Tighter Control by Chymotrypsin C (CTRC) Explains Lack of Association between Human Anionic Trypsinogen and Hereditary Pancreatitis

Novel chymotrypsin C (CTRC) variants from real-world genetic testing of pediatric chronic pancreatitis cases

BACKGROUND

Chymotrypsin C (CTRC) protects the pancreas against unwanted intrapancreatic trypsin activity through degradation of trypsinogen. Loss-of-function CTRC variants increase the risk for chronic pancreatitis (CP). The aim of the present study was to characterize novel CTRC variants found during genetic testing of CP cases at a pediatric pancreatitis center.

METHODS

We used next-generation sequencing to screen patients. We analyzed the functional effects of CTRC variants in HEK 293T cells and using purified enzymes.

RESULTS

In 5 separate cases, we detected 5 novel heterozygous CTRC variants: c.407C>T (p.Thr136Ile), c.550G>A (p.Ala184Thr), c.627Cdup (p.Ser210Leufs∗?, where the naming indicates a frame shift with no stop codon), c.628T>C (p.Ser210Pro), and c.779A>G (p.Asp260Gly). Functional studies revealed that with the exception of p.Ser210Leufs∗?, the CTRC variants were secreted normally from transfected cells. Enzyme activity of purified variants p.Thr136Ile, p.Ala184Thr, and p.Asp260Gly was similar to that of wild-type CTRC, whereas variant p.Ser210Pro was inactive. The frame-shift variant p.Ser210Leufs∗? was not secreted but accumulated intracellularly, and induced endoplasmic reticulum stress, as judged by elevated mRNA levels of HSPA5 and DDIT3, and increased mRNA splicing of XBP1.

CONCLUSIONS

CTRC variants p.Ser210Pro and p.Ser210Leufs∗? abolish CTRC function and should be classified as pathogenic. Mechanistically, variant p.Ser210Pro directly affects the amino acid at the bottom of the substrate-binding pocket while the frame-shift variant promotes misfolding and thereby blocks enzyme secretion. Importantly, 3 of the 5 novel CTRC variants proved to be benign, indicating that functional analysis is indispensable for reliable determination of pathogenicity and the correct interpretation of genetic test results.

Risk of chronic pancreatitis in carriers of the c.180C>T (p.Gly60=) CTRC variant: case-control studies and meta-analysis

Chymotrypsin C (CTRC) is a digestive serine protease produced by the pancreas that regulates intrapancreatic trypsin activity and provides a defensive mechanism against chronic pancreatitis (CP). CTRC exerts its protective effect by promoting degradation of trypsinogen, the precursor to trypsin. Loss-of-function missense and microdeletion variants of CTRC are found in around 4% of CP cases and increase disease risk by approximately 3-7-fold. In addition, a commonly occurring synonymous CTRC variant c.180C>T (p.Gly60=) was reported to increase CP risk in various cohorts but a global analysis of its impact has been lacking. Here, we analyzed the frequency and effect size of variant c.180C>T in Hungarian and pan-European cohorts, and performed meta-analysis of the new and published genetic association data. When allele frequency was considered, meta-analysis revealed an overall frequency of 14.2% in patients and 8.7% in controls (allelic odds ratio (OR) 2.18, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.72-2.75). When genotypes were examined, c.180TT homozygosity was observed in 3.9% of CP patients and in 1.2% of controls, and c.180CT heterozygosity was present in 22.9% of CP patients and in 15.5% of controls. Relative to the c.180CC genotype, the genotypic OR values were 5.29 (95% CI 2.63-10.64), and 1.94 (95% CI 1.57-2.38), respectively, indicating stronger CP risk in homozygous carriers. Finally, we obtained preliminary evidence that the variant is associated with reduced CTRC mRNA levels in the pancreas. Taken together, the results indicate that CTRC variant c.180C>T is a clinically relevant risk factor, and should be considered when genetic etiology of CP is investigated.

Alterations in the pH of pancreatic juice are associated with chymotrypsin C inactivation and lithostathine precipitation in chronic pancreatitis patients: a proteomic approach

BACKGROUND

The progression of chronic pancreatitis (CP), an inflammatory disease of the pancreas, causes pancreatic stones to form within the pancreatic ductal lumen/parenchyma, which occurs via protein plug formation. Pain is the most common symptom that necessitates clinical attention, and pain relief is the therapeutic goal for these patients. Endoscopic therapy and surgery are complimentary forms of therapy for pain relief. This study was envisaged to clarify the mechanism by which protein plug/soft stones form in pancreatic ducts prior to undergoing calcification.

METHODS

Protein plugs were obtained from twenty CP patients undergoing therapeutic ERCP for stone removal. Pancreatic juice was obtained from five CP patients without stones. Proteins were isolated by TCA/acetone precipitation, SDS PAGE and 2-D gel electrophoresis to determine the protein profile. Protein spots from the 2-D gel were excised and subjected to matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight (MALDI-TOF) for identification. The effect of altered pH and elevated concentrations of trypsin on pancreatic juice protein was assessed by SDS‒PAGE to determine the protein profile. Differentially expressed protein bands were excised and subjected to MALDI-TOF. In silico analysis was performed by docking lithostathine with the calcite molecule using AutoDock Vina and PyMOL to clarify their interaction during stone formation.

RESULTS

Twenty-three and twenty-nine spots from 2D gels of protein plugs and pancreatic juice, respectively, revealed that lithostathine (Reg1A) was the only protein in the protein plugs, whereas digestive enzymes and lithostathine were identified in pancreatic juice. Altered pH levels and increased trypsin concentrations in the pancreatic juice caused a protein to degrade via an unknown mechanism, and this protein was identified as chymotrypsin C (CTRC) by MALDI-TOF. Docking studies showed that the binding affinity of calcite was higher with the cleaved lithostathine, explaining the deposition of calcium that was observed around the protein plugs after calcified stones were formed through precipitation.

CONCLUSION

Our results suggest that chymotrypsin C (CTRC) is degraded in an acidic environment, leading to the precipitation of lithostathine in the ductal lumen.

Structural Basis of the Pancreatitis-Associated Autoproteolytic Failsafe Mechanism in Human Anionic Trypsin

Objective

Methods

Results

Conclusion

Evolutionary expansion of polyaspartate motif in the activation peptide of mouse cationic trypsinogen limits autoactivation and protects against pancreatitis

The activation peptide of mammalian trypsinogens typically contains a tetra-aspartate motif (positions P2-P5 in Schechter-Berger numbering) that inhibits autoactivation and facilitates activation by enteropeptidase. This evolutionary mechanism protects the pancreas from premature trypsinogen activation while allowing physiological activation in the gut lumen. Inborn mutations that disrupt the tetra-aspartate motif cause hereditary pancreatitis in humans. A subset of trypsinogen paralogs, including the mouse cationic trypsinogen (isoform T7), harbor an extended penta-aspartate motif (P2-P6) in their activation peptide. Here, we demonstrate that deletion of the extra P6 aspartate residue (D23del) increased the autoactivation of T7 trypsinogen threefold. Mutagenesis of the P6 position in wild-type T7 trypsinogen revealed that bulky hydrophobic side chains are preferred for maximal autoactivation, and deletion-induced shift of the P7 Leu to P6 explains the autoactivation increase in the D23del mutant. Accordingly, removal of the P6 Leu by NH₂-terminal truncation with chymotrypsin C reduced the autoactivation of the D23del mutant. Homozygous T7D23del mice carrying the D23del mutation did not develop spontaneous pancreatitis and severity of cerulein-induced acute pancreatitis was comparable with that of C57BL/6N controls. However, sustained stimulation with cerulein resulted in markedly increased histological damage in T7D23del mice relative to C57BL/6N mice. Furthermore, when the T7D23del allele was crossed to a chymotrypsin-deficient background, the double-mutant mice developed spontaneous pancreatitis at an early age. Taken together, the observations argue that evolutionary expansion of the polyaspartate motif in mouse cationic trypsinogen contributes to the natural defenses against pancreatitis and validate the role of the P6 position in autoactivation control of mammalian trypsinogens.NEW & NOTEWORTHY Unwanted autoactivation of the digestive protease trypsinogen can result in pancreatitis. The trypsinogen activation peptide contains a polyaspartate motif that suppresses autoactivation. This study demonstrates that evolutionary expansion of these aspartate residues in mouse cationic trypsinogen further inhibits autoactivation and enhances protection against pancreatitis.

Inactivation of mesotrypsin by chymotrypsin C prevents trypsin inhibitor degradation

Mesotrypsin is an unusual human trypsin isoform with inhibitor resistance and the ability to degrade trypsin inhibitors. Degradation of the protective serine protease inhibitor Kazal type 1 (SPINK1) by mesotrypsin in the pancreas may contribute to the pathogenesis of pancreatitis. Here we tested the hypothesis that the regulatory digestive protease chymotrypsin C (CTRC) mitigates the harmful effects of mesotrypsin by cleaving the autolysis loop. As human trypsins are post-translationally sulfated in the autolysis loop, we also assessed the effect of this modification. We found that mesotrypsin cleaved in the autolysis loop by CTRC exhibited catalytic impairment on short peptides due to a 10-fold increase in K_m , it digested β-casein poorly and bound soybean trypsin inhibitor with 10-fold decreased affinity. Importantly, CTRC-cleaved mesotrypsin degraded SPINK1 with markedly reduced efficiency. Sulfation increased mesotrypsin activity but accelerated CTRC-mediated cleavage of the autolysis loop and did not protect against the detrimental effect of CTRC cleavage. The observations indicate that CTRC-mediated cleavage of the autolysis loop in mesotrypsin decreases protease activity and thereby protects the pancreas against unwanted SPINK1 degradation. The findings expand the role of CTRC as a key defense mechanism against pancreatitis through regulation of intrapancreatic trypsin activity.

Natural single-nucleotide deletion in chymotrypsinogen C gene increases severity of secretagogue-induced pancreatitis in C57BL/6 mice

Genetic susceptibility to chronic pancreatitis in humans is frequently associated with mutations that increase activation of the digestive protease trypsin. Intrapancreatic trypsin activation is an early event in experimental acute pancreatitis in rodents, suggesting that trypsin is a key driver of pathology. In contrast to trypsin, the pancreatic protease chymotrypsin serves a protective function by mitigating trypsin activation through degradation. In humans, loss-of-function mutations in chymotrypsin C (CTRC) are common risk factors for chronic pancreatitis; however, the pathogenic effect of CTRC deficiency has not been corroborated in animal models yet. Here we report that C57BL/6 mice that are widely used for genetic manipulations do not express functional CTRC due to a single-nucleotide deletion in exon 2 of the Ctrc gene. We restored a functional Ctrc locus in C57BL/6N mice and demonstrated that in the novel Ctrc+ strain the severity of cerulein-induced experimental acute and chronic pancreatitis was significantly ameliorated. Improved disease parameters were associated with reduced intrapancreatic trypsin activation suggesting a causal link between CTRC-mediated trypsinogen degradation and protection against pancreatitis. Taken together with prior human genetic and biochemical studies, the observations provide conclusive evidence for the protective role of CTRC against pancreatitis.

Genetics, Cell Biology, and Pathophysiology of Pancreatitis

Since the discovery of the first trypsinogen mutation in families with hereditary pancreatitis, pancreatic genetics has made rapid progress. The identification of mutations in genes involved in the digestive protease-antiprotease pathway has lent additional support to the notion that pancreatitis is a disease of autodigestion. Clinical and experimental observations have provided compelling evidence that premature intrapancreatic activation of digestive proteases is critical in pancreatitis onset. However, disease course and severity are mostly governed by inflammatory cells that drive local and systemic immune responses. In this article, we review the genetics, cell biology, and immunology of pancreatitis with a focus on protease activation pathways and other early events.

Early Intra-Acinar Events in Pathogenesis of Pancreatitis

Premature activation of digestive enzymes in the pancreas has been linked to development of pancreatitis for more than a century. Recent development of novel models to study the role of pathologic enzyme activation has led to advances in our understanding of the mechanisms of pancreatic injury. Colocalization of zymogen and lysosomal fraction occurs early after pancreatitis-causing stimulus. Cathepsin B activates trypsinogen in these colocalized organelles. Active trypsin increases permeability of these organelles resulting in leakage of cathepsin B into the cytosol leading to acinar cell death. Although trypsin-mediated cell death leads to pancreatic injury in early stages of pancreatitis, multiple parallel mechanisms, including activation of inflammatory cascades, endoplasmic reticulum stress, autophagy, and mitochondrial dysfunction in the acinar cells are now recognized to be important in driving the profound systemic inflammatory response and extensive pancreatic injury seen in acute pancreatitis. Chymotrypsin, another acinar protease, has recently been shown be play critical role in clearance of pathologically activated trypsin protecting against pancreatic injury. Mutations in trypsin and other genes thought to be associated with pathologic enzyme activation (such as serine protease inhibitor 1) have been found in familial forms of pancreatitis. Sustained intra-acinar activation of nuclear factor κB pathway seems to be key pathogenic mechanism in chronic pancreatitis. Better understanding of these mechanisms will hopefully allow us to improve treatment strategies in acute and chronic pancreatitis.

Genome-wide association study identifies inversion in the CTRB1-CTRB2 locus to modify risk for alcoholic and non-alcoholic chronic pancreatitis

OBJECTIVE

Alcohol-related pancreatitis is associated with a disproportionately large number of hospitalisations among GI disorders. Despite its clinical importance, genetic susceptibility to alcoholic chronic pancreatitis (CP) is poorly characterised. To identify risk genes for alcoholic CP and to evaluate their relevance in non-alcoholic CP, we performed a genome-wide association study and functional characterisation of a new pancreatitis locus.

DESIGN

1959 European alcoholic CP patients and population-based controls from the KORA, LIFE and INCIPE studies (n=4708) as well as chronic alcoholics from the GESGA consortium (n=1332) were screened with Illumina technology. For replication, three European cohorts comprising 1650 patients with non-alcoholic CP and 6695 controls originating from the same countries were used.

RESULTS

We replicated previously reported risk loci CLDN2-MORC4, CTRC, PRSS1-PRSS2 and SPINK1 in alcoholic CP patients. We identified CTRB1-CTRB2 (chymotrypsin B1 and B2) as a new risk locus with lead single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) rs8055167 (OR 1.35, 95% CI 1.23 to 1.6). We found that a 16.6 kb inversion in the CTRB1-CTRB2 locus was in linkage disequilibrium with the CP-associated SNPs and was best tagged by rs8048956. The association was replicated in three independent European non-alcoholic CP cohorts of 1650 patients and 6695 controls (OR 1.62, 95% CI 1.42 to 1.86). The inversion changes the expression ratio of the CTRB1 and CTRB2 isoforms and thereby affects protective trypsinogen degradation and ultimately pancreatitis risk.

CONCLUSION

An inversion in the CTRB1-CTRB2 locus modifies risk for alcoholic and non-alcoholic CP indicating that common pathomechanisms are involved in these inflammatory disorders.

Genetic Risk in Chronic Pancreatitis: The Trypsin-Dependent Pathway

Genetic investigations have provided unique insight into the mechanism of chronic pancreatitis in humans and firmly established that uncontrolled trypsin activity is a central pathogenic factor. Mutations in the PRSS1, SPINK1, and CTRC genes promote increased activation of trypsinogen to trypsin by stimulation of autoactivation or by impairing protective trypsinogen degradation and/or trypsin inhibition. Here we review key genetic and biochemical features of the trypsin-dependent pathological pathway in chronic pancreatitis.