NA)-binding protein Hfq has been shown to function at the interface of RNA synthesis-degradation machinery; multiple, independent studies link Hfq to orderly cytosolic assemblies. In this work, using fast cell lysis/2D-PAGE and in vitro reconstitution analyses we studied the Hfq modifications and small protein-associated molecules (SPAM). We demonstrate that native Hfq carries stable modifications and simulate 2D patterns of native Hfq-SPAM complexes in reconstitution experiments with purified Hfq and synthetic NA probes. We also demonstrate that genetically engineered Hfq lacking the conserved arginine residues positioned near the rim of the disc formed by the subunits' N-terminal domains binds DNA with a reduced affinity in comparison with wild-type Hfq. These results are consistent with the proposed Hfq-mediated DNA remodeling and point to the involvement of this patch of conserved arginines in interactions with DNA.

Structural basis for activation of Swi2/Snf2 ATPase RapA by RNA polymerase

RapA is a bacterial RNA polymerase (RNAP)-associated Swi2/Snf2 ATPase that stimulates RNAP recycling. The ATPase activity of RapA is autoinhibited by its N-terminal domain (NTD) but activated with RNAP bound. Here, we report a 3.4-Å cryo-EM structure of Escherichia coli RapA-RNAP elongation complex, in which the ATPase active site of RapA is structurally remodeled. In this process, the NTD of RapA is wedged open by RNAP β' zinc-binding domain (ZBD). In addition, RNAP β flap tip helix (FTH) forms extensive hydrophobic interactions with RapA ATPase core domains. Functional assay demonstrates that removing the ZBD or FTH of RNAP significantly impairs its ability to activate the ATPase activity of RapA. Our results provide the structural basis of RapA ATPase activation by RNAP, through the active site remodeling driven by the ZBD-buttressed large-scale opening of NTD and the direct interactions between FTH and ATPase core domains.

Allosteric Activation of Bacterial Swi2/Snf2 (Switch/Sucrose Non-fermentable) Protein RapA by RNA Polymerase: BIOCHEMICAL AND STRUCTURAL STUDIES

Members of the Swi2/Snf2 (switch/sucrose non-fermentable) family depend on their ATPase activity to mobilize nucleic acid-protein complexes for gene expression. In bacteria, RapA is an RNA polymerase (RNAP)-associated Swi2/Snf2 protein that mediates RNAP recycling during transcription. It is known that the ATPase activity of RapA is stimulated by its interaction with RNAP. It is not known, however, how the RapA-RNAP interaction activates the enzyme. Previously, we determined the crystal structure of RapA. The structure revealed the dynamic nature of its N-terminal domain (Ntd), which prompted us to elucidate the solution structure and activity of both the full-length protein and its Ntd-truncated mutant (RapAΔN). Here, we report the ATPase activity of RapA and RapAΔN in the absence or presence of RNAP and the solution structures of RapA and RapAΔN either ligand-free or in complex with RNAP. Determined by small-angle x-ray scattering, the solution structures reveal a new conformation of RapA, define the binding mode and binding site of RapA on RNAP, and show that the binding sites of RapA and σ(70) on the surface of RNAP largely overlap. We conclude that the ATPase activity of RapA is inhibited by its Ntd but stimulated by RNAP in an allosteric fashion and that the conformational changes of RapA and its interaction with RNAP are essential for RNAP recycling. These and previous findings outline the functional cycle of RapA, which increases our understanding of the mechanism and regulation of Swi2/Snf2 proteins in general and of RapA in particular. The new structural information also leads to a hypothetical model of RapA in complex with RNAP immobilized during transcription.

Structural basis for transcription reactivation by RapA

RNA polymerase (RNAP) loses activity during transcription as it stalls at various inactive states due to erratic translocation. Reactivation of these stalled RNAPs is essential for efficient RNA synthesis. Here we report a 4.7-Å resolution crystal structure of the Escherichia coli RNAP core enzyme in complex with ATPase RapA that is involved in reactivating stalled RNAPs. The structure reveals that RapA binds at the RNA exit channel of the RNAP and makes the channel unable to accommodate the formation of an RNA hairpin. The orientation of RapA on the RNAP core complex suggests that RapA uses its ATPase activity to propel backward translocation of RNAP along the DNA template in an elongation complex. This structure provides insights into the reactivation of stalled RNA polymerases and helps support ATP-driven backward translocation as a general mechanism for transcriptional regulation.

Characterization of HelD, an interacting partner of RNA polymerase from Bacillus subtilis

Bacterial RNA polymerase (RNAP) is an essential multisubunit protein complex required for gene expression. Here, we characterize YvgS (HelD) from Bacillus subtilis, a novel binding partner of RNAP. We show that HelD interacts with RNAP-core between the secondary channel of RNAP and the alpha subunits. Importantly, we demonstrate that HelD stimulates transcription in an ATP-dependent manner by enhancing transcriptional cycling and elongation. We demonstrate that the stimulatory effect of HelD can be amplified by a small subunit of RNAP, delta. In vivo, HelD is not essential but it is required for timely adaptations of the cell to changing environment. In summary, this study establishes HelD as a valid component of the bacterial transcription machinery.

Characterization of the transcriptional stimulatory properties of the Pseudomonas putida RapA protein

RNA polymerase-associated factors can significantly affect its performance at specific promoters. Here we identified a Pseudomonas putida RNA polymerases-associated protein as a homolog of Escherichia coli RapA. We found that P. putida RapA stimulates the transcription from promoters dependent on a variety of σ-factors (σ(70), σ(S), σ(54), σ(32), σ(E)) in vitro. The level of stimulation varied from 2- to 10-fold, with the maximal effect observed with the σ(E)-dependent PhtrA promoter. Stimulation by RapA was apparent in the multi-round reactions and was modulated by salt concentration in vitro. However, in contrast to findings with E. coli RapA, P. putida RapA-mediated stimulation of transcription was also evident using linear templates. These properties of P. putida RapA were apparent using either E. coli- or P. putida-derived RNA polymerases. Analysis of individual steps of transcription revealed that P. putida RapA enhances the stability of competitor-resistant open-complexes formed by RNA polymerase at promoters. In vivo, P. putida RapA can complement the inhibitory effect of high salt on growth of an E. coli RapA null strain. However, a P. putida RapA null mutant was not sensitive to high salt. The in vivo effects of lack of RapA were only detectable for the σ(E)-PhtrA promoter where the RapA-deficiency resulted in lower activity. The presented characteristics of P. putida RapA indicate that its functions may extend beyond a role in facilitating RNA polymerase recycling to include a role in transcription initiation efficiency.

Functions of the Snf2/Swi2 family Rad54 motor protein in homologous recombination

Homologous recombination is a central pathway to maintain genomic stability and is involved in the repair of DNA damage and replication fork support, as well as accurate chromosome segregation during meiosis. Rad54 is a dsDNA-dependent ATPase of the Snf2/Swi2 family of SF2 helicases, although Rad54 lacks classical helicase activity and cannot carry out the strand displacement reactions typical for DNA helicases. Rad54 is a potent and processive motor protein that translocates on dsDNA, potentially executing several functions in recombinational DNA repair. Rad54 acts in concert with Rad51, the central protein of recombination that performs the key reactions of homology search and DNA strand invasion. Here, we will review the role of the Rad54 protein in homologous recombination with an emphasis on mechanistic studies with the yeast and human enzymes. We will discuss how these results relate to in vivo functions of Rad54 during homologous recombination in somatic cells and during meiosis. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Snf2/Swi2 ATPase structure and function.

Oligomerization of the E. coli core RNA polymerase: formation of (α2ββ'ω)2-DNA complexes and regulation of the oligomerization by auxiliary subunits

In this work, using multiple, dissimilar physico-chemical techniques, we demonstrate that the Escherichia coli RNA polymerase core enzyme obtained through a classic purification procedure forms stable (α₂ββ'ω)₂ complexes in the presence or absence of short DNA probes. Multiple control experiments indicate that this self-association is unlikely to be mediated by RNA polymerase-associated non-protein molecules. We show that the formation of (α₂ββ'ω)₂ complexes is subject to regulation by known RNA polymerase interactors, such as the auxiliary SWI/SNF subunit of RNA polymerase RapA, as well as NusA and σ⁷⁰. We also demonstrate that the separation of the core RNA polymerase and RNA polymerase holoenzyme species during Mono Q chromatography is likely due to oligomerization of the core enzyme. We have analyzed the oligomeric state of the polymerase in the presence or absence of DNA, an aspect that was missing from previous studies. Importantly, our work demonstrates that RNA polymerase oligomerization is compatible with DNA binding. Through in vitro transcription and in vivo experiments (utilizing a RapA^R599/Q602 mutant lacking transcription-stimulatory function), we demonstrate that the formation of tandem (α₂ββ'ω)₂–DNA complexes is likely functionally significant and beneficial for the transcriptional activity of the polymerase. Taken together, our findings suggest a novel structural aspect of the E. coli elongation complex. We hypothesize that transcription by tandem RNA polymerase complexes initiated at hypothetical bidirectional “origins of transcription” may explain recurring switches of the direction of transcription in bacterial genomes.

Structure and function of RapA: a bacterial Swi2/Snf2 protein required for RNA polymerase recycling in transcription

One of the hallmarks of the Swi2/Snf2 family members is their ability to modify the interaction between DNA-binding protein and DNA in controlling gene expression. The studies of Swi2/Snf2 have been mostly focused on their roles in chromatin and/or nucleosome remodeling in eukaryotes. A bacterial Swi2/Snf2 protein named RapA from Escherichia coli is a unique addition to these studies. RapA is an RNA polymerase (RNAP)-associated protein and an ATPase. It binds nucleic acids including RNA and DNA. The ATPase activity of RapA is stimulated by its interaction with RNAP, but not with nucleic acids. RapA and the major sigma factor σ70 compete for binding to core RNAP. After one transcription cycle in vitro, RNAP is immobilized in an undefined posttranscription/posttermination complex (PTC), thus becoming unavailable for reuse. RapA stimulates RNAP recycling by ATPase-dependent remodeling of PTC, leading to the release of sequestered RNAP, which then becomes available for reuse in another cycle of transcription. Recently, the crystal structure of RapA that is also the first full-length structure for the entire Swi2/Snf2 family was determined. The structure provides a framework for future studies of the mechanism of RNAP recycling in transcription. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Snf2/Swi2 ATPase structure and function.

RapA, Escherichia coli RNA polymerase SWI/SNF subunit-dependent polyadenylation of RNA

In this work, we describe RapA-dependent polyadenylation of model RNA substrates and endogenous, RNA polymerase-associated nucleic acid fragments. We demonstrate that the Escherichia coli RNA polymerase obtained through the classic purification procedure carries endogenous RNA oligonucleotides, which, in the presence of ATP, are polyriboadenylated in a RapA-dependent manner by an accessory poly(rA) polymerase. RNA polymerase isolated from poly(A) polymerase- (PAP-) and polynucleotide phosphorylase- (PNP-) deficient E. coli strain lacks accessory (rA)(n)-synthetic activity. Experiments with reconstituted RNA polymerase-PAP and RNA polymerase-PNP mixtures suggest that RapA enables the polyadenylation by PAP of RNA polymerase-associated RNA. Mutations disrupting RapA's ATP-hydrolytic function disrupt RapA-dependent polyadenylation, and the rapA(-)E. coli strain displays a measurable reduction in RNA polyadenylation. RapA-dependent polyadenylation can also be modulated by mutations in the section of RapA's SWI/SNF domain linked to interaction with single-stranded nucleic acid. We have developed enzymatic assays in which model, synthetic RNAs are polyriboadenylated in a RapA-dependent manner. Taken together, our results are consistent with RapA acting as an RNA polymerase-associated, ATP-dependent RNA translocase. Our work further links RapA to RNA remodeling and provides new mechanistic insights into the functional interaction between RNA polymerase and RapA.

RapA, the SWI/SNF subunit of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase, promotes the release of nascent RNA from transcription complexes

RapA, a prokaryotic member of the SWI/SNF protein superfamily, is an integral part of the RNA polymerase transcription complex. RapA's function and catalytic mechanism have been linked to nucleic acid remodeling. In this work, we show that mutations in the interface between RapA's SWI/SNF and double-stranded nucleic acid-binding domains significantly alter ATP hydrolysis in purified RapA. The effects of individual mutations on ATP hydrolysis loosely correlated with RapA's nucleic acid remodeling activity, indicating that the interaction between these domains may be important for the RapA-mediated remodeling of nonproductive transcription complexes. In this study, we introduced a model system for in vitro transcription of a full-length Escherichia coli gene (slyD). To study the function of RapA, we fractionated and identified in vitro transcription reaction intermediates in the presence or absence of RapA. These experiments demonstrated that RapA contributes to the formation of free RNA species during in vitro transcription. This work further refines our models for RapA function in vivo and establishes a new role in RNA management for a representative of the SWI/SNF protein superfamily.

Structure of RapA, a Swi2/Snf2 protein that recycles RNA polymerase during transcription

RapA, as abundant as sigma70 in the cell, is an RNA polymerase (RNAP)-associated Swi2/Snf2 protein with ATPase activity. It stimulates RNAP recycling during transcription. We report a structure of RapA that is also a full-length structure for the entire Swi2/Snf2 family. RapA contains seven domains, two of which exhibit novel protein folds. Our model of RapA in complex with ATP and double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) suggests that RapA may bind to and translocate on dsDNA. Our kinetic template-switching assay shows that RapA facilitates the release of sequestered RNAP from a posttranscrption/posttermination complex for transcription reinitiation. Our in vitro competition experiment indicates that RapA binds to core RNAP only but is readily displaceable by sigma70. RapA is likely another general transcription factor, the structure of which provides a framework for future studies of this bacterial Swi2/Snf2 protein and its important roles in RNAP recycling during transcription.

Escherichia coli RNA polymerase-associated SWI/SNF protein RapA: evidence for RNA-directed binding and remodeling activity

Helicase-like SWI/SNF proteins are present in organisms belonging to distant kingdoms from bacteria to humans, indicating that they perform a very basic and ubiquitous form of nucleic acid management; current studies associate the activity of SWI/SNF proteins with remodeling of DNA and DNA–protein complexes. The bacterial SWI/SNF homolog RapA—an integral part of the Escherichia coli RNA polymerase complex—has been implicated in remodeling post-termination DNA–RNA polymerase–RNA ternary complexes (PTC), however its explicit nucleic acid substrates and mechanism remain elusive. Our work presents evidence indicating that RNA is a key substrate of RapA. Specifically, the formation of stable RapA–RNA intermediates in transcription and other, independent lines of evidence presented herein indicate that RapA binds and remodels RNA during transcription. Our results are consistent with RapA promoting RNA release from DNA–RNA polymerase–RNA ternary complexes; this process may be accompanied by the destabilization of non-canonical DNA–RNA complexes (putative DNA–RNA triplexes). Taken together, our data indicate a novel RNA remodeling activity for RapA, a representative of the SWI/SNF protein superfamily.

RNA polymerase mutants defective in the initiation of transcription-coupled DNA repair

The bacterial Mfd protein is a transcription-repair coupling factor that performs two key functions during transcription-coupled DNA repair. The first is to remove RNA polymerase (RNAP) complexes that have been stalled by a DNA lesion from the site of damage, and the second is to mediate the recruitment of DNA repair proteins. Mfd also displaces transcription complexes that have been stalled by protein roadblocks, and catalyses the reactivation of transcription complexes that have become ‘backtracked’. We have identified amino acid substitutions in the β subunit of Escherichia coli RNAP that disrupt a direct interaction between Mfd and RNAP. These substitutions prevent Mfd displacing stalled RNAP from DNA in vivo and in vitro. They define a highly conserved surface-exposed patch on the β1 domain of RNAP that is required by Mfd for the initial step of transcription-coupled repair, the enhancement of roadblock repression and the reactivation of backtracked transcription complexes.

Interaction of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase with the ribosomal protein S1 and the Sm-like ATPase Hfq

We report evidence that ribosomal protein S1 and nucleic acid-binding protein Hfq copurify in molar ratios with RNA polymerase (RNAP). Purified S1 associates independently with RNAP, and Hfq binding to polymerase occurs in the presence of S1. Looking for a functional role of the RNAP-S1-Hfq association, we studied the effects of S1 and Hfq on transcription and coupled transcription-translation. S1 was capable of significant stimulation of the RNAP transcriptional activity from a number of promoters; the stimulatory effect was observed on linear as well as supercoiled DNA templates. In addition, we present biochemical and genetic evidence of ATPase activity associated with the Sm-like hexameric nucleic acid-binding protein Hfq. The limited sequence homology between Hfq and known ATP-utilizing enzymes suggests a new class of ATPases.

RapA, a bacterial homolog of SWI2/SNF2, stimulates RNA polymerase recycling in transcription

We report that RapA, an Escherichia coli RNA polymerase (RNAP)-associated homolog of SWI2/SNF2, is capable of dramatic activation of RNA synthesis. The RapA-mediated transcriptional activation in vitro depends on supercoiled DNA and high salt concentrations, a condition that is likely to render the DNA superhelix tightly compacted. Moreover, RapA activates transcription by stimulating RNAP recycling. Mutational analyses indicate that the ATPase activity of RapA is essential for its function as a transcriptional activator, and a rapA null mutant exhibits a growth defect on nutrient plates containing high salt concentrations in vivo. Thus, RapA acts as a general transcription factor and an integral component of the transcription machinery. The mode of action of RapA in remodeling posttranscription or posttermination complexes is discussed.

Growth phase and growth rate regulation of the rapA gene, encoding the RNA polymerase-associated protein RapA in Escherichia coli

The Escherichia coli rapA gene encodes the RNA polymerase (RNAP)-associated protein RapA, which is a bacterial member of the SWI/SNF helicase-like protein family. We have studied the rapA promoter and its regulation in vivo and determined the interaction between RNAP and the promoter in vitro. We have found that the expression of rapA is growth phase dependent, peaking at the early log phase. The growth phase control of rapA is determined at least by one particular feature of the promoter: it uses CTP as the transcription-initiating nucleotide instead of a purine, which is used for most E. coli promoters. We also found that the rapA promoter is subject to growth rate regulation in vivo and that it forms intrinsic unstable initiation complexes with RNAP in vitro. Furthermore, we have shown that a GC-rich or discriminator sequence between the -10 and +1 positions of the rapA promoter is responsible for its growth rate control and the instability of its initiation complexes with RNAP.