Management of a broken needle: retained in the first caesarean section, removed during the second abdominal delivery

Management of a Retained Broken Suture Needle During Cerclage Placement

BACKGROUND

Broken suture needles with unintentional foreign body retention are an uncommon occurrence during obstetric procedures. Few reports exist in the literature of cases in pregnant patients. We report a case with the pregnancy management of a broken needle during cerclage placement that was retained in the cervix until repeat cesarean delivery.

CASE

A 36-year-old woman, gravida 12 para 5, presented at 13 weeks of gestation for a history-indicated cerclage. The suture needle broke during the cerclage procedure, leaving a 35-mm needle fragment inside the cervical stroma between the 11 and 2 o'clock position that could not be recovered after multiple attempts. The procedure continued without needle recovery. Intraoperative pelvic X-ray was performed, demonstrating the retained fragment. No further attempts at recovery were made during the pregnancy, and a plan was made to proceed with removal at the patient's repeat cesarean delivery. The patient presented in labor at 32 1/7 weeks of gestation and underwent an uncomplicated cesarean delivery. The retained needle was subsequently removed after manual palpation of the fragment transvaginally.

CONCLUSION

Retained broken suture needles during obstetric procedures require careful management decisions in pregnant patients. Retention of a needle fragment until delivery may be considered if risks of removal outweigh the anticipated benefits.

Microsurgical Needle Retention Does Not Cause Pain or Neurovascular Injury in a Rat Model

Approximately 20% of retained foreign bodies are surgical needles. Retained macro-needles may become symptomatic, but the effect of microsurgical needles is uncertain. We present the first animal model to simulate microsurgical needle retention. Given a lack of reported adverse outcomes associated with macro-needles and a smaller cutting area of microsurgical needles, we hypothesized that microsurgical needles in rats would not cause changes in health or neurovascular compromise.

Methods

Male Sprague-Dawley rats (x̄ weight: 288.9 g) were implanted with a single, 9.0 needle (n = 8) or 8.0 needle (n = 8) orthogonal to the right femoral vessels and sutured in place. A control group (n = 8) underwent sham surgery. Weekly, a cumulative health score evaluating body weight, body condition score, physical appearance, and behavior for each rat was determined. Infrared thermography (°C, FLIR one) of each hindlimb and the difference was obtained on postoperative days 15, 30, 60, and 90. On day 90, animals were euthanatized, hindlimbs were imaged via fluoroscopy, and needles were explanted.

Results

The mean, cumulative health score for all cohorts at each weekly timepoint was 0. The mean temperature difference was not significantly different on postoperative days 15 (P = 0.54), 30 (P = 0.97), 60 (P = 0.29), or 90 (P = 0.09). In seven of eight rats, 8.0 needles were recovered and visualized on fluoroscopy. In six of eight rats, 9.0 needles were recovered, but 0/8 needles were visualized on fluoroscopy.

Conclusions

Microsurgical needle retention near neurovascular structures may be benign, and imaging for needles smaller than 8.0 may be futile. Further studies should explore microsurgical needle retention potentially through larger animal models.

Identifying lost surgical needles with visible and near infrared fluorescent light emitting microscale coating

BACKGROUND

Retained foreign bodies (RFOs) have substantial clinical and financial consequences. In laparoscopic surgery, RFOs can be a cause of needing to convert a minimally invasive surgery (MIS) procedure to an open operation. A coating for surgical models was developed to augment localization of needles using fluorescence appropriate for open and minimally invasive surgeries procedures.

METHODS

An epoxy matrix containing both dansyl chloride and indocyanine green was coated as visible and near infrared labels, respectively. With ultraviolet excitation, dansyl chloride emits green fluorescence and with NIR excitation, the ICG dye emits radiation observable with specialized near infrared capable laparoscopes. To evaluate the coatings, open and laproscopic surgeries were simulated in rabbits. Surgeons blinded to the type of needles (coated or non-coated) were timed while finding needles in standard conditions and with the use of the adjunct coatings. Control needles not located within 300 seconds were researched with the corresponding near infrared or ultraviolet light. Localization time was evaluated for statistical significance, P < .05.

RESULTS

All dual dye coated needles searched utilizing the near infrared camera (n = 26) or ultraviolet light (n= 26) were located within 300 seconds. Conversely, 9 needles in both control settings (no dye usage) were not located within 300 seconds. Mean time to locate control needles in open surgery and laparoscopic surgery was statistically 2-3× greater than time to localization with the use of dye as an adjunct (P = .0027 open, P < .001 laparoscopic).

CONCLUSION

Incorporation of a dual-dye fluorescent coating on surgical needles improved the efficiency of locating needles, may minimize the need to convert minimally invasive surgeries procedures to open, and may decrease the consequences of a missed RFO.

Laparoscopic needle-retrieval device for improving quality of care in minimally invasive surgery

BACKGROUND

Loss of a needle during laparoscopic surgery is a rare but potentially serious adverse event that can cause prolonged operative time and patient harm. Standard recovery techniques currently include instrument count, standard visual search, and plain abdominal x-rays. We developed a laparoscopic instrument to speed the retrieval of lost needles in the abdomen and pelvis.

STUDY DESIGN

We performed in vivo testing of a novel articulating laparoscopic magnet in a porcine model. Three experienced surgeons and 3 inexperienced surgeons conducted 116 needle-retrieval trials with the device and 58 trials with a standard visual approach. Surgeons were blind to the locations of randomly placed surgical needles within the abdominal cavity. Time to recovery was measured and capped at 15 minutes. Analysis was performed using univariate and multivariable methods.

RESULTS

The magnetic device was able to retrieve needles significantly faster than the standard approach (2.9 ± 4.0 minutes vs 8.0 ± 6.0 minutes; p < 0.0001). On multivariable analysis, faster recovery time remained independently significant when controlling for surgeon experience, needle size (small, medium, or large), and needle location (by quadrant) (p < 0.0001). There were 2 (2%) injuries to abdominal organs during the device trials and 4 (7%) injuries during the standard trials (p = 0.182).

CONCLUSIONS

Recovery of lost surgical needles during porcine laparoscopic surgery is safe and feasible with a simple articulating magnetic device. Our initial in vivo experience suggests that recovery is markedly faster using the magnetic device than the standard approach, even in the hands of experienced laparoscopic surgeons. This device will be particularly useful as minimally invasive robotic and single-site surgical techniques are adopted and, in the future, it should be integrated into the standard protocol for locating lost needles during surgery.

Retained surgical items and minimally invasive surgery

A retained surgical item is a surgical patient safety problem. Early reports have focused on the epidemiology of retained-item cases and the identification of patient risk factors for retention. We now know that retention has very little to do with patient characteristics and everything to do with operating room culture. It is a perception that minimally invasive procedures are safer with regard to the risk of retention. Minimally invasive surgery is still an operation where an incision is made and surgical tools are placed inside of patients, so these cases are not immune to the problem of inadvertent retention. Retained surgical items occur because of problems with multi-stakeholder operating room practices and problems in communication. The prevention of retained surgical items will therefore require practice change, knowledge, and shared information between all perioperative personnel.

[A piece of needle of a cesarean section found 45 years later]

We report the case of a patient who had a caesarian section 45 years ago in whom was discovered a piece of needle during assessment of an endometrial cancer. This piece of needle, close to the small bowel, was found inside a hysterotomy scar but no complication occurred during all this time.