Virtual photon exchange, intermolecular interactions and optical response functions

Quantum Electrodynamics of Dicke States: Resonant One-Photon Exchange Energy and Entangled Decay Rate

We calculate the fully retarded one-photon exchange interaction potential between electrically neutral, identical atoms, one of which is assumed to be in an excited state, by matching the scattering matrix (S matrix) element with the effective Hamiltonian. Based on the Feynman prescription, we obtain the imaginary part of the interaction energy. Our results lead to precise formulas for the distance-dependent enhancement and suppression of the decay rates of entangled superradiant and subradiant Dicke states (Bell states), as a function of the interatomic distance. The formulas include a long-range tail due to entanglement. We apply the result to an example calculation involving two hydrogen atoms, one of which is in an excited P state.

Two bridge-particle-mediated RET between chiral molecules

The problem of resonance energy transfer between a pair of chiral molecules mediated by two electrically polarizable bridging particles is solved using molecular QED theory. In this framework a single virtual photon propagates between any two-coupled entities and is responsible for the conveyance of excitation energy from emitter to absorber. Electric dipole and quadrupole, and magnetic dipole couplings linear in the Maxwell fields are employed for donor and acceptor, while each mediator scatters two virtual photons and responds quadratically to the electric displacement field via its electric dipole polarizability. This enables fourth-order diagrammatic perturbation theory to be used to compute the probability amplitude for the process. Individual multipole moment contributions to the Fermi golden rule rate are then extracted for oriented and isotropic systems. Discriminatory transfer rates arise when either the donor or the acceptor are electric-magnetic dipole and the other has a pure multipole moment, or when both are chiral, with mixed electric dipole-quadrupole contributions vanishing in the fluid phase. The bridge-mediated transfer rate is found to be a maximum for a collinear geometry. Moreover, a multi-level model of the mediator is necessary for energy migration. Asymptotically limiting rates for arbitrary and collinear geometries are also obtained for one centre purely electric dipolar and the other purely quadrupolar, or both donor and absorber purely quadrupolar. Understanding is gained of radiationless and radiative transfer mechanisms between chiral moieties in a dielectric medium.

Bridge-Mediated RET between Two Chiral Molecules

Molecular quantum electrodynamics (QED) theory is employed to calculate the rate of resonance energy transfer (RET) between a donor, D, described by an electric dipole and quadrupole, and magnetic dipole coupling, and an identical acceptor molecule, A, that is mediated by a third body, T, which is otherwise inert. A single virtual photon propagates between D and T, and between T and A. Time-dependent perturbation theory is used to compute the matrix element, from which the transfer rate is evaluated using the Fermi golden rule. This extends previous studies that were limited to the electric dipole approximation only and admits the possibility of the exchange of excitation between a chiral emitter and absorber. Rate terms are computed for specific pure and mixed multipole-dependent contributions of D and A for both an oriented arrangement of the three particles and for the freely tumbling situation. Mixed multipole moment contributions, such as those involving electric–magnetic dipole or electric dipole–quadrupole coupling at one center, do not survive random orientational averaging. Interestingly, the mixed electric–magnetic dipole D and A rate term is non-vanishing and discriminatory, exhibiting a dependence on the chirality of the emitter and absorber, and is entirely retarded. It vanishes, however, if D and A are oriented perpendicularly to one another. Near- and far-zone asymptotes of isotropic contributions to the rate are also evaluated, demonstrating radiationless short-range transfer and inverse-square radiative exchange at very large separations.

The Unified Theory of Resonance Energy Transfer According to Molecular Quantum Electrodynamics

An overview is given of the molecular quantum electrodynamical (QED) theory of resonance energy transfer (RET). In this quantized radiation field description, RET arises from the exchange of a single virtual photon between excited donor and unexcited acceptor species. Diagrammatic time-dependent perturbation theory is employed to calculate the transfer matrix element, from which the migration rate is obtained via the Fermi golden rule. Rate formulae for oriented and isotropic systems hold for all pair separation distances, R, beyond wave function overlap. The two well-known mechanisms associated with migration of energy, namely the R−6 radiationless transfer rate due to Förster and the R−2 radiative exchange, correspond to near- and far-zone asymptotes of the general result. Discriminatory pair transfer rates are also presented. The influence of an environment is accounted for by invoking the polariton, which mediates exchange and by introducing a complex refractive index to describe local field and screening effects. This macroscopic treatment is compared and contrasted with a microscopic analysis in which the role of a neutral, polarizable and passive third-particle in mediating transfer of energy is considered. Three possible coupling mechanisms arise, each requiring summation over 24 time-ordered diagrams at fourth-order of perturbation theory with the total rate being a sum of two- and various three-body terms.

Three-Body Dispersion Potentials Involving Electric Octupole Coupling

Non-pairwise additive three-body dispersion potentials dependent upon one or more electric octupole moments are evaluated using the theory of molecular quantum electrodynamics. To simplify the perturbation theory calculations, an effective two-photon interaction Hamiltonian operator is employed. This leads to only third-order theory being required to evaluate energy shifts instead of the usual sixth-order formula, and the summation over six time-ordered sequences of virtual photon creation and annihilation events. Specific energy shifts computed include DD-DD-DO, DD-DO-DO, DO-DO-DO, and DD-DO-OO terms, where D and O are electric dipole and octupole moments, respectively. The formulae obtained are applicable to an arbitrary arrangement of the three particles, and we present explicit results for the equilateral triangle and collinear configurations, which complements the recently published DD-DD-OO potential. In this last case it was found that the contribution from the octupole weight-1 term could be viewed as a higher-order correction to the triple-dipole dispersion potential DD-DD-DD. In a similar fashion the octupole moment is decomposed into its irreducible components of weights-1 and -3, enabling insight to be gained into the potentials obtained in this study. Dispersion interaction energies proportional to mixed dipole-octupole polarisabilities, for example, are found to depend only on the weight-1 octupole moment for isotropic species and are retarded. Additional approximations are necessary in the evaluation of wave vector integrals for these cases in order to yield energy shifts that are valid in the near-zone.

Perspective: Quantum Hamiltonians for optical interactions

The multipolar Hamiltonian of quantum electrodynamics is extensively employed in chemical and optical physics to treat rigorously the interaction of electromagnetic fields with matter. It is also widely used to evaluate intermolecular interactions. The multipolar version of the Hamiltonian is commonly obtained by carrying out a unitary transformation of the Coulomb gauge Hamiltonian that goes by the name of Power-Zienau-Woolley (PZW). Not only does the formulation provide excellent agreement with experiment, and versatility in its predictive ability, but also superior physical insight. Recently, the foundations and validity of the PZW Hamiltonian have been questioned, raising a concern over issues of gauge transformation and invariance, and whether observable quantities obtained from unitarily equivalent Hamiltonians are identical. Here, an in-depth analysis of theoretical foundations clarifies the issues and enables misconceptions to be identified. Claims of non-physicality are refuted: the PZW transformation and ensuing Hamiltonian are shown to rest on solid physical principles and secure theoretical ground.